Lake Laurel Pty Ltd v Nichols Constructions Pty Ltd (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 45 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Lake Laurel Pty Ltd & Ors v Nichols Constructions Pty Ltd & Ors (No 2) [2019] QSC 145

PARTIES:

LAKE LAUREL PTY LTD ACN 010 7023 511 TRADING AS BERGER CONTRACTING

(First Plaintiff)

LUTZ BERGER

(Second Plaintiff)

PETER JAMES RYAN

(Third Plaintiff)

v
NICHOLS CONSTRUCTIONS PTY LTD ACN 010 763 505

(First Defendant)

LESLIE EDWIN NICHOLS and LESLIE EDWIN NICHOLS AS PERSONAL REPRESENTATIVE OF JUDELLE CHRISTINE NICHOLS

(Second Defendants)

FILE NO/S:

BS No 3368 of 2014

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Trial

DELIVERED ON:

6 June 2019

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

20, 21, 23 and 24 May 2019

JUDGE:

Bowskill J

ORDER:

Judgment for the third plaintiff on his claim against the first and second defendants for payment of the principal sum under the loan agreement and the mortgage in the amount of $3,775,000.00 with interest and costs to be agreed between the parties or, failing agreement, to be determined by the court.

The parties are directed to provide a draft form of judgment reflecting the court’s decision, and addressing interest and costs.  If interest and costs are not agreed, the parties are to file and serve written submissions in relation to those issues within 7 days.

CATCHWORDS:

CONTRACTS – GENERAL CONTRACTUAL PRINCIPLES – CONSTRUCTION AND INTERPRETATION OF CONTRACTS – IMPLIED TERMS – GENERALLY – where the parties were involved in a project to subdivide land – where the first plaintiff and the first defendant entered into a loan agreement, with the second defendants as guarantors, which was secured by a registered mortgage, under which the first defendant agreed to pay the principal sum of $3,775,000.00 to the first plaintiff, by incremental instalments on the sale of each lot in the proposed subdivision, with the balance to be repaid 12 months from registration of the plan(s) of subdivision – where the debt under the loan agreement and mortgage were later assigned to the third plaintiff – where the third plaintiff claims the debt has become due and payable, as a consequence of the first defendant’s breach of express and implied terms of the loan agreement and mortgage, by allowing the development approval for the land to lapse, and failing to obtain registration of the plan(s) of subdivision within a reasonable time – where the defendants do not challenge the contention that the first defendant breached the loan agreement and/or the mortgage in the ways contended by the third plaintiff, but argue the principal sum has not become payable because of an earlier breach by the first plaintiff of the implied obligation under the loan agreement and the mortgage to cooperate – whether the implied obligation to cooperate required the first plaintiff to take steps to ensure that plan(s) for subdivision of the land were registered, or not to hinder or obstruct the first defendant’s efforts in that regard – whether such a breach, even if established, could be relied upon to defend the claim by the third plaintiff, as assignee, to recover the principal sum…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lake Laurel Pty Ltd v Nichols Constructions Pty Ltd (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] QSC 145
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Lake Laurel Pty Ltd and others brought a claim against Nichols Constructions Pty Ltd and others in relation to a loan agreement for $6.25 million, secured by a mortgage over land at 284 Patrick Street, Laidley. The third plaintiff, as assignee of the debt, claims that the principal sum has become due and payable as a consequence of breaches by the first defendant of the loan agreement and mortgage, specifically allowing the development approval for the land to lapse and failing to obtain registration of the plans of subdivision within a reasonable time. The defendants argue that the principal sum is not payable because the first plaintiff breached an implied obligation to cooperate under the loan agreement and mortgage. The central legal issues were whether the implied obligation to cooperate required the first plaintiff to take steps to ensure that plans for the subdivision of the land were registered, or not to hinder or obstruct the first defendant’s efforts in that regard, and whether such a breach, if established, could be relied upon to defend the claim by the third plaintiff to recover the principal sum.

The court found that the implied obligation to cooperate did not require the first plaintiff to take steps to ensure that plans for the subdivision of the land were registered, or to refrain from hindering or obstructing the first defendant’s efforts in that regard. The court was not persuaded, on the evidence before it, that anything the first plaintiff did or did not do obstructed or hindered the first defendant in doing that. The court concluded that the principal sum under the loan agreement had become due and payable, and there was judgment for the third plaintiff on his claim against the first and second defendants for payment of the principal sum under the loan agreement and the mortgage in the amount of $3,775,000.00. The parties were directed to provide a draft form of judgment reflecting the court’s decision and addressing interest and costs. If interest and costs were not agreed, the parties were to file and serve written submissions in relation to those issues within 7 days.

Orders

Orders of the court

Judgment for the third plaintiff on his claim against the first and second defendants for payment of the principal sum under the loan agreement and the mortgage in the amount of $3,775,000.00 with interest and costs to be agreed between the parties or, failing agreement, to be determined by the court.

The parties are directed to provide a draft form of judgment reflecting the court’s decision, and addressing interest and costs. If interest and costs are not agreed, the parties are to file and serve written submissions in relation to those issues within 7 days.

Background

Background to the litigation

As matters evolved by the end of the trial, following delivery of the decision on the separate questions, the defendants did not challenge the contention that Nichols Constructions has breached the loan agreement and/or the mortgage in each of the three ways contended by Mr Ryan. The defendants’ argument is that Lake Laurel was in breach of the loan agreement prior to any breach by Nichols Constructions, and therefore the principal sum is not payable.[1][1] Defendants’ closing submissions at [3].The facts Although the relevant factual framework was set out in [8]-[28] of the decision on the separate questions, there are some additional facts which are relevant to determination of the remaining issues. For ease of reading, the facts are reiterated below, supplemented by the additional matters. Most of this is uncontroversial and agreed between the parties.[2][2] See the third plaintiff’s submissions at [3]-[38], with which the defendants agreed (T 4-20). At relevant times, Lake Laurel carried on business as a civil works contractor, for subdivisions of land, under the name Berger Contracting. The second plaintiff, Mr Berger, was the sole director, secretary and shareholder of Lake Laurel. In March 2008, Lake Laurel purchased land at 284 Patrick Street, Laidley for $4.4 million, with the intention of subdividing it for residential purposes. The project was financed by Nichols Constructions, which entered into a written loan facility with Lake Laurel for $6.25 million and took a mortgage over 284 Patrick Street as security, in May 2008. Lake Laurel lodged an application for a development approval for the 284 Patrick Street land with the Lockyer Valley Regional Council in May 2008. Also at that time, Lake Laurel entered into a put and call option deed with Choice Homes (Qld) Pty Ltd, for the sale of all the residential lots within the 284 Patrick Street subdivision, for $98,000 per lot. In June 2008, Lake Laurel entered into a contract to purchase an adjacent block of land, Lot 261 Boundary Road, West Laidley, from Ms Ziebarth, for $2.2 million. In exchange for an immediate release of the $50,000 deposit, the purchase contract was subject to a lengthy settlement period, ending on 30 June 2010. This land is referred to either as Lot 261 or the Ziebarth Land. Mr Berger explained in his evidence that he needed the Ziebarth Land “to make Patrick Street work”, because fill was required from the higher Ziebarth Land, to fill the Patrick Street land, which was below the flood level.[3][3] T 3-33. In July 2008, Lake Laurel made an application for development approval for a proposed material change of use of Lot 261 and to reconfigure the lot (by subdividing it into 231 lots) (exhibit 9). In February 2010, Lake Laurel purchased another, smaller, block of land adjacent to the other two properties, called the Breuer Street land. On 2 March 2010, Lake Laurel obtained development approval from the Council for the 284 Patrick Street land, approving a development permit for a material change of use (changing the zoning from rural landscape to urban residential) and reconfiguration of the lot into 173 residential lots, to be developed in two stages (exhibit 18). The development approval was subject to a number of conditions, including a condition required by the Department of Transport and Main Roads (DTMR), a concurrency agency in relation to the proposed development, in the following terms:“CONDITION 3: STORMWATERIssue/ConcernsLaidley Plainlands Road and the proposed Grandchester to Gowrie High Speed Rail Corridor may be affected by this development if it changes the location, level or flow rate of water run-off.Condition of Development for the subject ApplicationPrior to the commencement of any works occurring on site and thereafter:(i) The applicant shall not increase the peak intensity of the stormwater run-off to Laidley-Plainlands Road nor adversely impact on stormwater quality.(ii) The development must not cause an increase in stormwater flows onto the proposed Grandchester to Gowrie High Speed Rail Corridor (“The Future Rail Corridor”) or interfere with stormwater flows from or within the corridor, generally in accordance with Stormwater Catchment Plan – Developed 08-1962/103, prepared by Michael Samms and Associates dated 05/09/2009”

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

I accept these submissions for Mr Ryan. I find that Nichols Constructions has breached the implied term of the loan agreement, which required that it cooperate and do all such things as are necessary to enable the other party, Lake Laurel, to have the benefit of the loan agreement, namely payment of the principal sum. I am not persuaded, on the evidence before me, that anything Lake Laurel did, or did not do, obstructed or hindered Nichols Constructions in doing that. Conclusion and orders It follows that I find Mr Ryan has made out his case, that the principal sum under the loan agreement, has become due and payable. On the basis of my findings above, the earliest date the principal sum became payable was in or about January 2017 (12 months from what I have determined was a reasonable time for the plans of subdivision to be registered). There will be judgment for the third plaintiff on his claim against the first and second defendants[53] for payment of the principal sum under the loan agreement and the mortgage in the amount of $3,775,000.00. I will direct the parties to provide a draft form of judgment, reflecting this decision, and addressing interest and costs. If interest and costs are not agreed, the parties will be directed to file and serve written submissions in relation to those issues within 7 days of delivery of this decision.[53] Apart from the issues already addressed in these reasons, no issue was raised by the defendants in relation to the liability of the second defendants as guarantors under the loan agreement.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In addition, there is no contention that, by operation of clause 10 of the mortgage, subject to the defendants’ argument of a prior disentitling breach by Lake Laurel, all moneys secured by the mortgage became due and payable.(ii) breach of the implied term that registration of the plan(s) of subdivision for the Ziebarth Subdivision would occur within a reasonable period of time The defendants do not challenge a finding that it was an implied term of the loan agreement and the mortgage that the plan(s) for the “Ziebarth Subdivision”, as that term is defined in clause 1 of the loan agreement, was required to be registered within a reasonable time.[18] [18] This is supported by York Air Conditioning and Refrigeration (A/sia) Pty Ltd v The Commonwealth (1949) 80 CLR 11 at 62; and Perri v Coolangatta Investments Pty Ltd (1982) 149 CLR 537 at 543. Nor do the defendants challenge the argument(s) of the third plaintiff as to what constituted a reasonable time. There were effectively three time periods identified by the third plaintiff:1.By 13 August 2012, on the basis of Mr Berger’s evidence, that it would take about 13 months after obtaining the development approval, to obtain operational works approval, to construct the civil works, and then to register the plan of subdivision.[19]2.By 13 April 2014, on the basis of the evidence of Mr McAnany, civil engineer, that he would estimate about 2 years and 9 months from the obtaining of development approval, to registration of the plans.[20]3.By 8 April 2013, which is 12 months before the proceedings were commenced (because payment was required 12 months from registration of the plan(s) of subdivision).[19] T3-34 and 3-38.[20] Exhibit 20 and T 3-74 to 3-76. What is a reasonable time is a question of fact, to be determined having regard to all the circumstances, including those which are known or foreseeable at the time of the contract as well as subsequent circumstances and events.[21][21] Hart v MacDonald (1910) 10 CLR 417 at 421-422; Telina Developments Pty Ltd v Stay Enterprises Pty Ltd [1984] 2 Qd R 585 at 587 and 591-592; Rudi’s Enterprises Pty Ltd v Jay (1987) 10 NSWLR 568 at 575-576. On the evidence I find that a reasonable time, for registration of the plan(s) of subdivision of Lot 261, was about three years from the January 2013 floods. I adopt the time periods estimated by Mr McAnany (a total of 2 years and 9 months, including 13 months for design and operational works approval, 12 months for civil works construction, 2 months for plan sealing and 6 months for slippage), round this up to three years, and calculate it from the time of the January 2013 floods, having regard to the evidence of Mr Boheim, a town planner with the Council. Mr Boheim gave evidence that both the 284 Patrick Street and Lot 261 sites were affected by floodwaters as a result of the January 2013 floods. He said that following the floods, Council developed “an awareness of issues with the design” of drainage and flooding requirements in relation to these sites, “that we weren’t previously aware of”. He said the Council requires the owner/developer of those sites to address those issues before the Council will seal any further plans. He confirmed that even if everything was constructed in accordance with the original development approval, the Council still would not seal the plan for stage 2, until these other drainage design issues are addressed.[22][22] T 4-8.