Metal Manufactures Pty Limited v Morton

Link copied
Case Copied 44 min read

HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

KIEFEL CJ,
GAGELER, GORDON, EDELMAN AND STEWARD JJ

METAL MANUFACTURES PTY LIMITED  APPELLANT

AND

GAVIN MORTON AS LIQUIDATOR OF
MJ WOODMAN ELECTRICAL CONTRACTORS
PTY LTD (IN LIQUIDATION) & ANOR  RESPONDENTS

Metal Manufactures Pty Limited v Morton

[2023] HCA 1

Date of Hearing: 12 October 2022
Date of Judgment: 8 February 2023

B19/2022

ORDER

1. Appeal dismissed.

2.The costs of this appeal be costs in the cause.

On appeal from the Federal Court of Australia

Representation

J T Gleeson SC with G P McNally SC and J W Pokoney for the appellant (instructed by Breene & Breene Solicitors)

J D McKenna KC with P E O'Brien for the respondents (instructed by Taylor David Lawyers)

Notice:  This copy of the Court's Reasons for Judgment is subject to formal revision prior to publication in the Commonwealth Law Reports.

  1. KIEFEL CJ, GORDON, EDELMAN AND STEWARD JJ. Metal Manufactures Pty Limited ("the appellant") was paid $50,000 and $140,000 by MJ Woodman Electrical Contractors Pty Ltd, a company now in liquidation ("MJ Woodman"). Both payments were made within the six‑month period prior to the winding up of MJ Woodman ("the relation-back period"). The liquidator of MJ Woodman ("the first respondent") sought to recover both payments from the appellant under s 588FF(1)(a) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ("the Act") on the basis that each was an unfair preference under s 588FA of the Act. The appellant alleges, and the respondents concede, that MJ Woodman owes the appellant $194,727.23. This is a separate and distinct debt from the liability which is said to arise under s 588FF(1)(a). The appellant contends that it has, pursuant to s 553C of the Act, a right to set off its potential liability to repay the alleged unfair preferences against the separate debt owed to it.

  2. Given that the separate debt exceeds the amount of the alleged unfair preferences, if the appellant could set off that debt under s 553C(1), the first respondent would not obtain an order for payment under s 588FF(1)(a). Accordingly, by an Amended Special Case, Derrington J reserved for consideration by the Full Court of the Federal Court the following question:

    "Is statutory set-off, under s 553C(1) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ("Act"), available to the [appellant] in this proceeding against the [first respondent's] claim as liquidator for the recovery of an unfair preference under s 588FA of the Act?"

  3. In a comprehensive set of reasons, the Full Court said that the question posed should be answered "No"[1]. In separate reasons, the Full Court also ordered that the issue of costs in the special case be remitted for determination by the docket judge[2]. For the reasons which follow, the answer given by the Full Court was correct, the costs order should not be disturbed, and the costs of this appeal should be costs in the cause.

    [1]Morton v Metal Manufactures Pty Ltd (2021) 289 FCR 556 at 560 [5] per Allsop CJ (Middleton and Derrington JJ agreeing).

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Metal Manufactures Pty Limited v Morton and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] HCA 1
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal concerned Metal Manufactures Pty Limited (the appellant) and the Liquidator of MJ Woodman Electrical Contractors Pty Ltd (the respondent). The dispute arose from the liquidator's claim to recover payments made by the company to the appellant within six months prior to its winding up, alleging these payments constituted unfair preferences under section 588FA of the *Corporations Act 2001* (Cth). The appellant sought to set off a separate debt owed to it by the company against the liquidator's claim for recovery of these alleged unfair preferences, relying on section 553C(1) of the Act. The matter was heard by the High Court of Australia.

The central legal issue before the High Court was whether section 553C(1) of the *Corporations Act 2001* (Cth) entitled a creditor, such as the appellant, to set off an amount received as an unfair preference against a debt it was ordered to repay to a company in liquidation, against another debt that the creditor could prove in the winding up. This question required the Court to consider the interaction between the provisions governing set-off in insolvency and those dealing with the recovery of voidable transactions, specifically unfair preferences.

The High Court reasoned that allowing a set-off in this context would be inconsistent with the statutory scheme of liquidation, particularly the *pari passu* principle which dictates that unsecured creditors generally rank equally in the distribution of a company's assets. The Court observed that an unfairly preferred creditor, by definition, has received more than they would in a winding up if the transaction were set aside. Permitting a set-off would allow such a creditor to improve their position relative to other creditors, undermining the purpose of the unfair preference provisions. Consequently, the Court concluded that a creditor cannot rely on section 553C(1) to set off a debt owed by the company against a claim for repayment of an unfair preference.

The appeal was dismissed, and the costs of the appeal were ordered to be costs in the cause, reflecting the unresolved nature of other defences raised by the appellant in the ongoing proceeding.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Appeal dismissed.

2. The costs of this appeal be costs in the cause.

Background

Background to the litigation

Metal Manufactures Pty Limited, a company, was placed in liquidation. The liquidator of the company, Morton, sought to recover payments made to the appellant, a creditor of the company, within six months prior to the winding up of the company, as unfair preferences under the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ("the Act"). The appellant argued that it was entitled to set off the amount it owed to the company against the liquidator's claim for recovery of the unfair preferences. The appellant owed a separate and distinct debt to the company, which it sought to set off against the amount it had received as an unfair preference. The liquidator argued that the set-off was not available to the appellant because the statutory scheme of liquidation in Pt 5.6 of the Act did not permit a creditor to improve its position in relation to other creditors by relying on an unfair preference.

The Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia considered whether s 553C(1) of the Act entitled the appellant to set off the amount it received as an unfair preference against the amount it owed to the company. The Full Court held that if the appellant was entitled to set off the two amounts, it would be at odds with the statutory scheme of liquidation in Pt 5.6 of the Act. The Full Court held that the appellant was not entitled to set off the amount it received as an unfair preference against the amount it owed to the company. The Full Court ordered that the costs of the Amended Special Case be reserved for determination by the docket judge upon the resolution of all of the outstanding issues between the parties. The Full Court also ordered that the costs of this appeal should be costs in the cause so that the costs can follow resolution of all yet to be determined questions, including whether the litigation should be treated as public interest litigation.

This appeal arose from proceedings in the Federal Court of Australia concerning a liquidator's claim against a creditor for the recovery of unfair preferences and insolvent transactions under the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). The liquidator of a company in liquidation sought to recover payments made to the appellant within six months prior to the winding up, claiming these payments were unfair preferences. The appellant, a creditor, argued for the right to set off an equivalent amount against another debt owed to the company, relying on s 553C(1) of the Act. This appeal followed a decision by the Full Court of the Federal Court which reserved the costs of the Amended Special Case for determination by the docket judge upon resolution of all outstanding issues between the parties. The Full Court recognised that the success or failure of the appellant's further defences would impact the issue of costs, leading to an order that the costs of this appeal should be costs in the cause. The appeal was dismissed, and the costs of the appeal were ordered to be costs in the cause.

Decision

Reasons for decision

KIEFEL CJ, GORDON, EDELMAN AND STEWARD JJ GAGELER J
As mentioned above, the Full Court of the Federal Court ordered that the costs of the Amended Special Case be reserved for determination by the docket judge upon the resolution of all of the outstanding issues between the parties. That was because the appellant had two further defences which have yet to be resolved. If those defences are successful, then, as the Full Court acknowledged, "the special case, while fully argued, may be of no moment as between the parties (though of significance to insolvency practice generally in Australia)"[85]. In such circumstances, the Full Court recognised that the success or failure of those further defences would bear upon the issue of costs. That conclusion should not be disturbed. Moreover, it also justifies an order that the costs of this appeal should be costs in the cause so that the costs can follow resolution of all yet to be determined questions, including whether the litigation should be treated as public interest litigation.[85]Morton as Liquidator of MJ Woodman Electrical Contractors Pty Ltd v Metal Manufactures Pty Ltd [No 2] [2022] FCAFC 1 at [8] per Allsop CJ, Middleton and Derrington JJ.Conclusion For these reasons, the appeal should be dismissed, with costs in the cause. The question reserved for the consideration of the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia was properly framed by reference to rights in issue in the ongoing proceeding in the Federal Court in which a liquidator (the first respondent in this Court) claims against a creditor (the appellant in this Court) an order, under s 588FF(1)(a) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ("the Act"), directing the creditor to repay to a company in liquidation (the second respondent in this Court) an amount equal to amounts that the company paid to the creditor in transactions which the liquidator claims to have been voidable because of s 588FE of the Act on the basis of those payments having been unfair preferences and insolvent transactions within the meanings of s 588FA and s 588FC of the Act. Informing the answer to that question about specific rights in issue in the ongoing proceeding is an examination of the general question of statutory construction on which the outcome of this appeal turns. Does s 553C of the Act entitle a creditor to set off an amount equivalent to that received as an unfair preference in repayment of a debt, which the creditor is ordered under s 588FF(1)(a) of the Act to repay to a company in liquidation, against the amount of another debt which the creditor can prove in the winding up of the company? To be observed at the outset is that the consequence of the creditor being entitled to set off the two amounts would be at odds with the scheme of Pt 5.6 of the Act, of which s 553C forms part. Within a system of winding up in which unsecured creditors of an insolvent company in liquidation generally rank pari passu in the distribution of the property of the company[86], an unfairly preferred creditor – who has by definition engaged in a transaction by which the creditor has received from the company more than the creditor would receive if the transaction were set aside and the creditor were to prove for the debt in the winding up of the company[87] – would be entitled to rely on the unfair preference to improve that creditor's position in relation to other creditors. [86]See s 555 of the Act.[87]See s 588FA(1)(b) of the Act.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: KIEFEL CJ, GORDON, EDELMAN AND STEWARD JJ, GAGELER J

The court began its analysis by addressing whether section 553C of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) allows a creditor to set off an amount equivalent to an unfair preference received from an insolvent company against another debt owed by the creditor during the winding up of the company. The court examined the statutory language of section 553C, which provides for set-off between mutual debts. However, the court found that allowing a creditor to set off an unfair preference would contradict the statutory scheme of liquidation and the pari passu principle in Part 5.6 of the Corporations Act. The pari passu principle mandates that unsecured creditors of an insolvent company should receive equal treatment in the distribution of the company’s property. Allowing a creditor to set off an unfair preference would effectively permit the unfairly preferred creditor to improve their position relative to other creditors, undermining the pari passu principle. The court concluded that such a set-off would not be consistent with the broader statutory scheme designed to ensure equitable treatment of creditors in liquidation.

Next, the court considered whether the liquidator's claim for recovery of unfair preferences under section 588FF(1)(a) of the Corporations Act is subject to a set-off under section 553C(1) of the same Act. The court determined that the liquidator's claim for recovery of unfair preferences is not subject to set-off. The statutory provisions concerning unfair preferences are specifically designed to prevent unfairly preferred creditors from retaining benefits that were not available to other creditors. Allowing a set-off in this context would effectively frustrate the purpose of these provisions, which is to restore the financial position of the company prior to the unfair preference being made. The court found that the statutory scheme does not permit the set-off of amounts recovered as unfair preferences under section 588FF(1)(a), reinforcing the principle that unfairly preferred creditors must repay the amounts received.

The court then addressed the issue of whether the litigation should be treated as public interest litigation, and how this affects the issue of costs. The court recognised that the nature of the litigation has implications for the allocation of costs, particularly if the litigation has broader implications for insolvency practice in Australia. The court determined that the costs of the Amended Special Case should be reserved for determination by the docket judge upon the resolution of all outstanding issues between the parties. This was because the appellant had two further defences which had yet to be resolved, and their success or failure would bear upon the issue of costs. The court justified this approach by noting that the success or failure of those further defences would affect whether the litigation should indeed be treated as public interest litigation, impacting the broader implications for insolvency practice.

The implications of the ongoing defences presented by the appellant on the resolution of the costs of the Amended Special Case were also considered. The court acknowledged that if the appellant's defences were successful, the special case, while fully argued, might be of no moment as between the parties. However, it would still be of significance to insolvency practice generally in Australia. Therefore, the success or failure of those defences would determine the court's approach to costs. The court concluded that it was appropriate to reserve the costs issue for determination by the docket judge once all issues had been resolved.

Finally, the court's decision on the set-off and unfair preferences has significant implications for insolvency practice in Australia. By clarifying that a creditor cannot set off an unfair preference against another debt owed by the creditor, the court reinforced the principle that unfairly preferred creditors must repay the amounts received. This decision ensures that the pari passu principle is upheld and that the statutory scheme of liquidation is not undermined. The court's decision provides certainty to liquidators and creditors alike, ensuring that unfairly preferred creditors do not retain benefits that were not available to other creditors. This reinforces the equitable distribution of assets in the winding up of insolvent companies, consistent with the statutory objectives of the Corporations Act.