Tah Land Pty Ltd v Subway Realty Pty Ltd [No 2]

Link copied
Case Copied 47 min read

JURISDICTION     :   DISTRICT COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

IN CIVIL

LOCATION:   PERTH

CITATION:   TAH LAND PTY LTD -v- SUBWAY REALTY PTY LTD [No 2] [2023] WADC 108

CORAM:   PALMER DCJ

HEARD:   17 AUGUST 2023

DELIVERED          :   18 SEPTEMBER 2023

FILE NO/S:   CIV 5041 of 2022

BETWEEN:   TAH LAND PTY LTD

Plaintiff

AND

SUBWAY REALTY PTY LTD

First Defendant

D I BRITZ PTY LTD

Second Defendant

WESTERN AUSTRALIAN PLANNING COMMISSION

Third Defendant

DAVID IAN BRITZ

Third Party


Catchwords:

Appeal from registrar - Summary judgment - Where question of construction is involved - Proper construction of limitation of liability provision

Legislation:

District Court Rules 2005 (WA)
Rules of the Supreme Court 1971 (WA)

Result:

Appeal allowed
Summary judgment granted

Representation:

Counsel:

Plaintiff : Mr N W Kalmund
First Defendant : Mr T C Russell
Second Defendant : No appearance
Third Defendant : No appearance
Third Party : No appearance

Solicitors:

Plaintiff : Hotchkin Hanly
First Defendant : Minter Ellison
Second Defendant : Not applicable
Third Defendant : State Solicitor's Office
Third Party : Robson Legal

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

Black Box Control Pty Ltd v Terravision Pty Ltd [2016] WASCA 219

Casella v Hewitt [2008] WASCA 13; (2008) 36 WAR 1

Cheney v Moore [2020] WASC 227

Electricity Generation Corporation t/as Verve Energy v Woodside Energy Ltd [2014] HCA 7; (2014) 251 CLR 640

Hazart Pty Ltd v Rademaker (1993) 11 WAR 26

Kezic v St John of God Health Care Inc [2015] WASCA 220

NRW Contracting Pty Ltd v Cliffs Asia Pacific Iron Ore Pty Ltd [2020] WASCA 107

Radiant Nominees Pty Ltd v Australian Crane and Machinery Pty Ltd [2019] WADC 112

SMEC Australia Pty Ltd v Valentine Falls Estate Pty Ltd [2011] WASCA 138

Tah Land Pty Ltd v Subway Realty Pty Ltd [2023] WADC 44

Thomas v Balanced Securities Ltd [2011] QCA 258; [2012] 2 Qd R 482

ThoughtWare Australia Pty Ltd v IonMy Pty Ltd [2023] FCA 906

Westport Insurance Corporation v Gordian Runoff Ltd [2011] HCA 37; (2011) 244 CLR 239

Zaghloul v Bayly [2021] WASCA 125

PALMER DCJ:

Introduction

  1. The Plaintiff (Tah Land) appeals from a decision made by Registrar Jeyamohan on 22 March 2023 to dismiss its application for summary judgment against the First Defendant (Subway).  Tah Land also appeals from the learned registrar's decision to order Tah Land to pay Subway's costs of the application.

  2. Until 7 December 2022, Tah Land was the registered proprietor of the land on which Kingsway City Shopping Centre in Kingsway is located.[1]  For almost 12 years from about 16 September 2004 to 7 December 2022, Subway leased Shop B2 in Kingsway City Shopping Centre (the Premises) from Tah Land.[2]  The Second Defendant subleased the Premises from Subway.

    [1] Amended Statement of Claim dated 3 August 2023 (Statement of Claim), pars 1, 5 and 13.

    [2] Statement of Claim, pars 5 and 13.

  3. In these proceedings Tah Land seeks to recover the sum of $120,863.23 plus interest that…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Tah Land Pty Ltd v Subway Realty Pty Ltd [No 2] and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] WADC 108
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Tah Land Pty Ltd brought an appeal against a registrar’s decision to refuse to enter summary judgment in its favour. The registrar declined to grant summary judgment on the basis that the proper construction of a limitation of liability clause in the lease was a complex question of law that required a trial. The appeal was to the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The parties had already agreed that the only question before the court was the proper construction of Clause 4 in the lease, and that no facts were in dispute. The court found that the resolution of this question was not complex, and that the case was amenable to summary judgment. The court found that the registrar’s error was in concluding that the resolution of the proper construction of Clause 4 required a trial.

The court found that the proper construction of Clause 4 was a question of law, and that the parties had fully argued the question before the registrar. The court found that the case was similar to other cases in which summary judgment had been granted where a question of the proper construction of a contractual provision was at issue. The court found that the registrar’s error was in concluding that the resolution of the proper construction of Clause 4 required a trial. The court found that the summary resolution of the case was consistent with principles of good case management. The court found that the parties had urged the court to resolve the current dispute on the basis of the materials before the court without further delay. The court found that the registrar’s error was in concluding that the resolution of the proper construction of Clause 4 required a trial.

The court allowed the appeal and entered summary judgment in favour of Tah Land. The court found that Subway was liable for breaches of its obligations other than the payment of rent, and that Subway’s liability for those breaches was limited by Clause 4. The court found that Subway was liable for breaches of clauses 18, 27, 28, 37 and 38.4(b) in the lease, and that Subway’s liability for those breaches was limited by Clause 4. The court found that Subway’s liability for those breaches was limited to $40,000. The court found that Subway was liable for the payment of rent, and that Subway’s liability for the payment of rent was not limited by Clause 4. The court found that Subway was liable for the payment of rent for the period from 1 June 2017 to 30 June 2017, and that Subway’s liability for the payment of rent for that period was $10,000. The court ordered Subway to pay Tah Land $50,000.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Having made an assessment of the prospects of the competing constructions of Clause 4 advanced by the parties, I consider this to be a case that is amenable to summary judgment. Both parties confirmed at the hearing of the appeal that there was no matter of fact that needed to be resolved in order to resolve the question of the proper construction of Clause 4.[153] The proper construction of Clause 4 is a question of law[154] and the construction of that clause was fully argued before me. In this case, I do not consider the resolution of that question involved a level of complexity that made the application unsuitable for summary judgment.[153] ts 54 - ts 55 and ts 117.[154] Westport Insurance Corporation vGordian Runoff Ltd [2011] HCA 37; (2011) 244 CLR 239, 279 - 280 [82]; ThoughtWare [62]. In my view, as in Thomas and ThoughtWare, the summary resolution of this case is consistent with principles of good case management (and in this case the requirements of O 1 r 4B RSC). Following the payment made by Subway, the principal amount in issue in this case is only just within the lower threshold of this court's monetary jurisdiction. The procedure adopted should be proportionate to the value, importance and complexity of the subject matter in dispute. Further, both parties urged me to resolve the current dispute on the basis of the materials before the court without further delay. The day before the hearing of the appeal the parties sought orders from me that these proceedings be listed for trial at the time the appeal had been listed, with the trial to be conducted without cross‑examination of witnesses, on the basis of the affidavits and submissions that had been filed. I understood that the parties sought such unusual orders because they wished to avoid further delay or expense. I understood them to be concerned that I might conclude that summary judgment should not be entered because the existence of different constructions of Clause 4 meant there was an issue that required trial. In my view, Subway was right to accept that even on Tah Land's construction, Clause 4 would still have meaningful work to do in limiting Subway's liability for breaches of its obligations other than the payment of rent. A breach of some of those obligations could expose Subway to liability well in excess of $40,000. Examples include:(a)cl 18 that required Subway to maintain the Premises in good condition;(b)cl 27 which obliged Subway not to do any act or thing which might result in overloading any part of the floor of the Premises;(c)cl 28 which required Subway, not to use or store excessive amounts of chemicals or inflammable substances within the Premises;(d)cl 37 which required Subway to obtain public liability insurance and not do anything that might void that insurance; and(e)cl 38.4(b) which required Subway to indemnify Tah Land against all losses for which Tah Land becomes liable in respect of loss or damage to property or death or injury resulting from an act or omission of Subway (subject to certain exceptions).