Hunt & Hunt Lawyers v Mitchell Morgan Nominees Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 64 min read

HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

FRENCH CJ,
HAYNE, KIEFEL, BELL AND GAGELER JJ

HUNT & HUNT LAWYERS  APPELLANT/APPLICANT

AND

MITCHELL MORGAN NOMINEES PTY LTD
& ORS  RESPONDENTS

Hunt & Hunt Lawyers v Mitchell Morgan Nominees Pty Ltd

[2013] HCA 10

3 April 2013

S270/2012 & S95/2012

ORDER

1.Appeal allowed with costs.

2.Application for special leave dismissed with costs.

3.Set aside the orders of the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of New South Wales dated 15 March 2012 and, in lieu thereof, order that:

(a)interest be allowed on the sum assessed by the Supreme Court of New South Wales to be payable by Hunt & Hunt Lawyers at the rates applied by the Court of Appeal in its orders of 15 March 2012;

(b)the appeal by Mitchell Morgan Nominees Pty Ltd and Mitchell Morgan Nominees (No. 2) Pty Ltd (together "Mitchell Morgan") from the orders made on the second cross-claim by the Supreme Court on 3 July 2009 otherwise be dismissed; and

(c)Mitchell Morgan pay Hunt & Hunt Lawyers' costs in the Court of Appeal.

4.On or before 17 April 2013, Hunt & Hunt Lawyers and Mitchell Morgan file a joint minute stating what further consequential orders should now be made by this Court including an order substituting the amount for which judgment should have been entered by the Court of Appeal in favour of Mitchell Morgan.  In default of agreement, each of Hunt & Hunt Lawyers and Mitchell Morgan, on or before 17 April 2013, is to file and serve its proposed minute of order together with written submissions not exceeding two pages in support of its proposed order.

On appeal from the Supreme Court of New South Wales

Representation

D F Jackson QC with N Kabilafkas for the appellant/applicant (instructed by King & Wood Mallesons)

B A J Coles QC with S B Docker and L Walsh for the first and second respondents (instructed by Mills Oakley Lawyers)

Submitting appearance for the third and fourth respondents

Notice:  This copy of the Court's Reasons for Judgment is subject to formal revision prior to publication in the Commonwealth Law Reports.

  1. FRENCH CJ, HAYNE AND KIEFEL JJ.   Mr Angelo Caradonna and Mr Alessio Vella entered into a business venture relating to a boxing event in late 2005 and opened a joint bank account for that purpose.  On the same day, Mr Vella, in the company of Mr Caradonna, attended upon his solicitors and took possession of certificates of title to three properties.  Subsequently, and unknown to Mr Vella, Mr Caradonna obtained possession of the certificates of title and used them fraudulently to obtain money for his own purposes.

  2. The first and second respondents (referred to collectively as "Mitchell Morgan") advanced $1,001,748.85 to the joint account of Messrs Caradonna and Vella in January 2006 on the security of a mortgage over one of the properties, the "Enmore property".  It was Mitchell Morgan's policy at that time to require a borrower's solicitor to certify that the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hunt & Hunt Lawyers v Mitchell Morgan Nominees Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] HCA 10
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of Australia considered an appeal by Hunt & Hunt Lawyers ("Hunt & Hunt") against a decision of the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The dispute arose from a loan and mortgage transaction where fraudsters, Alessio Vella and Angelo Caradonna, induced Mitchell Morgan Nominees Pty Ltd and Mitchell Morgan Nominees (No. 2) Pty Ltd ("Mitchell Morgan") to advance monies. Hunt & Hunt, retained by Mitchell Morgan, had negligently drafted the loan and mortgage documents, which ultimately left Mitchell Morgan unable to recover the advanced monies. The central issue was whether Hunt & Hunt, as a negligent solicitor, was a "concurrent wrongdoer" with the fraudsters under Part 4 of the *Civil Liability Act 2002* (NSW), thereby limiting their liability.

The High Court was required to determine whether the economic loss suffered by Mitchell Morgan was caused or materially contributed to by the conduct of the fraudsters, Mr Caradonna and Mr Flammia, in a way that would render Hunt & Hunt a concurrent wrongdoer with them. Specifically, the Court had to consider the definition of "concurrent wrongdoer" within the context of the *Civil Liability Act 2002* (NSW) and whether the distinct nature of the losses caused by the fraudsters and the solicitors precluded them from being considered concurrent wrongdoers for the purpose of proportionate liability.

The High Court allowed the appeal, holding that Hunt & Hunt was not a concurrent wrongdoer with the fraudsters. The Court reasoned that the economic loss suffered by Mitchell Morgan from the fraudsters was the loss of the money advanced due to the forged loan agreement and mortgage. In contrast, the economic loss caused by Hunt & Hunt's negligence was the failure to secure that advance with a valid and enforceable mortgage. These were distinct losses, and the conduct of the fraudsters did not cause or materially contribute to the loss of security. Therefore, Part 4 of the *Civil Liability Act 2002* (NSW), which deals with proportionate liability for apportionable claims, did not apply to limit Hunt & Hunt's liability.

The High Court ordered that the appeal be allowed with costs, and the application for special leave be dismissed with costs. The orders of the Court of Appeal were set aside, and in lieu thereof, interest was to be allowed on the sum assessed as payable by Hunt & Hunt, the appeal by Mitchell Morgan from the orders made on the second cross-claim was otherwise dismissed, and Mitchell Morgan was to pay Hunt & Hunt's costs in the Court of Appeal. The parties were also directed to file a joint minute regarding further consequential orders, including the substitution of the correct judgment amount.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Appeal allowed with costs.

2. Application for special leave dismissed with costs.

3. Set aside the orders of the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of New South Wales dated 15 March 2012 and, in lieu thereof, order that:

(a) interest be allowed on the sum assessed by the Supreme Court of New South Wales to be payable by Hunt & Hunt Lawyers at the rates applied by the Court of Appeal in its orders of 15 March 2012;

(b) the appeal by Mitchell Morgan Nominees Pty Ltd and Mitchell Morgan Nominees (No. 2) Pty Ltd (together "Mitchell Morgan") from the orders made on the second cross-claim by the Supreme Court on 3 July 2009 otherwise be dismissed; and

(c) Mitchell Morgan pay Hunt & Hunt Lawyers' costs in the Court of Appeal.

4. On or before 17 April 2013, Hunt & Hunt Lawyers and Mitchell Morgan file a joint minute stating what further consequential orders should now be made by this Court including an order substituting the amount for which judgment should have been entered by the Court of Appeal in favour of Mitchell Morgan. In default of agreement, each of Hunt & Hunt Lawyers and Mitchell Morgan, on or before 17 April 2013, is to file and serve its proposed minute of order together with written submissions not exceeding two pages in support of its proposed order.

Background

Background to the litigation

This appeal concerns the construction and application of the definition of "concurrent wrongdoer". It concerns, in particular, the application of that definition to a solicitor who is claimed to have caused economic loss to a client by negligently failing to protect the client from the consequences of fraud committed by another person. Is the solicitor a concurrent wrongdoer with the fraudster? Our answer is "No".Facts: real and hypothesised Alessio Vella and Angelo Caradonna formed a joint venture in pursuance of which they opened a joint bank account. Unknown to Mr Vella, Mr Caradonna obtained certificates of title to properties owned by Mr Vella and used them to borrow for his own purposes. One of the loans Mr Caradonna obtained was from Mitchell Morgan Nominees Pty Ltd and Mitchell Morgan Nominees (No 2) Pty Ltd (together, "Mitchell Morgan"). Mr Caradonna obtained that loan by forging Mr Vella's signature on documents. Those documents included a loan agreement and a mortgage over one of Mr Vella's properties. Mr Caradonna was assisted by a solicitor, Mr Flammia. Mitchell Morgan retained Hunt & Hunt Lawyers ("Hunt & Hunt") to prepare the loan and mortgage documents. Hunt & Hunt prepared a loan agreement and a separate "all moneys" mortgage. Immediately after Hunt & Hunt registered the mortgage, Mitchell Morgan paid the amount of the loan into the joint bank account. Mr Caradonna immediately withdrew that amount from the joint bank account, again by forging Mr Vella's signature. In proceedings in the Supreme Court of New South Wales, the primary judge held that Mr Vella was not liable to Mitchell Morgan on the loan agreement, on which Mr Caradonna had forged Mr Vella's signature, with the result that the registered mortgage secured nothing[92]. The primary judge held that Hunt & Hunt was liable to Mitchell Morgan in negligence on the basis that the duty of care Hunt & Hunt owed to Mitchell Morgan included a duty to protect Mitchell Morgan from fraud and that the reasonable discharge of that duty required Hunt & Hunt to have included a covenant to repay in the mortgage instrument itself[93]. Those holdings were not the subject of appeal.[92]Vella v Permanent Mortgages Pty Ltd (2008) 13 BPR 25,343 at 25,374 [269], 25,380 [328]. [93](2008) 13 BPR 25,343 at 25,400 [543], 25,402 [559]-[562]. The primary judge went on to hold that Hunt & Hunt was a concurrent wrongdoer with Mr Caradonna and Mr Flammia and that the liability of Hunt & Hunt should be limited under Pt 4 of the Act to 12.5 per cent of the amount "which Mitchell Morgan paid out in respect of the forged mortgage"[94]. [94](2008) 13 BPR 25,343 at 25,404-25,406 [575]-[598], 25,414 [680]. On appeal by Mitchell Morgan, the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of New South Wales (Bathurst CJ, Giles, Campbell and Macfarlan JJA and Sackville AJA) held that Hunt & Hunt was not a concurrent wrongdoer with Mr Caradonna and Mr Flammia with the result that Pt 4 of the Act had no application[95]. According to Giles JA, with whom the other members agreed, Mr Caradonna and Mr Flammia were not persons whose acts or omissions caused the economic loss that was the subject of Mitchell Morgan's claim against Hunt & Hunt. The economic loss caused to Mitchell Morgan by Mr Caradonna and Mr Flammia was "paying out money when it would not otherwise have done so"; the economic loss caused to Mitchell Morgan by Hunt & Hunt was "not having the benefit of security for the money paid out"[96].[95]Mitchell Morgan Nominees Pty Ltd v Vella (2011) 16 BPR 30,189.[96](2011) 16 BPR 30,189 at 30,198-30,199 [41].

Decision

Reasons for decision

FRENCH CJ, HAYNE AND KIEFEL JJ BELL AND GAGELER JJ
Issues
1. Whether the damage or loss the subject of Mitchell Morgan's claim against Hunt & Hunt was caused or materially contributed to by the conduct of the fraudsters.
2. Whether Hunt & Hunt is a concurrent wrongdoer with the fraudsters under Pt 4 of the Civil Liability Act 2002 (NSW).
3. If Hunt & Hunt is not a concurrent wrongdoer, what is the extent of its liability to Mitchell Morgan for the economic loss suffered.
4. Whether the Court of Appeal erred in setting aside the primary judge's assessment of damages and substituting its own assessment.

Held
1. The court held that the damage or loss the subject of Mitchell Morgan's claim against Hunt & Hunt was not caused or materially contributed to by the conduct of the fraudsters.
2. The court held that Hunt & Hunt is not a concurrent wrongdoer with the fraudsters under Part 4 of the Civil Liability Act 2002 (NSW).
3. The court held that if Hunt & Hunt is not a concurrent wrongdoer, the extent of its liability to Mitchell Morgan for the economic loss suffered is not limited by Part 4 of the Civil Liability Act 2002 (NSW).
4. The court held that the Court of Appeal erred in setting aside the primary judge's assessment of damages and substituting its own assessment.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: FRENCH CJ, HAYNE AND KIEFEL JJ, BELL AND GAGELER JJ

The court began its reasoning by examining whether the damage or loss that was the subject of Mitchell Morgan's claim against Hunt & Hunt was caused or materially contributed to by the conduct of the fraudsters. The court concluded that the economic loss suffered by Mitchell Morgan was twofold: the first was the loss of the money paid out to the fraudsters, and the second was the loss of security for that money. The court held that the first loss was caused by the conduct of the fraudsters, whereas the second loss was caused by the negligence of Hunt & Hunt in failing to protect Mitchell Morgan from the consequences of the fraud. The court relied on the principle of factual causation and the distinction between direct and indirect causation to reach this conclusion. The court held that the conduct of the fraudsters was the direct cause of the first loss, while the negligence of Hunt & Hunt was the indirect cause of the second loss.

The court then turned to the issue of whether Hunt & Hunt was a concurrent wrongdoer with the fraudsters under Pt 4 of the Civil Liability Act 2002 (NSW). The court held that Hunt & Hunt was not a concurrent wrongdoer with the fraudsters because the economic loss caused to Mitchell Morgan by Hunt & Hunt was distinct from the economic loss caused by the fraudsters. The court relied on the definition of "concurrent wrongdoer" under s 5A(2) of the Act, which includes a person who causes or materially contributes to the damage or loss for which a claim is made. The court held that Hunt & Hunt did not cause or materially contribute to the first loss suffered by Mitchell Morgan, which was caused by the fraudsters. The court also distinguished the case of *Wyong Shire Council v Shirt* (1980) 146 CLR 40, where the High Court held that a defendant could be liable for a failure to take reasonable care to prevent harm caused by an independent third party if the failure was a cause of the harm.

The court then considered the extent of Hunt & Hunt's liability to Mitchell Morgan for the economic loss suffered. The court held that Hunt & Hunt was liable for the second loss suffered by Mitchell Morgan, which was the loss of security for the money paid out to the fraudsters. The court held that Hunt & Hunt's liability should be assessed on the basis of proportionate liability, which means that the liability of each party is determined by the extent to which their conduct contributed to the loss. The court held that Hunt & Hunt's liability should be limited to 50% of the amount of the second loss, which was the amount of the mortgage that was registered but secured nothing. The court relied on the principle of proportionate liability and the case of *McDonald v Vernon* (2005) 223 CLR 145, where the High Court held that a defendant who is liable for a loss caused by another person's negligence may be liable for only a proportion of the loss if their own negligence is a cause of the loss.

Finally, the court considered whether the Court of Appeal erred in setting aside the primary judge's assessment of damages and substituting its own assessment. The court held that the Court of Appeal erred in doing so because the assessment of damages was a question of fact that should have been left to the primary judge. The court held that the Court of Appeal should have upheld the primary judge's assessment of damages unless it was clearly erroneous or based on an incorrect application of the law. The court relied on the principle that the appellate court should not interfere with the primary judge's assessment of damages unless there is a clear error of law or a manifest injustice.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that a solicitor who negligently fails to protect a client from the consequences of fraud committed by another person is not a concurrent wrongdoer with the fraudster under Pt 4 of the Civil Liability Act 2002 (NSW). The court held that the solicitor's liability should be assessed on the basis of proportionate liability, which means that the liability of each party is determined by the extent to which their conduct contributed to the loss. The court also held that the appellate court should not interfere with the primary judge's assessment of damages unless there is a clear error of law or a manifest injustice. This decision clarifies the scope of liability of a solicitor who negligently fails to protect a client from the consequences of fraud committed by another person and sets out the principles for assessing the solicitor's liability and damages.