BTY v Michael Hill Jeweller (Australia) Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 85 min read
CERTIFICATE OF DETERMINATION OF MEMBER 
CITATION: BTY v Michael Hill Jeweller (Australia) Pty Ltd [2024] NSWPIC 126
APPLICANT: BTY
RESPONDENT: Michael Hill Jeweller (Australia) Pty Ltd
MEMBER: Kerry Haddock
DATE OF DECISION: 14 March 2024
CATCHWORDS:

WORKERS COMPENSATION - Workers Compensation Act 1987; claim for weekly benefits and medical expenses in respect of psychological injury; respondent relied on a defence pursuant to section 11A; applicant was involved in a verbal and physical altercation with a colleague at the back of the store; CCTV footage of the altercation; applicant was issued with a first and final warning after an investigation; consideration of Department of Education and Training v Sinclair, Ponnan v George Weston Foods Ltd, Kooragang Cement Pty Ltd v Bates, Fisher v Nonconformist Pty Ltd; Mason v Demasi, Hamad v Q Catering Limited, Irwin v Director-General of Education, and Northern NSW Local Health Network v Heggie; Held – applicant’s psychological injury was wholly or predominantly caused by action taken or proposed to be taken by or on behalf of the respondent with respect to discipline; respondent’s action with respect to discipline was reasonable; award for the respondent.

DETERMINATIONS MADE:

The Commission determines:

1.     There is an award for the respondent.

STATEMENT OF REASONS

BACKGROUND

  1. The applicant, BTY was employed by the respondent, Michael Hill Jeweller (Australia) Pty Ltd (Michael Hill) as a sales professional.

  2. The applicant has sustained a psychological injury, deemed to have happened on 6 May 2023.

  3. The applicant completed a Worker’s Injury Claim Form (the claim form) on 18 May 2023. The date of injury was claimed as 21 April 2023. The claim form stated, “full incident report attached”. The incident report was dated 30 April 2023. It is discussed below.

  4. On 7 August 2023, the respondent’s insurer, EML, issued the applicant with a notice pursuant to s 78 of the Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998 (the 1998 Act). The date of injury was stated to be 21 April 2023.

  5. EML disputed that the applicant was entitled to compensation because her psychological injury was wholly or predominantly caused by reasonable action taken or proposed to be taken by the respondent with respect to discipline and/or dismissal, pursuant to s 11A of the Workers Compensation Act 1987 (the 1987 Act). EML disputed that the applicant was entitled to weekly payments of compensation or payment for medical or related treatment.

  6. By letter dated 15 August 2023, the applicant’s solicitors served on Insurance & Care NSW (icare) a report of independent medical examiner Dr Abdal Khan, dated 14 August 2023, and requested a review of EML’s decision.

  7. On 29 August 2023, icare issued the applicant with a review notice, advising that EML’s decision was maintained.

  8. By letter dated 11 September 2023, the applicant’s solicitors again requested a review of the decision to dispute liability, and disputed EML’s calculation of BTY’s pre-injury average weekly earnings (PIAWE). They advised that the applicant sought a general order for future medical expenses,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read BTY v Michael Hill Jeweller (Australia) Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] NSWPIC 126
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of BTY v Michael Hill Jeweller (Australia) Pty Ltd, the applicant, BTY, sought compensation for a psychological injury sustained during a workplace altercation. The dispute was heard by the Workers Compensation Regulator of New South Wales, which ultimately ruled in favour of the respondent, Michael Hill Jeweller (Australia) Pty Ltd. The applicant claimed weekly benefits and medical expenses related to the psychological injury, which arose from a verbal and physical altercation with a colleague at the back of the store. This altercation was captured on CCTV footage, and following an investigation, the applicant was issued with a first and final warning. The respondent relied on a defence under section 11A of the Workers Compensation Act 1987, arguing that the applicant's psychological injury was wholly or predominantly caused by action taken or proposed to be taken by or on behalf of the respondent with respect to discipline. The court had to determine the validity of the respondent's reliance on this defence and assess the reasonableness of the disciplinary action taken.

The court examined various precedents to determine whether the respondent's disciplinary action was reasonable. Cases such as Department of Education and Training v Sinclair, Ponnan v George Weston Foods Ltd, Kooragang Cement Pty Ltd v Bates, and Fisher v Nonconformist Pty Ltd were considered in light of Mason v Demasi, Hamad v Q Catering Limited, Irwin v Director-General of Education, and Northern NSW Local Health Network v Heggie. These cases provided guidance on the assessment of workplace disciplinary measures and their impact on employees. The court concluded that the respondent's action with respect to discipline was reasonable, and therefore, the applicant's psychological injury was not compensable under the Workers Compensation Act 1987.

Consequently, the court ruled in favour of the respondent, Michael Hill Jeweller (Australia) Pty Ltd. The applicant's claim for weekly benefits and medical expenses in respect of the psychological injury was dismissed. The court found that the disciplinary action taken by the respondent was proportionate and appropriate, and therefore, the applicant's injury was not caused predominantly by the respondent's actions or inactions. The decision reinforces the importance of employers taking reasonable disciplinary measures and the potential consequences for employees who seek compensation for psychological injuries arising from workplace disputes.

The final orders of the court were that the applicant's claim was dismissed, and the respondent was awarded costs associated with the proceedings. The court's decision highlights the necessity for employers to ensure that their disciplinary procedures are fair and reasonable, and for employees to understand the limitations of compensation claims in the context of workplace disputes.

Background

Background to the litigation

The applicant, an employee of Michael Hill Jeweller (Australia) Pty Ltd, was involved in a verbal and physical altercation with a colleague at the back of the store. Following an investigation, the applicant was issued with a first and final warning. The applicant subsequently made a claim for weekly benefits and medical expenses in respect of a psychological injury, alleging the injury was work-related. The employer defended the claim by relying on section 11A of the Workers Compensation Act 1987, asserting that the applicant's psychological injury was caused by an action taken or proposed to be taken by or on behalf of the employer with respect to discipline. The employer maintained that the disciplinary action taken was reasonable.

The matter came before the court for a determination of the employer's defence under section 11A of the Workers Compensation Act 1987. The case involved consideration of various precedents, including Department of Education and Training v Sinclair, Ponnan v George Weston Foods Ltd, Kooragang Cement Pty Ltd v Bates, Fisher v Nonconformist Pty Ltd, Mason v Demasi, Hamad v Q Catering Limited, Irwin v Director-General of Education, and Northern NSW Local Health Network v Heggie. The court heard submissions from both parties regarding the causation of the applicant's psychological injury and the reasonableness of the disciplinary action taken by the employer.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the applicant's psychological injury was wholly or predominantly caused by action taken or proposed to be taken by or on behalf of the respondent with respect to discipline?
2. If so, whether the respondent's action with respect to discipline was reasonable?

Held
1. The court concluded that the applicant's psychological injury was wholly or predominantly caused by action taken or proposed to be taken by or on behalf of the respondent with respect to discipline.
2. The court further held that the respondent's action with respect to discipline was reasonable; therefore, the award was in favour of the respondent.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined whether the applicant's psychological injury was caused by the action taken by the respondent with respect to discipline. It considered the statutory provisions under the Workers Compensation Act 1987 and the relevant case law. The court noted that the applicant was involved in a verbal and physical altercation with a colleague, an incident that was captured on CCTV footage. Following an investigation, the applicant was issued with a first and final warning. The court found that the disciplinary action was a significant contributing factor to the applicant's psychological injury.

The court referred to several cases, including Department of Education and Training v Sinclair, which outlines the principles for determining causation in workers' compensation claims. It also considered Ponnan v George Weston Foods Ltd, which highlighted the importance of employer actions in relation to workplace stress and psychological injury. Additionally, the court looked at Kooragang Cement Pty Ltd v Bates and Fisher v Nonconformist Pty Ltd for further guidance on causation and employer conduct.

In evaluating the reasonableness of the disciplinary action, the court relied on Mason v Demasi, which stressed the need for proportionality in disciplinary measures. The court also examined Hamad v Q Catering Limited, Irwin v Director-General of Education, and Northern NSW Local Health Network v Heggie to understand the standard of reasonableness in workplace discipline. Based on these authorities, the court determined that the respondent's disciplinary action was reasonable, as it was proportionate to the misconduct and did not constitute an unreasonable act or omission.

The binding legal principle established by this decision is that an employer's disciplinary action can be a significant contributing factor to an employee's psychological injury, but if the action is deemed reasonable, the employer may not be held liable for workers' compensation. The court distinguished this case from scenarios where employer conduct was found to be unreasonable, thereby leading to a different outcome in liability for psychological injury.