Northern NSW Local Health Network v Heggie

Link copied
Case Copied 81 min read

Court of Appeal


Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Northern NSW Local Health Network v Heggie [2013] NSWCA 255
Hearing dates:27 May 2013
Decision date: 09 August 2013
Before: Basten JA at [1];
Ward JA at [34];
Sackville AJA at [35].
Decision:

1. Appeal allowed.

2. Set aside the orders made by the Deputy President on 28 February 2012, including the orders as to costs.

3. In lieu thereof, order that the appeal from the determination of the Arbitrator made in the Certificate of Determination dated 13 September 2011 be dismissed.

4. The respondent [Mr Heggie] pay the costs of the appellant [the Health Network] of the appeal to this Court.

5. The respondent, if otherwise qualified, have a certificate under the Suitors' Fund Act 1951.

[Note: The Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 provide (Rule 36.11) that unless the Court otherwise orders, a judgment or order is taken to be entered when it is recorded in the Court's computerised court record system. Setting aside and variation of judgments or orders is dealt with by Rules 36.15, 36.16, 36.17 and 36.18. Parties should in particular note the time limit of fourteen days in Rule 36.16.]

Catchwords: WORKERS COMPENSATION - appeal to Presidential member pursuant to Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998, s 352 - reasonableness of action taken by employer with respect to discipline - whether decision of Arbitrator affected by an error of fact - whether decision of Presidential member exceeded authority conferred by s 352(5) - whether the Presidential member erred in point of law
Legislation Cited: Mental Health Act 2007, s 19
Supreme Court Act 1970, s 75A
WorkCover Legislation Amendment Act 1996, Sch 1
Workers Compensation Act 1987, ss 9, 9A, 11A
Workers Compensation Legislation Amendment Act 2010
Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998, ss 288, 294, 352, 353, 354, 366, 368, 375
Cases Cited: Allesch v Maunz [2000] HCA 40; 203 CLR 172
Branir Pty Ltd v Owston Nominees (No 2) [2001] FCA 1833; 117 FCR 424
CDJ v VAJ [1998] HCA 67; 197 CLR 172
Coal and Allied Operations Pty Ltd v Australian Industrial Relations Commission [2000] HCA 47; 203 CLR 194
Commissioner of Police v Minahan [2003] NSWCA 239
Department of Education and Training v Sinclair [2005] NSWCA 465; 4 DDCR 206
Irwin v Director-General of School Education (Compensation Court, 18 June 1998, unreported)
Jeffery v Lintipal Pty Ltd [2008] NSWCA 138
Kostas v HIA Insurance Services Pty Ltd [2010] HCA 32; 241 CLR 390
Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Yusuf [2001] HCA 30; 206 CLR 323
Norbis v Norbis [1986] HCA 17; 161 CLR 513
Onesteel Reinforcing Pty Ltd v Sutton [2012] NSWCA 282
Raulston v Toll Pty Ltd [2011] NSWWCCPD 25
State Transit Authority of New South Wales v Chemler [2007] NSWCA 249; 5 DDCR 286
Warren v Coombes [1979] HCA 9; 142 CLR 531
Watson v Qantas Airways Ltd [2009] NSWCA 322
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Northern NSW Local Health Network v Heggie and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] NSWCA 255
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal before the Court of Appeal of New South Wales concerned a decision of a Presidential Member of the Workers Compensation Commission, which had overturned an Arbitrator's determination. The dispute arose from a workers' compensation claim by Mr. Heggie against the Northern NSW Local Health Network, relating to a psychological injury allegedly sustained as a result of the Health Network's actions in disciplining him.

The primary legal issue before the Court of Appeal was whether the Deputy President, in hearing the appeal from the Arbitrator, had erred in point of law by failing to determine the correct question posed by section 352(5) of the *Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998* (WIM Act). Specifically, the Court had to consider if the Deputy President had correctly assessed whether the Arbitrator's decision regarding the reasonableness of the Health Network's actions was affected by an error of fact.

The Court found that the Deputy President had indeed committed an error of law. While the Arbitrator had determined that the Health Network's actions, including suspending Mr. Heggie on full pay and initiating an investigation, were reasonable, the Deputy President had considered a broader range of disciplinary actions, some of which were not found by the Arbitrator to be causative of the injury. By addressing a different question than that mandated by section 352(5) of the WIM Act, the Deputy President had exceeded the authority conferred by the legislation.

Consequently, the Court allowed the appeal, set aside the Deputy President's orders, and ordered that the appeal from the Arbitrator's decision be dismissed. The Court also ordered that Mr. Heggie pay the costs of the Health Network for the appeal to the Court of Appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Appeal allowed.

2. Set aside the orders made by the Deputy President on 28 February 2012, including the orders as to costs.

3. In lieu thereof, order that the appeal from the determination of the Arbitrator made in the Certificate of Determination dated 13 September 2011 be dismissed.

4. The respondent [Mr Heggie] pay the costs of the appellant [the Health Network] of the appeal to this Court.

5. The respondent, if otherwise qualified, have a certificate under the Suitors' Fund Act 1951.

[Note: The Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 provide (Rule 36.11) that unless the Court otherwise orders, a judgment or order is taken to be entered when it is recorded in the Court's computerised court record system. Setting aside and variation of judgments or orders is dealt with by Rules 36.15, 36.16, 36.17 and 36.18. Parties should in particular note the time limit of fourteen days in Rule 36.16.]

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Northern NSW Local Health Network v Heggie revolves around a disciplinary action taken by the employer against an employee, Mr Heggie, and the subsequent appeals process. Mr Heggie was employed by the Northern NSW Local Health Network and was suspended on full pay while the employer investigated allegations of misconduct against him. Following an arbitration decision that the employer's actions were reasonable, Mr Heggie appealed to a Deputy President under the Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998. The Deputy President's decision was then appealed to a Presidential member.

The factual events leading to the dispute began when the Health Network received information that Mr Heggie had engaged in misconduct. As a result, the Health Network suspended Mr Heggie on full pay and initiated an investigation into the allegations against him. Mr Heggie subsequently claimed that the suspension and investigation caused him psychological injury, leading to a workers' compensation claim. An Arbitrator initially found that the Health Network's actions were reasonable, which Mr Heggie appealed. The Deputy President's review of the Arbitrator's decision addressed a broader scope of disciplinary actions than what was mandated by statute, leading to the current appeal by the Health Network.

The Health Network argued that the Deputy President had erred in point of law by considering a wider range of disciplinary actions than required by the Act. The Health Network sought to have the Deputy President's orders set aside and for the appeal to be dismissed. Mr Heggie did not contest that if the Deputy President had indeed erred, the appropriate course would be to dismiss the appeal and order the Health Network to pay his costs. The Health Network also noted that its notice of appeal did not seek an order for Mr Heggie to pay its costs of the appeal to the Commission from the Arbitrator's decision.

The matter of Northern NSW Local Health Network v Heggie came before the court on appeal from the decision of a Deputy President of the Commission, which had itself been an appeal from an earlier decision of an Arbitrator. The original Arbitrator had determined that the actions taken by the Health Network with respect to the discipline of Mr Heggie were reasonable, and Mr Heggie subsequently appealed this decision to the Deputy President. The Deputy President, however, found an error of law in the reasoning of the Arbitrator and upheld the appeal, which led the Health Network to seek further review by a Presidential member of the Commission. The appeal to the Presidential member focused on whether the Deputy President's decision was itself affected by an error of law, specifically by addressing a different question than mandated by the relevant statutory provisions. The court found that the Deputy President did indeed address an incorrect question, leading to an error in law, and thus the matter was remitted back for reconsideration in accordance with the court's directions. The Health Network's appeal to the court was ultimately successful, resulting in the orders made by the Deputy President being set aside and the original Arbitrator's decision being reinstated.

Decision

Reasons for decision

I accept that the Deputy President's task of interpreting the Arbitrator's reasons and findings was by no means straightforward. Nonetheless, the Deputy President was required by s 352(5) of the WIM Act to determine whether the decision appealed against was affected by an error of fact. Reading the Arbitrator's reasons as a whole, his decision was that the actions of the Health Network in suspending Mr Heggie on full pay and initiating an investigation into the allegations against him were reasonable. The Deputy President had to consider whether that decision was affected by an error of fact. In my view, the Deputy President addressed a different question. He considered whether the Arbitrator had fallen into error in finding that a wider range of actions with respect to discipline had been reasonable. Those actions included some that the Arbitrator had not found to be causative of Mr Heggie's psychological injury. By addressing a question other than the one mandated by s 352(5) of the WIM Act, the Deputy President committed an error in point of law. If a decision of the Commission on appeal from an Arbitrator is affected by an error in point of law, the Court may remit the matter to the Commission constituted by a Presidential member for determination in accordance with the Court's decision and may make such other orders in relation to the appeal as the Court thinks fit: WIM Act, s 353(2). The Health Network's notice of appeal sought orders setting aside the orders made by the Deputy President and instead ordering that the appeal from the Arbitrator's decision be dismissed. Mr Hale did not suggest that if the Deputy President erred in point of law that there would be any utility in remitting the matter to the Deputy President. Nor did he dispute that it would be appropriate to make the orders sought in the Health Network's notice of appeal. In these circumstances, I think that orders should be made finally resolving this matter. I propose the following orders: I note that the notice of appeal does not seek an order that Mr Heggie pay the Health Network's costs of the appeal to the Commission from the decision of the Arbitrator.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court in Northern NSW Local Health Network v Heggie considered several issues pertaining to the interpretation and application of the Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998 (WIM Act). Firstly, the Court examined whether the decision of the Arbitrator was affected by an error of fact as required to be determined by s 352(5) of the WIM Act. The Arbitrator had found that the actions of the Health Network in suspending Mr Heggie and initiating an investigation were reasonable. The Deputy President's task was to ascertain whether this decision was tainted by an error of fact. The Deputy President, however, strayed from this mandate by considering whether the Arbitrator had erred in finding a wider range of disciplinary actions reasonable, which was not the precise question posed by s 352(5) of the WIM Act.

Secondly, the Court scrutinized whether the Deputy President's decision was affected by an error of fact by addressing a different question than that mandated by s 352(5) of the WIM Act. The Deputy President's consideration of whether the Arbitrator had erred in finding that a broader range of disciplinary actions were reasonable diverged from the statutory requirement to determine solely whether the Arbitrator's decision was affected by an error of fact. This deviation meant that the Deputy President was assessing a different issue, thus failing to adhere to the statutory mandate.

Thirdly, the Court determined whether the Deputy President's consideration of a different question constituted an error in point of law. By addressing a question other than the one mandated by s 352(5) of the WIM Act, the Deputy President indeed committed an error in point of law. The Court held that such an error warranted the Court's intervention to correct the Deputy President's deviation from the statutory requirement.

Fourthly, the Court considered whether, given the error in point of law, the matter should be remitted to the Commission or whether the Court should make orders finally resolving the matter. Section 353(2) of the WIM Act provides that if a decision of the Commission on appeal from an Arbitrator is affected by an error in point of law, the Court may remit the matter to the Commission or make such other orders as it deems fit. In this case, the Health Network's notice of appeal sought orders to set aside the Deputy President's orders and to dismiss the appeal from the Arbitrator's decision. Given that the Deputy President had committed an error in point of law and there was no suggestion that remitting the matter would be beneficial, the Court found it appropriate to make orders finally resolving the matter.

Lastly, the Court addressed whether Mr Heggie should pay the Health Network's costs of the appeal to the Commission from the decision of the Arbitrator. The notice of appeal did not seek an order for Mr Heggie to pay these costs. Therefore, the Court did not make such an order. Instead, the Court ordered that Mr Heggie pay the Health Network's costs of the appeal to the Court, ensuring that the prevailing party was compensated for the costs incurred in the legal proceedings.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that when a Deputy President of the Commission addresses a different question than that mandated by s 352(5) of the WIM Act, such action constitutes an error in point of law, warranting the Court's intervention to correct the error. If such an error is identified, the Court may either remit the matter to the Commission or make orders finally resolving the matter, as appropriate. This case also reinforces the principle that unless explicitly sought, the Court will not order a party to pay the costs of an appeal from an Arbitrator's decision to the Commission.