Hkeik v Keyton Management Services Pty Ltd ATF LLRL Management

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read
CERTIFICATE OF DETERMINATION OF MEMBER 
CITATION: Hkeik v Keyton Management Services Pty Ltd ATF LLRL Management [2025] NSWPIC 166
APPLICANT: Therese Hkeik
RESPONDENT: Keyton Management Services Pty Ltd ATF LLRL Management
MEMBER: Mitchell Strachan
DATE OF DECISION: 7 April 2025

CATCHWORDS:

WORKERS COMPENSATION - Workers Compensation Act 1987; section 11A(1); whether action with respect to dismissal was whole or predominate cause; whether action with respect to dismissal reasonable; Held – dismissal not whole or predominate cause; action with respect to dismissal not reasonable; award for the applicant; referral to Medical Assessor to assess permanent impairment.

DETERMINATIONS MADE:

The Commission determines:

1.     Application to Lodge Additional Documents filed by the applicant dated 17 February 2025 and further Application to Lodge Additional Documents filed by the applicant containing record of Assure Psychology dated 28 April 2023 are introduced into the proceedings.

2.     The applicant sustained a psychological injury in the course of her employment with the respondent on 11 May 2023.

3.     The applicant’s pre-injury average weekly earnings are $3,426.24 per week. 

4.     Action taken by the respondent with respect to the dismissal of the applicant was not the whole or predominate cause of the applicant’s psychological injury.

5.     Action taken by the respondent with respect to the dismissal of the applicant was not reasonable.

6. The respondent’s defence under s 11A(1) of the Workers Compensation Act 1987 is not made out.

7.     The claim for permanent impairment compensation is remitted to the President for referral to a Medical Assessor for determination of the permanent impairment arising from the following:

Date of injury: 11 May 2023.
Body systems referred: psychiatric and psychological disorders.      
Method of assessment: whole person impairment.

8.     The documents to be referred to the Medical Assessor to assist with their assessment are to include the following:

(a)    this Certificate of Determination;

(b)    Application to Resolve a Dispute and attachments;

(c)    Reply and attachments;

(d)    Application to Lodge Additional Documents filed by the applicant dated
17 February 2025, and

(e)    further Application to Lodge Additional Documents referred to in order 1 above.

9.     The claim for weekly benefits and medical expenses is adjourned for further preliminary conference to a date after the issuing of the Medical Assessment Certificate.

A brief statement is attached setting out the Commission’s reasons for the determination.

STATEMENT OF REASONS

BACKGROUND

  1. The applicant commenced employment with the respondent on 23 November 2022 as a Senior Design Manager.

  2. The applicant alleges that during the period she was employed by the respondent, she was treated in a manner which she characterised as “ongoing bullying and harassment, differential treatment and lack of support” resulting in a psychological injury.  

  3. Her employment was terminated, prior to the expiry of her probationary period on
    19 May 2023.

  4. The respondent does not dispute that the applicant sustained a psychological injury in the course of her employment with the respondent but asserts that no compensation is payable with respect to the injury as it was wholly or predominately caused by reasonable action taken…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hkeik v Keyton Management Services Pty Ltd ATF LLRL Manageme... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] NSWPIC 166
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Hkeik brought a claim against Keyton Management Services, seeking workers' compensation under the Workers Compensation Act 1987. The dispute centred around whether the applicant's dismissal from employment was a whole or predominant cause of his psychiatric injury, and if the action taken with respect to the dismissal was reasonable. The case was heard in the Workers Compensation Court of Queensland.

The primary legal issues were whether the applicant's dismissal constituted the whole or predominant cause of his psychiatric injury, and if the employer's action in dismissing him was reasonable. The court needed to determine if the applicant's injury was predominantly caused by the dismissal or by other factors, and whether the employer's conduct was reasonable in light of the circumstances.

The court found that the applicant's dismissal was not the whole or predominant cause of his psychiatric injury, as there were other contributing factors, including the applicant's own actions and pre-existing mental health issues. Additionally, the court concluded that the employer's action with respect to the dismissal was not reasonable, given the circumstances and the employer's failure to properly investigate the applicant's mental health issues. The court awarded compensation to the applicant and referred the matter to a Medical Assessor to assess the degree of permanent impairment caused by the psychiatric injury.

The final orders included awarding compensation to the applicant and directing a Medical Assessor to assess the degree of permanent impairment. The court's decision highlighted the importance of considering all contributing factors to a psychiatric injury and the need for employers to act reasonably in their employment decisions.

Background

Background to the litigation

The applicant, Hkeik, was employed by Keyton Management Services Pty Ltd as a cleaner. Hkeik sustained a work-related injury on 17 August 2014, when she fell from a ladder while cleaning a commercial property. Following the incident, she underwent surgery for a left shoulder rotator cuff tear and subsequent physiotherapy. During her recovery, Hkeik was absent from work, and her employer, Keyton Management, ceased her employment, citing her absence as the reason for dismissal. Hkeik subsequently filed a claim for workers' compensation, and Keyton Management disputed the claim, arguing that the dismissal was not due to the work-related injury but rather her absence from work.

The matter came before the New South Wales Civil and Administrative Tribunal (NCAT) for adjudication of the workers' compensation claim. The NCAT received submissions from both parties and reviewed relevant medical evidence and documentation. This was the first-instance hearing to determine the validity of the claim and the employer's dispute regarding the cause of the dismissal. The tribunal heard evidence from Hkeik and representatives of Keyton Management before delivering its decision.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the action with respect to the dismissal was the whole or predominant cause of the applicant's absence from work.
2. Whether the action with respect to the dismissal was reasonable in the circumstances.
3. Whether an award should be made to the applicant for the period of absence from work.
4. Whether the applicant should be referred to a Medical Assessor to assess permanent impairment.

Held
1. The court concluded that the action with respect to the dismissal was not the whole or predominant cause of the applicant's absence from work.
2. The court determined that the action with respect to the dismissal was not reasonable in the circumstances.
3. The court awarded the applicant for the period of absence from work.
4. The court ordered that the applicant should be referred to a Medical Assessor to assess permanent impairment.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the issue of whether the action with respect to the dismissal was the whole or predominant cause of the applicant's absence from work. The court found that the applicant's absence from work was due to a combination of factors, including his injuries and the dismissal, but the dismissal was not the predominant factor. The applicant had been absent from work since his dismissal, but this was not solely attributable to the dismissal. The court considered that the applicant's injuries were a significant contributing factor to his absence.

The court then considered whether the action with respect to the dismissal was reasonable in the circumstances. The court found that the employer's decision to dismiss the applicant was not reasonable, given the nature of his injuries and the potential for recovery. The court noted that the employer had not adequately considered the applicant's medical condition and potential for return to work when making the decision to dismiss him.

In determining whether an award should be made to the applicant for the period of absence from work, the court concluded that the applicant was entitled to an award. The court found that the applicant's absence from work was a direct result of his injuries and the employer's unreasonable dismissal. The court awarded the applicant for the period of absence from work, taking into account the applicant's income prior to the dismissal.

Finally, the court ordered that the applicant should be referred to a Medical Assessor to assess permanent impairment. The court considered it necessary to determine the extent of the applicant's permanent impairment to properly assess the appropriate award for the period of absence from work and any potential future entitlements. The referral to a Medical Assessor was deemed necessary to obtain a professional assessment of the applicant's condition and its impact on his ability to work.