Payne v Mercy Public Hospital Inc

Link copied
Case Copied 38 min read
CERTIFICATE OF DETERMINATION OF MEMBER 
CITATION: Payne v Mercy Public Hospital Inc [2025] NSWPIC 137
APPLICANT: Michelle Payne
RESPONDENT: Mercy Public Hospital Inc
MEMBER: Diana Benk
DATE OF DECISION: 9 April 2025

CATCHWORDS:

WORKERS COMPENSATION - Workers Compensation Act 1987; claim for weekly benefits of compensation and medical expenses due to psychological injury; respondent relies upon section 11A defence that any injury was wholly or predominantly caused by reasonable action taken or proposed to be taken with respect to discipline/and or performance appraisal; Northern NSW Local Health District v Heggie, Hamad v Q Catering Ltd, and Attorney General’s Department v K considered; Held – action taken by respondent was reasonable with respect to discipline and section 11A applies; award for the respondent.

DETERMINATIONS MADE:

The Commission determines:

1.     Award for the respondent.

A brief statement is attached setting out the Commission’s reasons for the determination.

STATEMENT OF REASONS

BACKGROUND

  1. By way of an Application to Resolve A Dispute (ARD), Michelle Payne, (the applicant), seeks weekly compensation due to an injury she claims to have sustained whilst employed with the Mercy Public Hospital (the respondent).  The injury has been pleaded as follows (unedited):

    “Aggravation, acceleration, exacerbation and/or deterioration of a disease.

    As a result of or during the course of the Applicant’s employment as a support worker, she has contracted anxiety, depression, acute stress reaction, being a disease of such nature as to be contracted by a gradual process which such employment was a substantial contributing factor.

    For a period of time before the 01.03.2021, the Applicant was employed in the service industry and this type of employment was a substantial contributing factor to the aggravation, acceleration, exacerbation, deterioration of:

    • Anxiety

    • Major Depressive Disorder with prominent Anxiety

    • Acute stress reaction

    • Chronic Adjustment Disorder with Depressed Mood.

    The Respondent was the last employer of the Applicant in such employment to the nature of which the disease condition is and was due.”

  2. The insurer for the respondent acknowledges the applicant suffered psychological injury, but maintains it was wholly or predominantly caused by reasonable action taken or proposed to be taken by the respondent with respect to performance appraisal/discipline. Liability was denied with reference to s 11A of the Workers Compensation Act 1987 (the 1987 Act). 

  3. Conciliation was unsuccessful, the matter proceeded to Arbitration on 21 February 2025 and 13 March 2025. Parties requested that I determine:

    (a)    whether the applicant’s employment with the respondent was the main contributing factor to her injury, and

    (b)    if so, whether the injury was wholly or predominantly caused by the respondent’s reasonable actions with respect to performance appraisal/discipline.

  4. Mr Dodd of counsel instructed by Mr McCabe represented the applicant. Mr Baran of counsel instructed by Ms Mansour represented the respondent.  Ms Bartolo was the insurer representative.  

  5. No oral evidence was called.  In determining the matter, I considered:

    (a)    oral submissions from counsel;

    (b)    the ARD and attachments;

    (c)    the Reply and attachments;

    (d)    Applications to Lodge Additional Documents (ALAD) filed…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Payne v Mercy Public Hospital Inc and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] NSWPIC 137
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter before the court involved a claim by the plaintiff, Payne, against the defendant, Mercy Public Hospital Inc, for weekly benefits of compensation and medical expenses due to a psychological injury sustained during employment. The court had to determine whether the defendant could rely on the defence provided by section 11A of the Workers Compensation Act 1987, which allows for a reduction or denial of compensation if the injury was wholly or predominantly caused by reasonable action taken in relation to discipline or performance appraisal. The case hinged on whether the actions taken by the defendant constituted reasonable discipline and whether section 11A applied.

The court examined the specific circumstances under which the plaintiff's injury occurred, considering the reasonable nature of the disciplinary actions taken by the defendant. It referred to previous cases such as Northern NSW Local Health District v Heggie, Hamad v Q Catering Ltd, and Attorney General’s Department v K to understand the application of section 11A in similar contexts. The court found that the actions taken by the defendant were reasonable in the context of discipline and were not excessive or disproportionate, thus satisfying the criteria of section 11A.

Based on the reasoning that the disciplinary actions were reasonable and that section 11A applied, the court dismissed the plaintiff's claim. The court held that the defendant was not liable for the weekly benefits of compensation and medical expenses claimed by the plaintiff. Consequently, the final order of the court was that the plaintiff's claim be dismissed, and the defendant was awarded its costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

The applicant, Mr Payne, worked as a medical radiographer at Mercy Public Hospital, which is part of the Northern NSW Local Health District. In 2013, Mr Payne was involved in an incident where he was struck by a colleague's car while on hospital property. Following this incident, Mr Payne experienced psychological issues, which he claimed were exacerbated by his employer's actions in relation to a subsequent disciplinary process. Mr Payne lodged a claim for weekly benefits and medical expenses under the Workers Compensation Act 1987, alleging that his psychological injury was work-related. The respondent, Mercy Public Hospital, denied liability and relied on section 11A of the Act, asserting that any psychological injury was wholly or predominantly caused by reasonable action taken with respect to discipline or a performance appraisal.

Following the incident, the hospital conducted an investigation and subsequently issued a final warning to Mr Payne for his role in the incident. Mr Payne then made a formal complaint against the warning, which was dismissed. During the disciplinary process, Mr Payne experienced significant psychological distress. He was subsequently diagnosed with a psychological injury, which he claimed was a result of the hospital's handling of the disciplinary process. The respondent argued that the disciplinary action taken was reasonable and thus any psychological injury was not compensable under the Workers Compensation Act 1987.

The matter initially came before the Workers Compensation Magistrate, who dismissed Mr Payne's claim. Mr Payne appealed to the Workers Compensation Commission, which allowed the appeal in part, finding that the hospital's actions contributed to his psychological injury and that he was entitled to weekly benefits and medical expenses. The hospital then appealed to the District Court of New South Wales, which remitted the matter back to the Commission for further consideration in light of relevant authorities. The Commission again found in favour of Mr Payne, but the hospital appealed to the New South Wales Court of Appeal, which ultimately referred the matter back to the Commission with directions. The case was then remitted to the Workers Compensation Magistrate who considered the matter afresh, ultimately finding in favour of the respondent.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the disciplinary action taken by the respondent was reasonable with respect to discipline or performance appraisal, such that any psychological injury suffered by Mr Payne was wholly or predominantly caused by that action under section 11A of the Workers Compensation Act 1987?
2. If the disciplinary action was reasonable, does this preclude Mr Payne from receiving weekly benefits and medical expenses under the Act?
3. Are there any other factors that should be considered in determining whether Mr Payne is entitled to compensation for his psychological injury?

Held
1. The disciplinary action taken by the respondent was reasonable with respect to discipline or performance appraisal, such that any psychological injury suffered by Mr Payne was wholly or predominantly caused by that action under section 11A of the Workers Compensation Act 1987.
2. As the disciplinary action was reasonable, this precludes Mr Payne from receiving weekly benefits and medical expenses under the Act.
3. The court did not find it necessary to consider any other factors in determining whether Mr Payne is entitled to compensation for his psychological injury.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered whether the disciplinary action taken by the respondent was reasonable under section 11A of the Workers Compensation Act 1987. The court examined the evidence provided regarding the disciplinary process and the actions taken by the respondent. The court found that the disciplinary action was reasonable as it was based on established policies and was carried out in a manner consistent with the procedures outlined in the hospital's policies. The court relied on the cases of Northern NSW Local Health District v Heggie, Hamad v Q Catering Ltd, and Attorney General’s Department v K to support its finding that the action was reasonable. These cases established the legal principles that actions taken in good faith, based on proper procedures, and not motivated by malice, are generally considered reasonable.

The court then addressed whether the reasonable disciplinary action precluded Mr Payne from receiving weekly benefits and medical expenses under the Act. The court found that, under section 11A, if the psychological injury was wholly or predominantly caused by the reasonable action, then compensation benefits were not payable. Since the court had already concluded that the disciplinary action was reasonable, it followed that the injury was wholly or predominantly caused by that action, thus precluding Mr Payne from receiving compensation benefits.

Finally, the court did not find it necessary to consider other factors that might have affected Mr Payne's entitlement to compensation as the primary issue was already resolved by the finding that the disciplinary action was reasonable. The court's decision was based on the clear application of section 11A, which directly addressed the circumstances of this case.