Pabai v Commonwealth of Australia (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 86 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Pabai v Commonwealth of Australia (No 2) [2025] FCA 796

File number: VID 622 of 2021
Judgment of: WIGNEY J
Date of judgment: 15 July 2025
Catchwords:

NEGLIGENCE – representative proceeding on behalf of Torres Strait Islanders against the Commonwealth of Australia – whether the Commonwealth has a duty to take reasonable steps to protect Torres Strait Islanders from the impacts of climate change – whether impacts of marine inundation and erosion caused property damage, loss of fulfilment of Ailan Kastom, and injury, disease or death – whether the loss of fulfilment of Ailan Kastom, the body of customs, traditions and beliefs distinctive to Torres Strait Islanders which creates a unique spiritual connection with the Torres Strait Islands and surrounding waters, is a compensable loss under the law of negligence – imposition of novel duties of care considered – whether posited duties of care would require the Court to pass judgment on issues of high or core government policy and political judgment – factual findings of the severe impacts of human-induced climate change on the Torres Strait Islands – ecosystems damaged and destroyed – devastating impacts on the traditional way of life and the ability to practise Ailan Kastom

EMISSIONS REDUCTION TARGETS – whether Commonwealth owed the applicants and Torres Strait Islanders a duty of care to take reasonable steps to set greenhouse gas emissions reduction targets having regard to the “Best Available Science” which prevent or minimise impacts of climate change in the region – where Commonwealth set greenhouse gas emissions reduction targets and provided those targets to the UN Convention on Climate Change as Nationally Determined Contributions pursuant to Art 4.2 of the Paris Agreement in 2015, 2020, 2021 and 2022 – whether those emissions reduction targets were set having regard to the best available science – where best available science indicates global average temperature increase must be held to well below 2°C above pre-industrial levels to limit the worst effects of climate change – whether setting emissions reduction targets are a matter of high or core government policy – whether relationship between the applicants and the Commonwealth more than a relationship between the governing and the governed –  whether posited standard of care appropriate – whether any breach of the alleged duty of care in respect of setting emissions reduction targets caused applicants to suffer compensable damage – whether Commonwealth materially contributed to loss or damage suffered by the applicants as a result of climate change – duty of care not established – factual findings that the Commonwealth failed to give genuine consideration of the best available science – Australian emissions reduction targets inconsistent with international obligations and objectives

CLIMATE CHANGE ADAPTATION – alleged duty of care to take reasonable care to protect against marine inundation and erosion – standard of care said to require the provision of predictable, adequate funding for the construction of seawalls and the leading and coordinating of a plan for funding – whether delays in funding…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Pabai v Commonwealth of Australia (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] FCA 796
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Pabai v Commonwealth of Australia (No 2) involved Torres Strait Islanders who sought compensation from the Commonwealth for the impacts of climate change, including property damage, loss of fulfilment of Ailan Kastom, and injuries, diseases, or deaths. The applicants argued that the Commonwealth had a duty to take reasonable steps to protect them from the impacts of climate change, including setting greenhouse gas emissions reduction targets, and providing adequate funding for the construction of seawalls to protect against marine inundation and erosion.

The court was required to determine whether the Commonwealth owed a duty of care to the applicants to take reasonable steps to set greenhouse gas emissions reduction targets in line with the best available science, and to provide adequate funding for the construction of seawalls. The court also considered whether the loss of fulfilment of Ailan Kastom was a compensable loss under the law of negligence. The court held that the posited duties of care would require it to pass judgment on issues of high or core government policy and political judgment, which would be inappropriate. The court found that the Commonwealth had set emissions reduction targets and provided funding for the construction of seawalls, but that the funding shortfall was not caused by any carelessness or neglect on the part of the Commonwealth.

The court held that the applicants had not established a breach of the alleged duty of care, and that any loss or damage suffered by the applicants as a result of inundation events could not be attributed to any breach of the duty of care. The court also held that the loss of fulfilment of Ailan Kastom was not a compensable loss under the law of negligence. The court found that declarations and injunctive relief sought by the applicants were inappropriate.

The court dismissed the proceeding and ordered the parties to confer and provide the Court with either agreed draft orders or competing draft orders, together with an outline of submissions in respect of the competing orders, and a note as to whether an oral hearing is requested to resolve the outstanding issues in respect of the orders.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The parties are to confer, through their legal advisers, and by no later than six weeks after the delivery of this judgment, provide the Court with either:

(a) agreed draft orders which give effect to this judgment and dispose of the proceeding, including in relation to costs; or

(b) if no agreement can be reached concerning the orders, competing draft orders, together with an outline of submissions (not exceeding ten pages in length) in respect of the competing orders, together with a note as to whether an oral hearing is requested to resolve the outstanding issues in respect of the orders.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves a representative proceeding on behalf of Torres Strait Islanders against the Commonwealth of Australia. The applicants sought to establish that the Commonwealth had a duty to take reasonable steps to protect Torres Strait Islanders from the impacts of climate change, including marine inundation and erosion, which resulted in property damage, loss of fulfilment of Ailan Kastom, and injury, disease, or death. Ailan Kastom refers to the customs, traditions, and beliefs of the Torres Strait Islanders, creating a unique spiritual connection with the Torres Strait Islands and surrounding waters. The applicants argued that the loss of fulfilment of Ailan Kastom constituted a compensable loss under the law of negligence. The case also explored whether the Commonwealth owed a duty of care to set greenhouse gas emissions reduction targets based on the best available science to prevent or minimise the impacts of climate change in the region. Additionally, the applicants claimed the Commonwealth had a duty to provide adequate funding for seawall construction to protect against marine inundation and erosion.

The matter came before the Federal Court as an application for declarations and injunctive relief. The applicants sought declarations regarding the existence and breach of a duty of care by the Commonwealth. They also sought an injunction to compel the Commonwealth to implement measures to protect the environment, cultural and customary rights, and reduce emissions. The case did not proceed to a final hearing on the merits, as the court found that the applicants did not establish the necessary duties of care and that no breach of such duties caused them compensable damage.

Decision

Reasons for decision

I should finally note that the applicants also submitted that the Commonwealth breached the alleged alternative duty of care because the funding that it provided was inadequate to construct all the seawalls that the Seawalls Project envisaged would be constructed on the six islands in question. As discussed earlier, that submission is somewhat confounding given that the Commonwealth provided all the funding that it was requested to provide. In any event, for the reasons given earlier, I reject the applicants’ submission that the fact that the funds ultimately provided by the Commonwealth and Queensland Government were insufficient to complete the Seawalls Project was attributable to any carelessness or breach of duty on the part of the Commonwealth. The inadequacy of the funding appears to have been the product of cost overruns and the overall implementation of the project by the TSIRC and its contractors. I do not accept that the inadequacy of the funding that was provided by the Commonwealth and Queensland Governments can be attributed to any carelessness on the part of the Commonwealth. Nor do I accept that the standard of care that the Commonwealth had to meet required it to make up for any funding shortfalls that arose as a result of cost overruns or the overall implementation of the project by the TSIRC. Conclusion in respect of breach of duty Even if the Commonwealth is found to have owed the alternative duty of care to Torres Strait Islanders, I am not satisfied that the standard of care referrable to that duty of care was the standard of care posited by the applicants. Nor am I persuaded that the Commonwealth breached what I would consider to be the appropriate standard of care. Ultimately, the Commonwealth provided all the funding that it was requested to provide for the Seawalls Project. While there were delays in the funding process, those delays were not solely attributable to the Commonwealth and were not unreasonable in all the circumstances. Moreover, while there was a shortfall in the funding necessary to complete the project, I am not persuaded that the shortfall was caused by any carelessness or neglect on the part of the Commonwealth. Did any breach of the duty of care in respect of the funding of the Seawalls Project cause the applicants to suffer any compensable damage? Given the findings that I have made concerning the alternative duty of care and breach, it is unnecessary to address whether the applicants proved that any breach of the alternative duty of care caused the applicants to suffer any compensable loss. It is, however, possible to address that issue shortly on the hypothetical basis that the applicants had made out their case in respect of duty and breach. The short answer is that I am not persuaded that the applicants would have made out their case in relation to causation and damage in any event. Loss and damage allegedly suffered by the applicants The applicants’ case in respect of loss or damage caused by the Commonwealth’s breach of the alternative duty of care was based on the occurrence of various inundation or flooding events on Boigu, where Mr Pabai Pabai resided, and Saibai, where Mr Kabai resided. Some of those events, however, occurred before 2011, when the TSIRC applied for funding for the Seawalls Project. Given the limited scope of the applicants’ case in respect of the breach of the alternative duty, it could not sensibly be said that any breach of that duty caused or contributed to any loss or damage suffered by the applicants as a result of inundation events which occurred before 2011. Similarly, it could not sensibly be said that any loss or damage suffered by the applicants as a result of inundation events which occurred after construction of the seawalls on Boigu and Saibai was completed could be attributed to any breach of the adaptation duty. The seawall on Saibai was completed in 2017 and the seawall on Boigu was completed in March 2022.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by considering whether the Commonwealth had a duty to take reasonable steps to protect Torres Strait Islanders from the impacts of climate change. The court found that imposing such a duty would require the Court to pass judgment on issues of high or core government policy and political judgment, which is beyond the Court's remit. The court noted that the Commonwealth had already taken various steps to address climate change and had set greenhouse gas emissions reduction targets. However, these targets were found not to be based on the best available science, and the Commonwealth had failed to give genuine consideration to the best available science. The court also found that the Commonwealth did not owe a duty of care to set emissions reduction targets based on the best available science, as setting such targets was a matter of high or core government policy.

The court further considered whether the loss of fulfilment of Ailan Kastom constituted a compensable loss under the law of negligence. The court found that such a loss did not constitute a compensable loss under the law of negligence. The court noted that the loss of fulfilment of Ailan Kastom was a consequence of climate change, and the Court was not prepared to impose a duty of care on the Commonwealth to prevent such a loss.

The court also considered whether the Commonwealth had a duty to provide adequate funding for seawall construction to protect against marine inundation and erosion. The court found that imposing such a duty would require the Court to pass judgment on the reasonableness of government policy, intergovernmental relations, and budgetary priorities, which is beyond the Court's remit. The court noted that the Commonwealth had provided all the requested funding for the Seawalls Project, and any delays in the funding process were not solely attributable to the Commonwealth or unreasonable in all the circumstances. The court also found that the shortfall in the funding necessary to complete the project was not caused by any carelessness or neglect on the part of the Commonwealth.

Finally, the court considered whether the Commonwealth had breached any duty of care by failing to provide adequate funding for the Seawalls Project. The court found that the Commonwealth had not breached any duty of care, as the shortfall in funding was the product of cost overruns and the overall implementation of the project by the TSIRC and its contractors. The court also found that the applicants had not proved that any breach of the duty of care caused them to suffer any compensable damage. The court noted that the applicants' case in respect of loss or damage caused by the Commonwealth's breach of the duty of care was based on the occurrence of various inundation or flooding events on Boigu and Saibai. However, some of those events occurred before 2011, when the TSIRC applied for funding for the Seawalls Project, and the seawalls on Boigu and Saibai were completed in 2017 and March 2022, respectively. The court concluded that it was not possible to say that any breach of the duty of care caused or contributed to any loss or damage suffered by the applicants as a result of inundation events which occurred before 2011 or after the completion of the seawalls on Boigu and Saibai.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that the Court is not prepared to impose duties of care on the Commonwealth in respect of climate change adaptation and emissions reduction targets, as doing so would require the Court to pass judgment on issues of high or core government policy and political judgment, which is beyond the Court's remit. The Court also found that the loss of fulfilment of Ailan Kastom does not constitute a compensable loss under the law of negligence.