Ezy-Fit Engineering Group Pty Limited v Microm Nominees Pty Limited (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 37 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Ezy‑Fit Engineering Group Pty Limited v Microm Nominees Pty Limited (No 2) [2024] FCA 1367

File number: SAD 99 of 2019
Judgment of: BANKS-SMITH J
Date of judgment: 27 November 2024
Catchwords:

DAMAGES - determination of inputs for purpose of assessment of lost profits

APPORTIONMENT - concurrent wrongdoers - representations misleading or deceptive - same representations made by two parties - value judgement as to apportionment of blame

Legislation:

Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) s 87CD Part VIA, Schedule 2 (Australian Consumer Law) ss 18, 236

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 51A

Cases cited:

British Fame (Owners) v Macgregor (Owners) [1943] AC 197

Doppstadt Australia Pty Ltd v Lovick & Son Developments Pty Ltd [2014] NSWCA 158

Ezy‑Fit Engineering Group Pty Limited v Microm Nominees Pty Limited [2024] FCA 441

Haines v Bendall (1991) 172 CLR 60

Hunt & Hunt Lawyers v Mitchell Morgan Nominees Pty Ltd [2013] HCA 10; (2013) 247 CLR 613

McBride v Christie's Australia Pty Ltd [2014] NSWSC 1729

Podrebersek v Australian Iron and Steel Pty Ltd (1985) 59 ALJR 492

Reinhold v New South Wales Lotteries Corporation (No 2) [2008] NSWSC 187; (2008) 82 NSWLR 762

Stav Investments Pty Ltd v Taylor; LK Group Investments Pty Ltd v Taylor [2022] NSWSC 208

Woods v Multi-Sport Holdings Pty Ltd [2002] HCA 9; (2002) 208 CLR 460

Yates v Mobile Marine Repairs Pty Ltd [2007] NSWSC 1463

Division: General Division
Registry: South Australia
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: Commercial Contracts, Banking, Finance and Insurance
Number of paragraphs: 91
Date of hearing: 8 November 2024
Counsel for the Applicants: Mr NJ Floreani SC with Mr W Cernev
Solicitor for the Applicants: CCK Lawyers
Counsel for the First Respondent: Mr CE Chenu
Solicitor for the First Respondent: Margaret River Law
Counsel for the Second Respondent: Ms M Conduit
Solicitor for the Second Respondent: Hall & Wilcox Lawyers
Counsel for the Cross‑Claimant: Ms M Conduit
Solicitor for the Cross‑Claimant: Hall & Wilcox Lawyers
Counsel for the Cross‑Respondent: Mr CE Chenu
Solicitor for the Cross‑Respondent: Margaret River Law

ORDERS

SAD 99 of 2019
BETWEEN:

EZY-FIT ENGINEERING GROUP PTY LIMITED (ACN 060 465 385)

First Applicant

EZY-FIT MARINE PTY LIMITED (ACN 144 828 188)

Second Applicant

AND:

MICROM NOMINEES PTY LIMITED (ACN 008 867 258)

First Respondent

FABRYKA AUTOMATOW TOKARSKICH WE WROCLAWIU SA

Second Respondent

AND BETWEEN:

FABRYKA AUTOMATOW TOKARSKICH WE WROCLAWIU SA

Cross-Claimant

AND:

MICROM NOMINEES PTY LIMITED (ACN 008 867 258)

Cross-Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

BANKS-SMITH J

DATE OF ORDER:

27 NOVEMBER 2024

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The parties are to confer and provide a minute of proposed orders by no later than 4.00 pm AWST on 5 December 2024 that reflects these reasons and those in Ezy‑Fit Engineering Group Pty Limited v Microm Nominees Pty Limited [2024] FCA 441.

Note:   Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

BANKS-SMITH J:

Background

  1. On…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ezy-Fit Engineering Group Pty Limited v Microm Nominees Pty... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] FCA 1367
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Ezy-Fit Engineering Group Pty Limited initiated legal proceedings against Microm Nominees Pty Limited (No 2) concerning a dispute over the sale and subsequent malfunction of a machine known as the FTM1000. The case was heard in the Federal Court of Australia. The primary issues that the court had to resolve involved the calculation of lost profits, the entitlement to pre-judgment interest, and the adjustment of rectification costs for inflation.

The court considered whether there was a need for further discounting of the lost profits, which was ultimately resolved by the parties agreeing that no further discounting was necessary. The parties also agreed that Ezy-Fit was entitled to pre-judgment interest on the loss of profits, as provided by section 51A(1)(a) of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth). Another key issue was whether the cost of rectifying the defects in the machine should be adjusted for inflation. The court concluded that while the figures provided were estimates, there was no reasonable basis to infer that the current costs of rectification were higher than the estimated amount, and thus no adjustment for inflation was warranted.

The court found that it was just for FATO HACO to bear a substantially greater responsibility than Ron Mack for Ezy-Fit's loss. FATO HACO was responsible for designing and manufacturing the FTM1000 and was best positioned to prevent the loss from occurring. The representations that led to the loss originated from FATO HACO, even though Ron Mack adopted them for its own commercial benefit. The court noted that Ron Mack had no reason to believe FATO HACO would deliver a machine that did not meet the representations, given their business relationship.

The court ordered that the parties confer and provide a minute of proposed orders by a specified deadline, reflecting the reasons outlined in the decision and the previous case Ezy-Fit Engineering Group Pty Limited v Microm Nominees Pty Limited [2024] FCA 441.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The parties are to confer and provide a minute of proposed orders by no later than 4.00 pm AWST on 5 December 2024 that reflects these reasons and those in Ezy‑Fit Engineering Group Pty Limited v Microm Nominees Pty Limited [2024] FCA 441.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

A question addressed by the experts as to the further discounting of lost profits was resolved by the parties. The parties agree that no further discounting is required.Issue 9 - pre-judgment interest on Ezy‑Fit's loss of profits This issue was resolved by the parties. The parties agree that Ezy‑Fit is entitled to an award of pre-judgment interest on the loss of profits component of its damages pursuant to s 51A(1)(a) of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth).Issue 10 - whether cost of rectification adjusted for inflation At [985] of Ezy‑Fit No 1 I estimated the rectification costs of the established defects at $193,200. In doing so, I said:Rectification costs in the main can be estimated. I will adopt the highest estimate of costs provided for in Schedule B to FAT HACO's closing submissions because those estimates take into account input from Mr Hegmann, are referred to in the reasons above and best provide for contingencies inherent in the process of estimation. Ezy‑Fit submitted that because some of the evidence as to hourly rates was given in 2021, the $193,200 cost of rectification limb of its damages should be adjusted for inflation. It asserted that the consumer price index (CPI) has increased substantially since then and that the figure of $193,200 should be increased in line with the CPI to the date of judgment. As I understand it, the core of Ezy‑Fit's submission is that the figure of $193,200 is lower than the current costs of rectification. I am not persuaded that there is a reasonable basis upon which I should infer that to be so, and there was no application to adduce evidence that Ezy‑Fit might have sought to rely on in this regard. However, and importantly, the figures that I determined (reflected at [985]) were estimates. I deliberately took a liberal approach to account for the possibility that rectification may be more complicated or time consuming than anticipated. I also generally allowed for higher rates than those proposed by FAT HACO: see, for example, Ezy‑Fit No 1 at [564] in relation to the squareness issue; at [576]-[578] in relation to the B‑Axis alignment issue; and at [609]-[610] in relation to the C-Axis home position. In my view, even taking into account inflation, there is a prospect that rectification as of November 2024 may cost less than $193,200. It may cost more. I am not dealing with invoices or quoted costs. I am satisfied in the circumstances of this case, and having regard to the assessment undertaken, that the appropriate relief is the sum as estimated. Further, I have no evidential basis to increase the cost of rectification in line with the CPI. Ezy‑Fit submitted that I could take CPI figures into account by way of judicial notice, referring to Woods v Multi-Sport Holdings Pty Ltd [2002] HCA 9; (2002) 208 CLR 460 at [69] (McHugh J), [168] (Callinan J). I accept that in some circumstances that may be appropriate. However, I have no evidence to suggest that the actual costs of undertaking the type of tasks involved in rectifying the FTM1000 have increased in line with the CPI, and nor am I convinced I can take judicial notice of such alleged fact.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

FATO HACO advanced its position as follows:(a)because FAT HACO and Ron Mack have liability to Ezy‑Fit for the same conduct, the starting point for apportionment should be 50-50 between them;(b)Ron Mack played an integral role in negotiating the contract and making the contravening representations, and did not merely pass on information. It played an active role and did so for its own commercial benefit. Ron Mack, not FAT HACO, was aware of Ezy‑Fit's intended use of the machine, and the Court should not infer that it would have made no difference if FAT HACO had been aware of Ezy‑Fit's intended use;(c)Ron Mack had sufficient knowledge and experience to advise Ezy‑Fit about the capabilities of the FTM1000. The contract between Ezy‑Fit and Ron Mack contemplated Ron Mack having expertise with the machine, because Ron Mack was responsible for the machine during the commissioning and warranty period. Further, Ron Mack did not need special familiarity with the FTM1000 to advise Ezy‑Fit on the content of the relevant representations because the representations were general and non-technical;(d)Ron Mack had responsibility for rectification of the FTM1000 and could have done so. Commissioning and repair during the warranty period were Ron Mack's responsibility under the contract, and Ron Mack did in fact attend rectification visits and made small repairs to the FTM1000; and(e)Ron Mack has retained proportionally more benefits from its contravention than FAT HACO because Ron Mack as a dealer received a significant mark-up for the sale of the machine without the need to design and manufacture it, and because Ron Mack chose to not contest the substance of these proceedings.Consideration It is just in the circumstances of this case that FAT HACO bear a substantially greater responsibility than Ron Mack for Ezy‑Fit's loss. Critically, FAT HACO designed and manufactured the FTM1000. FAT HACO was the party with the capacity to ensure the machine was delivered to Ezy‑Fit consistent with the representations made about it, and so best positioned to prevent Ezy‑Fit's loss from occurring: Yates v Mobile Marine Repairs Pty Ltd [2007] NSWSC 1463 at [97] (Palmer J). It is also significant that the content of the contravening representations emanated from FAT HACO. Although, as I found at [168] and [870] of Ezy‑Fit No 1, Ron Mack revised documents provided by FAT HACO before providing them to Ezy‑Fit, Ron Mack did not change or embellish the content of the representations (at [776]). I accept that Ron Mack adopted those representations for its own commercial benefit. But I also accept, in the absence of any evidence from Ron Mack, that objectively Ron Mack had no reason to believe that FAT HACO would deliver to Ezy‑Fit a machine that functioned inconsistently with those representations, given the apparent lengthy business relationship between them (I referred at [239] to the evidence of Mr Ostrowski about the business relationship between FAT HACO and Ron Mack).