Ezy-Fit Engineering Group Pty Limited v Microm Nominees Pty Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 76 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Ezy‑Fit Engineering Group Pty Limited v Microm Nominees Pty Limited [2024] FCA 441

File number: SAD 99 of 2019
Judgment of: BANKS-SMITH J
Date of judgment: 3 May 2024
Catchwords:

CONTRACT - agency - principal and agent - ostensible authority - implied actual authority - general principles - contract to buy lathe and milling machine - whether contract made between purchaser and dealer in Australia or between purchaser and manufacturer in Poland

CONTRACT - construction - pre-contractual representations - whether terms implied - whether statements in technical brochures incorporated as express terms

SALE OF GOODS - general principles - liability of seller - fitness for purpose - whether breach of term implied under s 14(a) Sale of Goods Act 1895 (SA)

CONSUMER LAW - allegation of misleading or deceptive conduct contrary to s 18 of the Australian Consumer Law (ACL) - conduct by way of representations made in technical brochures - pre-contractual representations - whether machine was defective and failed to perform in accordance with representations - reliance - whether representations were misleading

CONSUMER LAW - pleading of numerous disaggregated representations - whether pre‑commissioning and post-commissioning representations made

DAMAGES - where delivery time estimated - whether delay in performance caused applicants to lose tender for lucrative opportunity to manufacture periscopes - whether delay in performance had impact on receipt of government grant

DAMAGES - general principles - whether machine capable of repair - whether rectification reasonable - rectification costs - whether allowance should be made for rectification costs where damages assessed under s 236 of the ACL

DAMAGES - assessment of damages - loss of profits - whether defective machine resulted in lost opportunity to profit from high-end work - appropriate method of calculating damages - hypothetical alternative purchase - assessment of probability of opportunity eventuating - fair compensation - date and period of assessment - calculation

TORT - negligence - standard of care of manufacturer

EVIDENCE - expert evidence - where evidence of valuer rejected at trial - whether reasoning of valuer disclosed

EVIDENCE - parliamentary privilege - whether s 16 of the Parliamentary Privileges Act 1987 (Cth) prohibits using statements made in a Senate Estimates Committee hearing for making factual findings

EVIDENCE - whether failure to call witnesses gives rise to Jones v Dunkel inference

Legislation:

Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) s 139B, Schedule 2 (Australian Consumer Law) ss 18, 29, 236, 237

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) s 79

Parliamentary Privileges Act 1987 (Cth) s 16

Law Reform (Contributory Negligence and Apportionment of Liability) Act 2001 (SA) s 6

Sale of Goods Act 1895 (SA) ss 11, 14

Cases cited:

Amadio Pty Ltd v Henderson (1998) 81 FCR 149

Ashington Piggeries Ltd v Christopher Hill Ltd [1972] AC 441

Aqua-Marine Marketing Pty Ltd v Pacific Reef Fisheries (Australia) Pty Ltd (No 5) [2012] FCA 908

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v TPG Internet Pty Ltd [2013] HCA 54; (2013) 250 CLR 640

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ezy-Fit Engineering Group Pty Limited v Microm Nominees Pty... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] FCA 441
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Ezy-Fit Engineering Group Pty Limited brought claims against Microm Nominees Pty Limited and FAT HACO International Sp z o.o. regarding the purchase of a lathe and milling machine. Ezy-Fit claimed that the machine was defective, delivered late, and failed to meet the specifications. The case involved complex issues of contract law, consumer protection, and damages. The court had to decide on the existence and terms of the contract, the authority of the agents, the implied terms, the liability for breach, and the assessment of damages. The court found that there was a contract between Ezy-Fit and Ron Mack, who had ostensible authority to act on behalf of FAT HACO. The contract contained an implied term of fitness for purpose, which was breached by the defects and delay in delivery of the machine. The court also found that FAT HACO and Ron Mack engaged in misleading conduct by making false representations about the machine's capabilities and quality. The court awarded Ezy-Fit damages for the breach of contract and the misleading conduct under the Australian Consumer Law. The court adjourned the case for further directions on the calculation of damages.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The matter is adjourned for a directions hearing on a date to be fixed.

2. Prior to the hearing the parties are to confer and submit a joint minute of proposed orders, or competing minutes, which address the proposed steps to be undertaken to finalise the calculation of the lost profits assessment, having regard to these reasons.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Table of Contents

PART A: INTRODUCTION

[1]

The machine

[1]

The parties

[8]

Brief chronology

[13]

Proceeding issued

[19]

Summary of outcome

[22]

PART B: OVERVIEW OF THE WITNESSES

[23]

Ezy-Fit's lay witnesses

[25]

Phil Green

[25]

Chris Loughlin

[26]

Terry Kerin

[27]

Michael Klappers

[29]

Robert Hollamby

[29]

Steven Stewart

[31]

FAT HACO's lay witnesses

[31]

Adrian Maicher

[32]

Irek Ostrowski

[33]

Norbert Misiolek

[34]

Grzegorz Hoppe

[35]

Expert witnesses

[36]

Thomas Hegmann

[37]

David Miller

[38]

Joint Technical Report

[40]

Brian Morris

[41]

Anh Nguyen

[42]

Joint accounting report

[43]

Valuation evidence

[44]

PART C: THE BAE TENDER, THE GOVERNMENT GRANT AND OTHER PREPARATION

[45]

Events concurrent with contract negotiations

[45]

Why the BAE evidence is relevant

[46]

Ezy-Fit's 'defence readiness' strategy

[48]

Summary of the BAE tender process

[49]

The BAE tender evidence

[56]

The Commonwealth Government grant and the delivery timeline

[87]

Progress of the building works

[103]

Purchase of DMF600

[105]

Purchase of CMM and the CMM room build

[108]

The debrief and evidence as to why Ezy-Fit was unsuccessful

[111]

Determination - grant not affected by delay

[120]

Determination - delay in delivery did not cause Ezy-Fit to lose BAE tender

[123]

PART D: THE CONTRACT TO PURCHASE THE FTM1000

[137]

The evidence - formation of contract to purchase the FTM1000

[137]

Mr Green's background

[140]

Preliminary contact with FAT HACO

[145]

Communications commence with Ron Mack

[147]

Communication between Ezy-Fit and Ron Mack and Ron Mak and FAT HACO

[148]

Ezy-Fit's offer

[180]

14 October 2015 Quote

[186]

15 October 2015 Quote

[195]

29 October 2015 Ron Mack purchase order

[199]

The invoicing and payments

[201]

Mr Green's oral evidence

[203]

Determination - the date of the contract

[206]

PART E: AGENCY

[220]

The competing arguments

[220]

Principles

[223]

Examples from case law

[226]

Further evidence

[234]

Mr Green

[235]

Mr Ostrowski

[239]

First direct communication between Mr Green and FAT HACO

[244]

Second contract as between Ron Mack and FAT HACO

[245]

Differences in the contracts

[248]

Additional email exchanges October 2015

[249]

Demands issued to Ron Mack

[254]

Ostensible authority - analysis

[256]

Implied actual authority - analysis

[281]

PART F: PURPOSE AND TERMS OF THE CONTRACT

[290]

Purpose of buying machine

[290]

Was purpose known to Ron Mack at time of contract?

[296]

High precision and tolerances - meaning

[306]

Was purpose known to FAT HACO at time of contract?

[325]

Terms of contract

[329]

Express terms

[329]

Implied terms

[336]

Fitness for purpose

[338]

Merchantable quality

[345]

Applicable standards

[346]

Programming

[347]

Delivery and commissioning time of the essence

[348]

FTM1000 would be delivered complete and fully tested

[355]

PART G: DELAYS, COMMISSIONING AND TESTS

[356]

The pre-commissioning visit to Poland

[356]

Variation to specifications

[367]

Delay in delivery

[368]

Commissioning

[372]

Tests in Poland

[372]

Commissioning in Australia

[376]

PART H: DEFECTS AND RECTIFICATION VISITS

[392]

Preliminary

[392]

Defects and the First Rectification Visit

[406]

Defects notified

[406]

The First Rectification Visit

[407]

Defects outstanding after the First Rectification Visit

[417]

Machine testing undertaken by Mr Loughlin

[419]

Further defects and the Second Rectification Visit

[423]

Additional defects notified

[423]

The Second Rectification Visit

[424]

Defects outstanding after the Second Rectification Visit

[433]

Additional defects notified

[438]

The Third Rectification Visit

[441]

The Siemens Report

[448]

The recalibration and alleged reversal

[449]

Further defects notified after the Third Rectification Visit

[455]

Conclusion

[459]

PART I: IMPACT OF COLLISIONS

[461]

The collisions

[461]

PART J: THE STATE OF THE MACHINE - DEFECTS

[477]

A preliminary note

[477]

Some details about the FTM1000

[478]

Overview of expert evidence

[484]

Mr Hegmann's visit and tests

[491]

Mr Miller's visit and tests

[498]

The squareness issue

[502]

The ball bar test - circularity deviation

[502]

Comparing the ball bar test results

[509]

Mr Hegmann

[510]

Mr Miller

[514]

Renishaw testing on 27 February 2020

[523]

The FAT HACO testing at the Second Rectification Visit

[526]

The results and the squareness issue

[527]

Repeatability

[540]

Programming compensation

[546]

The cause and repairs

[550]

The B-Axis alignment error (originally Item 37)

[568]

The B-Axis clamped v unclamped error

[582]

The Schedule 1 defects

[590]

Item 2 - Tool calibration issue

[590]

Item 3 - Multiple tool holder

[593]

Item 19 - C-Axis home position (main chuck)

[597]

Item 20 - Spindle alignment

[611]

Item 21 - Centre alignment

[613]

Item 26 - Main chuck S1 - pressure of jaws

[617]

Item 27 - Chuck covers

[628]

Item 29 - Main C-Axis vibration

[632]

Item 30 - Circular and helical machining - vibration

[638]

Item 35 - SP2 standstill monitoring (alarm)

[639]

Item 36 - Machining inaccuracy (B-Axis misalignment)

[642]

Item 37 - B-Axis

[643]

Item 45 - Visiport window

[644]

Item 46 - Visiport window - positioning

[645]

Item 48 - Coolant leaking from behind the main head

[646]

Item 49 - Coolant does not stop when low

[647]

Item 50 - Hydraulic oil leak

[650]

Item 51 - Rear coolant cover

[654]

Item 54 - Swarf in rear machine cabinet

[657]

Item 55 - Z-Axis 'creep'

[660]

Item 56 - Graphics

[665]

Item 57 - Manufacture mode

[667]

Item 58 - Software issue

[670]

Item 59 - Standard G codes and machine function

[671]

Item 60 - Touch probe

[673]

Item 65 - Paint

[677]

Item 66 - Y-Axis

[687]

Item 68 - 5-Axes machining

[690]

Conclusion on defects

[706]

Subsequent use of the machine

[708]

PART K: LIABILITY - CONTRACT

[709]

Late delivery

[711]

Defects

[716]

Implied term - fitness for purpose

[718]

Section 14(a) Sale of Goods Act

[723]

Determination - breach of contract

[734]

PART L: LIABILITY - AUSTRALIAN CONSUMER LAW

[737]

Statutory context

[737]

Principles

[744]

Two preliminary issues

[752]

A pleading point

[753]

Conduits, attribution and direct liability

[758]

The Pre-contractual representations

[773]

Pleading

[773]

The Technical Document and General Brochure

[777]

Reliance on Technical Document and General Brochure

[780]

The 22 representations

[793]

(1) 'the FTM 1000 brings together the requirements for better machining high precision, easy to operation, quick way from drawing to workpiece, low maintenance and special features'

[795]

(2) ‘User friendly: generate the program with graphical support, no ISO/DIN knowledge required'

[796]

(3) 'Fast and simple programming, even during the machining process.'

[797]

(4) the FTM1000 would be 'low maintenance' with '… optimum swarf removal …' and '… [e]asy chip disposal from within work area to a chip conveyor …'

[798]

(5) '… construction ensures optimum swarf removal, easy setting and inspection of tools, optimal access to the workpiece for the operator and best cutting force distribution'

[802]

(6) 'High number of machining possibilities: the FTM 1000 can be equipped with C-axis and driven tools, direct measuring system on all axes, tool presetter, hydraulic steady rest, Y axis, milling B-axis with tool changer, sub-spindle, NC operated hydraulic rest and tailstock, special boring bar attachment'

[805]

(7) 'Complete flexibility … for a maximum number of machining options'

[807]

(8) 'Shortest machining time for large series and special applications'

[808]

(9) 'Cycles: stock removal, drilling, tapping, threading, grooving, undercut, milling cycles with C-axis …'

[810]

(10) 'the machine can carry out complicated milling, drilling and tapping operations'

[812]

(11) '… the requirements for better machining high precision …'

[819]

(12) 'large premium-quality ballscrews ensure precise positioning'

[820]

(13) 'High precision of all axes'

[824]

(14) 'the Linear Measuring System ensures a high positioning accuracy and higher repeatability'

[830]

(15) the FTM1000 could perform '… heavy milling…'

[833]

(16) the FTM1000 could '… make eccentric drilling, tapping, key-slot milling with static spindle …'

[835]

(17) the FTM1000 could perform '… complicated contour milling operation during slow rotation of the spindle …'

[838]

(18) the FTM1000 could perform '… precise positioning …'

[839]

(19) the FTM1000 would have '… high precision of all axes …'

[840]

(20) 'B-axis of milling/turning head has the ability to stop on an accuracy every 1 deg,

[841]

(21) '… [the FTM1000] can carry out complicated milling, drilling and tapping operations …'

[845]

(22) the 'C-Axis … enables very high positioning precision and high torque during slow spindle rotation …'

[846]

Two other Pre-contractual representations

[852]

The quality and performance representations

[858]

The warranty representations

[859]

Conclusion - FAT HACO's liability for the Pre-contractual representations

[860]

Conclusion - Ron Mack's liability for the Pre-contractual representations

[864]

The Pre-commissioning representations

[874]

The Post-commissioning representations

[885]

Determination - misleading conduct by representations

[890]

PART M: LIABILITY - NEGLIGENCE

[892]

Ezy Fit's case

[898]

Insufficient evidence of carelessness amounting to a breach of duty

[906]

An assumption about a duty of care

[906]

No negligence relating to delay in delivery or commissioning

[912]

Standard of care at the time FAT HACO began manufacture or design

[913]

Standard of care on commissioning

[918]

Standard of care on repairs

[930]

PART N: LOSS AND DAMAGES

[945]

Ezy Fit's pleaded claim for relief

[945]

Summary of competing positions

[948]

Contract claim - principles

[957]

ACL claim - principles

[967]

Sellars and the assessment of hypothetical loss

[977]

Causation, mitigation, and limits to claims for lost opportunity

[978]

Assessment of rectification costs

[983]

Difference in value

[990]

Ezy Fit's lost opportunity case

[1002]

Comparison

[1002]

Manner of assessment

[1007]

The complexity of the task

[1010]

Relevant findings

[1017]

Was there a commercial opportunity to perform high-end work?

[1018]

Does the opportunity and hypothetical model extend to use of the other machines?

[1035]

What is the degree of probability of the commercial opportunity eventuating?

[1046]

If Ezy Fit had not bought the FTM1000, would it have bought an alternative machine?

[1053]

When would an alternative machine have arrived?

[1057]

What is the start date for assessing when Ezy Fit would have commenced the additional

[1058]

What hourly rates would be charged for work on an alternative machine?

[1059]

What is the period of the lost opportunity?

[1062]

Utilisation of the FTM1000

[1073]

How should lost profits be calculated?

[1076]

Rejection of the 'recruitment' model

[1077]

The contract measure of damages

[1081]

Mitigation

[1083]

What about Ezy Fit Marine?

[1095]

Wasted expenditure basis for assessment

[1102]

PART O: OTHER MATTERS

[1106]

Jones v Dunkel rulings

[1106]

Apportionment

[1117]

Cross-claim

[1118]

CONCLUSION

[1120]

Attachment A

Attachment B

Attachment C

Attachment D

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Organisation of the evidence in these reasons has been complicated by the overlap in the relevance of some of the evidence going to the many issues, and by its at-times overwhelming level of detail. Although there are different ways in which the evidence could have been collected, I will commence with the process by which Ezy‑Fit Marine unsuccessfully tendered for the periscope work, and then address Ezy‑Fit Engineering's application for a Government grant to assist in the acquisition of machinery. These matters were playing out at the same time as Ezy‑Fit Engineering was negotiating with Ron Mack about the purchase and delivery of the FTM1000, and provide context to those negotiations.Why the BAE evidence is relevant In summary, the evidence about the BAE tender process is relevant to the proposition that, but for the delay in procuring the FTM1000, Ezy‑Fit Marine would have been the successful tenderer for the periscope work, and so it lost the opportunity to secure this high-end work. Communications with BAE during the tender process and information given to Ezy‑Fit Marine (and Ezy‑Fit) about why it was unsuccessful inform this exercise. The evidence about the Government grant process provides background to concerns expressed by Ezy‑Fit about estimates given by Ron Mack and FAT HACO of the delivery date for the FTM1000. The grant process involved deadlines. Those deadlines were extended, ultimately to a date that accommodated extensions in the delivery estimates. The evidence informs the contention by Ezy‑Fit that (to paraphrase) time was of the essence.Ezy-Fit's 'defence readiness' strategy In about 2010 Ezy‑Fit decided to pursue what it considered might be lucrative work in the field of defence. Mr Kerin said he was aware that the car industry in South Australia was winding down, agricultural work was also dwindling, and many products were being imported from China. Accordingly, he considered that defence work would be the next big opportunity. Ezy‑Fit set on a course of what Mr Kerin referred to as 'defence readiness', in order to better position itself to tender for or otherwise secure such work. This course included acquiring new machinery as necessary in order to compete for and undertake precision defence work.Summary of the BAE tender process BAE is a defence and security company which provides services to, amongst other clients, the Australian Defence Force. According to Mr Kerin, there were discussions 'for a couple of years' with BAE about potential periscope work prior to the events the subject of this proceeding. For example, at some point BAE invited Ezy‑Fit to do some repair work on a periscope, although in the end the work was not actually undertaken. On 11 August 2014 Ezy‑Fit formally received a request from BAE, as service provider to the Commonwealth, to provide a quotation for Collins Class periscope system tubes. Mr Green determined that the periscope work could be undertaken by Ezy‑Fit, but that it would require the use of three machines which would need to be acquired: a CNC turn-mill, a CNC milling machine and a CMM. A CMM is used to confirm critical measurements and is used for quality assurance purposes to measure work undertaken by other machines.

Decision

Reasons for decision

It seems to me likely that issues as between FAT HACO and Ron Mack will be dealt with in the course of submissions relating to apportionment, and the cross-claim for all intents and purposes falls away. However, I will hear from FAT HACO before making orders that might otherwise dismiss it.CONCLUSION For the above reasons, Ezy‑Fit has succeeded in relation to its claims in contract and under s 18 of the ACL against Ron Mack. It has succeeded in its claim against FAT HACO under s 18 of the ACL. The claims brought by Ezy‑Fit are otherwise to be dismissed. I propose to discuss the making of further directions with the parties concerning the calculation of the quantum of damages in a manner that reflects the reasons for judgment, and as to orders that otherwise give effect to these reasons. The proceedings are therefore adjourned for further directions on a date to be allocated.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

During the trial I upheld an objection to the tender by the applicants of a valuation report prepared by the valuing firm Mason Gray Strange. The reasons for upholding the objection are given later in these reasons. No other valuation evidence was tendered.PART C: THE BAE TENDER, THE GOVERNMENT GRANT AND OTHER PREPARATIONEvents concurrent with contract negotiations Organisation of the evidence in these reasons has been complicated by the overlap in the relevance of some of the evidence going to the many issues, and by its at-times overwhelming level of detail. Although there are different ways in which the evidence could have been collected, I will commence with the process by which Ezy‑Fit Marine unsuccessfully tendered for the periscope work, and then address Ezy‑Fit Engineering's application for a Government grant to assist in the acquisition of machinery. These matters were playing out at the same time as Ezy‑Fit Engineering was negotiating with Ron Mack about the purchase and delivery of the FTM1000, and provide context to those negotiations.Why the BAE evidence is relevant In summary, the evidence about the BAE tender process is relevant to the proposition that, but for the delay in procuring the FTM1000, Ezy‑Fit Marine would have been the successful tenderer for the periscope work, and so it lost the opportunity to secure this high-end work. Communications with BAE during the tender process and information given to Ezy‑Fit Marine (and Ezy‑Fit) about why it was unsuccessful inform this exercise. The evidence about the Government grant process provides background to concerns expressed by Ezy‑Fit about estimates given by Ron Mack and FAT HACO of the delivery date for the FTM1000. The grant process involved deadlines. Those deadlines were extended, ultimately to a date that accommodated extensions in the delivery estimates. The evidence informs the contention by Ezy‑Fit that (to paraphrase) time was of the essence.Ezy-Fit's 'defence readiness' strategy In about 2010 Ezy‑Fit decided to pursue what it considered might be lucrative work in the field of defence. Mr Kerin said he was aware that the car industry in South Australia was winding down, agricultural work was also dwindling, and many products were being imported from China. Accordingly, he considered that defence work would be the next big opportunity. Ezy‑Fit set on a course of what Mr Kerin referred to as 'defence readiness', in order to better position itself to tender for or otherwise secure such work. This course included acquiring new machinery as necessary in order to compete for and undertake precision defence work.Summary of the BAE tender process BAE is a defence and security company which provides services to, amongst other clients, the Australian Defence Force. According to Mr Kerin, there were discussions 'for a couple of years' with BAE about potential periscope work prior to the events the subject of this proceeding. For example, at some point BAE invited Ezy‑Fit to do some repair work on a periscope, although in the end the work was not actually undertaken.