Elanor Funds Management Ltd v Alceon Group Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 83 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Elanor Funds Management Ltd v Alceon Group Pty Ltd [2023] FCA 1291  

File number(s): QUD 404 of 2021
Judgment of: MCELWAINE J
Date of judgment: 30 October 2023
Catchwords:

AUSTRALIAN CONSUMER LAW – where applicant alleges misleading and deceptive conduct on the part of the respondents in relation to the sale of Bluewater Square Shopping Centre – where applicant contends express and implied representations were made as to the commencement date of certain leases, whether certain tenants were in arrears and the rental return of the Centre  – where applicant is a sophisticated investor and extensive due diligence undertaken – a no transaction case claiming pure economic loss as the difference between acquisition price of the Centre and true value at time of purchase – misleading and deceptive conduct as alleged not established – conduct in certain respects was not engaged in and in other respects was not objectively misleading or deceptive or likely to mislead or deceive – in any event, applicant fails to prove reliance and fails to prove that damage was suffered – applicant’s expert evidence does not establish difference in value to prove that the applicant suffered damage as an essential element of the claim

EVIDENCE – where expert valuer engaged for trial was previously engaged by applicant for mortgagee valuation – where expert took directions from applicant when drafting valuation – expert not truly independent, evidence afforded less weight

EVIDENCE – s 286 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) – what amounts to a financial record – not all business-related correspondence is a financial record

Legislation:

Australian Consumer Law, which is schedule 2 to the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) ss 18, 137, 236

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 286, 1305

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) s 79

Cases cited:

Addenbrooke Pty Ltd v Duncan (No 2) [2017]) FCAFC 76; 348 ALR 1

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v TPG Internet Pty Ltd [2013] HCA 54; 250 CLR 640

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v ABC Fund Managers Ltd [2001] VSC 383; 39 ACSR 443

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Dover Financial Advisers Pty Ltd [2019] FCA 1932

Barnes v Forty Two International Pty Ltd [2014] FCAFC 152; 316 ALR 408

Brewarrana Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Highways (No 2) (1973) 32 LGRA 170

Butcher v Lachlan Elder Realty Pty Ltd [2004] HCA 60; 218 CLR 592

Campbell v Backoffice Investments Pty Ltd [2009] HCA 25; 238 CLR 304

Google Inc v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission [2013] HCA 1; 249 CLR 435

Hanave Pty Ltd v LFOT Pty Ltd (formerly Jagar Projects Pty Ltd) (1999) 43 IPR 545

Harvard Nominees Pty Ltd v Tiller [2020] FCAFC 229; 282 FCR 530

Henville v Walker [2001] HCA 52; 206 CLR 459

Hughes-Holland v BPE Solicitors [2018] AC 599

Hunt and Hunt Lawyers (a firm) v Mitchell Morgan Nominees Pty Ltd [2013] HCA 10; 247 CLR 613

Jadwan Pty Ltd v Rae and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Elanor Funds Management Ltd v Alceon Group Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FCA 1291
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Elanor Funds Management Ltd v Alceon Group Pty Ltd involves Elanor, the applicant, alleging misleading and deceptive conduct on the part of the respondents, Alceon Group Pty Ltd, regarding the sale of the Bluewater Square Shopping Centre. Elanor contends that express and implied representations were made about the commencement date of certain leases, the status of tenants' payments, and the rental returns of the Centre. Elanor, described as a sophisticated investor, asserts that despite conducting extensive due diligence, it was misled by the respondents' conduct, resulting in a loss equal to the difference between the acquisition price and the Centre's true value at the time of purchase. The court was tasked with deciding whether the alleged misleading and deceptive conduct was established, whether Elanor relied on the representations, and whether Elanor suffered damages as a result.

The court examined the evidence and concluded that Elanor failed to prove the alleged misleading and deceptive conduct. The court found that the conduct in question was either not engaged in by the respondents or was not objectively misleading or deceptive. Furthermore, the court determined that even if the misleading and deceptive conduct had been established, Elanor failed to demonstrate reliance on the alleged representations and did not prove that it suffered damages. The expert evidence provided by Elanor's expert, who had previously been engaged for a mortgagee valuation, was given less weight due to perceived lack of independence. The court found that Elanor's expert was not truly independent, as they took directions from Elanor when drafting the valuation, which affected the weight afforded to the evidence.

The court also considered the nature of financial records under s 286 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) and concluded that not all business-related correspondence qualifies as a financial record. This finding further contributed to the dismissal of Elanor's claims. Ultimately, the court dismissed the proceeding, finding that Elanor had not proven the elements necessary to establish a claim for misleading and deceptive conduct under Australian Consumer Law.

The court ordered that the proceeding be dismissed and set out procedures for any applications for costs, limiting the submissions to no more than five pages. The matter of costs was to be determined on the papers, subject to any further orders of the court. The decision underscores the importance of proving reliance and damages in claims of misleading and deceptive conduct, as well as the necessity of expert evidence meeting certain standards of independence and objectivity.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The proceeding is dismissed.

2. Any application for costs is to be made in writing, within 14 days of the publication of these reasons, limited to no more than five pages.

3. Any response to an application for costs is to be made in writing within 7 days thereafter, limited to no more than five pages.

4. Subject to any further order of the Court, the question of costs will be determined on the papers.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

CPRAM relies on two proportionate liability defences. One, that Alceon is a concurrent wrongdoer by reason of the matters pleaded by Elanor against it and the other, that CBRE is a concurrent wrongdoer in that it failed to make sufficient inquiries during the due diligence in breach of its duty to exercise reasonable care pursuant to its engagement with Elanor. Finally, CPRAM pleads that if Elanor suffered loss and damage, then it contributed to that damage within the meaning of s 137B of the Act by failing to undertake and/or investigate matters which a reasonable person in the position of Elanor would have undertaken in the circumstances. In this regard, CPRAM places particular reliance upon the expert evidence of Ms Hansen.THE PRIMARY FACTS The parties managed to agree a somewhat narrow and limited set of facts in the form of the Statement of Agreed Facts dated 6 July 2023. Regrettably a large number of facts which ultimately were not in issue between the parties were not referred to in that document, despite case management orders that I made and which required the legal representatives for the parties to attend before a registrar of the Court in order to agree uncontentious facts. However, by the time of the trial, and the involvement of counsel, the territory of factual dispute narrowed considerably. To the extent that the Statement of Agreed Facts remains of utility in resolving the issues, I record the following. On 13 December 2012, Alceon and CPRAM entered into an investment management agreement. By it, establishment of the unregistered managed investment scheme known as the Bluewater Trust is recorded. CPRAM accepted appointment as one of the joint managers of the trust. Its duties included identification of intended trust acquisitions, management of trust assets (including asset level strategy), budgeting, forecasting, reporting and oversight of day-to-day asset management and administration of trust assets. It was also tasked with identification of opportunities for the disposal of trust assets. Alceon was registered as proprietor of the Centre by transfer on 3 April 2013 for a consideration of $41,750,000. Alceon entered into a property management agreement with Savills on 19 November 2015. By it, Savills accepted an appointment to provide each of the services in respect of the Centre as set out at schedule 2 to the agreement. The scope of services included the general administration of each of the tenancies by collecting rent, holding security deposits, ensuring compliance with tenant obligations, maintaining a tenancy schedule, maintaining tenancy files and financial management. In particular, the financial management obligation extended to the preparation of a monthly statement of monies received and expenses incurred, the issue of monthly invoices to tenants for rental payable and other charges, the collection of rent and charges and review of rental arrears. Savills also accepted an obligation to provide monthly financial management reports for the Centre. Savills operated a reporting system known as the MRI Management System (MRI) in order to comply with its financial management and reporting obligations to Alceon. Importantly, Alceon and CPRAM did not have the ability to make changes within MRI, but CPRAM could generate reports from it.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

For the detailed reasons that follow, I have concluded that Elanor has failed to prove to the civil standard the misleading and deceptive conduct that it relies upon and that in any event if I am wrong in that conclusion, then Elanor has failed to establish that it relied upon that misleading or deceptive conduct and further, has failed to prove that it suffered damage because of that conduct and the claimed reliance. Accordingly, the proceeding must be dismissed.PARTIES, DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE AND WITNESSES I commence with the applicant. Elanor is the responsible entity of the Elanor Investment Fund which is a registered managed investment scheme operated pursuant to a trust. Units in the trust form part of stapled securities that are listed on the Australian Stock Exchange. It is a corporation within the Elanor Investors Group which conducts an investment and funds management business. Mr Blake McNaughton since July 2019 has been employed by Elanor as an executive director within the office of the chief executive officer. Mr McNaughton holds a Bachelor of Commerce with majors in information systems management and management. As at August 2017, he had in excess of five years’ experience in analysing potential investments and in determining investment yields in order to identify investment opportunities for Elanor. Mr Michael Baliva is employed by Elanor as its co-head of real estate, a position he has held since 2014. Mr McNaughton reported to Mr Baliva as to the outcome of the assessments that he made concerning a prospective acquisition of the Centre by Elanor. Mr Baliva’s primary role was to report to Elanor’s board in relation to the proposed acquisition, and following the board resolution, his role was to negotiate the purchase terms, including the purchase price. He performed this work in conjunction with Mr McNaughton. Mr Alexander (Sandy) Hamilton in August 2017 was employed as the regional director for investment advisory services by CBRE. He is experienced in performing due diligence investigations for investors buying or selling multi-tenanted properties, including regional and sub-regional shopping centres in Australia. In August 2017, he was engaged by Mr McNaughton to undertake a due diligence assessment in relation to the Centre for Elanor. Ms Anna-Maree Coco has extensive experience in managing shopping centres in Queensland. Between May 2016 and November 2017, she was employed by Savills (QLD) Pty Ltd (Savills) as the on-site property manager at the Centre. Savills in turn was engaged by Alceon as manager of the Centre pursuant to an agreement dated 19 December 2015. Mr Paul Kwan is a registered valuer and is the head of valuation and advisory at Knight Frank Valuation and Advisory, Queensland. He was first engaged by Mr McNaughton on 21 August 2017 to prepare a valuation of the Centre for mortgagee purposes. Pursuant to that engagement, and a letter of instruction from the Bank of Queensland, he produced a market valuation report dated 6 September 2017 pursuant to which he calculated the market value of the Centre at $55.25 million exclusive of GST assuming a capitalisation rate of 7%. He was again engaged by Mr McNaughton on 2 September 2021 to prepare a “retrospective indicative valuation” of the Centre on the assumption that nine of the food court tenancies were vacant at a total gross annual rental loss of $701,448. Pursuant to that engagement, Mr Kwan on 15 September 2021, provided some “draft calculations” which valued the Centre at $52.5 million assuming a capitalisation rate of 7% and which he later revised on 17 September 2021, following correspondence with Mr McNaughton, to $51 million assuming a capitalisation rate of 7.75%.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.