Elanor Funds Management Ltd v Alceon Group Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 75 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Elanor Funds Management Ltd v Alceon Group Pty Ltd [2024] FCAFC 121

Appeal from: Elanor Funds Management Ltd v Alceon Group Pty Ltd [2023] FCA 1291
File number(s): QUD 521 of 2023                  
Judgment of: BROMWICH, THAWLEY AND O’SULLIVAN JJ
Date of judgment: 18 September 2024
Catchwords:

AUSTRALIAN CONSUMER LAW – appellant alleges misleading and deceptive conduct in relation to the sale of Bluewater Square Shopping Centre – where trial judge found that the respondents did not engage in misleading and deceptive conduct, appellant did not rely on any misleading conduct and the appellant did not suffer any damage – held that respondents engaged in misleading and deceptive conduct in representing that Centre tenants were not in arrears of rent and had no relevant history of arrears in rent – held that the appellant sustained damage because of the respondents’ conduct – damaged quantified on appeal – appeal allowed

AUSTRALIAN CONSUMER LAW – where second respondent pleaded apportionable claim against first respondent – where respondents concurrent wrongdoers – damage apportioned between respondents

EVIDENCE – where appellant alleges that trial judge relied on expert accounting evidence which relied on untested hearsay evidence in the form of annotations to business records – annotations objected to – annotations should have been rejected where controversial

PROCEDURAL FAIRNESS – where trial judge declined to consider appellant’s submissions about why various conclusions of expert in connection with actual rent arrears position were wrong or should be qualified, including on the basis that hearsay annotations were inadmissible and unreliable – appeal court able to consider and address the submissions on appeal – submissions mostly made out – actual arrears position quantified on appeal

EVIDENCE – assessment of credibility – trial judge treated reliance evidence with “caution” on the basis that such evidence must be treated with caution because it is self-serving and hypothetical – observations about whether such evidence must be treated with “caution”

EVIDENCE – assessment of credibility – trial judge treated evidence of an employee of the appellant with “caution” because employee was considered to have an interest in the outcome of the litigation – interest in outcome of litigation not identified – observations about whether evidence of an employee of a party must be treated with “caution”

EVIDENCE – assessment of credibility – one part of opinion evidence of expert witness considered by trial judge to be unexplained – lack of explanation considered to go to more than the reliability of the evidence – where expert’s explanation for opinion not referred to by trial judge

DAMAGES – assessment of market value by reference to opinions of experts adopting broadly the same methodologies – discussion of proper approach to determination of value – discussion of duty of court to form and act on its own opinion of value – role of expert is to furnish the court with the necessary scientific criteria for testing the accuracy of their conclusions, so as to enable the court to form its own independent judgment by…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Elanor Funds Management Ltd v Alceon Group Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] FCAFC 121
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal in Elanor Funds Management Ltd v Alceon Group Pty Ltd was brought before the court to address allegations of misleading and deceptive conduct under the Australian Consumer Law in relation to the sale of the Bluewater Square Shopping Centre. Elanor, the appellant, claimed that the respondents, Alceon and CPRAM, had misrepresented the financial health and tenant history of the Centre, leading to financial loss when Elanor purchased the property. The trial judge had found against Elanor on these grounds, but the appellant sought to overturn these findings on appeal.

The court was required to decide whether the respondents had indeed engaged in misleading or deceptive conduct, whether Elanor had relied on any such conduct, and if Elanor had suffered any damages as a result. Additionally, the court had to address issues relating to the assessment of damages, the admissibility and reliability of expert evidence, and the procedural fairness in the trial judge's handling of certain evidence and submissions. The appeal court needed to determine if the trial judge erred in their assessment of the evidence and in their conclusions regarding the liability and damages.

The appeal court found that the respondents had engaged in misleading and deceptive conduct by representing that Centre tenants were not in arrears and had no history of arrears, which was not true. The court also found that Elanor had relied on these misrepresentations and had suffered damages as a result. The court quantified the damages at $2.86 million, apportioning $2.002 million to Alceon and $858,000 to CPRAM. The court was critical of the trial judge's handling of expert evidence and submissions, finding that the trial judge had not properly assessed the credibility and admissibility of certain evidence, and had not adequately considered Elanor's arguments regarding the expert's conclusions. The appeal court allowed the appeal and set aside the original orders, substituting them with orders that reflect the correct apportionment of damages and costs.

The final orders of the court were to dismiss most contentions raised by the respondents, allow the appeal, set aside the original orders made by the trial judge, and order the respondents to pay Elanor damages and costs. The first respondent, Alceon, was ordered to pay $2.002 million plus interest, and the second respondent, CPRAM, was ordered to pay $858,000 plus interest. Both respondents were also ordered to pay Elanor's costs of the appeal and the proceedings at first instance.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The first respondent’s notice of contention be dismissed.

2. With the exception of Ground 5, the second respondent’s notice of contention be dismissed.

3. The appeal be allowed.

4. Set aside the orders made on 30 October 2023 and, in their place, order:

(a) the first respondent pay to the appellant the sum of $2,360,000, plus interest at Court rates calculated from 1 November 2017.

(b) the second respondent pay to the appellant the sum of $590,000, plus interest at Court rates calculated from 1 November 2017.

(c) the first and second respondents pay the appellant’s costs of the proceedings at first instance.

5. The first and second respondents pay the appellant’s costs of the appeal.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

In the reasons that follow, references to relevant affidavits are provided by stating the name of the deponent, followed by a number indicating whether the reference is to the first or second affidavit, followed by the relevant paragraph number. References to “AB” are to the page number of Part C of the Appeal Book. These include references to the trial transcript.FACTUAL BACKGROUND Elanor is a corporation within the Elanor Investors Group. It conducts an investment and funds management business. Elanor is the responsible entity of the Elanor Investment Fund which is a registered managed investment scheme operated pursuant to a trust. Units in the trust form part of stapled securities listed on the Australian Stock Exchange: J[10]. Mr Blake McNaughton, an executive director of Elanor, was centrally involved in assessing the purchase of the Centre as an investment to be marketed to sophisticated investors in a proposed unregistered management investment scheme. Mr McNaughton reported to Mr Michael Baliva as to the outcome of the assessments that he made concerning the prospective acquisition: J[12]. Mr Baliva was Elanor’s co-head of real estate: J[12]. Mr Baliva’s primary role was to report to Elanor’s board in relation to the proposed acquisition. The Centre was constructed in 2008 as a neighbourhood shopping complex. It comprised 49 tenancies with a Woolworths Supermarket as the anchor tenant: J[2]. It was purchased by Alceon on 3 April 2013 for $41,750,000: J[51]. Alceon entered into an investment management agreement with CPRAM on 13 December 2012 under which CPRAM accepted appointment as one of the joint managers of the “Bluewater Trust”. CPRAM’s duties included identification of intended trust acquisitions, management of trust assets, budgeting, forecasting, reporting and oversight of day-to-day asset management and administration of trust assets: J[19]. It also had the task of identifying opportunities for the disposal of trust assets: J[50]. Mr Frenil Shah was a director of CPRAM. He was the portfolio manager in relation to four shopping centres, including the Centre. Mr Shah’s responsibilities included supervising centre managers and liaising with external contractors and consultants. As portfolio manager he was responsible for oversight of the day-to-day management and administration of the Centre, financial analysis and reporting, as well as being a direct liaison with the tenants. Mr Frenil Shah supervised Mr Carrigan (a leasing manager), Mr Song (an analyst) and Mr Neil Shah (his brother and a junior analyst). Mr Frenil Shah recommended that Alceon engage Savills as the property manager for the Centre. Alceon engaged Savills as the on-site property manager at the Centre, under a property management agreement dated 19 December 2015: J[14]. Ms Anna-Maree Coco was employed by Savills as the on-site property manager between May 2016 and November 2017: J[14]. Savills provided services which included the general administration of each of the tenancies by collecting rent, holding security deposits, ensuring compliance with tenant obligations, maintaining a tenancy schedule, maintaining tenancy files and financial management: J[51]. Savills’ financial management obligation included the preparation of: monthly financial management reports for the Centre; a monthly statement of monies received and expenses incurred; the issue of monthly invoices to tenants; the collection of rent and charges; and review of rental arrears.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

It follows that ground seven of the notice of contention fails.CONCLUSION The appeal should be allowed. Elanor is entitled to damages of $2.86 million together with interest on that sum from 1 November 2017. In view of the apportionment I have determined, Alceon is to pay to Elanor the sum of $2.002 million together with interest on that sum from 1 November 2017. CPRAM is to pay the sum of $858,000 together with interest on that sum from 1 November 2017. Save for those figures, I agree with the orders proposed by Bromwich and Thawley JJ.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.