Lenane Holdings Pty Ltd v Summit Rural (WA) Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 82 min read

JURISDICTION     :   DISTRICT COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

IN CIVIL

LOCATION:   PERTH

CITATION:   LENANE HOLDINGS PTY LTD -v- SUMMIT RURAL (WA) PTY LTD [2023] WADC 42

CORAM:   SHEPHERD DCJ

HEARD:   7-10, 13 JUNE & 29, 31 AUGUST 2022

DELIVERED          :   6 APRIL 2023

FILE NO/S:   CIV 23 of 2021

BETWEEN:   LENANE HOLDINGS PTY LTD

Plaintiff

AND

SUMMIT RURAL (WA) PTY LTD

Defendant


Catchwords:

Negligence - Duty of care - Obligation of defendant in the hire of Caterpillar 938K Loader - Obligation of defendant in the hire of loader used in defendant's fertiliser plant - Whether duty of care extended to turning off isolator switch - Loader caught fire and destroyed - Whether harm caused by defendant's failure to turn off isolator switch - Causation - Contract - Whether defendant under contractual obligation to turn off isolator switch

Legislation:

Civil Liability Act 2002 (WA) s 3, s 5B, s 5B(1)(a), s 5B(2), s 5C, s 5C(1), s 5C(1)(a), s 5C(1)(b), s 5C(2), s 5C(2)(a), s 5C(2)(b), s 5D

Result:

Judgment for the plaintiff in the sum of $245,500

Representation:

Counsel:

Plaintiff : Mr J Healy & Mr M Massarotto
Defendant : Mr A P Hershowitz & Ms G C P Wilts

Solicitors:

Plaintiff : Barry Nilsson Lawyers
Defendant : Gillis Delaney Lawyers

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

Adeels Palace Pty Ltd v Moubarak; Adeels Palace Pty Ltd v Bou Najem [2009] HCA 48; (2009) 239 CLR 420

Allied Pumps Pty Ltd v Hooker [2020] WASCA 72

Briginshaw v Briginshaw [1938] HCA 34; (1938) 60 CLR 336

CGU Insurance Ltd v Coote [2018] WASCA 117

Chamberlain v The Queen (No 2) [1984] HCA 7; (1984) 153 CLR 521

Codelfa Construction Pty Ltd v State Rail Authority of New South Wales (1982) 149 CLR 337

Department of Housing and Works v Smith (No 2) [2010] WASCA 25; (2010) 41 WAR 217

D'Souza v Barclays Building Services (WA) Pty Ltd [2020] WADC 87

East Metropolitan Health Service v Ellis (by his Next Friend Christopher Graham Ellis) [2020] WASCA 147

Electricity Generation Corporation t/as Verve Energy v Woodside Energy Ltd [2014] HCA 7; (2014) 251 CLR 640

Fazio v Fazio [2012] WASCA 72

Graham Barclay Oysters Pty Ltd v Ryan [2002] HCA 54; (2002) 211 CLR 540

Hirst v Sydney South West Area Health Service [2011] NSWSC 664

Hunt & Hunt Lawyers v Mitchell Morgan Nominees Pty Ltd [2013] HCA 10; (2013) 247 CLR 613

Husher v Husher [1999] HCA 47; (1999) 197 CLR 138

Jones v Dunkel [1959] HCA 8; (1959) 101 CLR 298

Jones v Sutherland Shire Council [1979] 2 NSWLR 206

King v Nash [2022] WASC 102

Livingstone v Rawyards Coal Co (1880) 5 App Cas 25

Luxton v Vines [1952] HCA 19; (1952) 85 CLR 352

Medlin v State Government Insurance Commission [1995] HCA 5; (1995) 182 CLR 1

Montemaggiori v Wilson [2011] WASCA 177

New South Wales v Fahy [2007] HCA 20; (2007) 232 CLR 486

Osborne Park Commercial…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lenane Holdings Pty Ltd v Summit Rural (WA) Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] WADC 42
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Lenane Holdings Pty Ltd brought an action against Summit Rural (WA) Pty Ltd, seeking damages for the destruction of a Caterpillar 938K Loader by fire. The dispute arose from the loader catching fire and being destroyed while it was being hired by Summit. The plaintiff alleged that the loader caught fire because the defendant failed to turn off the isolator switch, which was a necessary precaution to prevent electrical faults from causing a fire. The case was heard in the District Court of Western Australia, where the plaintiff argued that the defendant breached its duty of care and contractual obligations by not turning off the isolator switch.

The primary legal issues that the court had to decide were whether the defendant had a duty of care to turn off the isolator switch, whether this duty of care was breached, and whether the breach of duty caused the harm suffered by the plaintiff. The court had to determine whether the defendant's failure to turn off the isolator switch was a necessary condition for the occurrence of the harm and whether it was appropriate for the defendant's liability to extend to the harm caused.

The court concluded that the defendant had a duty of care to turn off the isolator switch at the end of each shift to prevent harm to the loader, given that it was foreseeable that a failure to do so could result in electrical faults causing a fire. The court found that the defendant breached this duty by not turning off the isolator switch, and this breach was a necessary condition for the occurrence of the harm. The court also found that it was appropriate for the defendant's liability to extend to the harm caused, as the defendant operated complex machinery relying on energised circuits and knew that it had a duty to turn the isolator switch off. Therefore, the court held that the defendant was liable for the harm caused by its failure to turn off the isolator switch.

The court ordered that Summit Rural (WA) Pty Ltd pay Lenane Holdings Pty Ltd the sum of $398,596.40, representing the value of the destroyed loader, along with interest and costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Where there was no evidence It is necessary for me to say something about where there was no evidence of certain matters during the trial, or evidence of limited weight, and how I have approached those matters. They fall into four main categories:(i)no evidence from Caterpillar; (ii)no evidence from WesTrac; (iii)no evidence about how the after-market equipment was installed; and(iv)no evidence of any underlying fault within the loader prior to the fire. There was no evidence led at trial from the manufacturer of the loader, Caterpillar, as to the purpose of installing the master key/isolator switch, or at all. It appeared to be uncontested at trial that there was an Operator's Manual in place in 2018 (2018 Manual), that the 2018 Manual had been provided to Summit, but that it was physically within the cabin of the loader and was destroyed in the fire. I note that there was no evidence of those facts adduced at trial, however, both parties proceeded on what I take to be agreed facts on these points. There was no evidence led at trial as to the content of the 2018 Manual. Whilst there was evidence led at trial about the manual in operation in 2020 (the 2020 Manual),[39] there was no evidence as to whether this differed in any way to the 2018 Manual, and if so, how. [39] Exhibit 11. Specifically in respect of the critical issues in this case, there was no evidence led at trial that the 2018 Manual contained any detail in respect of the isolator switch. I have approached this matter on the basis that there is insufficient evidence before me from which I am able to draw an inference that the 2018 Manual would have been, or was, in identical, or even similar, terms to the 2020 Manual in respect of any sections to do with the isolator switch. For those reasons I do not consider that I can have regard to the 2020 Manual and have not done so in reaching my determination of this matter. There was no evidence called from anyone from WesTrac, the company responsible for servicing the loader. At trial copies of service dockets headed 'Time, Expenses Sheet and Service Reports' dated, variously, 30 April 2018, 5 July 2018, 8 August 2018 and 29 September 2018 were tendered into evidence by both parties (the WesTrac Service Records).[40] [40] Exhibits 13, 14, 15 and 57 respectively. In the absence of a witness from WesTrac, there was no explanation as to the notations on the face of those documents, nor whether the notations on the face of those documents comprised accurate or complete records of any examinations or servicing undertaken, or not undertaken, on the loader. The WesTrac Service Records make no mention of the existence of any known electrical faults within the loader. The 5 July 2018 Service Report documents that the alternator was replaced.[41] [41] Exhibit 14. There was no evidence before me to explain why the alternator was replaced, nor when the alternator first became faulty such that it was ultimately replaced. There was no evidence led at trial as to whether there was anything located within the alternator that would permit me to draw any inference about the alternator as a possible cause of, or contributor to, the fire.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Conclusions on duty of care The defendant had a duty of care co-existent with its contractual obligations to utilise, store, maintain and keep the loader in a manner which would avoid the risk of harm to the loader. The risk of harm includes damage to property. That the employee of the defendant, Mr Parsons, in his evidence made it clear that he knew that 'the machine had to be isolated' demonstrates that the defendant knew that it had a duty to turn the isolator switch off at the conclusion of each shift. The defendant was a commercial operator hiring the loader to work in a fertiliser plant. That the defendant operated complex machinery relying on energised circuits informs me that a reasonable person in the position of the defendant ought to have taken reasonable steps to ensure that the loader was safely stored overnight. It was reasonably foreseeable that a failure to remove any energised circuits within the engine compartment at the conclusion of a shift in all of the circumstances would give risk to a risk of harm, meaning damage to the loader. I therefore find that the precaution of turning the battery isolator switch into the off position was a precaution which a reasonable person in the defendant's position would have taken. For those reasons I conclude that the defendant failed to take the precaution that a reasonable person in the defendant's position would have taken in respect of a risk of harm that the defendant knew or ought to have known and in respect of which the risk was not insignificant. I therefore conclude that Summit breached the duty of care it owed to the plaintiff. Causation The CLA guides, but does not displace, the application of the common law on the issue of causation.[480][480] Wallace v Kam [2013] HCA 19; (2013) 250 CLR 375 [22] (Wallace). The issue of causation is governed by CLA s 5C which provides:5C.General principles(1)A determination that the fault of a person (the tortfeasor) caused particular harm comprises the following elements - (a)that the fault was a necessary condition of the occurrence of the harm (factual causation); and(b)that it is appropriate for the scope of the tortfeasor's liability to extend to the harm so caused (scope of liability).(2)In determining in an appropriate case, in accordance with established principles, whether a fault that cannot be established as a necessary condition of the occurrence of harm should be taken to establish factual causation, the court is to consider (amongst other relevant things) -(a)whether and why responsibility for the harm should, or should not, be imposed on the tortfeasor; and(b)whether and why the harm should be left to lie where it fell.(3)If it is relevant to the determination of factual causation to determine what the person who suffered harm (the injured person) would have done if the tortfeasor had not been at fault -(a)subject to paragraph (b), the matter is to be determined by considering what the injured person would have done if the tortfeasor had not been at fault; and (b)evidence of the injured person as to what he or she would have done if the tortfeasor had not been at fault is inadmissible. (4)For the purpose of determining the scope of liability, the court is to consider (amongst other relevant things) whether and why responsibility for the harm should, or should not, be imposed on the tortfeasor.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.