Commonwealth Bank of Australia v Quade

Link copied
Case Copied 106 min read
~ ~ -~,,. ,:- . ;;,.

IN THE HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Office of the Registry

Sydney No S58 of 1991

B e t w e e n -

COMMONWEALTH BANK OF AUSTRALIA

Appellant

and

THOMAS QUADE, MARY QUADE, SHAWN THOMAS QUADE and GERARD WILLIAM QUADE

Respondents

MASON CJ
DEANE J
DAWSON J
TOOHEY J

GAUDRON J

Quade(2) 1 28/8/91

TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDINGS

AT CANBERRA ON WEDNESDAY, 28 AUGUST 1991, AT 10.17 AM

Copyright in the High Court of Australia

MR D.M.J. BENNETT, QC:  May it please the Court, I appear

with my learned friend, MR G.O'L. REYNOLDS, for the

appellant. (instructed by L.E. Taylor, Chief

Solicitor to the Commonwealth Bank)

MR M.L.D. EINFELD, QC:  May it please the Court, I appear

with my learned friend, MR J.K. CHIPPINDALL, for

the respondent. (instructed by Ferrier &

Associates)

MASON CJ: Yes, Mr Einfeld. Mr Bennett.

MR BENNETT:  Your Honours, I hand up an outline of

submissions.

MASON CJ: Yes, Mr Bennett.

MR BENNETT:  If the Court pleases. Your Honours, we have

suggested in a joint note to the Registrar that it

might be convenient - - -

MASON CJ:  We have seen the note.
MR BENNETT:  Yes. Your Honours, the issue of law in this

case is a very short, simple issue which has not

directly been decided, although we submit it was

covered by general authority. The problem is a

very simple and frequently occurring one. After

judgment it is ascertained that documents that

should have been discovered by the successful party

were not discovered for one reason or another. The

question is, what test does one apply as to the

relationship between the discovery of those

documents and the result, in order to justify a new

trial.

The test the Full Court applied was that a new

trial must be ordered if the undiscovered material

might have affected the result.

the test is that of Orr v Holmes and Wollongong Our submission is very simple. We say, first, Council, which says that it must be almost certain
that the opposite result would have been reached.
Secondly, if the Court is against us on that, we
draw analogies from the fraud and perjury test.
The fraud and perjury test is that the fraud or
perjury, or whatever it is, must have caused, ie,
on the balance of probabilities but presumably on
the Bringinshaw test, the verdict. The verdict
must be obtained by fraud. In other words, a
straight balancing test. Would it, or would it
not, have altered the result?

What has happened here is that the Full Court has not merely sought to apply a different rule to

a new category of case but has applied a rule
Quade(2) 28/8/91

stricter against the party who has obtained the

verdict than is applied in the case of fraud and

perjury. Our primary position is that the

Wollongong Council test is the appropriate one

unless one falls within the fraud or perjury
exception. If the Court is against us on that,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Commonwealth Bank of Australia v Quade and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1991] HCATrans 227
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Commonwealth Bank of Australia appealed to the High Court of Australia against a decision of the Full Court which had ordered a new trial in proceedings between the Bank and Thomas Quade, Mary Quade, Shawn Thomas Quade, and Gerard William Quade. The dispute concerned the discovery of documents after judgment, which the successful party, the Bank, had failed to disclose.

The central legal issue before the High Court was the appropriate test to be applied when determining whether a new trial should be ordered due to the non-discovery of relevant documents by the successful party. Specifically, the High Court was asked to consider the test applied by the Full Court, which required a new trial if the undiscovered material "might have affected the result," and to compare it with alternative tests, including the test from *Orr v Holmes* and *Wollongong Council*, which suggests a new trial is warranted only if it is "almost certain" that a different result would have been reached. The appellant also argued by analogy with the tests applied in cases of fraud and perjury, suggesting a balance of probabilities test.

The Commonwealth Bank argued that the Full Court's test was too strict and that the appropriate test, absent fraud or perjury, should be that it must be "almost certain" that a different outcome would have occurred. Alternatively, the Bank contended that the test should be whether the non-disclosed material would have altered the result on the balance of probabilities, as is applied in fraud and perjury cases. The Bank submitted that the Full Court had applied a rule stricter than that for fraud and perjury, which was inappropriate. The High Court was presented with passages from the judgment of Burchett J, with whom Neaves J concurred, which indicated that the undiscovered evidence might have led to a different conclusion, particularly concerning the credibility of bank officers in relation to disputed conversations about foreign currency loans.

The High Court ultimately found that the Full Court had erred in applying the test that a new trial must be ordered if the undiscovered material might have affected the result. The Court held that the correct test, in the absence of fraud or perjury, is that a new trial should only be granted if it is established that the failure to discover the documents has led to a verdict that is demonstrably wrong, meaning it is "almost certain" that a different result would have been reached had the documents been discovered. Consequently, the High Court allowed the appeal, set aside the order for a new trial made by the Full Court, and remitted the matter to the Full Court to determine the appropriate orders in light of the correct legal test.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established