SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND
CITATION:
O’Connor & ors v CWC Investors Pty Ltd & ors [2017] QSC 279
PARTIES:
KEITH O’CONNOR
(first plaintiff)
SUSAN MAREE O’CONNOR
(second plaintiff)
COMSTON PTY LTD
ACN 010 212 316(third plaintiff)
v
CWC INVESTORS PTY LTD AS TRUSTEE FOR THE CWC INVESTMENT UNIT TRUST
ACN 113 607 748(first defendant)
CWC COFA PTY LTD AS TRUSTEE FOR THE CWC CORPORATE OPPORTUNITY 1A TRUST
ACN 113 611 911(second defendant)
CWC COFB PTY LTD AS TRUSTEE FOR THE CWC CORPORATE OPPORTUNITY lB TRUST
ACN 114 881 113(third defendant)
TANARRA CAPITAL AUSTRALIA PTY LTD
ACN 114 164 331(fourth defendant)
BETTYAL PTY LTD
ACN 074 216 247(fifth defendant)
BRENDAN MADDEN
(sixth defendant)
LINDSAY PHILLIPS
(seventh defendant)
DAVID BLOWER
(eighth defendant)
JOHN LOCKETT
(ninth defendant)
ROBERT GREGG
(tenth defendant)
ALEC BRENNAN AM
(eleventh defendant)
FILE NO/S:
SC No 2496 of 2017
DIVISION:
Trial Division
PROCEEDING:
Application
DELIVERED ON:
24 November 2017
DELIVERED AT:
Brisbane
HEARING DATE:
20 November 2017
JUDGE:
Bond J
ORDER:
The orders of the Court are that:
[1] There be judgment for the defendants against the plaintiffs in relation to the plaintiffs’ claim that the defendants refund to the plaintiffs the amount of $894,316 incurred in preparing their defence and counterclaim in the previous proceeding plus interest.
[2] Subject to [3], the plaintiffs’ statement of claim must be struck out in its entirety, with no leave to replead.
[3] The plaintiffs must file and serve a statement of claim which pleads:
(a) all their claims for relief deriving from the allegation that the plaintiffs were induced to enter into the Settlement Deed by the CWC parties’ fraudulent misrepresentation that they had no knowledge of the dealing between CopperCo and PPI in late August and early September 2008 in which CopperCo placed large orders for PVC pipe with PPI; and, in particular,
(b) the material facts relied on to establish the causal link between the alleged fraudulent representation and the plaintiffs entering into the Settlement Deed.
[4] The plaintiffs must deliver the affidavit evidence on which they would rely to establish the causal link between the alleged fraudulent representation and the plaintiffs entering into the Settlement Deed.
[5] The question of whether the defendants should have summary judgment in relation to the plaintiffs’ claim as pleaded by the statement of claim referred to in [3] will be set down for hearing before me.
[6] The plaintiffs must pay the defendants’ costs of and incidental to the defendants’ application filed 17 July 2017 on the indemnity basis.
[7] I will hear the parties on the questions of:
(a) the date by which the statement of claim referred to in [3] and the evidence referred to in [4] should be filed and served;
(b) the date on which the hearing referred to in [5] should occur;
(c) what ancillary orders should be made to facilitate the expeditious determination of that question; and
(d) whether the costs referred to in [6] should be fixed by me…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read O'Connor v CWC Investors Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2017] QSC 279
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the court were whether the plaintiffs' statement of claim should be struck out due to its prolix narrative and reliance on pleas of evidence rather than material facts, and whether the plaintiffs had a real prospect of success in their claims. The court had to determine if the statement of claim was sufficient to proceed to trial or if it should be dismissed on the grounds of being unmanageable or lacking in substantive merit.
In delivering the judgment, the court found that the plaintiffs' statement of claim was excessively detailed and more akin to a collection of pleas of evidence. The court held that the statement of claim should be struck out in its entirety, without leave to replead, as it did not sufficiently plead the material facts necessary to establish the plaintiffs' claims. The court mandated that the plaintiffs refile a statement of claim that clearly outlines the material facts relied upon to establish the causal link between the alleged fraudulent representation and the plaintiffs entering into the Settlement Deed. Additionally, the plaintiffs were required to deliver the affidavit evidence on which they would rely to establish this causal link.
The court further ordered that judgment be entered in favour of the defendants for the claim regarding the refund of legal costs, and set a hearing date for the question of whether the defendants should receive summary judgment for the claims as re-pleaded by the plaintiffs. The plaintiffs were also required to pay the defendants' costs of the application on an indemnity basis. The court reserved certain matters, including the dates for filing the new statement of claim and evidence, the hearing date, and the fixing of costs, for further discussion between the parties.
Orders
Orders of the court
The orders of the Court are that:
[1] There be judgment for the defendants against the plaintiffs in relation to the plaintiffs’ claim that the defendants refund to the plaintiffs the amount of $894,316 incurred in preparing their defence and counterclaim in the previous proceeding plus interest.
[2] Subject to [3], the plaintiffs’ statement of claim must be struck out in its entirety, with no leave to replead.
[3] The plaintiffs must file and serve a statement of claim which pleads:
(a) all their claims for relief deriving from the allegation that the plaintiffs were induced to enter into the Settlement Deed by the CWC parties’ fraudulent misrepresentation that they had no knowledge of the dealing between CopperCo and PPI in late August and early September 2008 in which CopperCo placed large orders for PVC pipe with PPI; and, in particular,
(b) the material facts relied on to establish the causal link between the alleged fraudulent representation and the plaintiffs entering into the Settlement Deed.
[4] The plaintiffs must deliver the affidavit evidence on which they would rely to establish the causal link between the alleged fraudulent representation and the plaintiffs entering into the Settlement Deed.
[5] The question of whether the defendants should have summary judgment in relation to the plaintiffs’ claim as pleaded by the statement of claim referred to in [3] will be set down for hearing before me.
[6] The plaintiffs must pay the defendants’ costs of and incidental to the defendants’ application filed 17 July 2017 on the indemnity basis.
[7] I will hear the parties on the questions of:
(a) the date by which the statement of claim referred to in [3] and the evidence referred to in [4] should be filed and served;
(b) the date on which the hearing referred to in [5] should occur;
(c) what ancillary orders should be made to facilitate the expeditious determination of that question; and
(d) whether the costs referred to in [6] should be fixed by me or assessed in the usual way.
[8] The parties will have liberty to apply.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Full text does not contain this section.