O'Connor v CWC Investors Pty Ltd (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

O’Connor & Ors v CWC Investors Pty Ltd & Ors (No 2) [2019] QSC 138

PARTIES:

KEITH O’CONNOR
(first plaintiff)

SUSAN MAREE O’CONNOR
(second plaintiff)

COMSTON PTY LTD
ACN 010 212 316
(third plaintiff)

v

CWC INVESTORS PTY LTD AS TRUSTEE FOR THE CWC INVESTMENT UNIT TRUST
ACN 113 607 748
(first defendant)

CWC COFA PTY LTD AS TRUSTEE FOR THE CWC CORPORATE OPPORTUNITY 1A TRUST
ACN 113 611 911
(second defendant)

CWC COFB PTY LTD AS TRUSTEE FOR THE CWC CORPORATE OPPORTUNITY 1B TRUST
ACN 114 881 113
(third defendant)

TANARRA CAPITAL AUSTRALIA PTY LTD
ACN 114 164 331
(fourth defendant)

BETTYAL PTY LTD
ACN 074 216 247
(fifth defendant)

BRENDAN MADDEN
(sixth defendant)

LINDSAY PHILLIPS
(seventh defendant)

DAVID BLOWER
(eighth defendant)

JOHN LOCKETT
(ninth defendant)

ROBERT GREGG
(tenth defendant)

ALEC BRENNAN AM
(eleventh defendant)

FILE NO:

BS No 2496 of 2017

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

7 June 2019

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

15 May 2019

JUDGE:

Flanagan J

ORDER:

1.    The application to stay the enforcement of the costs order of 11 October 2018 is dismissed.

2.    The O’Connor parties pay the CWC parties’ costs of and incidental to the application.

CATCHWORDS:

PROCEDURE – CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS – COSTS – INTERLOCUTORY PROCEEDINGS – where plaintiffs seek to stay the enforcement of a money order – where the money order arises out of two indemnity costs orders relating to a summary judgment and strike out application and a subsequently amended statement of claim – where the plaintiffs allege they will be bankrupted if a stay were not granted – where there is a history of the plaintiffs receiving loans from family members to continue the proceeding –whether a stay should be granted

Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld) r 800

Alexander v Cambridge Credit Corp Ltd (1985) 2 NSWLR 685, cited
Cook’s Construction Pty Ltd v Stork Food Systems Australasia Pty Ltd [2008] 2 Qd R 453, cited
Croney v Nand [1999] 2 Qd R 342, cited
Lee v Abedian & Ors [2017] QSC 22, considered
O’Connor & ors v CWC Investors Pty Ltd & ors [2017] QSC 279, cited
Virgtel Ltd v Zabusky (No 2) [2009] QCA 349, considered

COUNSEL:

The first plaintiff appeared on his own behalf and on behalf of the second and third plaintiffs

J D McKenna QC with D Fuller for the defendants

SOLICITORS:

The first plaintiff appeared on his own behalf and on behalf of the second and third plaintiffs
Minter Ellison for the defendants

  1. By application filed 21 December 2018 the applicants seek, pursuant to r 800 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld) (UCPR), a stay of the enforcement of a costs order made 11 October 2018.

  2. The costs order, which was made by the Deputy Registrar, was in the following terms:

    “The Plaintiffs pay the [sic] Defendants costs pursuant to:

    (a)the orders of the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read O'Connor v CWC Investors Pty Ltd (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] QSC 138
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of O'Connor v CWC Investors Pty Ltd (No 2), the plaintiffs sought to stay the enforcement of a money order resulting from two indemnity costs orders. These orders were made in relation to a summary judgment and a strike-out application, as well as an amended statement of claim. The plaintiffs argued that if the stay were not granted, they would be bankrupted. The defendants opposed the application, asserting that the plaintiffs had a history of receiving loans from family members to continue the proceedings.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether a stay should be granted to the plaintiffs to prevent the enforcement of the money order. The court had to consider the financial implications of enforcing the order on the plaintiffs and whether there were any exceptional circumstances that warranted a stay.

The court found that the plaintiffs had not demonstrated any exceptional circumstances that would warrant a stay of the enforcement of the money order. The court also noted that the plaintiffs had a history of receiving loans from family members to fund their legal proceedings, which was a relevant factor in determining whether a stay should be granted. The court held that the plaintiffs had not shown that they would be irreparably harmed if the money order were enforced. Consequently, the application to stay the enforcement of the money order was dismissed.

The final orders of the court were that the application to stay the enforcement of the costs order of 11 October 2018 was dismissed, and the plaintiffs were ordered to pay the defendants' costs of and incidental to the application.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application to stay the enforcement of the costs order of 11 October 2018 is dismissed.

2. The O’Connor parties pay the CWC parties’ costs of and incidental to the application.

Background

Background to the litigation

This case involves a dispute between the plaintiffs, Mr O'Connor and others, and the CWC parties, who were the majority shareholders of PPI Corporation Pty Ltd and its parent company PPI Corporation Holdings Pty Ltd. The previous proceeding was a commercial dispute relating to the ownership and management of PPI Corporation Pty Ltd and its parent company. The CWC parties alleged that Mr O'Connor, a former director and Chief Financial Officer of PPI Operations, had made unfounded allegations of criminal behaviour, fraud, dishonesty and misleading conduct against them and other defendants, improperly disclosed confidential information, and issued notices of default and a termination notice under the Shareholders Agreement without any legal basis. The previous proceeding settled on the second day of a two-week trial, with the parties agreeing to a Settlement Deed. The Settlement Deed provided, among other things, that the plaintiffs would pay the CWC parties $315,000, release one another from all claims, and withdraw certain allegations. Following the settlement, the CWC parties were awarded costs in two indemnity costs orders, one relating to a summary judgment and strike out application, and the other to a subsequently amended statement of claim. The plaintiffs now seek to stay the enforcement of the money order, alleging that they will be bankrupted if a stay is not granted.

The matter before the court is an application by the plaintiffs to stay the enforcement of a money order. The money order arises out of two indemnity costs orders relating to a summary judgment and strike out application, and a subsequently amended statement of claim. The plaintiffs argue that they will be bankrupted if the stay is not granted. The CWC parties oppose the application. This case follows on from a previous proceeding that settled on the second day of a two-week trial. Both parties in the previous proceeding were represented by Senior Counsel.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether a stay should be granted to prevent the enforcement of the money order.
2. Whether the plaintiffs will be bankrupted if the stay is not granted.

Held
1. The court decided that the application to stay the enforcement of the costs order of 11 October 2018 should be dismissed.
2. The plaintiffs, the O’Connor parties, were ordered to pay the CWC parties’ costs of and incidental to the application.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In his affidavit, Mr Fletcher, a solicitor for the CWC parties, provides the following background to the previous proceeding:[2][2] Affidavit of Michael Thomas Fletcher filed 8 May 2019, paragraphs 6-8.“The previous proceeding was a commercial dispute relating to the ownership and management of PPI Corporation Pty Ltd (PPI Operations) and its parent company PPI Corporation Holdings Pty Ltd (PPI). The CWC parties held a substantial majority of the shares in PPI. The first plaintiff (Mr O’Connor) and the third plaintiff in the present proceeding were also shareholders of PPI. Mr O’Connor was a former director of PPI and PPI Operations and the former Chief Financial Officer of PPI Operations.The CWC parties alleged, among other things, that Mr O’Connor had:(a) made unfounded allegations of criminal behaviour, fraud, dishonesty and misleading conduct against the CWC parties and other defendants in the current proceedings (who were directors and other officers of PPI and PPI Operations);(b) improperly disclosed PPI’s confidential information, attended PPI’s offices and accessed its documents; and(c) issued ‘notices of default’ and a ‘termination notice’ under the Shareholders Agreement between the parties without any legal basis.The relief the CWC parties sought included:(a) injunctions against Mr O’Connor restraining him from making allegations of fraud or criminal behaviour against anyone involved in PPI or PPI Operations, as the CWC parties alleged he had been doing;(b) injunctions against all the defendants in the previous proceeding restraining them from relying on the purported ‘notices of default’ and ‘termination notice’ to prevent the CWC parties from voting at PPI meetings, receiving or participating in any PPI distributions or transferring shares in PPI or receiving information about PPI or PPI Operations; and(c) declarations as to the termination of the Shareholders Agreement between the parties.” The previous proceeding settled on the second day of a two week trial. Both parties in the previous proceeding were represented by Senior Counsel.[3][3] Affidavit of Michael Thomas Fletcher filed 8 May 2019, paragraphs 10-11. Mr Fletcher summarises the settlement deed as having the following effect:[4]:“(a) Mr O’Connor and the third plaintiff agreed to pay the CWC parties $315,000 and to give the CWC parties a share mortgage over their shares in PPI to secure those obligations;(b) the parties agree to release one another from all claims in the previous proceeding and in relation to the Shareholders Agreement and the affairs of PPI and PPI Operations;(c) Mr O’Connor and the third plaintiff agreed to withdraw his allegations of criminal behaviour, fraud and similar matters and release the CWC parties and officers from any claims relating to those allegations and any claims relating to the sale of PPI and PPI Operations;(d) these releases were an absolutely bar and defence to any claim agreed to be released;(e) the parties agreed to discontinue the previous proceeding;(f) the O’Connor parties agreed that selling the assets of PPI Operations and PPI was in the shareholders’ best interests and agreed not to obstruct that sale;(g) the parties agreed to bear their own costs associated with the Settlement Deed; and(h) the parties agreed and acknowledge that they had freely entered into the Settlement Deed after having the opportunity to carefully consider its contents and to obtain legal or other professional advice on the matters in the Deed, and that they understood the content and consequences of entering into the Deed.”[4] Affidavit of Michael Thomas Fletcher filed 8 May 2019, paragraphs 10-12.