Players P/L (in Liq) (Receiver Appointed) v Clone P/L (No 3)

Link copied
Case Copied 45 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil)

PLAYERS P/L (IN LIQ) (RECEIVER APPOINTED) & ORS v CLONE P/L & ORS (No 3)

[2020] SASC 165

Judgment of Auxiliary Judge Norman a Master of the Supreme Court

9 September 2020

PROCEDURE - CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS - COSTS - TAXATION AND OTHER FORMS OF ASSESSMENT - PARTICULAR ITEMS - COUNSEL FEES - NUMBER OF COUNSEL - TWO COUNSEL

Held, trial at first instance before Hargrave AJ and subsequent Full Court appeal certified as appropriate for two senior counsel,  counsel fees of senior counsel Mr Karkar QC and Mr Sullivan QC allowed at the rate of $500 per hour and $5,000 per day, counsel fees of second senior counsel Mr Roberts QC allowed at $300 per hour and $3,000 per day from August 2010 until around the end of December 2013, at $350 per hour and $3,500 per day from January 2014, and at $450 per hour and $4,500 per day from on or around 30 November 2014.

Dust Diseases Act 2005, referred to.
Kroehn v Kroehn (1912) 15 CLR 137; 18 ALR 455; Dalgety Australia Operations Ltd v FF Seely Nominees Pty Ltd (No. 2) (1988) 49 SASR 75; Taplin v Amaca Pty Ltd [2020] SADC 3; Meyer v Amaca Pty Ltd (formerly James Hardie & Co. Pty Ltd) District Court, Master Norman, Decision No. 33 of 2013; Leighton Contractors Pty Ltd v Public Transport Authority of Western Australia (No. 7) [2009] WASC 218 at [44], applied.
Reynolds v Comcare District Court, Master Norman, delivered 2 July 2008; Hockley v BI Contracting District Court,  Master Rice, delivered 11 July 2011; Ewbank v Wallaby Grip District Court ,Master Rice, delivered 28 June 2012; Weber v Deakin University (No. 2) [2016] VSC 679; Pinehurst Nominees Pty Ltd v Coeur De Lion Investments Pty Ltd [2015] QSC 122 at [20]; Edwards v Legalese Pty Ltd T/A Peter Scragg & Associates (No. 2) [2012] SADC 110; Edwards v Legalese Pty Ltd [2014] SASCFC 58; Australian Securities and Investment Commission (ASIC) v West (2008) 100 SASR 496; Innes v AAL Aviation Limited (No. 2) [2018] FCAFC 130, discussed.
06r 264(2); British Metal Corporation v Ludlow [1938] 1 All ER 135; Dal Pont's Law of Costs 2nd Edition; Whitley (deceased) (1963) 3 All ER 45 at 54; Higgins v Nicol & Ors (No. 2) (1972) 21 FLR 34 at 41; Stanley v Phillips (1966) 115 CLR 470; re Fuller Holdings Pty Ltd (1979) 21 SASR 212; Bush v Condon & Barrett Pty Ltd [1975] 1 NSWLR 260 at 263; Goode v Onslow (1881) 23 LR (NSW 278(3); Young v Ballarat & Ballarat East water Cmrs (1880) 6 VLR (l) 14 at 14-18; Commonwealth Bank of Australia v Quade (1991) 178 CLR 134; Clone v Players (2018) 264 CLR 165; Clone v Players [2015] SASC 133, Judge Bowen Pain; Clone v Players (2016) 127 SASR 1, considered.

PLAYERS P/L (IN LIQ)…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Players P/L (in Liq) (Receiver Appointed) v Clone P/L (No 3) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] SASC 165
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Players P/L (in Liq) (Receiver Appointed) v Clone P/L (No 3), the Federal Court was required to consider the issue of costs, specifically the fees for two senior counsel retained by the Respondent. The Court was tasked with determining whether the costs incurred by the Respondent in retaining two senior counsel were incurred fairly and reasonably, and whether such costs were justified given the nature and complexity of the case.

The Court found that the engagement of two senior counsel was an unusual expense and would be justified only in cases of exceptional difficulty, complexity, or importance. The Court applied the test established in Leighton Contractors Pty Ltd v Public Transport Authority of Western Australia [No. 7], where the Court found that to allow costs of two senior counsel would further increase the costs for an unsuccessful litigant and would only be allowed where the case was of such difficulty, complexity, or importance to justify burdening the unsuccessful party with those costs. The Court observed that the emphasis was upon obtaining an adequate presentation to enable justice to be done, rather than upon the propriety of the steps taken by a litigant to ensure maximum success in their own cause.

The Court found that the costs incurred by the Respondent in retaining Mr Walker SC were not incurred fairly or reasonably. The Court observed that Mr Walker SC was retained only to present the argument raised by the Respondent’s Notice of Contention concerning the limitation issue and he appeared only at the hearing on 17 November 2016. The Court found that there was no apparent reason why the submissions on the limitation of actions issue could not have been presented by Mr Lockhart SC and Mr Colquhoun, who had already made the submissions on the limitation of actions issue at trial and had been prepared to present the submissions at the hearing on 8 and 9 August 2016. The Court found that the retention of Mr Walker SC was not necessary to adequately present the case, and disallowed the whole of the fees incurred by the Respondent in retaining Mr Walker SC.

The Court made orders disallowing the whole of the fees incurred by the Respondent in retaining Mr Walker SC, including the disbursement to Mr Walker in respect of his fees and the solicitors’ costs in retaining him.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

At [42] it observed:“Fourthly, while the Court was much assisted by the submissions of Mr Walker SC, we are not satisfied that the costs incurred by the Respondent in retaining him were incurred fairly or reasonably. Mr Walker was retained only to present the argument raised by the Respondent’s Notice of Contention concerning the limitation issue and he appeared only at the hearing on 17 November 2016. Ms Dransfield deposed that Mr Walker had been briefed because of his familiarity with the subject matter arising from his involvement as counsel in Commonwealth of Australia v Cornwell [2007] HCA 16; (2007) 229 CLR 519 and Innes v Commonwealth [2015] ACTA 33. However, there is no apparent reason why the submissions on the Notice of Contention could not have been presented by Mr Lockhart SC and Mr Colquhoun. They had made the submissions on the limitation of actions issue at trial and had been prepared to present the submissions on the issue at the hearing on 8 and 9 August 2016. Had the Court been able to complete the hearing on these days, they would have done so. There has been no suggestion that Mr Lockhart SC and Mr Colquhoun were not able to present that argument. In those circumstances, we do not accept the Respondent’s submission that the limitation issue “demanded specialist knowledge” making reasonable the retention of Mr Walker SC. We disallow the whole of the fees incurred by the Respondent in retaining Mr Walker SC. This includes the disbursement to Mr Walker in respect of his fees and the solicitors’ costs in retaining him.”Consideration Engagement of two senior counselThe appropriate test I have referred to Leighton Contractors Pty Ltd v Public Transport Authority of Western Australia [No. 7] (supra), where the Court found that to allow costs of two senior counsel would further increase the costs for an unsuccessful litigant and would only be allowed where the case was of such difficulty, complexity or importance to justify burdening the unsuccessful party with those costs. The test is concerned not with what a reasonable litigant might be prepared to do in order to win, but with what such a person would adjudge necessary or prudent in order to have his or her case properly presented. As Barwick CJ wrote in Stanley v Phillips (supra), the emphasis is upon obtaining an adequate presentation to enable justice to be done and not upon the propriety of the steps taken by a litigant to ensure the maximum of success in his own cause. The question is whether the services of more than one counsel are reasonably necessary for the adequate presentation of the case. The engagement of two senior counsel is an unusual expense and will be justified in few cases. The trial and appeal both involved complex issues of law In my findings on 24 June 2020, I observed at [98]–[101] that the legal matters in issue at the trial (and the appeal), were complex and included whether the then solicitors and counsel for Clone in the action, before Vanstone J, had breached duties of disclosure (and other duties) so as to justify setting aside the judgment in favour of Clone, a determination of the relevant test, including consideration of authorities dating back many years and across a number of different jurisdictions, a claim for $750,000 compensation by Players under the lease terminated by Clone, the subject of the dispute, and the costs of the substantial proceedings in the original action sought to be set aside, including the 26 day trial before Vanstone J and the Full Court appeal.