Australian Securities and Investments Commission v West

Link copied
Case Copied 71 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil)

AUSTRALIAN SECURITIES AND INVESTMENTS COMMISSION v WEST & ANOR

[2008] SASC 111

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Gray

9 May 2008

CORPORATIONS - GENERALLY - CORPORATIONS LEGISLATION

CORPORATIONS - MANAGED INVESTMENTS - WHAT CONSTITUTE - GENERALLY

CORPORATIONS - MANAGED INVESTMENTS - WINDING UP

CORPORATIONS - WINDING UP - OTHER GROUNDS FOR WINDING UP - JUST AND EQUITABLE

CORPORATIONS - SUPERVISION - COURTS - POWERS - INJUNCTIONS RELATING TO CONTRAVENTION OF LEGISLATION

PROCEDURE - COSTS - DEPARTING FROM THE GENERAL RULE - ORDER FOR COSTS ON INDEMNITY BASIS

Application by ASIC for winding up orders against second defendant, pursuant to s 461(1)(k) Corporations Act, and against alleged unregistered managed investment scheme operated by second defendant and first defendant, a director of the second defendant , pursuant to s 601EE Corporations Act – injunctive and declaratory relief and ancillary orders also sought against defendants – whether second defendant should be wound up – whether business operation of second defendant constitutes a managed investment scheme – whether alleged managed investment scheme should be wound up – whether alleged managed investment scheme was required to be registered (s 601EB) – whether alleged managed investment scheme was unregistered and therefore unlawful (s 601ED(5)) – whether interests in alleged managed investment scheme constituted “financial products” (s 763A) – whether defendants made offers in relation to issue of financial products in alleged managed investment scheme (s 1020A) – whether defendants unlawfully failed to provide a product disclosure statement in relation to offer and/or issue of interests in alleged managed investment scheme (s 1012B) – whether second defendant failed to keep necessary financial records (s 286) – whether second defendant unlawfully carried on financial services business without holding an Australian Financial Services Licence (s 911A) – whether the defendants should be permanently restrained from further promoting or operating the managed investment scheme (ss 1101B, 1324(1) – whether the defendants should be permanently restrained from carrying on any business related to a managed investment scheme or being involved in the promotion or establishment of a managed investment scheme that requires registration – whether declarations of contravention should be made against defendants – whether defendants should pay ASIC's costs on an indemnity basis – whether certificate for senior counsel – consideration of legislative scheme of Corporations Act, ASIC Act 2001 (Cth), Financial Services Reform Act 2001 (Cth) and Managed Investments Act 1998 (Cth) – consideration of documentary evidence tendered at trial.

Held (allowing the application): second defendant wound up and liquidator appointed – mortgage investment business constituted an unregistered managed investment scheme - mortgage investment business wound up and liquidator appointed – declarations of contravention against the following Corporations Act provisions made: ss 286, 601ED(5), 911A, 1020A, 1012B – permanent injunctions against the defendants granted – first defendant to pay costs of action on an indemnity basis and costs of placing second defendant into provisional liquidation on a party and party basis - second defendant to pay the costs of ASIC on a party…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Securities and Investments Commission v West and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] SASC 111
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) sought winding up orders against John West & Associates Pty Ltd (JWA) and its director, Jonathan Peter West, under the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). ASIC also sought injunctive relief and declarations that the defendants had contravened various provisions of the Corporations Act, including those relating to managed investment schemes. The primary issue was whether JWA's mortgage investment business constituted an unregistered managed investment scheme. Secondary issues included whether the defendants unlawfully failed to provide a product disclosure statement and whether they operated a financial services business without a licence.

The court considered the legislative framework and documentary evidence provided by ASIC. The evidence included affidavits from ASIC investigators and financial records of JWA. The court found that JWA's business operations constituted an unregistered managed investment scheme. ASIC's application for winding up orders was successful, and the court appointed a liquidator for JWA and the managed investment scheme. The court also issued declarations of contravention against the defendants for various breaches of the Corporations Act and granted permanent injunctions against the defendants. The court ordered Jonathan Peter West to pay ASIC's costs on an indemnity basis and the costs of placing JWA into provisional liquidation on a party and party basis. JWA was ordered to pay ASIC's costs to the date of the provisional liquidation order, also on a party and party basis.

The court's decision was based on the evidence presented and the applicable legislative provisions. The court found that the defendants' actions constituted breaches of the Corporations Act and that the operation of JWA's business as an unregistered managed investment scheme warranted winding up. The court's reasoning and the outcome reflect the importance of compliance with financial regulations and the consequences for non-compliance.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

ASIC submitted that I should adopt the course followed in ASIC v Takaran Pty Ltd[12] where Barrett J concluded that in some circumstances, inferences to be drawn from documents admitted into evidence would be sufficient to make findings as to the existence of a managed investment scheme.[13] This is the approach that I propose to adopt. [12] ASIC v Takaran Pty Ltd (2002) 170 FLR 388.[13] ASIC v Takaran Pty Ltd (2002) 170 FLR 388 at [15].Affidavit Evidence The primary affidavit evidence relied upon by ASIC was from Ralph Murray Holmes, the Assistant Director Enforcement within ASIC’s Adelaide office, Jeremy Gordon Peel and Kathy-Anne Prosser, who are both ASIC investigators, Melissa Joy Smith, a lawyer employed by ASIC and Mr du Plessis, the Director of Forensic Technology at Ferrier Hodgson. Mr Holmes, in his capacity as Assistant Director Enforcement was familiar with ASIC’s investigation and with the nature of the within proceedings. Mr Holmes’ affidavit, sworn 24 July 2007, summarises the effect of many of the financial records and provides a general background to financial dealings through the JWA Trust Account. Mr Peel was a leader of the investigation and took a principal role in the section 19 examination of Mr West on 27 and 28 July 2006. Mr Peel’s affidavit, sworn 15 March 2007, sets out in considerable detail the history of and findings from the ASIC investigation. The affidavit also sets out the nature and function of the scheme. Exhibited to the affidavit is the transcript of the section 19 examination as well as copies of original borrower and loan documentation relevant to the investigation. Ms Prosser was involved in the investigation the subject of these proceedings. Ms Prosser’s affidavit, sworn 15 March 2007, undertakes a thorough analysis of the evidence obtained from Mr West’s section 19 examination transcript. Ms Prosser’s affidavit also sets out the deposit and payment transaction history of moneys in the Financial Horizons Trust Account which was the trust account for the scheme between March 2002 to July 2005. Exhibited to the affidavit are copies of original banking and financial records of the Financial Horizons Trust Account, JWA, Sovereign Securities and JRS West Family Trust relevant to the ASIC investigation. Ms Smith prepared ASIC’s tender bundle of documents for trial. Ms Smith’s affidavit of 6 June 2007 sets out in detail the facts concerning the background to the investigation, the institution of the within proceedings, and the matters concerning the defendants’ discovery and the state of documents produced generally. Exhibited to the affidavit are copies of original documents discovered by the defendants. Ms Smith’s affidavits of 14 and 21 June 2007 set out further matters concerning the defendants’ discovery and the state of documents produced generally. Exhibited to the affidavits are copies of original documents discovered by the defendants, and correspondence between ASIC and Mr West’s solicitor concerning the discovery process. Exhibited to the affidavit of 14 September 2007 is a copy of the “Form 507 Report as to Affairs” of JWA and “Form 507A Statement Verifying Report under section 475(1)”, both signed by Mr West on 9 August 2007 and filed by the provisional liquidator in the within proceedings. The Form 507 sets out the assets and liabilities of JWA and certain particulars relating to those assets and liabilities. Exhibited to Ms Smith’s affidavit of 7 August 2007 are copies of original documents relevant to Mrs West’s involvement in JWA and the scheme, including the historical company extract for JWA, correspondence with Mr West’s solicitor and extracts from Mr West’s examination transcript.

Decision

Reasons for decision

As earlier observed, Mr West initially sought to have JWA placed in voluntary administration and opposed the appointment of a provisional liquidator. In my view, it is appropriate that Mr West pay the costs of and incidental to the placing of the company in provisional liquidation. These costs should be taxed on a party and party basis.Conclusion Having regard to the foregoing reasons, during the course of the trial I ordered that:-John West & Associates Pty Ltd (ACN 008 156 929) be wound up pursuant to section 461(1)(k) of the Corporations Act;-Austin Robert Meerten Taylor, official liquidator, of Meertens Chartered Accountants, Level 10, 68 Grenfell Street, Adelaide SA 5000, be appointed liquidator of John West & Associates Pty Ltd;-The mortgage investment business, being a managed investment scheme, be wound up pursuant to section 601EE of the Corporations Act; and-Austin Robert Meerten Taylor, official liquidator, of Meertens Chartered Accountants, Level 10, 68 Grenfell Street, Adelaide SA 5000, be appointed liquidator of the managed investment scheme for the purpose of winding it up, and pursuant to section 601EE(2) of the Corporations Act, he shall have the powers and responsibilities that a liquidator would have pursuant to the Act as if the scheme was a corporation, with such modifications as may be necessary. I now make the following declarations:-That from 4 June 2003 Jonathan Peter West and John West & Associates Pty Ltd (in liq) have contravened section 601ED(5) of the Corporations Act by operating a mortgage investment business, being a managed investment scheme, which was required to be registered under section 601EB of the Corporations Act, but which was not registered;-That from 4 June 2003 Jonathan Peter West and John West & Associates Pty Ltd (in liq) have contravened section 1020A of the Corporations Act by making offers relating to the issuing of interests in the managed investment scheme to retail clients, or accepting offers from retail clients to acquire interests in the scheme, when the scheme was required to be registered when it was not registered;-That from 4 June 2003 Jonathan Peter West and John West & Associates Pty Ltd (in liq) have contravened section 1012B of the Corporations Act by not providing a product disclosure statement in connection with making offers to issue interests in the managed investment scheme to retail clients; or issuing interests in the managed investment scheme to retail clients; or receiving offers to acquire interests in the scheme from retail clients; -That from 17 March 2000 John West & Associates Pty Ltd (in liq) has failed to keep financial records in contravention of section 286 of the Corporations Act; and-That from 4 June 2003 Jonathan Peter West and John West & Associates Pty Ltd (in liq) have contravened section 911A of the Corporations Act, by carrying on a financial services business in this jurisdiction without holding an Australian Financial Services Licence. I now make the following further orders:-That a permanent injunction be ordered pursuant to section 1324(1) of the Corporations Act restraining Jonathan Peter West and John West & Associates Pty Ltd (in liq), whether by themselves, their servants, agents or otherwise, from further promoting or operating the managed investment scheme;-That a permanent injunction be ordered pursuant to sections 1101B and 1324(1) of the Corporations Act, restraining Jonathan Peter West, whether by himself, his servants, agents or otherwise, from:ocarrying on any business related to, concerning or directed to be, a managed investment scheme within the meaning of the Corporations Act; orobeing in any way, directly or indirectly, knowingly concerned in or a party to the promotion or establishment of, or the carrying on of the business of, a managed investment scheme within the meaning of the Corporations Actthat requires, in any case, registration under section 601ED of the Corporations Act if it is not registered; -That Jonathan Peter West pay the Australian Securities and Investments Commission its costs of action to be taxed on an indemnity basis;-That John West & Associates Pty Ltd (in liq) pay the Australian Securities and Investments Commission its costs of action, taxed on a party and party basis with such costs limited to the costs incurred to 30 July 2007 (being the date of the appointment of the provisional liquidator), such costs to be reimbursed out of the property of the company; -That Jonathan Peter West pay the Australian Securities and Investments Commission its costs of and incidental to the placing of John West & Associates Pty Ltd (in liq) in provisional liquidation; and-Certified fit for two counsel, including Queen’s Counsel.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

A report into the JWA Trust Account dated 10 September 2007 prepared by Mr McCabe provides a comprehensive review and analysis of the operation of the JWA Trust Account from the period 1 April 2006 to 31 March 2007 and examines ledgers of the Financial Horizons Trust Account and bank statements of the Adelaide Bank account used to operate the JWA Trust Account. Unlawful Operation of Managed Investment Scheme ASIC’s primary case was that the mortgage investment business constituted a single scheme involving, during relevant periods, more than 20 members and contributions exceeding $2 million in 12 months. ASIC’s alternative case was that if the mortgage investment business did not constitute a single scheme, each sub-scheme, involving multiple investors associated with each borrower, constituted a managed investment scheme and those sub-schemes were promoted by the defendants who were in the business of promoting those schemes. ASIC submitted that Mr West and JWA contravened various provisions of the Corporations Act relating to managed investment scheme interests. It was contended that the defendants operated a managed investment scheme that was unregistered and unlawful. ASIC further submitted that the defendants breached section 601ED(5) of the Corporations Act by operating a managed investment scheme which was not registered when it was required to be registered. ASIC contended that the defendants breached section 1020A of the Corporations Act by making offers to, or accepting offers from, retail clients relating to managed investment scheme interests. ASIC pointed out that although the plea for winding-up on the just and equitable ground, and complaints about the failure to keep written records and the absence of an Australian Financial Services Licence, as well as the failure to provide a product disclosure statement, were highlighted in the originating process and in submissions by ASIC’s counsel, the defendants had never contended that JWA kept financial records as required by section 286 of the Act, had never contended that they held an Australian Financial Services Licence as required by section 911A of the Act, and had never contended that they provided a product disclosure statement as required by section 1012B of the Act. Further, ASIC submitted that no answer to these obvious breaches of the Corporations Act had ever been offered by the defendants. Instead, the defendants concentrated on defending discrete, technical aspects of the claims relating to the existence of a managed investment scheme. ASIC contended that in the face of their own records, the defendants asserted that loans were not made to Mr West or to JWA, and that Mr West and JWA acted as agents or trustees and merely facilitated loans being made directly by investors to borrowers. Before considering these submissions it is appropriate to set out and explain the relevant legislative provisions concerning managed investment schemes.Legislative Scheme During the early 1990s, concerns developed in Australia about the need for the control and regulation of the financial services industry. It was perceived that small investors were disadvantaged and in need of a measure of protection. The legislators faced the difficulty of enacting a regulatory scheme that could accommodate the wide and diverse financial services industry practices. In the event, amendments were introduced to the Corporations Act that implemented relevant legislation in response to these needs. At the same time, the Managed Investments Act 1998 (Cth) was enacted. Shortly thereafter the Financial Services Reform Act 2001 (Cth) was also enacted.