Ruhani v Director of Police

Link copied
Case Copied 74 min read

HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

GLEESON CJ,
McHUGH, GUMMOW, KIRBY, HAYNE, CALLINAN AND HEYDON JJ

MOHAMMAD ARIF RUHANI  APPELLANT

AND

DIRECTOR OF POLICE THROUGH THE SECRETARY
OF JUSTICE AS DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROSECUTOR               RESPONDENT

Ruhani v Director of Police

[2005] HCA 42

Date of order:  9 December 2004
Date of publication of reasons:  31 August 2005
Date of further orders:  31 August 2005
C8/2004

ORDER

Made on 9 December 2004:

The objection to the competency of the appeal is disallowed.

Made on 31 August 2005:

1.Motion seeking joinder of the Republic of Nauru and the Commonwealth of Australia dismissed.

2.        Appellant to pay the costs of the respondent of the motion.

3.Respondent to pay the costs of the appellant of the objection to competency.

4.        Costs provided for in orders (2) and (3) be set off.

On appeal from the Supreme Court of Nauru

Representation:

G Griffith QC with K L Walker and L G De Ferrari for the appellant (instructed by Vadarlis & Associates)

P J Hanks QC with S J Lee and S P Donaghue for the respondent (instructed by Clayton Utz)

Notice:  This copy of the Court's Reasons for Judgment is subject to formal revision prior to publication in the Commonwealth Law Reports.

  1. GLEESON CJ. Section 5 of the Nauru (High Court Appeals) Act 1976 (Cth) ("the Nauru Act") confers, or purports to confer, upon this Court jurisdiction to hear and determine appeals from the Supreme Court of Nauru in accordance with the terms of an Agreement between the Commonwealth of Australia and the Republic of Nauru. The historical background to the Agreement, and to the legislation, is explained in the reasons of other members of the Court. The appellant was unsuccessful in proceedings for habeas corpus brought by him against the respondent in the Supreme Court of Nauru. He appealed to this Court. An objection to the competency of the appeal was filed by the respondent. It was heard as a preliminary issue. The ground of objection was that s 5 of the Nauru Act is invalid. On 9 December 2004, the Court disallowed the objection to competency. The following are my reasons for joining in that order.

  2. The essential ground of invalidity asserted by the respondent was that s 5 of the Nauru Act purports to confer on this Court a form of judicial power that is extraneous to Ch III of the Constitution. The jurisdiction purportedly conferred is not jurisdiction to hear and determine an appeal of a kind referred to in s 73 of the Constitution. That is agreed. Nor, so it is submitted, is it original jurisdiction of a kind identified in s 75 or s 76. That is disputed. In particular, the appellant contends that what is involved is a conferral of original jurisdiction in a matter arising under a law made by the Parliament, within the meaning of s 76(ii).

  3. As an alternative to the s 76(ii) argument, the appellant also contended that, even if the jurisdiction conferred by the

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ruhani v Director of Police and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] HCA 42
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In *Ruhani v Director of Police*, the High Court of Australia considered an objection to its competency to hear an appeal from the Supreme Court of Nauru. The appellant, Mr Ruhani, an asylum seeker detained in Nauru, sought to appeal a decision of the Nauruan Supreme Court to the High Court of Australia. The Director of Police objected to the competency of the High Court to hear this appeal, arguing that the *Nauru (High Court Appeals) Act 1976* (Cth) was invalid.

The central legal issues before the High Court were whether the *Nauru (High Court Appeals) Act 1976* validly conferred jurisdiction on the High Court to hear appeals from the Supreme Court of Nauru, and if so, whether this jurisdiction was original or appellate. Specifically, the Court had to determine if the Act purported to confer appellate jurisdiction beyond that permitted by section 73 of the Constitution, or if it conferred original jurisdiction not authorised by sections 75 and 76 of the Constitution. The Court also considered whether the Act could be supported by the "external affairs" power, and whether the rights and obligations adjudicated under the Act were sufficiently connected to Australian law.

The High Court disallowed the objection to competency. The Court reasoned that the Act, by providing for appeals from the Supreme Court of Nauru, was not attempting to confer jurisdiction beyond the constitutional limits of the High Court's appellate power under section 73. Instead, the Court found that the Act was a valid exercise of the Commonwealth's legislative power, particularly in relation to external affairs and its relations with Pacific island states. The Court determined that the proceedings brought under the Act constituted a "matter arising under any law made by Parliament" within the meaning of section 76(ii) of the Constitution, thereby supporting the conferral of jurisdiction.

On 9 December 2004, the objection to the competency of the appeal was disallowed. Subsequently, on 31 August 2005, motions seeking the joinder of the Republic of Nauru and the Commonwealth of Australia were dismissed. The appellant was ordered to pay the respondent's costs of the joinder motion, while the respondent was ordered to pay the appellant's costs of the competency objection, with these costs to be set off.

Orders

Orders of the court

Made on 9 December 2004:

The objection to the competency of the appeal is disallowed.

Made on 31 August 2005:

1. Motion seeking joinder of the Republic of Nauru and the Commonwealth of Australia dismissed.

2. Appellant to pay the costs of the respondent of the motion.

3. Respondent to pay the costs of the appellant of the objection to competency.

4. Costs provided for in orders (2) and (3) be set off.

Background

Background to the litigation

By a Notice of Appeal filed in this Court, Mr Ruhani appeals from the judgment and order of the Supreme Court of Nauru. The material facts Mr Ruhani was brought to the Republic of Nauru on 21 December 2001 by Australian sea transport. The Australian Department of Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs rejected his application for refugee status. Under a Memorandum of Understanding between Australia and Nauru[10], accommodation for Mr Ruhani and other asylum seekers was established on Nauru at two facilities: Topside and Former State House. Since February 2003 or earlier, Mr Ruhani has been detained in Topside Camp on Nauru. He neither applied for nor consented to the issue of a Nauruan visa for himself. Nor did he authorise any person to apply for a Nauruan visa on his behalf. Nevertheless, he was granted a Nauruan special purpose visa on 7 January 2002, which was subsequently extended at the request of the Australian Government. The International Organization for Migration ("the IOM") manages the facility where Mr Ruhani is detained and provides assistance in obtaining passports and travel documents to asylum seekers who elect to return to their country of origin. Mr Ruhani has not elected to return to his country of origin and has not requested assistance in applying for passports or travel documents from the IOM.[10]Memorandum of Understanding between Australia and Nauru for co-operation in the management of Asylum-seekers and related issues, dated 9 December 2002 and extended 25 February 2004. Parties' submissions before this Court The Director objected to the competency of this Court to hear Mr Ruhani's "appeal" from the Supreme Court of Nauru. He contends that the Nauru Appeals Act is invalid because it purports to confer on this Court judicial power that is not part of the judicial power of the Commonwealth. The Director submitted that:1.The Nauru Appeals Act purports to confer appellate jurisdiction on this Court.2.Section 73 of the Constitution exhaustively defines the appellate jurisdiction of this Court (apart from possible supplementation under s 122 in relation to appeals from Territory courts), and does not authorise the appeal conferred by the Nauru Appeals Act.3.The Nauru Appeals Act is not supported by any head of legislative power capable of conferring additional jurisdiction on this Court.4.Alternatively, if the Nauru Appeals Act confers original jurisdiction on this Court, the Act is invalid. That is because the original jurisdiction of this Court is exhaustively defined by ss 75 and 76 of the Constitution and proceedings under the Nauru Appeals Act do not fall within those sections. Counsel for the Director conceded that there was at least one s 76(ii) "matter" arising under the Nauru Appeals Act, namely, the question of whether this Court can rule on the objection to competency. And there was another "matter": the appeal involved the interpretation of the Constitution[11]. As a result, the Director did not dispute that this Court has jurisdiction to determine the objection to competency. But he contended that the Court had no jurisdiction to determine the merits of the appeal.[11]Constitution, s 76(i).

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

GLEESON CJ HUGH J

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: GLEESON CJ, HUGH J