Viscariello v Legal Profession Conduct Commissioner

Link copied
Case Copied 67 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Full Court)

VISCARIELLO v LEGAL PROFESSION CONDUCT COMMISSIONER

[2021] SASCFC 24

Judgment of The Full Court  

(The Honourable Justice Lovell, the Honourable Justice Hughes and the Honourable Auxiliary Justice Tilmouth)

14 May 2021

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW - PREROGATIVE WRITS AND ORDERS - MANDAMUS - DISCRETION OF COURT AND MATTERS PRECLUDING RELIEF - DISCRETION TO REFUSE RELIEF

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL - APPEAL - GENERAL PRINCIPLES - INTERFERENCE WITH DISCRETION OF COURT BELOW - IN GENERAL

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL - APPEAL - GENERAL PRINCIPLES - ADMISSION OF FURTHER EVIDENCE - EVIDENCE NOT AVAILABLE AT HEARING

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL - APPEAL - GENERAL PRINCIPLES - INTERFERENCE WITH DISCRETION OF COURT BELOW - PARTICULAR CASES - OTHER MATTERS - COSTS

PROFESSIONS AND TRADES - LAWYERS - COMPLAINTS AND DISCIPLINE - GENERALLY

The appellant appeals two judgments of a single judge of the Supreme Court: the substantive proceedings dismissing the appellant’s application for judicial review and an adverse costs order.

The appellant had made numerous professional conduct complaints against various members of the legal profession from as early as 2006. The complaints were initially made to the Legal Practitioner’s Conduct Board ("the Board"). Legislative amendments in 2014 replaced the Board with the Legal Profession Conduct Commissioner ("the Commissioner"). The inaugural Commissioner was conflicted with the appellant, and subsequently investigations of the appellant’s outstanding complaints were delegated. Sporadic developments of the appellant’s complaints occurred between 2006 and 2019, when the appellant commenced proceedings in the Supreme Court.

The appellant made an application for judicial review of the Commissioner’s alleged failure to investigate his complaints pursuant to the Commissioner’s statutory duty under s 77B of the Legal Practitioners Act 1981. The appellant contended that the undue delay in investigating his complaints warranted an order of mandamus compelling the Commissioner to investigate his complaints, and further amounted to maladministration. The appellant also sought declarations of invalidity regarding some of the Commissioner’s delegations, previously held as unlawful but nonetheless not invalid.

The primary judge dismissed the appellant’s application for judicial review and refused to make orders of mandamus to compel the Commissioner to investigate his complaints. In dismissing the application, the primary judge held that there was no evidence that the Commissioner had actually or constructively failed to discharge his statutory duty, as alleged. Further, the primary judge did not find the Commissioner or his office had engaged in maladministration. The primary judge further refused to make declarations of invalidly regarding the challenged delegations made by the Commissioner. An adverse costs order was also made against the appellant.

The appellant articulated 35 grounds of appeal, which as agitated on appeal, distil to complaints that the primary judge erred by:

1. Failing to grant mandamus compelling the Commissioner to investigate the complaints in light of the undue delay in dealing with them;

2. Failing to find that the delays amounted to maladministration;

3. Finding the subject delegations were not invalid;

4. Failing to afford the appellant procedural fairness; and

5. In making the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Viscariello v Legal Profession Conduct Commissioner and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] SASCFC 24
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Full Court of the Supreme Court of South Australia considered an appeal by Mr Viscariello against a decision of a primary judge who had dismissed his application for judicial review and an order of mandamus compelling the Legal Profession Conduct Commissioner to investigate his complaints. Mr Viscariello also appealed an adverse costs order made against him. The primary judge had found that the Commissioner had not failed to discharge his statutory duty to investigate, and that certain delegations made by the Commissioner were not invalid.

The legal issues before the Full Court included whether the primary judge erred in dismissing the application for judicial review and refusing mandamus, whether the primary judge erred in finding the delegations valid, whether the primary judge failed to afford procedural fairness, and whether the primary judge erred in making an adverse costs order. A significant aspect of the appeal involved the Commissioner's application to adduce fresh evidence, namely that all of Mr Viscariello's complaints had been finally determined by a delegate of the Commissioner after the primary judge's decision.

The Court, allowing the Commissioner's application to adduce fresh evidence, reasoned that the subsequent finalisation of all complaints rendered the appeal futile. It held that the primary judge did not err in dismissing the application for judicial review or in concluding that any failure by the Board to investigate became the responsibility of the Commissioner. Furthermore, the Court found that the application for judicial review was bound to fail on discretionary grounds of futility due to the subsequent determinations. The Court also determined that the primary judge did not err in making an adverse costs order, finding it fell within his discretion.

Consequently, the appeal was dismissed. The Court upheld the primary judge's decision, finding no grounds for the issue of mandamus or declarations of invalidity, and affirmed the costs order made against Mr Viscariello.

Orders

Orders of the court

Held, per Tilmouth AJ (Lovell and Hughes JJ agreeing), allowing the respondent’s application for fresh evidence pursuant to r 215.1 of the Uniform Civil Rules 2020 (SA).

Held, per Tilmouth AJ (Lovell and Hughes JJ agreeing), dismissing the appeal:

1. The primary judge did not err in dismissing the application for judicial review or in concluding that any failure to fulfil the statutory duty to properly investigate by the Board became the responsibility of the Commissioner;

2. The application for judicial review was bound to fail in any event on the discretionary grounds of futility;

3. The primary judge did not err, and was within his discretion, in ordering an adverse costs judgment against the appellant.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Insofar as there was an implicit challenge to a delegation to Mr Bourne, as Mr Bourne did not make any relevant determinations there is no purpose or efficacy in a declaration of invalidity. Any such declaration would not produce any foreseeable consequences for the parties.[97] These aspects of the appeal must therefore fail.Application for fresh evidence and judicial review as a discretionary remedy[97] Ainsworth v Criminal Justice Commission (1992) 175 CLR 564, 581–582.Application for fresh evidence The majority of the various complaints lodged by Mr Viscariello remained extant at the time the underlying proceedings were commenced on 19 December 2013. They remained that way during the course of the trial in March 2018, and as of the date on which the primary judge delivered his judgment on 1 July 2019. In the meantime, on 15 September 2017, the Commissioner delegated all extant complaints to Ms Eszenyi. These delegations remain unchallenged. When the Second Notice of Appeal was filed on 18 July 2019, Ms Eszenyi had completed some but not all determinations of those complaints. It emerges that she progressively made determinations up to 18 February 2020, by which time all complaints were finalised. That is to say, all these determinations post-dated the hearing before the primary judge.[98] [98] Second affidavit of Mr Gregory May (Commissioner) filed 1 October 2020. As this subsequent course of events was not available to the primary judge, the Commissioner now seeks to adduce it as “fresh evidence” in the appeal, pursuant to rule 215.1(2)(i) of the Uniform Civil Rules 2020 (SA). The Commissioner contends the evidence sought to be adduced demonstrates that the appeal is futile, fundamentally because the underlying complaints made by Mr Viscariello which were subject to the application for judicial review and now subject to this appeal, were finally determined. Mr Viscariello opposed the application to adduce fresh evidence. As the determinations by Ms Eszyenyi came after the trial, Mr Viscariello’s counsel submitted in writing that they had no material effect on whether the primary judge committed error and were therefore “irrelevant”. It was further submitted in Mr Viscariello’s written reply that there was in any event, utility in making declarations of invalidity of the delegations even if the only remaining issue is costs. It is accepted for the present purpose that an extant issue as to costs could constitute a live controversial matter for that purpose. Rule 215.1(2)(i) provides a discretionary power to the Court as follows: 215.1—Interlocutory orders(1) The Court may, at a directions hearing or in chambers, make orders on its own initiative or on the application of any person in relation to an appellate proceeding.(2) For example, the Court may make orders—… (i)relating to evidence sought to be adduced at the hearing of the appellate proceeding; … Remedial Rules of Court of this kind are unconfined by common law principles. Instead they are designed:[99]… to give to the Full Court a discretionary power to admit further evidence where that evidence, if accepted, would demonstrate that the order under appeal is erroneous … to facilitate the avoidance of errors which cannot be otherwise remedied by the application of the conventional appellate procedures. McHugh, Gummow and Callinan JJ proceeded to observe in CDJ v VAJ (No 1):[100] … The power to admit the further evidence exists to serve the demands of justice. Ordinarily, where it is alleged that the admission of new evidence requires a new trial, justice will not be served unless the Full Court is satisfied that the further evidence would have produced a different result if it had been available at the trial. Without that condition being satisfied, it could seldom, if ever, be in the interests of justice to deprive the respondent of the benefit of the orders made by the trial judge and put that person to the expense, inconvenience and worry of a new trial.[99] CDJ v VAJ (No 1) (1998) 197 CLR 172 at [109].[100] (1998) 197 CLR 172 at [111].

Decision

Reasons for decision

Thus, the claim before the primary judge concerned not only an application for judicial review of the Commissioner’s alleged failure to investigate Mr Viscariello’s complaints pursuant to the statutory duty under s 77B of the Legal Practitioners Act 1981, but also included the validity of the delegations made by the Commissioner in relation to the said complaints.Decision of primary judge The primary judge dismissed Mr Viscariello’s application for judicial review and consequently refused to issue an order of mandamus compelling the Commissioner to investigate Mr Viscariello’s complaints. He considered the evidence did not support a conclusion that the Commissioner actually or constructively refused to discharge the statutory duty to investigate those complaints, as alleged. The primary judge further held that the delegations made by the Commissioner as complained of in Mr Viscariello’s amended claim were not invalid. An adverse costs order was later made against Mr Viscariello.The appeal Mr Viscariello appeals to the Full Court against the substantive decision of the primary judge[12] and the adverse costs order.[13] Mr Viscariello contends that the appeal be allowed with costs and that this Court hold that mandamus should have issued, based on unreasonable delay, and declare the delegations to Mr Bourne invalid. [12] Viscariello v Legal Profession Conduct Commissioner [2019] SASC 111. [13] Viscariello v Legal Profession Conduct Commissioner (No 2) [2019] SASC 165. Mr Viscariello’s Second Amended Notice of Appeal alleged 35 grounds of appeal, of which grounds 26, 27, 28, 32, 33 and 34 were not pursued. The grounds of appeal condense into complaints that the primary judge erred in: failing to grant declarations compelling the Commissioner to investigate the complaints in light of the undue delay in dealing with them, failing to find that the delays amounted to maladministration, finding the subject delegations were not invalid, failing to afford procedural fairness and erred in making the adverse cost order against Mr Viscariello. The principal contention advanced on Mr Viscariello’s behalf in this appeal, is that the primary judge erred in failing to take proper account of the entire course of the complaints prior to the 2014 Amendments, and as a consequence, did not engage with the requirements of due process in considering his complaints to the point that the proceedings were invalid. Embedded within this submission is that delays, as well as the failure to expeditiously or properly investigate those complaints, were so protracted that there was in effect, a constructive failure to exercise the jurisdiction to investigate those complaints to the point that they became amenable to judicial review or equivalent orders to writs of mandamus quashing them. Subsidiary issues pursued on his behalf were the failure to find maladministration by the Board as well as the Commissioner, and a miscarriage in the discretion to award costs against Mr Viscariello.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The appeal must therefore fail because the application for judicial review is bound to fail on the twin discretionary grounds of futility. Maladministration Given the above conclusions, no grounds for the issue of orders in the nature of mandamus are shown. It follows there is necessarily no basis for finding maladministration. This contention founds on the point that the failure to pay regard to the entire past conduct of the Board, as well as the Commissioner, amounted to maladministration within the meaning of s 5(4) of the Independent Commission Against Corruption Act 2012 (SA), and on the assertion that a failure to fulfil the statutory duty to properly investigate by the Board became the responsibility of the Commissioner. For the above reasons, there was no error by the primary judge in concluding otherwise. Procedural Fairness This aspect of the appeal related to the contention that the primary judge failed to afford Mr Viscariello procedural fairness by dismissing the mandamus/judicial review action and allegation of maladministration on grounds not pleaded, not argued at trial and not subject to submissions by the parties. The complaint wholly relates to the point disposed of above encompassing the conclusion that any acts or omissions of the Board could not be “sheeted home” to the Commissioner and therefore the Commissioner could not be held responsible for any acts or omissions of the Board. For all the reasons advanced earlier, there is no foundation for the conclusion that there was in the result a denial of procedural fairness. The issue was fully ventilated before this Court and for the reasons advanced above, the point was destined to fail anyway.Costs The primary judge made an order that Mr Viscariello pay 85 per cent of the costs of the Commissioner in the proceedings before him, in addition to other ancillary costs orders.[113] [113] Viscariello v Legal Profession Conduct Commissioner (No 2) [2019] SASC 165 at [19]. It was submitted that the discretion to award costs against Mr Viscariello miscarried because the primary judge took into account an irrelevant consideration that Mr Viscariello should have re-assessed his prospects following the abolition of the Board and the creation of the office of the Commissioner, particularly when that issue was not raised during the course of the trial on behalf of the Commissioner or by the primary judge of his own motion during the hearing. It was further submitted that this amounted to an unfair, unjust and irrelevant “veiled criticism of the Appellant” causing the costs discretion to miscarry. Considered in context, it is apparent the primary judge did no more than observe that the basis of the attacks by Mr Viscariello did not change in response to the significant legislative changes wrought by the 2014 Amendments, as they should have. This aspect of his case fails in any event for the reasons detailed earlier. For the same reasons, the failure to raise the issue was of no consequence given that the order for costs fell well within discretionary limits. As Mr Viscariello is not successful on any ground of appeal, there is no occasion to review or vary the cost order. Miscellaneous