Legal Practitioners Conduct Board v Viscariello

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Full Court)

LEGAL PRACTITIONERS CONDUCT BOARD v VISCARIELLO

[2013] SASCFC 37

Judgment of The Full Court

(The Honourable Justice Gray, The Honourable Justice Sulan and The Honourable Justice Blue)

21 May 2013

PROFESSIONS AND TRADES - LAWYERS - COMPLAINTS AND DISCIPLINE - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - PROCEEDINGS IN COURT

PROFESSIONS AND TRADES - LAWYERS - COMPLAINTS AND DISCIPLINE - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - PROCEEDINGS IN TRIBUNALS

Order sought by the Legal Practitioners Conduct Board that the practitioner’s name be removed from the roll of legal practitioners - where practitioner was charged with unprofessional conduct in engaging in conduct to defeat an adverse costs order, and falsely and dishonestly giving evidence in the Supreme Court - where the Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal found the practitioner guilty of unprofessional conduct in respect of both events - whether the practitioner is shown not to be a fit and proper person to be a legal practitioner of the Supreme Court upon whose roll the practitioner’s name presently appears.

Held: Name of the practitioner, John Viscariello, to be removed from the roll of legal practitioners - the practitioner is not a fit and proper person to be entrusted with the important duties and responsibilities of a practitioner - a period of suspension would not afford adequate protection to the public.

Moyes & Anor v J & L Developments Pty Ltd & Anor (No 2) [2007] SASC 261; Legal Practitioners Conduct Board v Phillips (2002) 83 SASR 467; Viscariello v Legal Practitioners Conduct Board (No 2) [2013] SASCFC 27; The Minister for Justice and Attorney-General v A T Brown (Unreported, Supreme Court of Queensland, Court of Appeal, Fitzgerald P, Davies and Demack JJ, 11 June 1993); Viscariello v Legal Practitioners Conduct Board [2012] SASCFC 147; A Solicitor v Council of the Law Society of New South Wales (2004) 216 CLR 253; The Attorney-General and Minister for Justice v Gregory [1998] QCA 409; O'Reilly v Law Society of New South Wales (1988) 24 NSWLR 204; Legal Practitioners Conduct Board v Morel (2004) 88 SASR 401; Legal Practitioners Conduct Board v Lind (2011) 110 SASR 531; Incorporated Law Institute of New South Wales v Meagher (1909) 9 CLR 655; New South Wales Bar Association v Cummins (2001) 52 NSWLR 279; The Council of the New South Wales Bar Association v Sahade [2007] NSWCA 145; Legal Practitioners Conduct Board v Kerin (2006) 246 LSJS 371; Legal Practitioners Conduct Board v Hay (2001) 83 SASR 454; The Law Society of New South Wales v McNamara (1980) 47 NSWLR 72; In Re A Practitioner (1984) 36 SASR 590, considered.

LEGAL PRACTITIONERS CONDUCT BOARD v VISCARIELLO
[2013] SASCFC 37

Full Court:      Gray, Sulan and Blue JJ

THE COURT.

  1. The Legal Practitioners Conduct Board seeks an order that the practitioner’s name be removed from the roll of legal practitioners. 

  2. The practitioner, John Viscariello, was charged by the Legal Practitioners…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Legal Practitioners Conduct Board v Viscariello and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] SASCFC 37
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Legal Practitioners Conduct Board sought the removal of John Viscariello's name from the roll of legal practitioners. The dispute concerned allegations of unprofessional conduct, specifically that Mr Viscariello engaged in conduct to defeat an adverse costs order and gave false and dishonest evidence in the Supreme Court. The Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal had found Mr Viscariello guilty of unprofessional conduct on both counts. The matter came before the Full Court of the Supreme Court of South Australia on appeal.

The legal issues before the Full Court were whether the Tribunal had erred in its findings that Mr Viscariello had engaged in unprofessional conduct by attempting to defeat an adverse costs order through an amendment to a trust deed, and by giving false and dishonest evidence to the Supreme Court. Crucially, the Court was required to determine whether, based on these findings, Mr Viscariello was a fit and proper person to continue to be admitted as a legal practitioner.

The Court dismissed Mr Viscariello's appeal, upholding the Tribunal's findings. Regarding the first count, the Court found overwhelming evidence that Mr Viscariello amended the Stirling trust deed to defeat adverse costs orders, noting inconsistencies in his evidence and his admissions. On the second count, the Court concluded that Mr Viscariello's evidence that J & L Developments had acted in its own right, rather than as trustee, was knowingly false and dishonest, as his conduct and subsequent actions belied his assertions. The Court found that the Tribunal's findings were open to it on the evidence presented.

The Court ordered that the name of John Viscariello be removed from the roll of legal practitioners. The Court reasoned that Mr Viscariello was not a fit and proper person to be entrusted with the duties and responsibilities of a legal practitioner, and that a period of suspension would not adequately protect the public.

Orders

Orders of the court

Held: Name of the practitioner, John Viscariello, to be removed from the roll of legal practitioners - the practitioner is not a fit and proper person to be entrusted with the important duties and responsibilities of a practitioner - a period of suspension would not afford adequate protection to the public.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Legal Practitioners Conduct Board sought the removal of John Viscariello's name from the roll of legal practitioners in South Australia due to allegations of unprofessional conduct. In June 2004, Mr Viscariello, acting as solicitor for J & L Developments, amended clause 20(b) of the Stirling trust deed with the intention of defeating adverse costs orders against J & L Developments in the development approval litigation. This conduct was deemed to be unprofessional. In December 2006, Mr Viscariello gave evidence in the Supreme Court, falsely and dishonestly claiming that J & L Developments had acted in its own right in lodging the development application and in the subsequent appeals. The Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal found him guilty of unprofessional conduct in both instances.

Further investigation revealed that Mr Viscariello's evidence before the Tribunal was internally inconsistent and contradicted his earlier accounts. He admitted that the change to clause 20(b) of the trust deed was motivated by the forthcoming hearing of the appeal before Debelle J. The Tribunal found that J & L Developments had not been acting in its own right in lodging the application for development approval and in the subsequent appeals. Mr Viscariello's evidence concerning his own state of mind as controller of J & L Developments was knowingly false. His subsequent conduct in mid-2004, mid-2006, and September 2006 belied his evidence.

The Tribunal's findings of unprofessional conduct were sustained by the Full Court of the Supreme Court of South Australia. The Court concluded that Mr Viscariello's conduct amounted to unprofessional conduct and that he was not a fit and proper person to be entrusted with the important duties and responsibilities of a legal practitioner. As a result, the Court ordered that Mr Viscariello's name be removed from the roll of legal practitioners. A period of suspension was deemed insufficient to protect the public.

The matter of Legal Practitioners Conduct Board v Viscariello originated in the Supreme Court of South Australia where the Legal Practitioners Conduct Board brought proceedings against Mr Viscariello for alleged unprofessional conduct. The Board sought an order for Mr Viscariello's name to be removed from the roll of legal practitioners, alleging he had engaged in conduct to defeat an adverse costs order and had given false and dishonest evidence in the Supreme Court. The proceedings initially involved findings by the Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal, which found Mr Viscariello guilty of unprofessional conduct on both counts. Following this, Mr Viscariello appealed the Tribunal's decision to the Full Court of the Supreme Court, which ultimately dismissed his appeal, affirming the Tribunal's findings. The matter then proceeded to the current court, which was tasked with determining whether Mr Viscariello was fit and proper to remain on the roll of legal practitioners. Throughout the proceedings, the court had to consider the extensive evidence and arguments presented, including the internal inconsistencies in Mr Viscariello's testimony and his subsequent conduct, which corroborated the Tribunal's conclusions of unprofessional conduct.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The practitioner’s unprofessional conduct has been addressed in the Tribunal’s findings and in our dismissal of the practitioner’s appeal. It is convenient to repeat our summary of the practitioner’s unprofessional conduct from our decision in Viscariello v Legal Practitioner’s Conduct Board (No 2):[10][10] Viscariello v Legal Practitioners Conduct Board (No 2) [2013] SASCFC 27, [8]-[9].In our decision on the appeal published on 21 December 2012, we sustained the Tribunal’s conclusion that Mr Viscariello was guilty of unprofessional conduct. On the first count we concluded:[11][11] Viscariello v Legal Practitioners Conduct Board [2012] SASCFC 147, [122]-[123].Conclusion – 2004 eventsNo error has been demonstrated in the Tribunal’s finding that Mr Viscariello made the June 2004 amendment to clause 20(b) of the Stirling trust deed for the purpose of attempting to defeat adverse costs orders against J & L Developments in the development approval litigation. No material error has been demonstrated in the reasoning of the Tribunal. The findings made by the Tribunal were open to it. We would go further. On the evidence before the Tribunal, the conclusion was overwhelming that this was Mr Viscariello’s purpose. Mr Viscariello unequivocally admitted in his evidence before Debelle J on 1 December 2006 and his letter to the Board dated 23 November 2007 that the change to clause 20(b) of the trust deed was motivated by the forthcoming hearing of the appeal before Debelle J. His evidence in this respect before the Tribunal was both internally inconsistent and contrary to those earlier accounts in December 2006 and November 2007.It was not in issue that the above conduct occurred whilst Mr Viscariello was acting as solicitor for J & L Developments and that if the allegations were established the conduct amounted to unprofessional conduct.In regard to the second count of unprofessional conduct, we concluded:[12]Mr Viscariello complained that the Tribunal erred in concluding that the evidence given by Mr Viscariello on 1 December 2006 was given falsely and dishonestly. This complaint has been addressed above. We repeat our rejection above.It follows that, if the Tribunal did not err in reaching its conclusion that J & L Developments under the control of Mr Viscariello had not been acting in its own right in lodging the development application and in the subsequent appeals, the evidence which he gave to that effect on 1 December 2006 was knowingly false. As his evidence concerned his own state of mind as controller of J & L Developments, there is no room for any contention that his evidence was honest but mistaken. The fundamental premise of Mr Viscariello’s evidence was that, in or before March 2003, he was concerned to ensure that the Stirling property be insulated from any claims if liabilities incurred by J & L Developments in the development of the house on the Stirling property, including any liabilities incurred by reason of the application for development approval and any subsequent litigation. His evidence was that he decided that J & L Developments would undertake the entirety of the development in its own right to insulate the Stirling property from any such liabilities. He decided that it would be agreed between J & L Developments in its own right and J & L Developments as trustee of the Stirling Trust that J & L Developments would develop the property on the basis that it would earn a profit margin in so doing. If Mr Viscariello had so decided, it would have been vital for him to document the decision and arrangements so that, in any future dispute, the position would not depend upon his mere assertion as to his intentions. To achieve the very purpose which he said he had, he would have prepared a document or documents and executed them on behalf of J & L Developments in its own right and J & L Developments as trustee of the Stirling Trust. He would have ensured that the existence and execution of the documents was verified by a third party such as submitting the documents to the Stamp Duties Office for stamping. He would also have decided what consideration was payable by the Stirling Trust to J & L Developments for undertaking the development and on what terms.Mr Viscariello took none of these steps. His evidence was that he never determined the consideration that Stirling Trust would pay to J & L Developments. There never was any agreement between J & L Developments and the Stirling Trust for the payment of such consideration. It did not convene a meeting of directors of J & L Developments or prepare minutes of a meeting recording the decision or any agreement. His own conduct belies the evidence which he gave before Debelle J and the Tribunal.Mr Viscariello’s subsequent conduct in mid-2004 in changing clause 20(b) of the Stirling trust deed, in mid-2006 in changing the trustee of the Stirling Trust and in September 2006 in deposing to the grounds of opposition to the charging order without mentioning J & L Developments having acted in its own right also belies his evidence.No error has been demonstrated in the Tribunal’s finding that J & L Developments acted in its capacity as trustee of the Stirling Trust and not in its own right in lodging the application for development approval and in relation to the subsequent appeals. No material error has been demonstrated in the reasoning of the Tribunal. The findings made by the Tribunal were open to it. We would go further. The evidence before the Tribunal was overwhelming. The conclusion that J & L Developments had not been acting in its own right, that Mr Viscariello belatedly advanced this contention in an attempt to defeat the charging orders being sought and that he gave false evidence before Debelle J when he said that J & L Developments had been acting in its own right was open and should in our view be confirmed.[12] Viscariello v Legal Practitioners Conduct Board [2012] SASCFC 147, [172]-[178].

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Full Court of the Supreme Court of South Australia considered the appeal against the Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal's decision finding the practitioner guilty of unprofessional conduct and recommending his removal from the roll of legal practitioners. The practitioner, Mr Viscariello, had been found guilty of two instances of unprofessional conduct: attempting to defeat adverse costs orders and providing false and dishonest evidence in the Supreme Court. The court's reasoning focused on whether these instances constituted unprofessional conduct and whether Mr Viscariello was a fit and proper person to remain on the roll of legal practitioners.

First, the court addressed whether Mr Viscariello's conduct in attempting to defeat adverse costs orders constituted unprofessional conduct. The court found that the Tribunal's conclusion was correct, as Mr Viscariello had made the June 2004 amendment to clause 20(b) of the Stirling trust deed for the purpose of attempting to defeat adverse costs orders against J & L Developments. The court held that the Tribunal's findings were supported by evidence and that there was no error in their reasoning. The court concluded that the conclusion that Mr Viscariello's purpose was to defeat the adverse costs orders was overwhelming.

Second, the court addressed whether Mr Viscariello's false and dishonest evidence given in the Supreme Court constituted unprofessional conduct. The court rejected Mr Viscariello's complaint that the Tribunal erred in concluding that his evidence was given falsely and dishonestly. The court found that the evidence before the Tribunal was overwhelming that Mr Viscariello gave false evidence concerning his own state of mind as the controller of J & L Developments. The court concluded that Mr Viscariello's evidence was knowingly false, as it concerned his own state of mind and there was no room for the contention that his evidence was honest but mistaken.

Third, the court addressed whether Mr Viscariello was a fit and proper person to remain on the roll of legal practitioners. The court found that Mr Viscariello was not a fit and proper person to be entrusted with the important duties and responsibilities of a legal practitioner. The court held that the practitioner's unprofessional conduct demonstrated a lack of honesty, integrity, and trustworthiness, which are essential qualities for a legal practitioner. The court concluded that a period of suspension would not afford adequate protection to the public.

Lastly, the court addressed the appropriate remedy for Mr Viscariello's unprofessional conduct. The court held that the appropriate remedy was the removal of Mr Viscariello's name from the roll of legal practitioners, as it was necessary to protect the public and maintain the integrity of the legal profession. The court found that removal was the most appropriate remedy, as it would prevent Mr Viscariello from practicing law in the future and would serve as a deterrent to other legal practitioners.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that a legal practitioner found guilty of unprofessional conduct, particularly conduct involving dishonesty and a lack of integrity, is not a fit and proper person to remain on the roll of legal practitioners, and their removal from the roll is the appropriate remedy. The court distinguished prior authority by emphasizing the importance of honesty, integrity, and trustworthiness in legal practitioners, and by holding that a period of suspension would not afford adequate protection to the public in this case. The court followed prior authority in affirming the Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal's findings and in applying the principles of unprofessional conduct to the facts of the case.