Viscariello v Legal Practitioners Conduct Board

Link copied
Case Copied 77 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Full Court: Civil)

VISCARIELLO v LEGAL PRACTITIONERS CONDUCT BOARD

[2012] SASCFC 147

Judgment of The Full Court

(The Honourable Justice Gray, The Honourable Justice Sulan and The Honourable Justice Blue)

21 December 2012

PROFESSIONS AND TRADES - LAWYERS - COMPLAINTS AND DISCIPLINE - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS

PROFESSIONS AND TRADES - LAWYERS - COMPLAINTS AND DISCIPLINE - PROFESSIONAL MISCONDUCT - MISLEADING COURT AND PERVERTING THE COURSE OF JUSTICE

PROFESSIONS AND TRADES - LAWYERS - COMPLAINTS AND DISCIPLINE - PROFESSIONAL MISCONDUCT AND UNSATISFACTORY PROFESSIONAL CONDUCT - IMPROPER DEALINGS

The appellant was charged in the Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal with two counts of unprofessional conduct.  First, that the appellant engaged in conduct in an attempt to defeat adverse costs orders against a company of which the appellant was at various times a director and shareholder and for which the appellant acted as solicitor. Second, that he falsely gave evidence before a Judge of the Supreme Court of South Australia.

The charges arose out of the purchase of land by the company and subsequent litigation arising from the proposed development of that land. The company purchased the land as trustee of a discretionary trust, of which the appellant and his partner were beneficiaries. The company then made an application to the relevant Council for development consent to construct a house on the land. Consent was refused and the company appealed to the Environment, Resources & Development Court, which allowed the appeal. The company resisted a subsequent appeal to the Supreme Court by two objectors. The Supreme Court appeal exposed the company to a potential liability to pay the costs of the other parties if the appeal proved successful. The appellant acted for the company in relation to the appeals.

In June 2004, the trust deed constituting the trust was amended by the appellant to remove a clause providing for the trustees to be indemnified out of the assets of the trust fund for liabilities incurred in the course of acting for the trust and to replace it with a clause providing that the trustees were not indemnified out of the assets of the trust fund for such liabilities.

Subsequently, the appeal was allowed and the parties corresponded regarding the costs of the appeals.

In 2006, the appellant caused the company to be replaced by another of which he was the sole director as trustee of the trust and transferred the land the the new trustee. 

The other parties to the appeal took action to recover their costs of the Environment, Resources & Development Court and the Supreme Court appeals. They applied in the District and Supreme Courts for charging orders over the land.

During the hearing of the application to the Supreme Court for charging orders, the appellant gave evidence that the company was acting in its own right, and not as trustee of the trust, in pursuing the development of the land and in particular in applying for development consent and in the subsequent appeals.

The Tribunal found the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Viscariello v Legal Practitioners Conduct Board and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] SASCFC 147
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Supreme Court of South Australia, constituted by Gray, Sulan and Blue JJ, heard an appeal by Mr Viscariello against findings of professional misconduct made by a disciplinary tribunal. The dispute concerned Mr Viscariello's actions in amending a trust deed and subsequently transferring property, which the Legal Practitioners Conduct Board alleged were undertaken with the purpose of defeating adverse costs orders made against a company he was involved with, J & L Developments Pty Ltd.

The primary legal issues before the court were whether the tribunal's findings that Mr Viscariello's amendment of the Stirling Trust deed in June 2004, and his subsequent actions in 2006 involving the removal of J & L Developments as trustee and the transfer of property, were made with the intention of defeating adverse costs orders, were reasonably open on the evidence. The court was required to determine if these actions constituted professional misconduct.

The court dismissed Mr Viscariello's appeal, finding that the tribunal's conclusions were well-supported by the evidence. Regarding the 2004 amendment, the court noted Mr Viscariello's own admissions in evidence before Debelle J and in a letter to the Board, which clearly indicated his intention to protect the Stirling property from potential costs orders. The court found that even though the costs had not yet been taxed, the liability was not merely theoretical, as costs orders had already been made and further costs were being incurred in ongoing appeals. The court held that such actions could be voidable even if directed at future or contingent creditors. However, the court found that the tribunal's findings in relation to the 2006 events were not open on the charge as presented.

Background

Background to the litigation

We have reached the conclusion that Mr Viscariello’s appeal should be dismissed. We consider that the findings of the Tribunal should be confirmed. Those findings were open to the Tribunal. We would go further. The evidence before the Tribunal overwhelmingly supported the conclusion that the charges had been made out and that, as a consequence, Mr Viscariello’s unprofessional conduct should now be addressed. Our reasons follow.Background Mr Viscariello was admitted as a legal practitioner of this Court on 16 December 2002. He was first engaged as a consultant solicitor by Gretsas Chrzaszcz. In 2003, he commenced as a consultant solicitor with McNamara Business and Property Law. He was appointed a director of the company which conducted that legal practice in 2008. Between 1978 and 1993, Mr Viscariello had worked in the building construction and property development industry. In May 1992, he and his father acquired a shelf company, of which they became the directors and shareholders. Mr Viscariello held 99 shares and his father held one share. The company was renamed J & L Developments Pty Ltd. J & L Developments undertook a land division development at Newton in 1992-1993. Nick Nicolaou acted at all material times as accountant for J & L Developments on the instructions of Mr Viscariello. In March 2002, Mr Viscariello and his then partner Tanya Hamilton-Smith entered into a contract to purchase a property situated at 33 Birch Road, Stirling.[8] In September 2002, Ms Hamilton-Smith replaced Mr Viscariello’s father as a director of J & L Developments. [8] Referred to in these reasons as the Stirling property. In October 2002, a discretionary trust entitled the Stirling Property Trust (“the Stirling Trust”) was created by a Deed of Settlement dated 2 September 2002. J & L Developments was trustee. Mr Viscariello and Ms Hamilton-Smith were joint appointors with power to change the trustee. They were also the corpus beneficiaries. Mr Viscariello and Ms Hamilton-Smith nominated J & L Developments to become the purchaser of the Stirling property and settlement took place on 17 October 2002. J & L Developments acquired the Stirling property as trustee of the Stirling Trust. Mr Viscariello and Ms Hamilton-Smith wished to construct a two storey house on the Stirling property. In September 2002, another discretionary trust entitled the Little Hampton Trust was created by a Deed of Settlement dated 15 April 2002. Ms Hamilton-Smith was the initial trustee. Mr Viscariello and Ms Hamilton-Smith were joint appointors with power to change the trustee. They were also the corpus beneficiaries. On 14 October 2002, J & L Developments replaced Ms Hamilton-Smith as trustee. J & L Developments as trustee of the Little Hampton Trust acquired land at Littlehampton[9] from Ms Hamilton-Smith in 2002. It then undertook a land division, dividing the land into 18 allotments. J & L Developments as trustee of the Little Hampton Trust obtained an Australian Business Number and registered for GST. Domenic Rinaldi was the accountant for the Little Hampton Trust from 2002 to April 2004. Mr Rinaldi lodged quarterly Business Activity Statements on behalf of the Little Hampton Trust on instructions from Mr Viscariello. The first Business Activity Statement (“BAS”) was lodged by the Little Hampton Trust in July 2003 for the April-June 2003 quarter. [9] Referred to in these reasons as the Littlehampton property.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The substance of the dispute before the Tribunal was whether, in so acting, Mr Viscariello’s purpose was, or included, attempting to defeat adverse costs orders made in the development approval litigation. The Tribunal found that a prime motivation of Mr Viscariello was an attempt to defeat such adverse costs orders.Finding Not Reasonably Open on the Evidence Mr Viscariello complained that the Tribunal’s finding that the amendment of clause 20(b) of the trust deed of the Stirling Trust in June 2004 was made by Mr Viscariello with the object of defeating adverse cost orders against J & L Developments was not reasonably open on the evidence. We reject this contention. In his evidence in chief and cross-examination before Debelle J, extracted above, Mr Viscariello expressly admitted that he amended the trust deed for the purpose of ensuring that the other parties to the development approval litigation did not prosecute, or successfully prosecute, a claim against the Stirling property in respect of their costs. His evidence was that this was part of a belt and braces approach in that, in his own mind, the primary defence to such a claim would be that the company had acted in its own right and not as trustee of the Stirling Trust but it would rely upon this fallback position if necessary. There was no suggestion in his evidence before Debelle J that the amendment was motivated or prompted by any other potential threat against the assets of the Stirling Trust, or that the amendment was not linked to the forthcoming hearing of the appeal. In his letter to the Board dated 23 November 2007, Mr Viscariello reinforced that evidence. His letter included the following statements:The amendment in June 2004 of the trust deed of the Stirling Property Trust occurred because I believed that J & L Developments made the development application in its own right and not in its capacity as the trustee of the Stirling Property Trust. I believed that there was no basis for the assets of the trust to be at risk in relation to any liability that J & L Developments incurred independently of its role as trustee of the trust. The amendment to the trust deed was made to make it clear that J & L Developments did not have any right to call upon assets of the trust to satisfy any liability it incurred independently of its role as trustee of the trust…The letter dated 27 August 2007 from the Honourable Justice Debelle states that he has a concern that “in executing a deed for the deliberate purpose of defeating an order for costs … might constitute unprofessional conduct”. He is there referring to the amendment made to the trust deed on 1 June 2004 … At the hearing on Friday, 13 July 2007 I was represented by counsel, Mr Peter Heinrich … at page 7 line 28 and following His Honour stated that in his opinion a step was taken “… to seek to frustrate the ordinary consequences of the litigation, namely an order for costs…”Mr Heinrich responded and made submissions on my behalf … In summary, the submissions were to the following effect:1.The steps taken in relation to the amendment of the trust deed were arguably lawful…2.His Honour decided that the amendment to the trust deed did not remove the right to indemnity. However, he accepted that the point was arguable…I believe that the Honourable Justice Debelle accepted the above submissions in the course of deciding to dismiss the application for indemnity costs. I refer to paragraph 8 of the Second Reasons, where His Honour stated (a) that the amendment to the trust deed was a “… step believed [by J & L Developments] to be lawfully available to protect itself from the liability for costs…” …The conduct that is in issue is the role that I had in an arguably lawful step to minimise or reduce the potential financial exposure of J & L Developments and Stirling Property Trust in legal proceedings. This involved a legal argument in connection with an amendment to a trust deed.(Emphasis added)

Decision

Reasons for decision

We reject Mr Viscariello’s further contention. As at 1 June 2004, costs orders had already been made in favour of both the Council and the objectors by the Environment, Resources and Development Court on 5 April 2004. While those costs had not yet been taxed and hence quantified, the liability cannot be characterised as a mere possible theoretical future liability. Further, costs had already been incurred by the Council and Mr Moyes and Mr Brooks in the appeal to this Court which had been lodged on 19 April 2004. There had been a hearing on 5 May 2004, at which Mr Viscariello attended, and the preparation of Mr Moyes and Mr Brooks and the Council for the hearing of the appeal must have been substantially complete by 1 June 2004 three days before the hearing date. If the appeal were to prove successful, it was inevitable that an adverse costs order would be made against J & L Developments which would include the costs which had already been incurred by the objectors and the Council up to 1 June 2004. It is well established that, for the purposes of section 588FE(5), a transaction will be voidable as being for the purpose of defeating, delaying or interfering with the rights of creditors if those creditors are future or contingent creditors.[23][23] See Williams v Lloyd; Re Williams [1934] HCA 1; (1934) 50 CLR 341 at 372 per Dixon J; Hardie v Hanson [1960] HCA 8; (1960) 105 CLR 451 at 456 per Dixon CJ and Cannane v J Cannane Pty Ltd(in liquidation) [1998] HCA 26; (1998) 192 CLR 557 at [10] per Brennan CJ and McHugh CJ, [31] per Gaudron J, and [54] per Gummow J, as to predecessors to section 588FE(5).Conclusion – 2004 events No error has been demonstrated in the Tribunal’s finding that Mr Viscariello made the June 2004 amendment to clause 20(b) of the Stirling trust deed for the purpose of attempting to defeat adverse costs orders against J & L Developments in the development approval litigation. No material error has been demonstrated in the reasoning of the Tribunal. The findings made by the Tribunal were open to it. We would go further. On the evidence before the Tribunal, the conclusion was overwhelming that this was Mr Viscariello’s purpose. Mr Viscariello unequivocally admitted in his evidence before Debelle J on 1 December 2006 and his letter to the Board dated 23 November 2007 that the change to clause 20(b) of the trust deed was motivated by the forthcoming hearing of the appeal before Debelle J. His evidence in this respect before the Tribunal was both internally inconsistent and contrary to those earlier accounts in December 2006 and November 2007.2006 Events The Board’s case in relation to the second limb of count 1 was that in 2006 Mr Viscariello engaged in conduct in an attempt to defeat adverse costs orders whereby he advised and undertook the removal of J & L Developments as trustee of the Stirling Trust and replaced it with Palm Hills and transfer of the legal title to the Stirling property from J & L Developments to Palm Hills. The Tribunal found that this was deliberate conduct with the objective of defeating adverse cost orders against J & L Developments. 2006 Conduct Not Open on the Charge

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Tribunal’s finding that Mr Viscariello’s conduct in 2006 was deliberate and aimed at defeating adverse costs orders against J & L Developments was supported by the evidence. The Court found that Mr Viscariello’s actions in advising and executing the removal of J & L Developments as trustee of the Stirling Trust and replacing it with Palm Hills, and transferring the legal title to the Stirling property from J & L Developments to Palm Hills, were deliberate steps taken with the intent to thwart the adverse costs orders. This conclusion was based on Mr Viscariello’s own admissions and the overall context of his actions. The Court found that Mr Viscariello's testimony regarding his intentions and the purpose behind his actions was not credible, particularly in light of his earlier admissions and the strategic nature of the steps taken.

The Court also considered the broader context of Mr Viscariello’s conduct. Given that costs orders had already been made in the development approval litigation and that an adverse costs order against J & L Developments was inevitable if the appeal were to be successful, the Court found that Mr Viscariello’s actions were a calculated attempt to remove J & L Developments from any potential financial liability. The Tribunal was entitled to infer that Mr Viscariello’s conduct in 2006 was part of a deliberate strategy to avoid the consequences of the adverse costs orders, consistent with his earlier actions in amending the trust deed in 2004.

In reaching its conclusion, the Court emphasized that the Tribunal’s findings were well-supported by the evidence. Mr Viscariello’s own admissions and the logical sequence of events leading up to and following the changes in the trusteeship of the Stirling Trust provided a compelling narrative of deliberate action. The Tribunal correctly found that Mr Viscariello’s conduct in 2006 was not merely an innocent attempt to restructure the trust for legitimate business reasons, but rather a deliberate attempt to defeat the adverse costs orders against J & L Developments.

The Court did not find any material error in the Tribunal’s reasoning or its findings. The evidence overwhelmingly supported the conclusion that Mr Viscariello’s actions in 2006 were deliberate and aimed at defeating adverse costs orders. The Tribunal’s findings were open to it based on the evidence and the logical inferences that could be drawn from that evidence. The Court found no basis to disturb the Tribunal’s conclusion that Mr Viscariello engaged in deliberate conduct in 2006 with the objective of defeating adverse costs orders against J & L Developments.

The ratio decidendi of this aspect of the case is that a legal practitioner’s conduct can be found to be deliberate and aimed at defeating adverse costs orders if the evidence demonstrates a clear intention and strategic actions to avoid the financial consequences of those orders. The Court confirmed that the Tribunal was entitled to make findings based on the totality of the evidence and the logical inferences that can be drawn from it. The Court also reinforced that the Tribunal’s findings on the deliberate nature of the conduct and the intent behind it were well-supported and not reasonably open to question.