Viscariello v Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil: Application for Judicial Review)

VISCARIELLO v LEGAL PRACTITIONERS DISCIPLINARY TRIBUNAL

[2015] SASC 116

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Parker

7 August 2015

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW - JUDICIAL REVIEW - PROCEDURE AND EVIDENCE - APPLICATIONS

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW - JUDICIAL REVIEW - PROCEDURE AND EVIDENCE - EXTENSION OF TIME - GENERALLY

PROFESSIONS AND TRADES - LAWYERS - COMPLAINTS AND DISCIPLINE - PROFESSIONAL MISCONDUCT AND UNSATISFACTORY PROFESSIONAL CONDUCT - GENERALLY

Mr Viscariello applied for permission to proceed with two judicial reviews of adverse findings by the Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal on the basis of failure to accord procedural fairness and jurisdictional error. Mr Viscariello also sought an extension of time for both judicial reviews. He further sought a stay of a costs order made against him by the Tribunal and that the matter be assigned a special classification by the Chief Justice. Mr Viscariello was found guilty of unprofessional conduct by the Tribunal for amending a trust deed to defeat a costs order and giving false evidence in the Supreme Court. On a second charge he was found guilty of unsatisfactory conduct in pursuing a claim without a reasonable basis. Mr Viscariello appealed to the Full Court against the finding by the Tribunal of unprofessional conduct on the first charge. The Full Court found that Mr Viscariello had engaged in unprofessional conduct and unsatisfactory conduct as charged, and was not a fit and proper person to be to a practitioner. Mr Viscariello applied to the High Court for special leave, which was refused.

Held (Parker J) dismissing all applications:

(1)  In deciding whether to grant an extension of time the Court must consider the length of the delay, the reason for the delay, whether the applicant has prospects of success and the extent of any prejudice to the respondent.

(2)  The grounds for review arose and time commenced to run when the Tribunal published its findings and made its recommendation and costs order. Mr Viscariello lodged his applications more than two years later, which was seriously out of time.

(3)  The Court declined to exercise discretion to extend time for the lodgement of the two applications for judicial review as there was no reasonable basis upon which Mr Viscariello might establish a right to an order for judicial review.

(4)  The Court refused permission to proceed with the two applications. The quashing of the Tribunal decision would be futile and serve no useful purpose because it would not affect in any way the orders made by the Full Court dismissing Mr Viscariello’s appeal, nor would it affect the order that he be struck off the roll of practitioners.

(5)  The applications for the Tribunal’s costs order to be stayed and for the judicial review to be referred to the Chief Justice to be assigned a special classification must also be refused.

Legal Practitioners Act 1981 s 74(1), s 84(4), s 87(7), referred to.
Ferdinands v District Court [2010] SASC 265; Viscariello v Legal Practitioners Conduct Board (2014)…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Viscariello v Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] SASC 116
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Viscariello v Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal, the court was asked to consider an application by Mr Viscariello for an extension of time to seek permission to proceed with judicial review of decisions made by the Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal and the Full Court. Mr Viscariello sought the extension on the basis that he had not previously pursued judicial review due to his focus on his appeal against the Tribunal's decision that led to his striking off as a legal practitioner. The court was required to determine whether the delay in seeking judicial review was justifiable and whether the application had any merit.

The court considered the delay in bringing the application, noting that Mr Viscariello had waited over two years to seek judicial review after the Tribunal had made its findings and orders. The court found that the delay was unjustified and that Mr Viscariello had not shown any reasonable basis for his claim that he would be successful in having the Tribunal's findings quashed. The court also found that the application was unlikely to succeed on the grounds of futility and that any remedy would be futile. Given the serious delay and lack of merit in the application, the court refused the application for an extension of time and dismissed the application for judicial review.

The court's decision was based on the principle that time should not be extended where there is a significant delay and no reasonable prospect of success. The court found that Mr Viscariello had not demonstrated any justifiable reason for the delay and that the application was unlikely to succeed. The court also noted that the Full Court had already considered the merits of the Tribunal's findings and had dismissed Mr Viscariello's appeal. The court concluded that the application for judicial review was futile and that the application for an extension of time should be refused.

Background

Background to the litigation

Mr Viscariello has also lodged an application under r 242 in which he seeks that the Full Court reconsider his appeal against the decision of the Tribunal. At his request, the hearing of that application has been deferred pending the Court’s decision on the permission to proceed with the judicial review.Background On 20 August 2008 the Legal Practitioners Conduct Board laid a charge (the first charge) against Mr Viscariello alleging that he had been guilty of unprofessional conduct on two grounds. These grounds may be summarised as follows:(a)Mr Viscariello amended a trust deed so as to remove the right of indemnity that J & L Developments Pty Ltd (JLD) held as trustee against the assets of the Stirling Property Trust (SPT). He had taken that action in an attempt to defeat an adverse costs order that might be made by this Court against JLD; and(b)on 1 December 2006 Mr Viscariello gave false and dishonest evidence in this Court before Debelle J in Moyes & Anor v J & L Developments & Anor (No 2).[4] The evidence was that JLD has acted in its own right, and not as trustee of the SPT, in making an application for provisional development consent and in subsequent appeal proceedings in the Environment, Resources and Development (ERD) Court and in this Court.[4] [2007] SASC 261. The brief background to the first ground is that JLD owned certain land at Stirling. In 2003 it applied for development approval to build a house on that land for Mr Viscariello and his family. That application was refused by the local council. JLD then appealed to the ERD Court. That Court allowed the appeal and granted provisional development consent. Objectors to the development application appealed to this Court. Mr Viscariello acted as solicitor for JLD in the ERD Court and in this Court. The appeal was listed for hearing on 4 June 2004. On about 1 June 2004 Mr Viscariello amended the trust deed of the SPT to remove the right of indemnity held by JLD as trustee. The Board alleged that this action put the primary assets of the SPT out of the control of JLD so as to defeat a potential costs order. On 2 January 2009 the Board laid another charge (the Fences Act charge) against Mr Viscariello alleging that between November 2004 and June 2005 he had acted unsatisfactorily in pursuing a claim for a contribution under the Fences Act 1975 on behalf of JLD in his capacity as its solicitor. The basis upon which his conduct was alleged to be unsatisfactory was that any competent practitioner would have concluded that the claim was not reasonably arguable. The Tribunal proceedings The hearing before the Tribunal extended over 33 hearing days. Mr Viscariello was represented by very experienced senior and junior counsel. The report of the Tribunal extends over 42 pages. The Tribunal found that it was satisfied to a very high degree of the correctness of the allegations that led to its finding that Mr Viscariello was guilty of unprofessional conduct. Mr Viscariello admitted the facts relating to the Fences Act charge. He also admitted that those facts amounted to unsatisfactory conduct. Mr Viscariello specifically admitted that he considered that the application made to the Magistrates Court was arguable, but then failed to consider whether it was reasonably arguable under the Fences Act. The Tribunal concluded that any competent practitioner would have considered whether the application was reasonably arguable and would have concluded that it was not. On the basis of the agreed facts, the Tribunal found Mr Viscariello guilty of unsatisfactory conduct in relation to the Fences Act charge.The appeals to the Full Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

I think it very unlikely that Mr Viscariello could establish at trial that the Tribunal fell into jurisdictional error, acted contrary to the Legal Practitioners Act or denied him procedural fairness. However, I need not decide those issues given my firm view that a trial judge would decline to grant any remedy on the grounds of futility. Conclusion I refuse Mr Viscariello an extension of time to seek permission to proceed with the two applications for judicial review filed on 30 May 2014 and 30 June 2014. To the extent that it is necessary in light of the refusal of an extension of time, I also refuse permission to proceed with those two applications. Due to those conclusions, his applications for the Tribunal’s costs order to be stayed and for the judicial review to be referred to the Chief Justice to be assigned a special classification must also be refused.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Mr Wait on behalf of the Attorney-General submitted that permission to proceed with the action for judicial review should be refused on the grounds of futility, delay and lack of merit. There was no reasonable basis upon which Mr Viscariello might establish a right to an order for judicial review. Time should not be extended. ConsiderationDelay In deciding whether to grant an extension of time the Court must consider the length of the delay, the reason for the delay, whether the applicant has prospects of success and the extent of any prejudice to the respondent.[16][16] Ferdinands v District Court [2010] SASC 265 at [18]–[19]. The applications in this matter were filed on 30 May 2014 and 30 June 2014 respectively. At that time r 200(2) required an action for judicial review to be commenced as soon as practicable after the date when the grounds for the review arose, and in any event, within 6 months after that date. The orders sought by Mr Viscariello are directed at quashing decisions made by the Tribunal and not the later orders of the Full Court and of the High Court. I therefore reject his contention that time did not commence to run until the High Court rejected his application for special leave on 3 December 2013. The grounds for review arose when the Tribunal published its findings on 3 April 2012 and made its recommendation and costs order on 12 April 2012. Mr Viscariello lodged his applications more than two years later. They are seriously out of time. The question is whether the Court should exercise its discretion to extend the time for the lodgement of Mr Viscariello’s applications. He submits that if he had applied for judicial review before he had lodged an appeal, or before his appeal was finally determined, he would have been met with the objection that he should not have applied for judicial review before his appeal rights were exhausted.[17] He also submits that, while the delay has not prejudiced the Legal Profession Conduct Commissioner,[18] he has suffered a fundamental injustice which has deprived him of the right to practise his chosen profession. For these reasons he submitted that time should be extended.[17] Winen v District Court [2003] SASC 440; Weinal v Parsons (1994) 178 LSJS 48.[18] The Commissioner assumed the powers and functions of the Board from 1 July 2014. The submission by Mr Viscariello that time should be extended because he had pursued his appeal rights is not relevant to the Fences Act dispute. He did not appeal against the findings and orders of the Tribunal in relation to that matter. He took no action to challenge the adverse findings and orders for more than two years. He informed the Court that he had not done so because his attention was focused on the more serious finding by the Tribunal that led to his striking off. However, he now wishes to have this adverse finding set aside. If he succeeds in having the finding of unprofessional conduct that led to his striking off quashed, he does not regard it as acceptable to have the finding of unsatisfactory conduct left standing. That would continue to be a blemish on his reputation.