Viscariello v Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal

Link copied
Case Copied 36 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil: Application)

VISCARIELLO v LEGAL PRACTITIONERS DISCIPLINARY TRIBUNAL & ANOR

[2019] SASC 98

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Bampton

7 June 2019

PROFESSIONS AND TRADES - LAWYERS - COMPLAINTS AND DISCIPLINE - PROFESSIONAL MISCONDUCT AND UNSATISFACTORY PROFESSIONAL CONDUCT

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL - APPEAL - PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - EXTENSION OF TIME FOR APPEAL

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW - JUDICIAL REVIEW - PROCEDURE AND EVIDENCE - EXTENSION OF TIME - GENERALLY

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW - JUDICIAL REVIEW - PROCEDURE AND EVIDENCE - APPLICATIONS

Application by second defendant for, inter alia, summary dismissal of action for judicial review – where judicial review action commenced out of time challenging the validity of the laying of charges against the plaintiff by the Legal Practitioners Conduct Board in the Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal that led to a finding of unprofessional conduct and the plaintiff’s name being struck off the roll of practitioners – where plaintiff unsuccessfully appealed the finding and strike off order – whether charges validly laid, amended, and prosecuted in the Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal – whether grounds for judicial review exist.

Held, in summarily dismissing the action for judicial review: each charge was validly laid, amended and prosecuted before the Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal – the out of time action for judicial review cannot succeed on any view of the facts or law.

Legal Practitioners Act 1981 (SA) s 82, s 86, s 88, s 89; Supreme Court Civil Rules 2006 (SA) r 200A, r 200B, r 200C, r 242; Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal Rules (SA) r 4, r 9; Fences Act 1975 (SA); Legal Practitioners (Miscellaneous) Amendment Act 2013 (SA) Pt 4 Sch 2 cl 13, cl 14; Freedom of Information Act 1991 (SA), referred to.
Viscariello v Legal Practitioners Conduct Board (2012-13) 284 LSJS 452; R v Australian Broadcasting Tribunal; Ex parte Hardiman (1980) 144 CLR 13; Viscariello v Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal; Viscariello v Legal Profession Conduct Commissioner [2016] SASCFC 107; Hall & Ors v City of Burnside & Ors (2006) 102 SASR 298; Hall v City of Burnside & Ors (No 9) [2008] SASC 361; General Steel Industries Inc v Commissioner of Railways (NSW) (1964) 112 CLR 125, applied.
R v Halmi [2005] NSWCCA 263; Wei v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (2015) 257 CLR 22; B (A solicitor) v Victorian Lawyers RPA Ltd & Anor; G (A solicitor) v Victorian Lawyers RPA Ltd & Anor (2002) 6 VR 642, distinguished.
Moyes v J & L Developments Pty Ltd (No 2) [2007] SASC 261; Viscariello v Legal Practitioners Conduct Board (No 2) (2013) 285 LSJS 501; Legal Practitioners Conduct Board v Viscariello (2013) 286 LSJS 125; Legal Practitioners Conduct Board v Viscariello (No 2) (2013) 233 A Crim R 534; Viscariello v Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal & Ors [2015] SASC 192; Viscariello v Livesey & Anor [2014] SASCFC 40; Viscariello v Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal [2015] SASC 116, discussed.

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Viscariello v Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] SASC 98
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal in Viscariello v Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal was brought by Mr Viscariello against the Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal and the Legal Practitioners Conduct Board. Mr Viscariello had previously been found guilty of professional misconduct and had his name struck off the roll of legal practitioners. He sought judicial review of the Tribunal’s decision to lay charges against him, claiming the charges were not validly laid. The Tribunal sought summary dismissal of the action on the basis that it was brought out of time. The primary issue before the court was whether the action for judicial review was brought within the required time frame and whether there were any grounds for judicial review.

The court found that each charge was validly laid, amended, and prosecuted before the Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal. The charges were served on Mr Viscariello in a timely manner, and he was aware of all proceedings before the Tribunal. The amendments made to the charges did not require the Board to make a new decision, as they did not allege further conduct by Mr Viscariello. The court held that the action for judicial review could not succeed as it was brought out of time and there were no grounds for judicial review.

The court summarily dismissed the action for judicial review. The court concluded that the authorities relied on by Mr Viscariello were distinguishable and did not assist in resolving the matter. The Board and the Tribunal had complied with statutory obligations, and disciplinary proceedings are not criminal in nature. The court found that the charges were validly laid and amended, and the action for judicial review was brought out of time. Therefore, the application for summary dismissal was successful.

No further orders were made.

Background

Background to the litigation

In this case, Mr Viscariello, a legal practitioner, faced proceedings before the Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal regarding allegations of unprofessional conduct. The Legal Practitioners Conduct Board laid two charges against Mr Viscariello, which were served on him in August 2008. The charges were subsequently amended, and the matter proceeded to a hearing before the Tribunal. Mr Viscariello was represented by experienced counsel throughout the Tribunal proceedings. Following the hearing, the Tribunal found Mr Viscariello guilty of unprofessional conduct and ordered his name be struck off the roll of practitioners. Mr Viscariello appealed the decision but the appeal was unsuccessful.

Subsequently, Mr Viscariello commenced an action for judicial review, seeking to challenge the validity of the charges laid against him. He argued that the charges were not validly laid, amended, or prosecuted, and that there were grounds for judicial review. The Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal, represented by the Commissioner, applied to summarily dismiss the action on the basis that it was commenced out of time and that the charges were validly laid, amended, and prosecuted. The Commissioner relied on evidence demonstrating that Mr Viscariello was aware of the proceedings and the charges served on him within the requisite timeframes, and that the Board had complied with statutory obligations in laying and amending the charges. The court considered the arguments and submissions from both parties, including the authorities relied upon by Mr Viscariello, and concluded that the action for judicial review could not succeed due to the validity of the charges and the absence of grounds for judicial review.

The matter in Viscariello v Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal originated from a disciplinary proceeding against the plaintiff, a legal practitioner, by the Legal Practitioners Conduct Board within the Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal. Following the Board's laying of charges, the Tribunal conducted a hearing and found the plaintiff guilty of unprofessional conduct, resulting in the striking off of the plaintiff's name from the roll of practitioners. The plaintiff appealed the Tribunal's decision, but the appeal was ultimately dismissed. Dissatisfied with the outcome, the plaintiff commenced a judicial review action against the decisions of the Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal, challenging the validity of the laying of charges against him. This judicial review action was initiated out of the statutory time limit, prompting the second defendant to apply for its summary dismissal.

In response to the plaintiff's out-of-time judicial review action, the second defendant filed an application for summary dismissal, arguing that the action was time-barred and did not meet the criteria for an extension of time. The plaintiff, in turn, resisted the application, asserting that he had commenced the action within the requisite six-month period from when the grounds for judicial review arose. The court considered the evidence provided by both parties, including the statutory timelines and the plaintiff's awareness of the proceedings, to determine the validity of the charges and the timeliness of the judicial review action. The court concluded that the charges were validly laid, amended, and prosecuted, and that the judicial review action, being out of time, could not succeed.

Decision

Reasons for decision

GMM40 is the Tribunal record for the 2008 action and the 2009 action. Of note, Mr Viscariello was represented throughout the Tribunal proceedings by senior practitioners and senior counsel all experienced in disciplinary proceedings.Conclusion The authorities that Mr Viscariello sought to rely on included an interstate criminal case[21] and a migration case.[22] Mr Viscariello also sought to rely on a disciplinary case affirming the need for strict statutory compliance by statutory boards;[23] however, as set out below, there was statutory compliance by the Board and the Tribunal. Further, disciplinary proceedings are not criminal in nature.[24] I adopt the Commissioner’s counsel’s reply submissions regarding the authorities relied on by Mr Viscariello and agree that they are distinguishable on their facts and do not assist in resolving this matter.[21] R v Halmi [2005] NSWCCA 263.[22] Wei v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (2015) 257 CLR 22.[23] B (A solicitor) v Victorian Lawyers RPA Ltd & Anor; G (A solicitor) v Victorian Lawyers RPA Ltd & Anor (2006) 6 VR 642.[24] Viscariello v Legal Practitioners Conduct Board (2012-13) 284 LSJS 452. Mr Viscariello asserts that he commenced this action within six months of the grounds arising. I am satisfied, having regard to the evidence relied on by the Commissioner, that the first and second charges laid in accordance with the Act and the Rules were served personally on him shortly after they were laid. He was also aware of all proceedings before the Tribunal, including the grants of leave to amend the first and second charges pursuant to the Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal Rules. Accordingly, no grounds arose in the six months preceding the commencement of this action. I am satisfied, having regard to the evidence relied on by the Commissioner, that in relation to the first charge the Board made a decision to lay the first charge on 13 December 2007 as demonstrated by GMM7. I am satisfied that the Board made a decision to authorise to its then Director to sign and serve the charge, evidenced by the Board’s minute of 13 December 2007 (GMM7). Having regard to the second affidavit of Ms Billich and its exhibits, I am satisfied that the first charge was signed and laid on 20 August 2008 and served on Mr Viscariello on 22 August 2008. The first charge was amended pursuant to leave granted by the Tribunal during a hearing on 9 December 2011 when Mr Viscariello was represented by Mr Wells QC and Mr Hoile. The effect of the amendments was to delete conduct and particulars that the Board was no longer pursuing. As the amendments did not allege further conduct by Mr Viscariello it can reasonably be inferred, given the Director was of the view that the amendments made pursuant to leave granted on 22 April 2010 to the second charge did not need to go back to the Board, the Board did not need to make a decision regarding the amendments to the first charge. This did not breach the Board’s statutory obligations under s 75 of the Act.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of Viscariello v Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal, the court addressed several critical issues regarding the validity of charges laid against the plaintiff, the timeliness of the action for judicial review, and the grounds for such review. The first issue the court tackled was whether the charges laid against the plaintiff by the Legal Practitioners Conduct Board were validly laid, amended, and prosecuted in the Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal. The court found that the charges were validly laid and amended, adhering to statutory requirements. The Board had made a decision to lay the charges, evidenced by Board minutes, and these decisions were executed by the Board's Director. The amendments to the charges did not require a fresh decision by the Board as they did not allege further misconduct by the plaintiff. The court relied on the statutory framework governing the conduct of disciplinary proceedings and concluded that the charges were procedurally sound. The authorities relied on by the plaintiff, including interstate criminal and migration cases, were distinguished as they did not apply to the statutory compliance required in disciplinary proceedings.

The second issue was whether the action for judicial review was commenced out of time and, if so, whether the court should grant an extension of time for the appeal. The plaintiff argued that he commenced the action within six months of the grounds arising. However, the court found that the plaintiff was aware of all proceedings before the Tribunal, including the grants of leave to amend the charges. Therefore, no grounds arose in the six months preceding the commencement of this action. The court held that the action for judicial review was out of time and could not succeed regardless of the facts or law. The court declined to extend the time for the appeal, emphasizing the importance of strict compliance with procedural timelines in judicial review actions.

The third issue involved whether there were grounds for judicial review of the decisions made by the Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal. The court found that there were no grounds for judicial review as the charges were validly laid, amended, and prosecuted in accordance with the statutory framework. The amendments did not necessitate a fresh decision by the Board and did not breach the Board’s statutory obligations. The court also noted that the authorities cited by the plaintiff were not applicable to the case, as they dealt with different legal contexts and did not assist in resolving the issues at hand.

The fourth issue pertained to the applicability of the authorities relied on by the plaintiff. The court held that the authorities cited by the plaintiff were distinguishable and did not assist in resolving the issues in this case. Specifically, the court found that disciplinary proceedings are not criminal in nature and thus, the criminal cases cited by the plaintiff were not relevant. Furthermore, the migration case and the disciplinary case affirming strict statutory compliance were also deemed inapplicable. The court adopted the Commissioner’s submissions that the plaintiff’s reliance on these authorities was misplaced.

Lastly, the court considered whether the plaintiff was aware of all proceedings before the Tribunal, including the grants of leave to amend the charges, and when the grounds for judicial review arose. The court found that the plaintiff was indeed aware of all proceedings, as evidenced by the fact that he was represented by experienced practitioners throughout the Tribunal proceedings. Consequently, no new grounds arose in the six months preceding the commencement of this action for judicial review.

In summary, the court's reasoning led to the conclusion that the charges were validly laid, amended, and prosecuted, and the action for judicial review was out of time. The authorities cited by the plaintiff were not applicable, and the plaintiff was aware of all proceedings before the Tribunal. The binding legal principle established by this decision is that strict compliance with statutory requirements and procedural timelines is necessary in disciplinary proceedings and judicial review actions. The court did not depart from prior authority but rather clarified the application of existing principles in the context of legal practitioners' disciplinary proceedings.