Viscariello v Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil: Application for Judicial Review)

VISCARIELLO v LEGAL PRACTITIONERS DISCIPLINARY TRIBUNAL & ORS

[2015] SASC 192

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Bampton

8 December 2015

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW - JUDICIAL REVIEW - GENERALLY

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW - JUDICIAL REVIEW - PROCEDURE AND EVIDENCE - EXTENSION OF TIME - GENERALLY

PROCEDURE - SUPREME COURT PROCEDURE - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - PROCEDURE UNDER RULES OF COURT - IN GENERAL AND PRELIMINARY MATTERS

Mr Viscariello was found to have no standing to lay charges against the second and third Defendants in the Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal (the Tribunal).  Mr Viscariello’s appeal as of right to a single Judge of the Supreme Court against the Tribunal’s decision was dismissed.  Mr Viscariello’s appeal to the Full Court against the dismissal of his appeal is stayed pending his compliance with an order for security for costs.  Mr Viscariello’s application for permission to appeal the security for costs order was refused by the Full Court. 

On 16 May 2014 Mr Viscariello commenced an action for judicial review against the Tribunal’s decision.  Permission to proceed pursuant to 6R 200 was granted by a Master.

Whether action is an abuse of process - whether extension of time to commence an action of judicial review and permission to proceed should be revoked.

Held:

1  The action for judicial review is an abuse of process.

2  The extension of time to commence the action for judicial review is revoked.

3  The grant of permission to proceed is revoked and the action is permanently stayed as an abuse of process.

Legal Practitioners Act 1981 (SA) s 82(2), 82(4); Supreme Court Civil Rules 2006 (SA) r 200; Limitation of Actions Act 1936 (SA) s 48, referred to.
Viscariello v Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal [2015] SASC 116, applied.
Viscariello v Livesey & Anor (2013) 286 LSJS 525, [2013] SASC 99; Viscariello v Livesey & Anor [2014] SASCFC 40; R v Australian Broadcasting Tribunal; Ex parte Hardiman (1980) 144 CLR 13; Public Service Association of SA Inc v Industrial Relations Commission of SA (2012) 249 CLR 398; Re Glynn; Ex parte Royle [2003] WASCA 122; Jeffery & Katauskas Pty Ltd v SST Consulting Pty Ltd (2009) 239 CLR 75; Port of Melbourne Authority v Anshun Pty Ltd (1981) 147 CLR 589; Williams v Spautz (1992) 174 CLR 509; Somasundaram v M Julius Melchior & Co [1989] 1 All ER 129; Viscariello v Livesey & Anor [2013] SASC 198, considered.

VISCARIELLO v LEGAL PRACTITIONERS DISCIPLINARY TRIBUNAL & ORS
[2015] SASC 192

Civil

BAMPTON J.

Introduction

  1. Mr Viscariello was found to have no standing to lay charges in the Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal (the Tribunal) against Mr Livesey QC and Ms Flaherty.  His appeal as of right to a single Judge of the Supreme Court against the Tribunal’s decision was dismissed.  Mr Viscariello appealed that dismissal to the Full court.  The prosecution of the Full Court appeal is stayed pending Mr Viscariello’s compliance with an…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Viscariello v Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] SASC 192
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Viscariello v Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal, the primary issue was whether the plaintiff, Mr Viscariello, had standing to bring a judicial review action against the Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal’s decisions. Mr Viscariello sought to challenge the Tribunal's decisions to dismiss charges of unprofessional conduct against Mr Livesey and Ms Flaherty, alleging they engaged in misconduct in the context of their representation of Ms George in litigation involving Mr Viscariello’s former domestic partner, Ms Hamilton-Smith. The Tribunal had dismissed the charges against Mr Livesey and Ms Flaherty, ruling that Mr Viscariello lacked standing to lay the charges.

The court needed to determine the scope of the Tribunal’s jurisdiction and whether the dismissal of the charges on the basis of lack of standing was within its authority. The plaintiff argued that the Tribunal overstepped its jurisdiction by making findings on his standing and dismissing the charges, as these matters were beyond its statutory powers. The court had to assess the validity of Mr Viscariello's claims and whether the Tribunal’s decisions were reviewable under judicial review principles.

The court found that Mr Viscariello’s action for judicial review was an abuse of process. The court held that the Tribunal had the jurisdiction to determine the issue of standing and to dismiss the charges if the plaintiff lacked standing. The court further found that Mr Viscariello's failure to meet the order for security resulted in the stay of his appeal against the Tribunal’s decisions. Consequently, the court revoked the extension of time to commence the judicial review action and permanently stayed the action as an abuse of process.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The action for judicial review is an abuse of process.

2. The extension of time to commence the action for judicial review is revoked.

3. The grant of permission to proceed is revoked and the action is permanently stayed as an abuse of process.

Background

Background to the litigation

The action for judicial review commenced by Mr Viscariello against the decisions of the Tribunal, which are the subject of the stayed Full Court appeal, is a flagrant abuse of process. In my view permission to proceed should be revoked and the action permanently stayed as an abuse of process. My reasons for arriving at this view are as follows.Background Mr Viscariello alleges that Mr Livesey and Ms Flaherty engaged in unprofessional conduct arising out of their representation of a Ms George in the litigation involving his former domestic partner Ms Hamilton-Smith. The conduct charged against Mr Livesey is alleged to have occurred in the performance of his role as counsel instructed by the firm Minter Ellison. The conduct charged against Ms Flaherty, a solicitor with Minter Ellison, is alleged to have occurred in her role as instructing solicitor. Mr Viscariello was a director of two companies: Bernsteen Pty Ltd (in liquidation) (Bernsteen) and Newmore Pty Ltd (in liquidation) (Newmore). On 5 December 2001, an administrator was appointed to Bernsteen and Newmore and on 21 December 2001, they went into liquidation. Mr Macks who was appointed the Liquidator instructed Minter Ellison to act as his solicitors in the liquidation of Bernsteen and Newmore. During the course of the liquidations, Mr Macks provided support to Ms George in relation to litigation involving Ms Hamilton-Smith and Minter Ellison was retained by Ms George. On 7 June 2011 Mr Viscariello purported to lay charges of unprofessional conduct against Mr Livesey and Ms Flaherty to the Tribunal as a person claiming to be aggrieved by reason of their alleged professional misconduct pursuant to s 82(2)(d) of the Legal Practitioners Act 1981 (the LPA). The charges alleged that Mr Livesey and Ms Flaherty misled or attempted to mislead courts by making statements, or allowing evidence to be adduced, which they knew to be false or incomplete. The Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal proceedings[1] [1] See transcript of proceedings in In The Matter of The Legal Practitioners Act 1981 Action No 9 of 2011 between John Viscariello and Mark Livesey QC and Action No 10 of 2011 between John Viscariello and Tyneil Flaherty and orders made 14 August 2012 and 10 October 2012. Both Mr Livesey and Ms Flaherty made application to the Tribunal to dismiss the charges against them, for reasons including Mr Viscariello’s lack of standing. At a directions hearing before the Tribunal on 5 September 2011, Mr Viscariello requested that the question of his standing be determined as a preliminary issue. At a further directions hearing on 4 October 2011, Mr Viscariello again requested that the issue of standing be determined before any further business was considered. Two weeks later on 15 October 2011 Mr Viscariello again submitted to the Tribunal that the question of his standing was a threshold issue and conceded that the Tribunal had no jurisdiction to conduct an inquiry unless his standing was established.

Decision

Reasons for decision

BAMPTON J
To date Mr Viscariello has not met the order for security and as such his appeal against the decision of White J is stayed.The action for judicial review of the Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal’s decisions 14 August and 10 October 2012 On 16 May 2014 Mr Viscariello commenced this action for judicial review pursuant to r 200 of the Supreme Court Civil Rules 2006 (the SCR) naming the Tribunal as the defendant. Mr Viscariello also sought “to the extent necessary an order extending the time in which the plaintiff is able to bring his action for Judicial Review”. Rule 200(2) mandated that an action for judicial review had to be commenced within six months after the date when the grounds for review arose. As Mr Viscariello brought the action prior to the amendments to the SCR, which came into effect on 1 October 2014, he required permission to proceed pursuant to 6R 200(1).[5] Under the repealed SCR the Court could grant permission if satisfied that there was a reasonable basis on which the applicant might establish a right to an order for judicial review.[5] See Clause 3(b) of Amendment 26 to the SCR which states that the amendments made to r 200 apply only to proceedings commenced on or after 1 October 2014. In accordance with 6R 200(1) on 19 May 2014 Mr Viscariello filed an ex‑parte interlocutory application, FDN 3, seeking permission to proceed further in the Court. Mr Viscariello’s affidavit sworn 15 May 2014 In his affidavit filed in support of the action for judicial review, FDN 2, Mr Viscariello deposes that he brought the charges against Mr Livesey and Ms Flaherty because the Legal Practitioners Conduct Board (the Board) failed to carry out its statutory duty under the LPA to investigate complaints which he and Ms Hamilton-Smith had made to the Board about them. Mr Viscariello contends that the only power the Tribunal had under the LPA was to inquire into the conduct of Mr Livesey and Ms Flaherty under s 82(4) of the LPA. He states that the Tribunal did not have the power, authority or jurisdiction under the LPA to: ·make the finding that he was not a person claiming to be aggrieved and had no standing to lay the charges against the second and third defendants;·make the orders on 14 August 2012 dismissing the charges; and·make the costs orders on 10 October 2012. Mr Viscariello argues that the question of law, namely the statutory interpretation of the meaning and application of s 82(2) of the LPA was not within the Tribunal’s power, authority or jurisdiction.[6][6] Affidavit of Mr Viscariello, sworn 15 May 2014, page 14. He also refers to his appeal against the orders of the Tribunal being dismissed by White J in Viscariello v Livesey & Anor,[7] to the order for security for costs imposed by Kelly J, and his Application for Permission to Appeal against Kelly J’s decision which was refused by the Full Court in Viscariello v Livesey & Anor.[8][7] (2013) 286 LSJS 525, [2013] SASC 99.[8] [2014] SASCFC 40. He deposes that at no stage have Mr Livesey or Ms Flaherty been called upon by the Tribunal or this Court to answer the allegations the subject of the charges he made against them.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: BAMPTON J

The court began by addressing the central issue of whether the action for judicial review was an abuse of process. In this regard, the court noted Mr Viscariello's persistent attempts to challenge the Tribunal's decisions despite multiple unsuccessful appeals and refusals of permission to appeal. The court held that the action was a flagrant abuse of process, as it amounted to an abuse of the judicial system and a misuse of legal proceedings. The court relied on the principle that judicial review is a remedy to be exercised with caution and restraint, and that an abuse of process occurs when proceedings are brought for an improper purpose or in a manner that is vexatious or oppressive.

The court further examined the issue of whether the extension of time granted to Mr Viscariello to commence the action for judicial review was appropriate. Under the repealed Supreme Court Civil Rules 2006, an applicant for judicial review was required to obtain permission from the court to proceed with the action if it was brought outside the six-month limitation period. The court held that Mr Viscariello had not met the order for security for costs, which was a prerequisite for obtaining permission to proceed. The court revoked the extension of time and held that the grant of permission to proceed was revoked and the action was permanently stayed as an abuse of process.

The court then addressed the issue of whether the Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal had the power, authority, or jurisdiction to determine the standing of Mr Viscariello in the context of the charges laid. The court held that the Tribunal had the power, authority, and jurisdiction to determine the issue of standing as a preliminary matter, as it was necessary to establish whether it had jurisdiction to hear the charges. The court relied on the principle that the jurisdiction of a tribunal must be determined by reference to the relevant statutory provisions and the nature of the proceedings.

The court further examined whether the Tribunal had the power, authority, or jurisdiction to make findings that Mr Viscariello was not a person claiming to be aggrieved and had no standing to lay the charges. The court held that the Tribunal did have the power, authority, and jurisdiction to make such findings, as it was a necessary step in determining whether it had jurisdiction to hear the charges. The court relied on the principle that a tribunal must first determine its jurisdiction before it can proceed to hear the merits of a case.

The court then considered whether the Tribunal had the power, authority, or jurisdiction to dismiss the charges and make costs orders. The court held that the Tribunal did have the power, authority, and jurisdiction to dismiss the charges and make costs orders, as it was within the scope of its statutory powers under the Legal Practitioners Act 1981. The court relied on the principle that a tribunal has the power to make any order that is necessary or appropriate to the exercise of its jurisdiction.

Finally, the court addressed the issue of whether the statutory interpretation of the meaning and application of s 82(2) of the Legal Practitioners Act 1981 was within the Tribunal's power, authority, or jurisdiction. The court held that the issue of statutory interpretation was within the Tribunal's power, authority, and jurisdiction, as it was a question of law that arose in the course of the proceedings. The court relied on the principle that a tribunal has the power to interpret and apply the relevant statutory provisions in the exercise of its jurisdiction.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that the Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal has the power, authority, and jurisdiction to determine the issue of standing as a preliminary matter, to make findings that a person is not a person claiming to be aggrieved and has no standing to lay charges, to dismiss charges and make costs orders, and to interpret and apply the relevant statutory provisions in the exercise of its jurisdiction. The court distinguished prior authority that suggested otherwise, as it was based on a misinterpretation of the statutory provisions and the nature of the proceedings.