Legal Profession Conduct Commissioner v Mancini

Link copied
Case Copied 45 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Full Court)

LEGAL PROFESSION CONDUCT COMMISSIONER v MANCINI

[2022] SASCFC 1

Judgment of The Full Court  

(The Honourable President Livesey, the Honourable Justice Stanley and the Honourable Justice Doyle)

1 August 2022

PROFESSIONS AND TRADES - LAWYERS - COMPLAINTS AND DISCIPLINE - DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS - SOUTH AUSTRALIA

PROFESSIONS AND TRADES - LAWYERS - COMPLAINTS AND DISCIPLINE - PROFESSIONAL MISCONDUCT AND UNSATISFACTORY PROFESSIONAL CONDUCT

The Legal Profession Conduct Commissioner (the Commissioner) seeks an order that the respondent practitioner’s name be struck off the roll of practitioners pursuant to s 89(2)(d) of the Legal Practitioners Act 1981 (SA).

The practitioner has a long history of disciplinary proceedings.  On 17 May 2016, the Commissioner laid a charge against the practitioner alleging nine counts of professional misconduct.  Five were assertions that the practitioner made false and misleading representations to the Legal Services Commission and four comprised assertions that the practitioner claimed or attempted to claim fees from the Legal Services Commission which he knew, or should have reasonably known, he was not entitled to claim.

In 2017, the Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal (the Tribunal) found the practitioner not guilty of professional misconduct, but guilty of unsatisfactory professional conduct on all nine counts.  On appeal, the Full Court found the practitioner guilty of three counts of professional misconduct and remitted the remaining six counts to the Tribunal.  On 13 August 2020, the second Tribunal found the practitioner guilty of professional misconduct on four counts. The Tribunal directed that the question of penalty be referred to this Court for determination.

Held (the Court) allowing the Commissioner’s application:

1.The name of the practitioner, George Joseph Stephen Mancini, will be struck from the roll of practitioners kept by this Court.

2.      The practitioner is ordered to pay the Commissioner’s costs in this Court.

Legal Practitioners Act 1981 (SA) ss 82, 77J, 88A, 89; Legal Services Commission Act 1977 (SA); Supreme Court Civil Rules 2006 (SA) r 200, referred to.
Berger v Counsel of the Law Society of New South Wales [2019] NSWCA 119; Clyne v The New South Wales Bar Association (1960) 104 CLR 186; Giudice v Legal Profession Complaints Committee [2014] WASCA 115; Hart v Parole Board [2017] SASC 184; Law Society of New South Wales v Foreman (No 2) (1994) 34 NSWLR 408; Law Society of South Australia v Murphy (1999) 201 LSJS 456; Law Society of South Australia v Rodda (2002) 83 SASR 541; Legal Practitioners Conduct Board v Clisby [2012] SASCFC 43; Legal Practitioners Conduct Board v Fletcher [2005] SASC 382; Legal Practitioners Conduct Board v Hay (2001) 83 SASR 454; Legal Practitioners Conduct Board v Jones [2010] SASCFC 51; Legal Practitioners Conduct Board v Lind ( 2011) 110 SASR 531; Legal Practitioners Conduct Board v Morel (2004) 88 SASR 401; Legal Practitioners Conduct Board v Phillips (2001) 83 SASR 467; Legal Practitioners Conduct Board v Viscariello [2013] SASCFC 37; Legal Profession Conduct…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Legal Profession Conduct Commissioner v Mancini and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] SASCFC 1
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by the Legal Profession Conduct Commissioner against a decision of the Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal concerning Mr Mancini, a legal practitioner. The initial proceedings before the Tribunal resulted in Mr Mancini being found guilty of unsatisfactory professional conduct on nine counts. The Commissioner appealed this decision to the Full Court of the Supreme Court of South Australia, which allowed the appeal in part, substituting findings of professional misconduct on three counts and remitting the remaining six for re-hearing. A differently constituted Tribunal subsequently found Mr Mancini guilty of professional misconduct on four of those counts. The second Tribunal then referred the question of penalty to the Supreme Court for determination.

The legal issues before the Supreme Court were whether Mr Mancini was a fit and proper person to remain a member of the legal profession, and if not, what orders should be made regarding his registration. The Court was required to consider the nature and circumstances of the professional misconduct, including findings of dishonesty, in light of Mr Mancini's extensive disciplinary history, which included prior findings of unprofessional conduct and misleading conduct. The Court also had to consider the purpose of disciplinary proceedings, which is to protect the public interest by maintaining professional standards and assuring public confidence in the legal profession, rather than solely to punish the practitioner.

The Court reasoned that its primary function in such proceedings is to act in the public interest and to maintain confidence in the legal profession. It noted that Mr Mancini had been convicted of seven counts of professional misconduct, many involving dishonesty, and had a long history of prior disciplinary findings dating back to 1990. While acknowledging evidence suggesting Mr Mancini had developed some insight into his past errors and had made changes to his practice, the Court concluded that his conduct demonstrated a lack of the essential qualities, character, and integrity required for legal practice.

Consequently, the Court ordered that Mr Mancini's name be struck from the roll of practitioners. The Court also indicated that Mr Mancini would likely be ordered to pay the Commissioner's costs in the Supreme Court proceedings, subject to further submissions from the parties.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

For the reasons that follow, an order should be made striking the practitioner’s name from the roll. The Commissioner’s evidence The Commissioner relied upon material supported by affidavits of Ms Philippa Branson affirmed on 25 March and 28 May 2021. It is appropriate to outline that material. The charge was originally laid against the practitioner in the Tribunal on 17 May 2016. Nine counts of professional misconduct were alleged. The matter was heard by the Tribunal, presided over by Ms Maharaj QC, on 28 April and 19 May 2017 (the first Tribunal). The Tribunal’s decision and reasons were delivered on 10 August 2017: the practitioner was found not guilty of professional misconduct but guilty of unsatisfactory professional conduct on all nine counts. The Commissioner appealed. The appeal was heard on 12 February 2018. The Full Court of the Supreme Court of South Australia (the Full Court) delivered its judgment on 2 May 2018.[1] The Full Court allowed the Commissioner’s appeal. On counts 1, 2 and 4, the Full Court substituted findings of professional misconduct and, on the remaining six counts, the matter was remitted for re-hearing before a differently constituted Tribunal. [1] Legal Profession Conduct Commissioner v Mancini (2018) 130 SASR 349 (Kelly, Blue and Parker JJ). On remittal, the Tribunal, with Mr Sallis presiding, heard the matter between 24 and 25 July 2019 and delivered findings and reasons on 13 August 2020 (the second Tribunal).[2] The Tribunal found the practitioner guilty of professional misconduct on counts 3, 5, 7 and 9, with counts 6 and 8 found not proven. [2] Re Legal Profession Conduct Commissioner v Mancini (Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal, Action No 8 of 2016, 13 August 2020). Submissions on penalty and costs were heard on 15 October 2020 and, by its decision and reasons delivered on 18 February 2021, the second Tribunal directed that the question of penalty be referred to this Court for determination. The Commissioner emphasises that the practitioner has been convicted of seven counts of professional misconduct and that most of these involve explicit findings of dishonesty. It will be necessary to return to those findings. Before addressing the findings made against the practitioner it is appropriate to outline his extensive history of disciplinary proceedings.The practitioner’s disciplinary history In February 1990, the practitioner was found guilty of unprofessional conduct for lying to a client. He was admonished. In March 1992, the practitioner was found guilty of four counts of unprofessional conduct involving delay, lack of communication and one breach of an undertaking. He was admonished. In March 1995, the practitioner was again found guilty of unprofessional conduct due to a lack of communication. He was again admonished. In October 2011, the practitioner was found guilty of unsatisfactory conduct due to a failure to complete work and a lack of communication. He was reprimanded. In November 2013, the Tribunal, with Mr S P O’Sullivan QC presiding, found the practitioner guilty of unprofessional conduct for misleading a psychologist and failing to pay him. The charge was framed in the Tribunal as the making of a false and misleading statement to a psychologist, concerning four different matters. In the first matter the practitioner wrote to the psychologist, telling the psychologist that the client had deposited monies in trust for the purposes of a psychological report. In fact, at the time the letter was sent, the practitioner ought to have known that there were no monies in trust.[3] The practitioner received the psychologist’s report on 3 June 2009 but thereafter failed to pay the attached invoice in the sum of $1,210. In correspondence between July and September 2010, the psychologist wrote to the practitioner seeking settlement of outstanding invoices in this and other matters. In the absence of a response, the psychologist made a complaint to the Legal Practitioners Conduct Board (the Board) in November 2010. [3] Re Legal Practitioners Conduct Board v Mancini (Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal, Action No 2 of 2012, 19 April 2013), [72].

Decision

Reasons for decision

This Court must act in the public interest and so as to ensure that confidence continues to be reposed in the legal profession. In those circumstances it must be concluded that the practitioner lacks the qualities, character and integrity which are essential to legal practice. No order short of strike-off would be appropriate. Conclusion The practitioner’s name should be struck from the roll of practitioners kept by this Court. Subject to hearing from the parties, the practitioner should be ordered to pay the Commissioner’s costs in this Court.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Dr Lim described the practitioner as having developed a greater level of insight into his past mistakes and errors of judgment, and that his current focus on self-care and the significant changes made to his professional practice, albeit belatedly, represent an encouraging reflection of his commitment to positive change. Dr Lim expresses the opinion that there are positive indicators to the practitioner’s strength of character provided by his commitment to personal development and capacity to openly admit faults and weaknesses.Consideration of the application The purpose of disciplinary proceedings is to protect the public interest. This Court acts in the public interest.[35] When acting in the public interest the Court acts to protect the public rather than punish the practitioner.[36] Nonetheless, protecting the public includes both deterring the practitioner before the Court as well as deterring other practitioners from similar misconduct in the future.[37] By deterring similar misconduct the Court seeks to maintain professional standards and, thereby, assure the public that it may have confidence in the legal profession.[38][35] Wentworth v New South Wales Bar Association (1992) 176 CLR 239, 250-251 (Deane, Dawson, Toohey and Gaudron JJ).[36] TheLaw Society of South Australia v Murphy (1999) 201 LSJS 456, 461 (Doyle CJ, with whom Millhouse and Prior JJ agreed).[37] Law Society of New South Wales v Foreman (No 2) (1994) 34 NSWLR 408, 471 (Giles AJA).[38] Legal Practitioners Conduct Board v Clisby [2012] SASCFC 43, [9] (Doyle CJ and Stanley J). The Court must carefully evaluate the nature and the circumstances of the professional misconduct in order to determine the ultimate issue, which is whether the practitioner is fit to remain a member of the legal profession.[39] The evaluation must be undertaken recognising that, for so long as the practitioner’s name remains on the roll, he is held out as being fit to practise the profession of the law.[40] The Court must determine whether the Commissioner has shown that this practitioner is not a fit and proper person to practise at this time.[41] Any orders made by this Court must be directed to ensuring that, to the extent that the practitioner is shown to be not fit to practise, the entitlement to practise is either restricted or denied.[42][39] Ziems v The Prothonotary of the Supreme Court of New South Wales (1975) 97 CLR 279, 297-298 (Kitto J).[40] Legal Profession Conduct Commission v Kaminski [2021] SASCFC 39, [12] (Livesey P, Bleby and David JJA).[41] Ziems v The Prothonotary of The Supreme Court of New South Wales (1957) 97 CLR 279, 297-298 (Kitto J); Clyne v The New South Wales Bar Association (1960) 104 CLR 186, 189 (Dixon CJ, McTiernan, Fullagar, Menzies and Windeyer JJ); Law Society of New South Wales v Foreman (No 2) (1994) 34 NSWLR 408; Law Society of South Australia v Rodda (2002) 83 SASR 541, 545 (Doyle CJ, with whom Williams J agreed).[42] Law Society of New South Wales v Foreman (No 2) (1994) 34 NSWLR 408, [441] (Mahoney JA); Legal Practitioners Conduct Board v Fletcher [2005] SASC 382, [21] (Debelle J, with whom Besanko and Vanstone JJ agreed), Legal Profession Conduct Commissioner v Cleland [2021] SASC 10, [41]-[45] (Livesey JA, with whom Kelly P and Bleby JA agreed).