SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA
(Civil: Application)
THE STATE OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA v KEN & ORS
[2021] SASC 10
Judgment of the Honourable Justice Stanley
HEALTH LAW - BURIAL AND CREMATION - BODIES AND GRAVES
HEALTH LAW - BURIAL AND CREMATION - POWERS OF AUTHORITIES
PROCEDURE - STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS: JURISDICTION, POWERS AND GENERALLY - INHERENT AND GENERAL STATUTORY POWERS
Kunmanara Barney Randolph Shane David Waye died intestate on 4 July 2018. There is a dispute between his biological parents, David “Scotty” Ken and Marceena Waye concerning the place of his burial. The bodily remains of the deceased have been stored at the mortuary of the Royal Adelaide Hospital since 6 September 2018. The State of South Australia has instituted proceedings seeking orders as to the final burial place of the deceased. The respondents to those proceedings are the deceased’s biological parents, the deceased’s paternal grandmother Yuminya Ken, the deceased’s paternal aunt Tjimpuna Williams, and the deceased’s sister Bessie Waye.
The deceased’s father, Yuminya Ken and Tjimpuna Williams want the deceased buried at Pukatja (Ernabella). The deceased’s mother and sister want the deceased buried at Port Augusta. The dispute between the parties is intractable.
In the circumstances the dignity of the deceased and the conscience of the community require that a declaration as to the place at which the deceased be buried is made so that he can be buried without further delay, but with all proper respect and decency.
The deceased was born in Port Augusta on 6 July 1993. Accordingly, he was 24 years of age at the time of his death. It appears he died leaving no assets. The evidence is he died without issue and without a wife or de facto partner.
Held:
1. After undertaking a balancing of common law principles and practical considerations, as well as attention to cultural, spiritual and religious factors, Pukatja has the stronger claim to be the appropriate place of burial of the deceased.
2. The place for burial of the deceased, Kunmanara Barney Randolph Shane David Waye, who was reported to have died on 4 July 2018, is to be Pukatja.
South Australia v Smith (2014) 119 SASR 247, applied.
Minister for Families and Communities v Brown [2009] SASC 86; Jones v Dodd (1999) 73 SASR 328; Jones v Dodd [1999] SASC 458; Love v Commonwealth (2020) 375 ALR 597, discussed.Calma v Sesar (1992) 2 NTLR 37; Darcy v Duckett [2016] NSWSC 1756; Abraham v Stone [2017] NSWSC 1684; Nayacakalou v Vincent [2020] NSWSC 24; Mabo v Queensland (1992) 175 CLR 1, considered.
THE STATE OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA v KEN & ORS
[2021] SASC 10STANLEY J:
Introduction
Kunmanara Barney Randolph Shane David Waye[1] died intestate on 4 July 2018. There is a dispute between his biological parents, David “Scotty” Ken and Marceena Waye concerning the place of his burial. The bodily remains of the deceased have been stored at the mortuary of the Royal Adelaide Hospital…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read The State of South Australia v Ken and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2021] SASC 10
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the Court involved reconciling the common law principles of burial rights with the cultural and spiritual significance of the burial place to the deceased's family. The Court had to determine whether the deceased's expressed wishes, if any, should take precedence, or whether the cultural authority of the paternal family should be considered. The Court also needed to assess the practical implications of the decision, including the impact on the deceased's family and the broader community.
The Court concluded that Pukatja had a stronger claim to be the appropriate burial place for the deceased. This decision was based on the cultural and spiritual significance of Pukatja to the deceased and his paternal family, who wished to conduct the burial according to their law and custom. The Court found that Pukatja was the deceased's country and that his paternal family had the cultural authority to decide on the burial place. The Court also noted the importance of the deceased's connection to his paternal family and their traditions.
The final orders of the Court were that the deceased would be buried at Pukatja, with the Department of Human Services to request the undertaker to conduct the burial in a manner that respects the wishes of the deceased's paternal family. The Court also ordered that notice of the funeral be given to relevant parties, and that the stay on the orders would be lifted if no appeal was filed by a specified date. The Court emphasized the need to respect the dignity of the deceased and the conscience of the community in making its decision.
Orders
Orders of the court
Kunmanara Barney Randolph Shane David Waye died intestate on 4 July 2018. There is a dispute between his biological parents, David “Scotty” Ken and Marceena Waye concerning the place of his burial. The bodily remains of the deceased have been stored at the mortuary of the Royal Adelaide Hospital since 6 September 2018. The State of South Australia has instituted proceedings seeking orders as to the final burial place of the deceased. The respondents to those proceedings are the deceased’s biological parents, the deceased’s paternal grandmother Yuminya Ken, the deceased’s paternal aunt Tjimpuna Williams, and the deceased’s sister Bessie Waye.
The deceased’s father, Yuminya Ken and Tjimpuna Williams want the deceased buried at Pukatja (Ernabella). The deceased’s mother and sister want the deceased buried at Port Augusta. The dispute between the parties is intractable.
In the circumstances the dignity of the deceased and the conscience of the community require that a declaration as to the place at which the deceased be buried is made so that he can be buried without further delay, but with all proper respect and decency.
The deceased was born in Port Augusta on 6 July 1993. Accordingly, he was 24 years of age at the time of his death. It appears he died leaving no assets. The evidence is he died without issue and without a wife or de facto partner.
Held:
1. After undertaking a balancing of common law principles and practical considerations, as well as attention to cultural, spiritual and religious factors, Pukatja has the stronger claim to be the appropriate place of burial of the deceased.
2. The place for burial of the deceased, Kunmanara Barney Randolph Shane David Waye, who was reported to have died on 4 July 2018, is to be Pukatja.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
I make the following findings of fact:1.the deceased was born on 6 July 1993 at Port Augusta;2.from infancy until he was about 20 years of age he lived on the APY lands at Pukatja;3.he was a fully initiated wati;4.in about the last five years of his life he lived at various times with his mother at Port Augusta, in Coober Pedy and at Pukatja;5.he died at Adelaide on 4 July 2018;6.he died intestate and without any known assets;7.there has been no application for a grant of letters of administration, and in the circumstances it is unlikely any will be made;8.his mother and sister live at Port Augusta; 9.his father and extended paternal family live at Pukatja;10.the deceased did not express any wish as to his place of burial;11.his mother and sister want him buried in Port Augusta; and12.his father and his extended paternal family, including the third and fourth respondents, want him buried at Pukatja.Consideration In this matter I am not assisted by consideration of who might be entitled to obtain letters of administration in the event that such an application were to be made. Both the first and second respondents, the deceased’s father and mother, could apply for letters of administration. However, as I have found, there has been no application for a grant of letters of administration and it is unlikely any will be made. In these circumstances, the historical common law approach to assigning a right of burial assumes “an air of unreality”.[23][23] Jones v Dodd [1999] SASC 125 at [50], (1999) 73 SASR 328 at 336. In addition, there is no evidence of the deceased expressing any wish as to the location of his burial. There is a clear division of views amongst the deceased’s living close relatives concerning his place of burial. That division can loosely be ascribed as being between the paternal and maternal branches of the deceased’s family. The deceased’s mother and sister reside in Port Augusta. The deceased was born in Port Augusta. During the last five years of his life the deceased spent considerable time in Port Augusta, but also in Coober Pedy and Pukatja. I accept that when he was dying the deceased wanted to return to his mother’s home but, for the reasons I have explained above, I cannot find that he expressed any wish as to the place of his burial. On the other hand, the deceased’s father, grandmother and aunt want the deceased buried at Pukatja where he grew up and lived most of his life. Like his father and grandfathers, the deceased is a fully initiated wati. Pukatja is his country. The paternal family assert that they have cultural authority to decide where the deceased will be buried. They live on their traditional lands and wish to conduct the burial of the deceased according to their law and custom. In Love v Commonwealth[24] Bell J said that the High Court in Mabo v Queensland[25] recognised a connection that Aboriginal Australians have with “country” that is essentially spiritual.[26] In Love Nettle J observed that central to the traditional laws and customs of Aboriginal communities was, and is, an essentially spiritual connection with “country”, including a responsibility to live in the tracks of ancestral spirits and to care for land and waters to be handed on to future generations.[27][24] [2020] HCA 3, (2020) 375 ALR 597.[25] (1992) 175 CLR 1.[26] [2020] HCA 3 at [70], (2020) 375 ALR 597 at 613-614.[27] [2020] HCA 3 at [276], (2020) 375 ALR 597 at 666.