HEALTH LAW - BURIAL AND CREMATION - BODIES AND GRAVES
HEALTH LAW - BURIAL AND CREMATION - POWERS OF AUTHORITIES
Application by Minister for the Department of Communities and Social Inclusion seeking orders with respect to disagreement concerning burial of intestate deceased - two applications for funeral assistance made to Minister - deceased of Aboriginal descent - first defendant (putative domestic partner who lives in Ceduna) submitted that deceased should be buried in Coober Pedy, in accordance with traditional beliefs - second defendant (son of the deceased) submitted that deceased should be buried at Port Augusta with his deceased young son and where other children including the second defendant live - relevant considerations to determine place of burial - the body of the deceased presently in the custody of an undertaker awaiting the Court's decision.
Held: that the deceased to be buried in Port Augusta in accordance with the wishes of the second defendant.
STATE OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA v SMITH & ANOR [2014] SASC 64
NICHOLSON J.
Introduction
The Department for Communities and Social Inclusion (“the Department”) has caused an application to be brought, in the name of the State of South Australia,[1] seeking orders as to the final burial place and mode of burial of Raymond William Boland who died, intestate, on 3 December 2013. The need for the Court to intervene has arisen because there has been prolonged disagreement among family members of the deceased as to the appropriate burial location.
The Department, together with the Minister for Family and Community Services, is responsible for the administration of the Family and Community Services Act 1972
Grounds of appeal
[14] The appellant contends that the primary judge erred in finding that the respondent had discharged the onus of establishing the matters required under the relevant provision.
[15] It was submitted that his Honour failed to give adequate weight to the evidence of the second witness, and that the findings of fact were not reasonably open on the material before the Court.
[16] The respondent, for its part, submits that no error is disclosed, and that the conclusions reached were well within the range of outcomes available to the primary judge.
Consideration
[17] It is convenient to deal first with the question of construction, as the resolution of that issue informs the remaining grounds advanced by the appellant.
[18] For the reasons that follow, we are of the view that the appeal should be allowed in part and the matter remitted for further determination.
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read State of South Australia v Smith and more:
The matter before the court involved a dispute over the burial of Raymond William Boland, who died intestate in Ceduna on 3 December 2013. The Minister for the Department of Communities and Social Inclusion sought orders to resolve the conflict between the deceased's putative domestic partner, Melissa Smith, and his son, Peter Wilton, regarding the appropriate location for his burial. Melissa Smith argued for a burial in Coober Pedy, in accordance with traditional beliefs, while Peter Wilton preferred a burial at Port Augusta, where other family members, including his deceased son Alvin, were interred. The court had to determine the relevant considerations for deciding the place of burial, with the body currently in the custody of an undertaker awaiting the court's decision.
The court had to decide the legal issues surrounding the determination of the place of burial, particularly in the context of Aboriginal cultural practices and the statutory obligations of the Department. The court considered the evidence presented by both parties and the submissions made by counsel. The key legal issues were the weight to be given to the cultural and spiritual factors, the wishes of the deceased's children, and the practical considerations in resolving the dispute. The court had to balance these factors while ensuring the dignity of the deceased and the integrity of the Department's processes.
The court's reasoning involved a comprehensive analysis of the evidence and the relevant legal principles. The court considered the deceased's lifestyle, relationship, and practices, as well as the wishes of the deceased's children and extended family. The court concluded that the interests of the deceased's children should be given greater weight than those of the extended family. The court also found that the burial place of the deceased would be significant to the second defendant and his siblings for many years to come. The court determined that the wishes of the second defendant should be preferred over those of the Coober Pedy extended family, and that there was no clear and strong cultural imperative that would override this consideration.
The court ordered that the deceased be buried in Port Augusta, subject to contractual rights and obligations, and that the undertaker act upon the Department's directions. The court also ordered that at least three days' notice of the funeral be given in local papers and to the solicitors for the first defendant, providing sufficient detail of the funeral arrangements. The court did not order any costs for the proceedings. The court will hear further submissions from the parties regarding any other orders that may need to be made and steps to delay the funeral to allow the first defendant to consider these reasons and, if advised, lodge an appeal.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
The Department, in endeavouring to carry out its administrative functions in accordance with its statutory obligations, found itself in receipt of conflicting requests for assistance pursuant to the funeral assistance program. It was faced with circumstances where: family conflict could not be resolved by the Department; it was essential that arrangements for the burial of the deceased be resolved with as much haste as decently could be managed; the dignity of the deceased and of all interested family members was of paramount concern; the integrity of the Department’s processes needed to be protected and preserved and where it would seem that neither of the protagonists had the wherewithal, financial or otherwise, to take the necessary steps to bring this matter before the Court in a timely manner. In these circumstances, I am satisfied that the State, through the Department, has standing to bring this application. Factual background The deceased was born, in Port Augusta on 4 October 1975, of Aboriginal descent. He was brought up in Coober Pedy and the surrounding lands. It is common ground that, as an adult, he pursued an itinerant lifestyle. He regularly travelled between Coober Pedy, Port Augusta, and Ceduna. He remained in each location for up to two or three months at a time staying with and visiting family. The deceased died on 3 December 2013 in Ceduna. He was with the first defendant at the time. The first defendant, Melissa Smith, is the putative domestic partner of the deceased. They first met in Coober Pedy in 1999 shortly after which they commenced a relationship. They have one child together, Norman Boland, who is seven years old. The first defendant and Norman have lived in Ceduna for all of Norman’s life. The first defendant maintains that her relationship with the deceased as domestic partners endured until his death. However, members of the second defendant’s Port Augusta family do not accept this. The second defendant, Peter Wilton, at 17, is the oldest of three children of the deceased and another former partner, Katrina Wilton. One of those siblings, Alvin Wilton, is deceased and is buried in Port Augusta. The second defendant lives and has been brought up in Port Augusta. As already mentioned, two separate applications for funeral assistance have been made. The Department has agreed to arrange and pay for the costs of a funeral subject to the dispute over the place of burial being resolved. Whilst the applications for funeral assistance were made by or on behalf of the first and second defendants respectively there is a sense in which each represents the interest of a wider group of family members of the deceased, one in Coober Pedy and one in Port Augusta. It also seems to have been the case that each defendant has been under significant pressure from members of their respective communities to ensure that the deceased is buried appropriately, particularly given the importance placed on the final resting place of the deceased in Aboriginal culture. This much has been made clear by what transpired in the weeks following the making of the two applications.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
The authorities decided in this State, considered to this point, suggest that no standard approach or hard and fast rule can be formulated and applied when determining a burial dispute of this nature. The proper approach, ultimately, requires a balancing of common law principles and practical considerations, as well as attention to any cultural, spiritual and religious factors that are of importance. Further, it is the unique factual context of the dispute itself which will determine the weight which particular factors should be accorded. This was the approach applied, more recently, by this Court in Minister for Families and Communities v Brown & Ors.[29]In that matter, Gray J considered not only which party had a stronger claim under common law, but also the “lifestyle, relationship and practices of the deceased”,[30] in reaching a conclusion as to burial rights. [29] [2009] SASC 86.[30] [2009] SASC 86 at [31]. The evidence The evidence received by the Court was by way of affidavit only. There was no cross-examination of any of the deponents. The plaintiff read the following affidavits:(i)affidavit of Christine Anne Moore (Manager, Concessions and Support Services, Department for Communities and Social Inclusion) sworn 21 March 2014;(ii)second affidavit of Christine Anne Moore sworn 17 April 2014; and(iii)third affidavit of Christine Anne Moore sworn 15 May 2014. The following affidavits were read in the first defendant’s case:(i)affidavit of Melissa Gail Smith (first defendant) affirmed 14 May 2014;(ii)affidavit of Lulu Renee Boland (maternal aunt of the deceased) affirmed 1 May 2014;(iii)affidavit of Jennifer O’toole (maternal aunt of the deceased) affirmed 1 May 2014; and(iv)affidavit of Julie O’toole (maternal aunt of the deceased) affirmed 1 May 2014. The following affidavits were read in the second defendant’s case:(i)affidavit of Peter Wilton (second defendant) affirmed 27 April 2014;(ii)affidavit of Katrina Marissa Wilton (mother of the first defendant) affirmed 9 May 2014;(iii)affidavit of Bevan Wilton (maternal grandfather of the second defendant) affirmed 9 May 2014; and(iv)affidavit of Leanne Wilton (maternal step-grandmother of the second defendant) affirmed 9 May 2014. The Court also had available to it, in addition to the oral submissions made by counsel for each of the three parties, written submissions filed on behalf of each of the three parties. Three close family members of the deceased did not provide an affidavit setting out their wishes (if any) or their understanding (if any) of the deceased’s wishes: the deceased’s father, Mr Simon Boland, who is alive and living in Coober Pedy; the deceased’s youngest living son, Norman, who is seven years old and lives in Ceduna with his mother the first defendant (although, I am content to infer that Norman’s position is aligned with that of the first defendant); and the deceased’s daughter, Victoria, who is a minor and the younger sister of the second defendant (although again, I am prepared to infer that her position is aligned with that of the second defendant and their mother, Katrina Wilton).
Decision
Reasons for decision
NICHOLSON J
Ultimately, in my view, the interests of the deceased’s children should be accorded a greater weight than the interests of the Coober Pedy extended family even those of the maternal aunties. The nature and closeness of the respective relationships (children as against extended family) supports this. In addition, and in the ordinary course of events, it is to be expected that the burial place of the deceased will be of significance to the second defendant and his siblings for many years and for much longer than it will be of significance to the deceased’s very elderly grandparents and his maternal aunties in Coober Pedy.Conclusion None of the matters I have discussed point clearly and decisively in the one direction. However, given the limited weight that I am able to give to the first three of the four main considerations discussed above, it seems to me that the fourth factor does assume the greatest significance. In my view, the wishes of the second defendant should be preferred over those of the Coober Pedy extended family. I have weighed in the balance, as best I can, all of the evidence before me and have reduced it to the four main considerations addressed above to which I have paid particular attention. In my view, the Court should take an approach that best serves the interests of all three surviving children and in the knowledge that the deceased’s young son, Alvin, is buried in Port Augusta. I am satisfied that it cannot be said that this is necessarily inconsistent with the wishes of the deceased, nor that there is a contrary cultural imperative so clear and so strong that it should overwhelm this consideration. Subject to hearing from the parties as to their form, I propose to make the following orders and declaration.(i)The place of burial for the deceased, Raymond William Boland, who is reported to have died on 3 December 2013 is to be Port Augusta.(ii)Subject to any contractual rights and obligations enjoyed and to be observed by the undertaker, Fulham Funerals SA Pty Ltd and the Department of Communities and Social Inclusion, the Department is to request the undertaker to bury the deceased in a manner that observes, insofar as is practicable, the wishes of the second defendant, Peter Boland-Wilton. (iii)I declare that the undertaker is, subject to orders (i) and (ii) above, entitled to receive and to act upon the directions of the Department with respect to a burial of the deceased.(iv)At least three days notice of the funeral is to be given in the Advertiser, a local paper servicing Port Augusta, a local paper servicing Coober Pedy and to the solicitors for the first defendant providing sufficient detail of the funeral arrangements so that family members might be able to attend.(v)There is no order as to the costs of these proceedings. I will hear the parties further as to any other orders that may need to be made. I will also hear the parties further as to what steps might be put in place, if any, to delay the funeral so as to enable a short period of time within which the first defendant can consider these reasons and, if so advised, lodge an appeal.