ESTATE OF RICHARD BARNEY JONES DECEASED
PADDY JONES v LAUREL MARIE DODD
Civil
Debelle J
This is an unfortunate dispute as to the place where a deceased person is to be buried. The right to the possession of a dead body for burial is a justiciable issue: Calma v Sesar (1992) 2 NTLR 237, and Burnes v Richards (unreported, Supreme Court of New South Wales, Cohen J, 6 October 1993).
The plaintiff is the father of the deceased. He wishes to have his son buried in Oodnadatta. In these reasons I refer throughout to the deceased as “the deceased” lest I offend by naming him. I take that precaution even though he may not be a traditional Aboriginal.
The first defendant Ms Dodd is a woman with whom the deceased had lived in a de facto relationship for a period of about five years. That relationship came to an end about ten years ago. She lives with two children of that relationship in Port Augusta. She seeks to have the deceased buried in Port Augusta. She had retained the second defendant, an undertaker, to make the funeral arrangements. The second defendant has not been served and has taken no part in these proceedings. It is common ground, however, that he has agreed to abide the order of the court.
The relief initially sought by the plaintiff was for an order restraining Ms Dodd from proceeding with the funeral arrangements she had made for the burial of the deceased at Port Augusta on 8 July 1998. The parties have agreed that, although there is no claim by the plaintiff for the right to bury the body of the deceased or a cross-application to that effect by Ms Dodd, that is the question which the court should determine. It is common ground that I am to decide that issue regardless of the state of the pleadings or formal applications.
The deceased is of Aboriginal descent. He died on 24 June 1998. It is common ground that he died at or near Walatina Station which is near Marla. His body is at present held by the Coroner. The reason for that has not been proved. However, it appears that there will be no difficulty in the Coroner releasing the body for burial.
It appears that the deceased has lived for the greater part of his life either at Oodnadatta or in areas in the north of South Australia near Oodnadatta. It is also clear that he has spent some of his life in Port Augusta. It appears that he lived in Port Augusta for some years with Ms Dodd. The precise period is not clear but it would appear on the affidavit evidence to be a period of less than five years. The deceased also visited Port Augusta from time to time. In recent years he has gone to Pt Augusta on at least three or four occasions in each year for the purpose of seeing his two children.
The deceased has…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read JONES v DODD No. SCGRG-98-896 Judgment No. S6769 and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1998] SASC 6769
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court examined the relevant legal principles, including the lack of a general right of property in a deceased person's body and the general rule that the executors or administrators of the estate have the right to the body. In the absence of an executor or administrator, the court determined that the next of kin, in order of their relationship to the deceased, have the right to burial. As the deceased's children were not of full age, the father, as the next in the degrees of kinship, had the right to the body for the purpose of conducting the burial. The court also considered the relevance of Aboriginal customary law, which emphasised the importance of burying the deceased in their geographical area to allow their spirit to return in the form of their totem.
The court ultimately decided in favour of the father, granting him the right to bury the deceased at Oodnadatta. The court acknowledged the emotional conflict between the parties but emphasised the need to resort to legal principles to resolve the issue. The court ordered that the father must provide at least three days' notice of the funeral and publish the funeral arrangements in "The Advertiser" to allow those who wish to attend from Port Augusta to do so. The court also noted that no order would be made as to costs, in light of the parties' agreement on this matter.
The final orders were as follows: The plaintiff, Paddy Jones, shall be entitled to the body of the deceased for the purpose of making the burial arrangements. The plaintiff is at liberty to bury the deceased at the cemetery at Oodnadatta. The plaintiff shall cause notice of the funeral arrangements to be published in "The Advertiser" so that there is not less than three days notice of the funeral. No order as to costs.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Full text does not contain this section.