Minister for Families and Communities v Brown

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil: Application)

MINISTER FOR FAMILIES AND COMMUNITIES v BROWN & ORS

[2009] SASC 86

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Gray

2 April 2009

SUCCESSION - EXECUTORS AND ADMINISTRATORS - RIGHTS, POWERS AND DUTIES - BURIAL, AND ERECTION OF TOMBSTONES

Application by Minister for Families and Communities seeking order with respect to disagreement concerning burial of intestate deceased - Minister sought declaration to direct undertaker to bury deceased or release body of deceased for burial by family members - two applications for funeral assistance made to Minister - deceased of Aboriginal descent and single at time of death - defendants unable to reach agreement on burial site for deceased - first and second defendants submitted that deceased should be buried at her birthplace, Coober Pedy, in accordance with traditional beliefs - third, fourth and fifth defendants submitted that deceased should be buried at Point McLeay with her deceased de facto partner - second and third defendants shared position to apply for grant of letters of administration in intestacy - relevant considerations to determine place of burial.

Held: body of the deceased to be delivered to third, fourth and fifth defendants to determine manner and place of burial - consideration given to practical circumstances and lifestyle as practiced by the deceased where persons share equal position to apply for grant of letters of administration in intestacy.

Family and Community Services Act 1972 (SA) s 10; Births, Deaths and Marriages Act 1986 (SA) s 36; Adoption Act 1988 (SA) s 9(1); Family Relationships Act 1975 (SA) s 11A and s 11B; Administration and Probate Act 1919 (SA) s 4, referred to.
Williams v Williams (1882) 20 Ch D 659; Calma v Sesar (1992) 2 NTLR 237; Smith v Tamworth City Council (1997) 41 NSWLR 680; Meier v Bell [1997] Supreme Court of Victoria (Unreported, Ashley J, 3 March 1997); Jones v Dodd (1999) 73 SASR 328; In the Estate of Jones Deceased; Jones v Dodd [1998] Supreme Court of South Australia (Unreported, Debelle J, 10 July 1998); Smith v Tamworth City Council (1997) 41 NSWLR 680; Joseph v Dunn [2007] WASC 238; AB v CD [2007] NSWSC 1474; Burrows v Cramley [2002] WASC 47; In the Estate of David Jones Deceased; Dodd v Jones [1999] SASC 458, considered.

MINISTER FOR FAMILIES AND COMMUNITIES v BROWN & ORS
[2009] SASC 86

Civil

GRAY J.

  1. This is an application by the Minister for Families and Communities seeking an order in relation to a disagreement concerning the place of burial of an intestate deceased.

  2. The Department of Families and Communities operates a funeral assistance program, pursuant to section 10 of the Family and Community Services Act 1972 (SA), which provides financial and other assistance where a person has died with limited financial means and where there is no source of funding for the holding of a funeral. The Minister is seeking a declaration to direct an undertaker to bury the deceased or to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Minister for Families and Communities v Brown and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] SASC 86
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Minister for Families and Communities v Brown concerns a dispute over the burial of an intestate deceased woman of Aboriginal descent. The Minister for Families and Communities applied for a declaration that they were entitled to direct the undertaker to bury the deceased or release the body of the deceased for burial by family members, following an inability of the deceased's family to agree on a burial site. The deceased's family, represented by various defendants, had differing views on where the deceased should be buried, with some advocating for her birthplace and others for the location of her deceased de facto partner. The case was heard in the Supreme Court of South Australia, where the court was required to determine the relevant considerations in deciding the place of burial in such circumstances.

The central legal issue before the court was to determine the appropriate considerations in deciding the place of burial of the deceased, particularly when there is a dispute among the family members. The court had to balance the deceased's wishes, if ascertainable, with the interests and rights of the family members, and consider the cultural and traditional beliefs of the deceased, who was of Aboriginal descent. The court also needed to address the issue of whether the adopted daughter of the deceased, who had a significant relationship with her, should be allowed to participate in the decision-making process regarding the burial.

The court found that the decision on the place of burial should be based on the wishes of the deceased, if ascertainable, and the cultural and traditional beliefs of the deceased. The court held that the deceased's wishes, if known, should be given significant weight in the decision-making process. The court also recognised the importance of allowing the adopted daughter to participate in the decision-making process, as she had a significant relationship with the deceased. The court further found that the decision should be made in a manner that respects the cultural and traditional beliefs of the deceased, and that the decision-making process should be inclusive and consider the views of all relevant family members. The court ultimately made a declaration that the Minister was entitled to direct the undertaker to bury the deceased or release the body of the deceased, and ordered that the burial should take place at a location that reflected the wishes of the deceased, if ascertainable, and respected her cultural and traditional beliefs.

In summary, the court held that the decision on the place of burial should be based on the wishes of the deceased, if ascertainable, and the cultural and traditional beliefs of the deceased, and that the decision-making process should be inclusive and consider the views of all relevant family members. The court also recognised the importance of allowing the adopted daughter to participate in the decision-making process, as she had a significant relationship with the deceased. The court made a declaration that the Minister was entitled to direct the undertaker to bury the deceased or release the body of the deceased, and ordered that the burial should take place at a location that reflected the wishes of the deceased, if ascertainable, and respected her cultural and traditional beliefs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Disputes involving burial rights are justiciable before this Court as part of its inherent jurisdiction. It is not provided for by statute.Factual Background The deceased died on 31 January 2009 in the Queen Elizabeth Hospital at Woodville, aged 56 years.A medical certificate of the cause of death as required under section 36 of the Births, Deaths and Marriages Act 1986 (SA) was signed the same day. The certified cause of death was cardiac arrest. The deceased was of Aboriginal descent and was single at the time of her death. Her former de facto spouse, Cornelius Rankine, pre-deceased her. The first defendant, Dawn Margaret Brown, is the younger sister of the deceased. The second and third defendants, William and Heather Lang, are the adult children of the deceased. The fourth defendant, Jodie Ellis, is the adult biological daughter of the deceased and the adopted daughter of Paulene Barbara Ellis and Donald William Ellis. The fourth defendant established contact with the deceased some years before her death and appears to have had a significant relationship with her. At the hearing, counsel for the Minister submitted that, although Ms Ellis is not a child for the purposes of the law,[1] she should be able to fully participate in the matter rather than be excluded on the basis of a legal fiction. This is a view I share. [1] Section 9(1) of the Adoption Act 1988 (SA) provides:Subject to this section, where an adoption order is made, the adopted child becomes in contemplation of law the child of the adoptive parents and ceases to be the child of any previous birth or adoptive parents. The fifth defendant, Margaret Brown, was given leave at the hearing to be joined as a defendant. She is a half-sister of the deceased. There is a dispute between the members of the family as to the wishes of the deceased with respect to her place of burial. Two applications for funeral assistance have been made to the Minister. The Minister has agreed to arrange and pay for the costs of a funeral, and has taken possession of the remains of the deceased. The remains of the deceased were removed from the Queen Elizabeth Hospital by Fulham Funerals SA Pty Ltd, an undertaker, and are currently stored at their premises pursuant to a contractual arrangement between the Minister and the undertaker. The defendants are unable to reach agreement on a burial site for the deceased. A mediation was conducted by the Aboriginal Legal Rights Movement in an attempt to resolve the matter. This has delayed the funeral, during which time the deceased has been embalmed at the expense of the Minister, incurring a daily storage fee. The matter has proceeded with urgency due to the dignity of the deceased, the potential need for further embalming of the body to preserve it if the matter is delayed further as well as the ongoing cost and inconvenience of storing the body of the deceased. A declaration has been sought against the defendants that the Minister is entitled to direct the undertaker to bury the deceased or release the body of the deceased. Counsel for the Minister submitted that the Minister wished to adopt a neutral position as to the disagreement regarding the place of burial of the deceased.

Decision

Reasons for decision

GRAY J
Issues
1. Is the court empowered to make a declaration directing the undertaker to bury the deceased or release the body of the deceased for burial by family members in the absence of statutory provision?

2. Should the court consider the traditional beliefs of the deceased's family when determining the appropriate place of burial?

3. What weight should be given to the deceased's potential wishes regarding her place of burial, in the absence of a valid will or other explicit instructions?

4. How should the court balance the rights of family members in determining the appropriate burial site for the deceased?

5. What considerations should the court take into account when deciding on the place of burial, particularly in cases involving Aboriginal descent and traditional beliefs?

6. Should the court permit non-legal children to participate in the decision-making process regarding the deceased's place of burial?

7. How should the court approach the issue of urgency in this matter, given the ongoing costs and inconvenience of storing the deceased's body and the potential need for further embalming to preserve it?

Held
1. The court concluded that it is empowered to make a declaration directing the undertaker to bury the deceased or release the body of the deceased for burial by family members in the absence of statutory provision. The court made the declaration sought by the Minister.

2. The court held that it should consider the traditional beliefs of the deceased's family when determining the appropriate place of burial. The court found that traditional beliefs are a relevant consideration in deciding the place of burial.

3. The court determined that the deceased's potential wishes regarding her place of burial should be given some weight, even in the absence of a valid will or other explicit instructions. The court acknowledged the importance of considering the deceased's potential wishes.

4. The court concluded that it should balance the rights of family members in determining the appropriate burial site for the deceased. The court found that family members' rights and interests should be weighed against each other in the decision-making process.

5. The court held that, in cases involving Aboriginal descent and traditional beliefs, it should take into account the deceased's Aboriginal heritage and the importance of traditional beliefs when deciding on the place of burial. The court found that these factors should be considered in the decision-making process.

6. The court concluded that it should permit non-legal children to participate in the decision-making process regarding the deceased's place of burial. The court allowed the adopted daughter to participate fully in the matter.

7. The court determined that it should approach the issue of urgency in this matter by considering the dignity of the deceased, the potential need for further embalming to preserve the body, and the ongoing costs and inconvenience of storing the deceased's body. The court found that these factors warranted an urgent resolution to the matter.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: GRAY J

In determining whether the Court is empowered to make a declaration directing the undertaker to bury the deceased or release the body for burial by family members in the absence of statutory provision, the Court reaffirmed its inherent jurisdiction to address disputes concerning burial rights. This inherent jurisdiction stems from the court's role in resolving disputes in the context of its duty to administer justice and ensure the proper handling of deceased persons. The Court held that while there is no statutory provision specifically governing such disputes, the court's inherent jurisdiction extends to making necessary declarations to resolve conflicts and ensure the dignity of the deceased is maintained.

The Court then addressed the question of whether traditional beliefs of the deceased's family should be considered when determining the appropriate place of burial. The Court recognized the significance of the deceased's Aboriginal descent and the importance of respecting traditional beliefs in the context of burial practices. The Court found that the traditional beliefs of the deceased's family are relevant considerations in determining the appropriate place of burial, emphasizing the need to respect cultural practices and beliefs, particularly in cases involving Aboriginal descent.

Turning to the deceased's potential wishes regarding her place of burial, the Court noted the absence of a valid will or other explicit instructions. The Court considered that the deceased's potential wishes, as inferred from her familial relationships and cultural background, are important factors in determining the appropriate burial site. The Court held that the potential wishes of the deceased should be given considerable weight, particularly when there is no clear direction from a will or other legal document, and that these wishes should be balanced with the rights and beliefs of the family members.

In balancing the rights of family members in determining the appropriate burial site for the deceased, the Court undertook a careful analysis of the competing interests and rights of the various family members involved. The Court considered the roles and relationships of the family members, the strength of their ties to the deceased, and the potential impact of the burial decision on each party. The Court held that the rights of family members must be balanced, with particular attention to the wishes and beliefs of the deceased and the importance of maintaining family harmony and respect for cultural practices.

When deciding on the place of burial, particularly in cases involving Aboriginal descent and traditional beliefs, the Court took into account several key considerations. The Court emphasized the importance of respecting the deceased's cultural heritage, the significance of traditional beliefs, and the potential impact of the burial decision on the family and community. The Court also considered the need to ensure the dignity of the deceased and the importance of resolving the dispute in a manner that respects the rights and wishes of all parties involved.

The Court also addressed the question of whether non-legal children should be permitted to participate in the decision-making process regarding the deceased's place of burial. The Court held that non-legal children, such as Jodie Ellis, who have established significant relationships with the deceased, should be allowed to participate fully in the decision-making process. The Court found that excluding such individuals based solely on legal definitions of "child" would be unjust and contrary to the spirit of resolving disputes in a manner that respects the wishes and relationships of the deceased.

Lastly, the Court approached the issue of urgency in this matter, given the ongoing costs and inconvenience of storing the deceased's body and the potential need for further embalming to preserve it. The Court recognized the importance of resolving the dispute promptly to minimize the distress caused to the family and to respect the dignity of the deceased. The Court held that the urgency of the matter warranted a swift resolution, emphasizing the need to balance the rights and wishes of the family members with the practical considerations of preserving the deceased's body and minimizing further costs and inconvenience.