HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Dixon C.J., McTiernan, Fullagar, Menzies and Windeyer JJ.
CLYNE v. N.S.W. BAR ASSOCIATION
1 July 1960
Legal Practitioners—High Court
Legal Practitioners—Barristers—Striking off roll—Grave professional misconduct—Instigation of baseless prosecution—Devised to intimidate solicitor—Extravagant attack in opening proceedings upon professional character and reputation of solicitor—No evidence to support allegations. Legal Practitioners—Solicitor—Conduct of case for client without means—Maintenance—Whether maintenance now a crime. High Court—Appeal as of right—Appeal from order striking name of barrister from rolls—Special leave necessary—Judiciary Act 1903-1959 (Cth), s. 35 (1) (a) (1) (2), (1) (b).
Decision
July 1.
THE COURT delivered the following written judgment:-
This is an appeal from an order of the Full Court of the Supreme Court of New South Wales. That order is that the name of the appellant be struck off the roll of barristers of the State of New South Wales on the ground that he has been guilty of such grave professional misconduct as shows him not to be a fit and proper person to practise as a barrister. The charges made against him arose out of four prosecutions for indictable offences and the conduct of these by the appellant at the preliminary hearing before a magistrate. These prosecutions were, on the advice of the appellant, launched by a client of his against a solicitor, and were admittedly devised as a means of intimidating that solicitor into ceasing to act for a certain lady in certain civil proceedings pending between her and that client. In opening the proceedings before the magistrate the appellant deliberately used the occasion to make a savage public attack on the professional character of that solicitor. He made that attack in extravagant terms, alleging fraud, perjury and blackmail. He knew that he had no evidence to substantiate such allegations. At the end of his opening he invited the man whom he was prosecuting for a crime to defend himself before any evidence had been given against him, and intimated that, if he were to cease to act for his client, the criminal proceedings would have achieved their object and could be discontinued. It is necessary, of course, that we should explain our view in some detail, but we may say at once that we are of opinion that the Supreme Court was entirely right in the conclusion which it reached. (at p188)
2. With regard to the jurisdiction of the Supreme Court, it is sufficient to refer to Ziems v. The Prothonotary of the Supreme Court of N.S.W. (1957) 97 CLR 279, at pp 290, 291 . The words "fit and proper person" are the words used in the Charter of Justice of 1823, which issued under the authority of the Imperial statute 4 Geo. IV, c. 96, and by which the present Supreme Court of New South Wales was constituted. Clause 10 of the Charter provided for the admission of persons to practise in the Court. It empowered the Court to approve, admit and enrol persons who had been…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Clyne v New South Wales Bar Association and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1960] HCA 40
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issue before the High Court was whether the Bar Association had acted within its powers in finding Mr. Clyne guilty of professional misconduct and, consequently, whether it was justified in refusing to admit him to practice. This involved an examination of the relevant provisions of the Legal Practitioners Act 1963 (NSW) and the principles governing the admission and disciplinary proceedings of barristers.
The Court analysed the evidence presented to the Bar Association and concluded that the findings of misconduct were well-founded. It applied the principle that a barrister must possess not only legal knowledge but also a high degree of probity and character. The Court held that the Bar Association was entitled to consider the applicant's past conduct when determining his fitness to practice, and that the findings of dishonesty and lack of candour were sufficient grounds to refuse admission.
The appeal was dismissed, and the decision of the New South Wales Bar Association was upheld.
Background
Background to the litigation
This is an appeal from an order of the Full Court of the Supreme Court of New South Wales, which struck off the name of the appellant, a barrister, from the roll of barristers on the ground that he had been guilty of grave professional misconduct. The Supreme Court held that the appellant was not a fit and proper person to practise as a barrister. The appeal was brought as of right, but the High Court held that an appeal as of right did not lie and the appeal was brought under special leave. The key procedural steps involved the appellant instituting baseless prosecutions against a solicitor acting for the appellant's client's estranged wife, with the aim of intimidating the solicitor into ceasing to act for her. The appellant made serious and unfounded allegations against the solicitor in opening the case before the magistrate, without any evidence to support them. The Supreme Court found this conduct to be a gross abuse of the appellant's position as a barrister and a breach of fundamental rules governing the conduct of members of the legal profession. The High Court upheld the Supreme Court's decision, dismissing the appeal.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Is the appellant guilty of such grave professional misconduct as shows him not to be a fit and proper person to practise as a barrister?
2. Did the appellant abuse his position as a barrister in making baseless and defamatory allegations against another solicitor?
3. Is it appropriate for a solicitor to maintain litigation for a client without means, and under what conditions?
4. Does maintenance, as a crime at common law, still apply to solicitors conducting litigation for their clients?
5. Does the appellant have the right to appeal to the High Court as of right, or should special leave be granted?
Held
1. The appellant is guilty of such grave professional misconduct as shows him not to be a fit and proper person to practise as a barrister. Result: Appeal dismissed.
2. The appellant abused his position as a barrister by making baseless and defamatory allegations against another solicitor. Result: Appeal dismissed.
3. It is appropriate for a solicitor to maintain litigation for a client without means, subject to the conditions that the solicitor has considered the case and believes that the client has a reasonable cause of action or defence, and that the solicitor must not bargain for an interest in the subject-matter of litigation or for remuneration proportionate to the amount which may be recovered.
4. Maintenance, as a crime at common law, does not apply to solicitors conducting litigation for their clients, provided the conditions mentioned in issue 3 are met.
5. The appellant does not have the right to appeal to the High Court as of right; however, special leave should be granted. Result: Special leave granted.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The High Court upheld the decision of the Supreme Court of New South Wales to strike the appellant off the roll of barristers, finding that his conduct demonstrated grave professional misconduct and showed him not to be a fit and proper person to practise as a barrister. The appellant had initiated baseless prosecutions against another solicitor with the intent to intimidate him into ceasing to act for a client. In doing so, he made defamatory and unsupported allegations against the solicitor during the preliminary hearing, without any intention of substantiating them with evidence. The court emphasized the importance of maintaining high ethical standards within the legal profession and the need to protect the public and the integrity of the legal system from unscrupulous conduct.
The court held that the appellant abused his position as a barrister by using his influence to attack the professional character of another solicitor in an attempt to achieve a personal objective. The baseless and defamatory allegations made by the appellant were not supported by any evidence and were made with reckless disregard for the truth. The court found this conduct to be a clear abuse of the appellant's position and a violation of the fundamental rules governing the conduct of members of the legal profession.
Regarding the maintenance issue, the court clarified that a solicitor may act for a client without means and expend their own money in payment of counsel's fees and other litigation costs, provided that they have honestly investigated the case and believe their client has a reasonable cause of action or defense. The solicitor must not, however, bargain with their client for an interest in the subject matter of litigation or for remuneration proportionate to the amount that may be recovered.
Lastly, the court determined that the appeal did not lie as of right, as the order of the Supreme Court did not involve a sum or matter at issue amounting to or of the value of 1500 pounds. However, special leave to appeal was granted due to the importance of the issues raised by the case for the legal profession and the public. The appeal was ultimately dismissed, affirming the decision to strike the appellant off the roll of barristers.