Background
Background to the litigation
The agreed facts are – and we make findings of fact in relation to conduct – as follows:[16][16] Exhibit 2 (deidentified) (original emphasis).1.The practitioner was admitted to legal practice in Western Australia on 4 September 2001 and at all material times the practitioner was an Australian legal practitioner within the meaning of [s] 5(a) of the [LP Act].2.Between 1 October 2002 and 31 June 2016 the practitioner practised as a sole practitioner in Perth under the trading name Tang Legal (firm) and from 1 July 2016 has practised under the trading name Tang Law. 3.On 3 October 2013 Mr S and Mr M (Mr S's migration agent) signed a costs agreement for the provision of legal services by the firm. 4.Also on 3 October 2013, TFC was registered by ASIC and Mr S and Mr M were the directors of, and Mr S the sole shareholder in, TFC.5.On 4 October 2013 Mr S and TFC (as "Owner") entered into a project management agreement (PMA) with a company (Trustee) as trustee for the F Trust (as "Manager"). By the terms of the PMA, F Trust provided project management services for the development of land owned by Mr S and TFC (Development).6.The practitioner's father (father) was the director, secretary and held half of the shares in the Trustee. The other half of the shares in the Trustee were held by the practitioner's mother.7.At all material times the practitioner had the day to day management of the affairs of F Trust. 8.The practitioner had a series of retainers with TFC and Mr S for the provision of legal services, relevantly:8.1with Mr S and Mr M dated 4 October 2013 for incorporation of a new company, which was TFC;8.2with Mr S and Mr M dated 4 October 2013 for settlement in relation to the purchase of the Property;8.3with TFC dated 30 January 2014 for the provision of commercial law advice and to draft and prepare employment agreements; and8.4with TFC dated 7 February 2014 for drafting and preparing off-the-plan contracts, application for strata titles and settlement in respect to the Property.9.By a written contract dated 5 February 2015 (Contract) and on the recommendation of the practitioner, TFC engaged Mr B, trading as 5R[,] to provide consulting engineering services in relation to the Development for a fixed fee of $50,000 plus GST, half of which was due and payable at the time the Contract was entered into and the other half due and payable once Development Approval for the Development had been obtained from the local authority. 10.The practitioner had acted on behalf of TFC in negotiating the terms of the Contract including Mr B's fee thereunder.11.Mr B had been introduced to the practitioner through a mutual friend and business associate, Mr K, in or about 2013. 12.The Development was the first time that either the practitioner, F Trust, TFC or Mr S had worked with Mr B.13.The practitioner undertook all communications and correspondence with Mr B in relation to the Contract and the Development on behalf of TFC and F Trust.14.Paragraphs 1 to 7 of the [asserted facts, reproduced at [16] below,] are relevant here. The terms as defined in the asserted facts are used below.15.At all relevant times, the practitioner owed fiduciary obligations to TFC in respect of the Development, which obligations arose from the practitioner's role in F Trust and F Trust's relationship with TFC.16.In early April 2016 Mr B contacted the [Committee] about the practitioner including, relevantly, in respect to the Cash Payment.17.By letter dated 30 September 2016 the Committee wrote to the practitioner, relevantly, in respect of the Cash Payment and enclosing a copy of the Acknowledgement of Receipt, and requested the practitioner's explanation as to the circumstances in which Ms K signed the Acknowledgement of Receipt for the $12,500 [C]ash [P]ayment and whether the Cash Payment was in fact received by the firm and, if so, to explain into which account the sum was deposited and against which matter it was credited.18.On 1 November 2016 the practitioner provided a response to the Committee's 30 September 2016 letter in which he stated: 18.1"I confirm that both myself and Tang Law did not receive the "kickback" referred to by [Mr B]"; and 18.2that the Acknowledgement of Receipt ["](if it is in fact signed by [Ms K]) would be a personal matter between [Mr B] and [Ms K]".19,The practitioner's statements were:19.1at paragraph 18.1, not candid in respect to the Cash Payment and failed to state the basis on which the practitioner had solicited the Cash Payment and for whom; 19.2at paragraph 18.2, false and misleading as in fact Ms K had received the Cash Payment at the practitioner's direction and at the firm's office and the Cash Payment did not relate to a personal matter between Mr B and Ms K but to the arrangement as to payment of the Cash Payment made between the practitioner and Mr B,and the practitioner well knew the statements lacked candour and were false and misleading and that they had the potential to mislead the Committee and the practitioner intended that the Committee rely on and be misled by the statements and that its investigation into his conduct be obstructed. It was only after the Committee had obtained and put to him for comment the text messages referred to in paragraph 20.2 below that the practitioner changed his position in respect of these statements.20.By letter dated 22 June 2017 the practitioner was:20.1formally notified that Mr B's complaint in respect of the Cash Payment was being investigated;20.2provided with copies of photographs taken by Mr B of the exchange of text messages between the practitioner and Mr B on 3 and 4 March 2015 (text messages);20.3provided with a photograph of Mr B's iPhone showing the mobile phone number for "Kelvin";20.4informed of his right to make submissions to the Committee in respect to the conduct complained of;20.5requested to make submissions to the Committee in respect to the conduct complained of; and20.6reminded of his obligations under [r] 50(2) and [r 50](3) of the [LPCR] to be open and candid in his dealing with the Committee and to provide a full and accurate account of his conduct in relation to the matters covered in the 22 June 2017 letter.21.By letter dated 7 August 2017 in response to the 22 June 2017 letter, the practitioner provided his response to the Committee (7 August 2017 Letter) stating that "With regrets" he admitted: 21.1F Trust "did receive the sum of $12,500 ("Commission") from [Mr B]";21.2he "did assist [F Trust] with communicating with [Mr B] in relation to the accepting and collecting the Commission";21.3the text messages had been sent by the practitioner to Mr B;21.4Mr B had passed the Cash Payment to his firm where it was collected by Ms K; and21.5the receipt of the Cash Payment "was for and on behalf of [F Trust] (not for myself)".22.The practitioner enclosed with his 7 August 2017 Letter a letter from his father, also dated 7 August 2017 and addressed to the Committee (Father's Letter), in which his father stated, relevantly: "[Mr B] agreed to pay my company commission $12,500 and I accept. So I asked Kelvin to tell him to pass money to [Ms K]". 23.By letter dated 8 November 2018 the Committee requested the practitioner provide, relevantly:23.1a full and accurate written account in chronological order of how the practitioner assisted the Trust as trustee for F Trust as stated in his 7 August 2017 Letter;23.2a full and accurate written account of the circumstances surrounding the request for a receipt by Ms K of the Cash Payment from Mr B at the firm's office on 4 May [sic March] 2015, including the practitioner's role in soliciting and receiving the Cash Payment, the instructions he gave Ms K about collecting the Cash Payment and directions as to what do with the cash sum on receipt and what happened to the Cash Payment sum, including whether the practitioner received any part of it and if so, how much and what he did with it;23.3all documents relevant to the circumstances surrounding the request for and receipt by Ms K of the Cash Payment, including copies of any bank records recording any deposit of all or any part of the cash comprising the Cash Payment;23.4all documents relevant to his communications with the directors of TFC about the Cash Payment and to state whether the directors of TFC were aware of his role in respect of the Cash Payment;23.5a full and accurate explanation to the Cash Payment as to why he made the statements in the 1 November 2016 letter in light of the admissions made in the 7 August 2017 Letter.24.On 30 January 2019 the practitioner's senior counsel met with the [a]pplicant and discussed, amongst other things, how the practitioner could cooperate with the [a]pplicant in the resolution of the matters then under investigation.25.On 15 February 2019 the Committee issued to the practitioner a summons to provide written information verified by statutory declaration and to produce documents (Summons) pursuant to [s] 520(1)(a), [s] 520(1)(c) and [s] 520(3) of the LP Act.26.At paragraph 1 in the Summons the practitioner was referred to: 26.1statements he made in his 7 August 2017 Letter in which he said, amongst other things, that "I did assist [F Trust] with communicating with [Mr B] in relation to accepting the Commission"; 26.2statements made in the Father's Letter in which the father said, amongst other things, that "[Mr B] agreed to pay my company commission $12,500 and I accept. So I asked Kelvin to tell him to pass money to [Ms K].";and asked to:a)provide a full and accurate written factual account of how he assisted F Trust in respect of:i)the agreement between the father's company (F Trust) and Mr B (Agreement) referred to in the Father's Letter;ii)a full and accurate written account of the circumstances surrounding the request for a receipt by Ms K of the Cash Payment from Mr B at the firm's office on 4 May [sic March] 2015, including the practitioner's role in soliciting and receiving the Cash Payment, the instructions he gave Ms K about collecting the Cash Payment and directions as to what to do with the cash sum on receipt and what happened to the Cash Payment sum, including whether the practitioner received any part of it and if so, how much and what he did with it;b)produce all documents relevant to the circumstances surrounding the request for and receipt by Ms K of the Cash Payment, including copies of any bank records recording any deposit of all or any part of the cash comprising the Cash Payment;c)produce all documents relevant to his communications with the directors of TFC about the Cash Payment and to state whether the directors of TFC were aware of his role in respect of the Cash Payment;d)provide a full and accurate explanation to the Committee as to why he made the statements in the 1 November 2016 letter in light of the admissions made in the 7 August 2017 Letter.27.By letter dated 4 March 2019 the practitioner provided his response to the Summons which information was not verified by statutory declaration as required by the Summons and in which at paragraph 7, he apologised for his conduct in "asking for the payment of the $12,500 at all".28.By letter dated 25 March 2019 the Committee requested from the practitioner, amongst other things:28.1that his response to the Committee be provided by statutory declaration, as required by the Summons; and28.2a more fulsome response to paragraph 1 of the Summons than that which was provided in his letter of 4 March 2019, in particular in relation to the Agreement, including details of the practitioner's involvement in the Agreement and details of the communications between the practitioner and his father, the practitioner and Mr B and what the practitioner knew about any communications between his father and Mr B.29.On 9 April 2019 the practitioner, under compulsion pursuant to s 520(1) of the LP Act and making objection to answering the questions posed by the Committee on the grounds that his answers may incriminate him within the meaning of [s] 468 and [s] 521(3) of the LP Act, provided to the Committee his statutory declaration made on 9 April 2019, annexed to which and marked "Annexure A" was a letter from the practitioner to the Committee dated 9 April 2019 (Statutory Declaration).30.In the Statutory Declaration the practitioner stated that:30.1he "undertook all communication on behalf of [F Trust] with [Mr B]";30.2"To the best of my knowledge and belief there were no communications at that time (whether relating to the $12,500.00 or otherwise) between [his father] and [Mr B]";30.3"As I previously have said, I sent the text message to [Mr B] with the request for the $12,500";30.4"To the best of my memory, I had discussed the request with [Mr B] before I sent the text message/s. I am unable to say now when those discussions took place and how many there were. I do not recall now the substance of what was discussed between me and [Mr B] before I sent the text message. I do not remember who started the communications between me and [Mr B] as to the payment of the 12,500.00";