DAVIES v Chicago Boot Company Pty Ltd (No 3)

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil: Application)

DAVIES & ANOR v CHICAGO BOOT COMPANY PTY LTD (NO 3)

[2007] SASC 399

Reasons of Judge Lunn a Master of the Supreme Court

14 November 2007

PROCEDURE

Application for leave to file a fresh statement of claim - evidence allowable on such an application - degree of particularity required held governed by significant prejudice to the other party if it was not ordered - inconsistent pleadings - rolled up pleadings of causes of action which were mutually exclusive.

DAVIES & ANOR v CHICAGO BOOT COMPANY PTY LTD (NO 3)
[2007] SASC 399

Reasons on plaintiffs’ application to file a further statement of claim.

  1. JUDGE LUNN: This matter already has a long and complicated history, but it is not necessary to canvass it for the purpose of this application. The plaintiffs are the liquidators of each of Harris Scarfe Limited (“HSL”) and Harris Scarfe Wholesale Pty Ltd (“HSW”). In these consolidated actions the plaintiffs seek to recover under Part 5.7B of the Corporations Law (“the Law”) alleged preferential payments made to the defendant by HSL or HSW.

  2. By a notice for specific directions issued on 13 July 2007 the plaintiffs seek leave to file a second further amended statement of claim (“the SOC”) in a form exhibited to an affidavit of their solicitor (FDN 88B).  This was opposed by the defendant.

  3. All parties have filed a substantial amount of affidavit evidence which is of marginal relevance.  This is a pleadings dispute and not an application for summary judgment by the defendant.  Primarily it is to be dealt with on the face of the SOC: Solowij v Parish of St Michael, Burley M, [2001] SASC 256. If an arguable case is made out on the pleading its resolution should be left to the trial: Woodhead Australia Pty Ltd v The Paspalis Group of Companies (1991) 103 FLR 122, or for a summary judgment application under R 25.04.

    Whether the plaintiffs are pleading a “transaction” for the purpose of s 588FF of the Law.

  4. Paragraphs 9.9 and 21 and 23  of the SOC plead:

    9.9The intention of both HSL and HSW (which intention was formed before 1 July 2000, the specific date of which is not known to the plaintiffs) was that after 1 July 2000 stock obtained from suppliers for sale in the Harris Scarfe business would be purchased by HSL and not HSW.

    …..

    Payment with HSW cheque of HSL Debt

    21In addition to paragraphs 19 and 20, and in the alternative to paragraph 22 of this pleading, if the defendant provided the HSW stock (as defined in paragraph 22 of this pleading) to HSL pursuant to the HSL Contract, then the HSW Transaction was made in error, it being the intention of HSL and HSW (in this instance) that HSL would pay the debt itself and;

    21.1For the reason that HSL’s debt to the defendant was being discharged by HSW, HSL did not make payment of the debt…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read DAVIES v Chicago Boot Company Pty Ltd (No 3) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] SASC 399
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The plaintiffs, liquidators of Harris Scarfe Limited and Harris Scarfe Wholesale Pty Ltd, applied for leave to file a second further amended statement of claim against the defendant, Chicago Boot Company Pty Ltd, seeking to recover preferential payments made to the defendant by Harris Scarfe Limited or Harris Scarfe Wholesale Pty Ltd. The defendant opposed the application, arguing that the proposed statement of claim contained inconsistent, rolled-up, and insufficiently particular pleadings. The Supreme Court of South Australia considered whether the plaintiffs were pleading a "transaction" for the purpose of s 588FF of the Corporations Law, and whether the pleadings contained sufficient particularity as required by the Supreme Court Rules 1987. The court held that while some of the pleadings were permissible, others were impermissible or inadequate, and ordered that the plaintiffs make further amendments to the statement of claim. The court also ordered that separate judgments be sought in respect of the claims for each of Harris Scarfe Limited and Harris Scarfe Wholesale Pty Ltd, and set a hearing date for the parties to discuss further amendments and costs.

The plaintiffs sought leave to file a second further amended statement of claim, which the defendant opposed on various grounds. The court held that the plaintiffs' pleadings were permissible in some respects, such as in alleging that a course of dealings initiated by the debtor company could constitute a "transaction" for the purpose of s 588FF of the Corporations Law, notwithstanding that not all of its component parts considered in isolation could rightly be said individually to be transactions. However, the court found that other pleadings were impermissible or inadequate, such as in alleging that the subjective intentions of Harris Scarfe Limited were relevant to any pleaded cause of action, or in pleading that Harris Scarfe Limited and Harris Scarfe Wholesale Pty Ltd were parties to the relevant transactions for the purpose of s 588FA of the Law. The court ordered that the plaintiffs make further amendments to the statement of claim, and set a hearing date for the parties to discuss further amendments and costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.