SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA
(Civil: Application)
CLONE PTY LTD v PLAYERS PTY LTD (IN LIQUIDATION RECEIVERS APPOINTED) & ORS
[2012] SASC 12
Judgment of The Honourable Justice Kourakis
3 February 2012
PROCEDURE - CONTEMPT, ATTACHMENT AND SEQUESTRATION - CONTEMPT - WHAT CONSTITUTES - BREACH OF UNDERTAKING TO COURT
PROCEDURE - DISCOVERY AND INTERROGATORIES - DISCOVERY AND INSPECTION OF DOCUMENTS - PRODUCTION AND INSPECTION - GROUNDS FOR RESISTING PRODUCTION - CLIENT LEGAL PRIVILEGE
Clone Pty Ltd (Clone) and Players Pty Ltd (in liquidation) (receivers appointed) (Players, collectively the Players Parties) had a dispute over the ownership of various liquor and gaming licences – a trial proceeded before a judge of the Supreme Court who found in favour of Clone – an important factual finding at trial concerned the form of a lease agreement (the Agreement) when it was executed by the principals of Players – orders were made by the trial Judge effecting the transfer of the licences from Players to Clone.
The Players Parties seek to set aside those orders by a new action and an application brought in the concluded action following the finding of additional photocopies of the Agreement after trial – whether other recently-discovered evidence of communications between Clone’s legal representatives was reasonably capable of showing that they had abused trial procedures in order to prevent the Players Parties discovering the Agreement – whether the Players Parties are bound by the rule of preclusion preventing the use of the documents in any proceedings other than the taxation of costs – whether the internal documents evidence communications which are protected by litigation privilege.
Held: Application for permission to use internal documents dismissed – the internal documents are privileged and are covered by the rule of preclusion – there are insufficient grounds to exempt the Players Parties from the rule - the production of documents on a taxation of costs pursuant to the rules of the Court waives litigation privilege in those documents only for the limited purpose of the taxation.
There is no evidence of improper conduct by Clone’s legal representatives and no prima facie case that the privileged communications were made for an improper purpose
Supreme Court of Judicture Act 1873 (UK) s 16; Supreme Court of Judicature Act 1875 (UK); Supreme Court Act 1935 s 6, s 17, s 17(1), s 17(2), s 25, s 40, s 42, s 43, s 50, s 72; Supreme Court Act 1855-6 s 7, s 8, s 18, s 19; The Third Judge and District Court Act 1858 -; The Equity Act 1866 s 9, s 11, s 153; The Fourt Judge Act 1919 -; Supreme Court Act Amendment Act 1865 -; The Court of Appeals Amendment Act 1865 s 2; Supreme Court Act 1867 s 31; Supreme Court Act 1878 s 5, s 7, s 15, s 16, s 17; The Commonwealth of Australia Constitution Act s 73; Supreme Court Procedure Act 1853 s 175, s 176, referred to.
Bright v Eynon (1757) 1 Burr 390; 97…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Clone Pty Ltd v Players Pty Ltd (in Liquidation Receivers Ap... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2012] SASC 12
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court found that the internal documents were privileged and covered by the rule of preclusion. The court held that there were insufficient grounds to exempt Players from the rule. The production of documents on a taxation of costs pursuant to the rules of the court waives litigation privilege in those documents only for the limited purpose of the taxation. The court held that even if there was reason to suspect impropriety, it would not exempt Players from their obligation not to make collateral use of the documents. Allowing Players to prosecute their case on speculation about documents produced by Clone would promote a mischief of a kind the rule of preclusion was designed to suppress.
The court refused the application of Players that they be exempted from their obligation not to make collateral use of the internal documents. The court found that the internal documents were privileged and that they were covered by the rule of preclusion. The application for permission to use the internal documents was dismissed.
Background
Background to the litigation
The Players Parties further contended that the newly discovered evidence raised questions about whether they were bound by the rule of preclusion, which prevents the use of certain documents in proceedings other than the taxation of costs. Specifically, they sought to challenge whether the internal documents of Clone, which they claimed contained protected communications, could be used in their application. This hinged on whether these internal documents evidenced communications protected by litigation privilege. The crux of the matter was thus whether the internal documents were privileged, covered by the rule of preclusion, and whether there were sufficient grounds to exempt the Players Parties from this rule. The Players Parties argued that the internal documents evidenced an improper purpose, while Clone maintained that these documents were privileged and should not be used collaterally.
The court examined the nature of the internal documents and their potential privilege. It found that the documents did indeed contain communications protected by litigation privilege. Furthermore, the court determined that these documents were covered by the rule of preclusion, which prohibits their use in proceedings other than for the taxation of costs. Despite the Players Parties’ assertions that the documents evidenced impropriety, the court found no sufficient grounds to exempt them from the rule of preclusion. It concluded that allowing the use of these documents would promote the very mischief that the rule of preclusion was designed to prevent. Consequently, the application by the Players Parties to use the internal documents was dismissed.
The matter in Clone Pty Ltd v Players Pty Ltd (in Liquidation Receivers Appointed) & Ors originated from a trial in the Supreme Court where Clone successfully claimed ownership of certain liquor and gaming licences against Players, with the trial judge making orders to transfer these licences from Players to Clone. The decision was based on a critical factual finding about the form of a lease agreement executed by the principals of Players. Following the trial, Players sought to set aside the trial court's orders by initiating a new action and an application in the concluded action. The application arose after the discovery of additional photocopies of the Agreement and concerns that Clone's legal representatives may have abused trial procedures to prevent the discovery of the Agreement. Players argued that recently-discovered evidence of communications between Clone's legal representatives could show such abuse. This case proceeded as an interlocutory application in the concluded action, focusing on whether the Players Parties could use the internal documents produced by Clone during the taxation of costs to support their allegations, despite the rule of preclusion and litigation privilege. The application was dismissed as the internal documents were found to be privileged and covered by the rule of preclusion, and there were insufficient grounds to exempt the Players Parties from this rule.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In Clone Pty Ltd v Players Pty Ltd (in Liquidation Receivers Appointed) & Ors, the Court addressed several critical issues regarding the discovery of documents post-trial, the potential breach of an undertaking to the Court, the application of the rule of preclusion, and the protection of litigation privilege. The case arose from a dispute between Clone Pty Ltd and Players Pty Ltd (in liquidation), concerning the ownership of various liquor and gaming licenses. The trial had resulted in a finding in favour of Clone, which included a significant factual finding about the form of a lease agreement executed by the principals of Players. Post-trial, the Players Parties sought to set aside the orders made by the trial judge, citing newly discovered photocopies of the Agreement and additional evidence of communications between Clone’s legal representatives. The court's reasoning on these matters is detailed below.
The first issue considered by the court was whether the newly discovered photocopies of the Agreement constituted a breach of an undertaking given to the Court. The court examined the circumstances under which the undertaking was given and the nature of the documents in question. It found that the discovery of these documents did not constitute a breach of the undertaking. The court reasoned that the undertaking was specific to the discovery process during the trial, and the subsequent discovery of additional documents post-trial did not violate the terms of the undertaking. The court relied on established principles that an undertaking is a commitment to disclose documents at a specific stage of the proceedings, and the discovery of new documents after the proceedings are concluded does not breach such an undertaking.
The second issue involved whether the additional evidence of communications between Clone’s legal representatives was reasonably capable of showing that they had abused trial procedures to prevent the discovery of the Agreement. The court meticulously analyzed the content of the communications and assessed whether there was evidence of an improper purpose or conduct. It concluded that the evidence did not reasonably suggest any abuse of trial procedures. The court applied the principle that a party seeking to set aside trial findings on the basis of alleged procedural abuses bears a heavy burden of proof. The authorities relied upon emphasized the need for clear and compelling evidence of impropriety. The court held that the evidence provided by the Players Parties was speculative and insufficient to establish any abuse of trial procedures.
The third issue was whether the Players Parties were bound by the rule of preclusion, which prevents the use of internal documents in any proceedings other than the taxation of costs. The court examined the scope and application of the rule of preclusion, considering the principle that documents produced during the taxation of costs waive litigation privilege only for the limited purpose of taxation. The court concluded that the Players Parties were indeed bound by the rule of preclusion. It relied on precedents that established the rule's purpose to prevent the misuse of documents produced during court proceedings. The court distinguished the current situation from cases where exceptional circumstances justified exemption from the rule, finding no such circumstances present in this case.
The fourth issue addressed whether the internal documents evidenced communications protected by litigation privilege. The court found that the internal documents did indeed contain communications protected by litigation privilege. It applied the principle that litigation privilege protects confidential communications between a client and their legal representative made for the dominant purpose of obtaining or giving legal advice. The court relied on established authorities that set out the criteria for determining the existence of litigation privilege. It concluded that the documents met the criteria for privilege as they contained privileged communications regarding the legal strategy and advice.
Finally, the court considered whether there were sufficient grounds to exempt the Players Parties from the rule of preclusion if the internal documents were found to be privileged. The court held that there were not sufficient grounds for exemption. It reasoned that even if the documents were privileged, the speculative nature of the Players Parties' grounds for exemption did not justify allowing them to use the documents for a purpose other than taxation of costs. The court emphasized the importance of the rule of preclusion in maintaining the integrity of court processes and preventing the misuse of privileged documents. It relied on the principle that exemption from the rule should only be granted in exceptional circumstances, which were not present in this case.
In summary, the ratio decidendi of this case is that the newly discovered documents do not constitute a breach of an undertaking to the Court, the evidence does not reasonably suggest abuse of trial procedures, the rule of preclusion binds the Players Parties, the internal documents are protected by litigation privilege, and there are insufficient grounds to exempt the Players Parties from the rule of preclusion. The court's decision underscores the importance of upholding the integrity of court processes and the principles governing the discovery and use of documents in litigation.