Yokogawa Australia Pty Ltd v Alstom Power Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 75 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Full Court)

YOKOGAWA AUST PTY LTD & ORS v ALSTOM POWER LTD

[2009] SASC 377

Judgment of The Full Court

(The Honourable Justice Duggan, The Honourable Justice Sulan and The Honourable Justice Kourakis)

11 December 2009

PROCEDURE - DISCOVERY AND INTERROGATORIES - DISCOVERY AND INSPECTION OF DOCUMENTS - PRODUCTION AND INSPECTION - GROUNDS FOR RESISTING PRODUCTION - LEGAL PROFESSIONAL PRIVILEGE

Appeal against decision of single judge refusing application seeking production of documents for inspection - whether documents in Kadlunga list privileged on basis of legal professional privilege, without prejudice privilege or both - whether description of documents adequate - scope of without prejudice privilege - whether internal communications protected by without prejudice privilege - whether post-settlement communications protected by without prejudice privilege - whether without prejudice privilege extends to protect negotiations in earlier settlement between the plaintiff and another party from disclosure in this action between appellants and respondent - whether without prejudice privilege protects earlier negotiations pleaded in this action between plaintiff and defendants - whether without prejudice privilege restricted to admissions made in course of settlement negotiations -  whether waiver of without prejudice privilege on part of respondent by putting state of mind and in particular the reasonableness of its state of mind in issue - whether waiver of legal professional privilege on part of respondent - whether sufficient evidence to support claim of privilege on part of respondent - whether single judge erred in conducting inspection of documents.

Held: Appeal dismissed - single judge did not err in upholding claim for privilege - litigation had connection with same subject matter as negotiations - not appropriate to confine without prejudice privilege to admissions - without prejudice privilege applies irrespective of whether settlement reached - single judge correct in finding that documents subject to without prejudice privilege were prepared during the course of negotiations - considerations relating to waiver of legal professional privilege applicable to without prejudice privilege - respondent had not waived privilege by putting state of mind in issue - objective reasonableness of settlement different enquiry in present circumstances from reasonableness of state of mind - single judge did not err in conducting inspection of documents.

Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) s 51AA; Evidence Act 1929 (SA) s 67C; Supreme Court Rules 1987 (SA) R 59; Insurance Contracts Act 1984 (Cth) s 28(3), referred to.
Unity Insurance Brokers Pty Ltd v Rocco Pezzano Pty Ltd (1998) 192 CLR 603; Biggin & Co Ltd v Permanite Ltd [1951] 2 KB 314; Mann v Carnell (1999) 201 CLR 1; Benecke v National Australia Bank (1993) 35 NSWLR 110; Adelaide Steamship Co Ltd v Spalvins (1998) 81 FCR 360; DSE (Holdings) Pty Ltd v Intertan Inc [2003] FCA 384; BNP Paribas v Pacific Carriers Ltd [2005] NSWCA 72; Sarkis v Summitt Broadway Pty Ltd trading as Sydney City Mitsubishi [2006] NSWCA 358; Pickering v Edmunds (1994) 63 SASR 357; Ampolex Ltd v Perpetual Trustee Co (Canberra)…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Yokogawa Australia Pty Ltd v Alstom Power Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] SASC 377
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Yokogawa Australia Pty Ltd v Alstom Power Ltd was heard in the Supreme Court of South Australia. The central dispute involved an appeal against a decision of a single judge, who had previously refused an application by the appellants seeking the production of documents for inspection. The key issue at hand was whether certain documents, listed in what is referred to as the Kadlunga list, were privileged on the basis of legal professional privilege, without prejudice privilege, or both. Additionally, the court needed to determine whether the descriptions of the documents were adequate and the scope of the without prejudice privilege.

The court examined the arguments presented regarding the applicability of legal professional privilege and without prejudice privilege to the documents in question. The court found that the single judge had not erred in upholding the claim for privilege, as the litigation was connected with the same subject matter as the negotiations. The court held that the without prejudice privilege applies irrespective of whether a settlement was reached and that it is not appropriate to confine the privilege to admissions made during settlement negotiations. Furthermore, the court concluded that the respondent had not waived the privilege by putting its state of mind in issue, and the considerations relating to waiver of legal professional privilege were applicable to the without prejudice privilege as well.

The appeal was ultimately dismissed. The court found that the single judge had not erred in conducting the inspection of the documents, and the inspection procedure could not be criticised. The court also noted that while there was some debate regarding the application of section 67C of the Evidence Act 1929 (SA), it was not necessary to express a view on the matter due to the outcome of the appeal. The judges agreed with the reasons provided by Duggan J, dismissing the appeal and affirming the decision of the single judge.

Background

Background to the litigation

Yokogawa Australia Pty Ltd (YDRML) and Alstom Power Ltd (Alstom) were involved in a contractual dispute relating to delays and breaches of contract at a power station. As part of this dispute, YDRML sought the production of documents from Alstom for inspection to establish the extent of Alstom's liability and the reasonableness of a settlement reached with another party, the Financial Facility Provider (FFP). Alstom resisted the production of these documents, claiming that they were privileged under either legal professional privilege or without prejudice privilege. The case proceeded to an appeal against a decision by a single judge who refused YDRML's application for the production of these documents.

The documents in question were part of a list referred to as the Kadlunga list, which included internal communications and negotiations related to the settlement with FFP. Alstom argued that these documents were privileged because they were prepared during the course of settlement negotiations and thus protected by without prejudice privilege. Additionally, Alstom contended that the documents were also protected by legal professional privilege because they contained legal advice. YDRML argued that Alstom had waived any privilege by putting the reasonableness of its state of mind in issue. The appeal centred on whether the documents were indeed privileged, whether the description of the documents was adequate, and if the single judge had erred in conducting an inspection of the documents.

The appeal was dismissed by the court, which found that the single judge had not erred in upholding the claim for privilege. The court held that the without prejudice privilege applied irrespective of whether a settlement was reached and that the privilege extended to all internal communications during negotiations. The court also determined that Alstom had not waived the privilege by putting the reasonableness of its state of mind in issue, as this was a different inquiry from the objective reasonableness of the settlement. The court further concluded that the single judge did not err in conducting an inspection of the documents, as this procedure placed the judge in the best position to rule on the privilege claims.

The case of Yokogawa Australia Pty Ltd v Alstom Power Ltd came before the court on appeal from a decision made by a single judge. The appeal centred on the single judge's refusal to grant an application for the production of documents for inspection, particularly those listed in the Kadlunga list, on the grounds of legal professional privilege, without prejudice privilege, or both. The appeal involved intricate procedural arguments concerning the adequacy of the description of the documents, the scope of without prejudice privilege, and whether certain internal and post-settlement communications were protected by this privilege. The appeal also explored whether the without prejudice privilege could extend to protect negotiations in an earlier settlement between the plaintiff and another party from disclosure in the current action between the appellants and the respondent. The court considered whether the privilege should be restricted to admissions made in the course of settlement negotiations and whether the respondent had waived the privilege by putting its state of mind in issue. Additionally, the appeal addressed whether there was a waiver of legal professional privilege on the part of the respondent and whether sufficient evidence supported the claim of privilege. The appeal also scrutinised whether the single judge had erred in conducting an inspection of the documents. The appeal was dismissed, with the court affirming that the single judge had not erred in upholding the claim for privilege, and that the without prejudice privilege applies irrespective of whether a settlement was reached. The court found that the documents in question were prepared during the course of negotiations and that the considerations relating to the waiver of legal professional privilege were applicable to without prejudice privilege. The court also determined that the respondent had not waived the privilege by putting its state of mind in issue, and that the objective reasonableness of the settlement was a different inquiry from the reasonableness of the respondent's state of mind.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In any event, the judge inspected the documents and was thereby placed in the best position to rule on them. It is to be noted that in Barnes v Commissioner of Taxation the Full Court reached the conclusion that the evidence provided by the appellants was manifestly insufficient and did not establish any basis for the claim of privilege. However, their Honours decided to inspect the documents and were thus placed in a position to rule on them. In the present case, even if the descriptions had been inadequate causing the judge to inspect the documents, the procedure thus adopted could not be criticised.Evidence Act 1929 (SA) s 67C Finally, Mr Harris drew attention to s 67C of the Evidence Act 1929 (SA). This section excludes from evidence communications made in connection with an attempt to negotiate a settlement of civil dispute in documents prepared in connection with such negotiations. The section then provides for a number of exceptions. According to the argument, the situation created by the section is a matter to be taken into account by the court in deciding whether there should be an order for production in a particular case. There appears to be some support for this proposition in Esso Australia Resources Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation.[82] However, I do not think it has any practical application in the present case and, in the light of my view as to the ultimate resolution of the issues on appeal, it is unnecessary to express any view on the argument.[82] (1999) 201 CLR 49 at [33]. I would dismiss the appeal. SULAN J: I would dismiss the appeal. I agree with the reasons of Duggan J. KOURAKIS J: I agree that the appeal should be dismissed for the reasons given by Duggan J. On the question of waiver I wish to make the following additional observations on the differences between the issues joined on the pleadings in this case and the issues which arose for consideration in Unity Insurance Brokers Pty Ltd v Rocco Pezzano Pty Ltd.[83] The appellant’s reliance on some passages from the reasons given in Unity Insurance Brokers and several other authorities is misplaced because of the particular way in which the respondent’s claim is framed.[83] (1998) 192 CLR 603. Alstom’s case is primarily framed on the basis that breaches of contract by YDRML resulted in delays which exposed it to a liability under the terms of its contract with FFP.[84] On proof of that case, Alstom would be entitled to compensation for the contractual liability it had incurred. It is not an element of any part of Alstom’s case, so framed, that the settlement was reasonable. The legal advice Alstom received is therefore irrelevant to the issues raised on the claim framed in that way. The resolution of those issues depends exclusively on findings of fact about the delays in the work at the power station and a determination of the legal effect of those facts against the contractual relationship of the parties. If, on such an analysis, a finding is made that YDRML’s breach of contract left Alstom contractually liable to FFP for an amount exceeding the settlement sum, Alstom will be entitled to a compensatory award for the amount of the settlement sum. On this premise, YDRML can only benefit from any reduction of the liability flowing from the settlement negotiated by Alstom; YDRML cannot complain that any settlement sum less than the actual liability Alstom incurred was not caused by its breach because, on this premise, the amount paid by Alstom discharged an even greater, proven, liability which had been caused by YDRML’s breach. If it is at all open for YDRML to put a case that Alstom could have negotiated a more advantageous settlement, it is by way of a defensive contention that Alstom could reasonably have done more to mitigate its loss; but that would be a case on which YDRML carried the persuasive burden. YDRML cannot unilaterally deny Alstom its legal professional, or without prejudice, privilege over the settlement communications by pleading such a case, even though the privileged communications may be very relevant to the issues joined over the alleged contractual breaches.[84] I gratefully adopt the abbreviations used in the reasons of Duggan J.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the documents in the Kadlunga list are privileged on the basis of legal professional privilege, without prejudice privilege, or both.
2. Whether the description of the documents is adequate to support a claim of privilege.
3. What is the scope of without prejudice privilege in the context of this case?
4. Whether internal communications are protected by without prejudice privilege.
5. Whether post-settlement communications are protected by without prejudice privilege.
6. Whether without prejudice privilege extends to protect negotiations in an earlier settlement between the plaintiff and another party from disclosure in this action between appellants and respondent.
7. Whether without prejudice privilege protects earlier negotiations pleaded in this action between the plaintiff and defendants.
8. Whether without prejudice privilege is restricted to admissions made in the course of settlement negotiations.
9. Whether the respondent has waived the without prejudice privilege by putting its state of mind and, in particular, the reasonableness of its state of mind in issue.
10. Whether the respondent has waived the legal professional privilege by putting its state of mind in issue.
11. Whether there is sufficient evidence to support the respondent's claim of privilege.
12. Whether the single judge erred in conducting the inspection of the documents.

Held
1. Whether the documents in the Kadlunga list are privileged on the basis of legal professional privilege, without prejudice privilege, or both: The court held that the documents were subject to without prejudice privilege.
2. Whether the description of the documents is adequate to support a claim of privilege: The court held that the descriptions of the documents were adequate.
3. What is the scope of without prejudice privilege in the context of this case: The court held that without prejudice privilege applies irrespective of whether a settlement is reached.
4. Whether internal communications are protected by without prejudice privilege: The court held that internal communications are protected by without prejudice privilege.
5. Whether post-settlement communications are protected by without prejudice privilege: The court held that post-settlement communications are protected by without prejudice privilege.
6. Whether without prejudice privilege extends to protect negotiations in an earlier settlement between the plaintiff and another party from disclosure in this action between appellants and respondent: The court held that without prejudice privilege does not extend to protect negotiations in an earlier settlement.
7. Whether without prejudice privilege protects earlier negotiations pleaded in this action between the plaintiff and defendants: The court held that without prejudice privilege protects earlier negotiations pleaded in this action.
8. Whether without prejudice privilege is restricted to admissions made in the course of settlement negotiations: The court held that without prejudice privilege is not restricted to admissions made in the course of settlement negotiations.
9. Whether the respondent has waived the without prejudice privilege by putting its state of mind and, in particular, the reasonableness of its state of mind in issue: The court held that the respondent had not waived the without prejudice privilege.
10. Whether the respondent has waived the legal professional privilege by putting its state of mind in issue: The court held that the respondent had not waived the legal professional privilege.
11. Whether there is sufficient evidence to support the respondent's claim of privilege: The court held that there was sufficient evidence to support the respondent's claim of privilege.
12. Whether the single judge erred in conducting the inspection of the documents: The court held that the single judge did not err in conducting the inspection of the documents.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of Yokogawa Australia Pty Ltd v Alstom Power Ltd, the court addressed several complex issues regarding the privilege of documents listed in the Kadlunga list. The primary issues revolved around whether these documents were privileged under legal professional privilege, without prejudice privilege, or both, and whether the descriptions provided were adequate to support a claim of privilege. The court also considered the scope of without prejudice privilege in the context of the case, including whether internal and post-settlement communications were protected, and whether this privilege extended to earlier negotiations between the plaintiff and another party.

The court began by examining whether the documents in the Kadlunga list were privileged on the basis of legal professional privilege or without prejudice privilege. The court found that the documents were subject to without prejudice privilege, as they were prepared during the course of negotiations. The court emphasized that without prejudice privilege applies irrespective of whether a settlement was reached, and it was not appropriate to confine this privilege to admissions made in the course of settlement negotiations.

Regarding the adequacy of the document descriptions, the court noted that the judge had inspected the documents, placing him in the best position to rule on their privilege. Although the descriptions provided might have been inadequate, the inspection procedure could not be criticized, especially considering the precedent set in Barnes v Commissioner of Taxation, where the Full Court inspected documents despite insufficient evidence provided by the appellants.

The court further explored the scope of without prejudice privilege, considering whether it extended to internal communications. It was determined that without prejudice privilege indeed covers internal communications, as these are integral to the negotiation process. Similarly, the court found that post-settlement communications were also protected by this privilege, as they are part of the ongoing negotiation process.

The court addressed whether without prejudice privilege extended to earlier negotiations between the plaintiff and another party, concluding that it did not. The court distinguished these earlier negotiations from the current action between the appellants and the respondent, finding that the privilege did not apply to these past negotiations.

The issue of whether without prejudice privilege was restricted to admissions made in the course of settlement negotiations was also examined. The court rejected this limitation, affirming that without prejudice privilege applies broadly to all communications made in the course of negotiations, regardless of whether they constitute admissions.

The court examined whether the respondent had waived the without prejudice privilege by putting its state of mind and the reasonableness of its state of mind in issue. The court held that the respondent had not waived the privilege, as the objective reasonableness of the settlement was a different inquiry from the reasonableness of the respondent’s state of mind. This distinction was crucial in maintaining the integrity of the privilege.

The court also considered whether the respondent had waived legal professional privilege by putting its state of mind in issue, concluding that the considerations relating to the waiver of legal professional privilege were applicable to without prejudice privilege. The court found that the respondent had not waived the privilege by raising these issues.

Finally, the court assessed whether there was sufficient evidence to support the respondent's claim of privilege. The court found that the single judge did not err in conducting the inspection of the documents, as he was in the best position to rule on their privilege. This inspection was deemed appropriate, especially considering the precedent set in Barnes v Commissioner of Taxation.

In conclusion, the court upheld the single judge's decision, finding that the documents were indeed subject to without prejudice privilege and that the judge did not err in conducting the inspection. The court dismissed the appeal, affirming that the privilege applied to the documents in question and that the procedure followed was appropriate.