SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA
(Civil)
ALSTOM LTD v YOKOGAWA AUSTRALIA PTY LTD & ANOR (No 7)
[2012] SASC 49
Judgment of The Honourable Justice Bleby
2 April 2012
CONTRACTS - GENERAL CONTRACTUAL PRINCIPLES - CONSTRUCTION AND INTERPRETATION OF CONTRACTS
Contract between power station owner and head contractor for refurbishment and automation of power station – consideration of terms of contract – whether head contract a turnkey or performance-based contract – consideration of nature and effect of turnkey contract.
Subcontract between head contractor and Electrical Control and Instrumentation subcontractor for refurbishment and automation of power station – consideration of terms of subcontract – consideration of relevant principles of interpretation – entire contract clause – relevant surrounding circumstances – ascertainment of objective intention of parties – use of recitals in pre-contract – whether subcontract a turnkey or performance-based contract – effect of provisions relating to meeting of performance dates and performance guarantees – whether primary obligation to meet performance dates and guarantees.
CONTRACTS - GENERAL CONTRACTUAL PRINCIPLES - FORMATION OF CONTRACTUAL RELATIONS - MATTERS NOT GIVING RISE TO BINDING CONTRACT - VAGUENESS AND UNCERTAINTY
Construction of subcontract – Article 3.3.1 a variation of provisions of head contract – whether void for uncertainty – whether gives rise to an obligation to comply with performance guarantees.
CONTRACTS - GENERAL CONTRACTUAL PRINCIPLES - CONSTRUCTION AND INTERPRETATION OF CONTRACTS - PENALTIES AND LIQUIDATED DAMAGES
CONTRACTS - GENERAL CONTRACTUAL PRINCIPLES - CONSTRUCTION AND INTERPRETATION OF CONTRACTS - INTERPRETATION OF MISCELLANEOUS CONTRACTS AND OTHER MATTERS
Whether substitution of certain expressions in head contract directed to be made by subcontract should not be made – whether Liquidated Damages provisions should be construed to reflect an accurate pre-estimate of contractor’s loss – whether provisions in subcontract relating to Liquidated Damages and Performance Guarantee Payments are exclusive remedies – effect and construction of overriding provision excluding liability for “any direct, economic or consequential loss whatsoever” – consideration of what constitutes “indirect … or consequential loss” – consideration of what constitutes “economic … loss” – whether in context a contract definition of Economic Loss applies – ordinary meaning of “economic loss”.
CONTRACTS - GENERAL CONTRACTUAL PRINCIPLES - CONSTRUCTION AND INTERPRETATION OF CONTRACTS
Whether provisions of subcontract exclude concurrent common law duty of care – relationship created solely by subcontract – whether subcontract sets out completely and exclusively the legal rights and obligations of the parties.
EQUITY - GENERAL PRINCIPLES - MISTAKE - EQUITABLE REMEDIES - RECTIFICATION
Claim for rectification of subcontract – contract price defined as meaning “the fixed lump sum for the [EC&I works] of $33,877,559.50 …” – whether should be rectified to read “… $37,265,315.45 …” being the definition figure plus 10% GST – consideration of principles of rectification – whether evidence sufficient to justify rectification order.
CONTRACTS - GENERAL CONTRACTUAL PRINCIPLES - CONSTRUCTION AND INTERPRETATION OF CONTRACTS
CONTRACTS - GENERAL CONTRACTUAL PRINCIPLES - CONSTRUCTION AND INTERPRETATION OF CONTRACTS - IMPLIED TERMS - TERMS ESSENTIAL TO ENABLE PERFORMANCE
CONTRACTS - GENERAL CONTRACTUAL PRINCIPLES - DISCHARGE, BREACH AND DEFENCES TO…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Alstom Ltd v Yokogawa Australia Pty Ltd (No 7) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2012] SASC 49
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court found that the head contract was indeed a turnkey contract, as it required the head contractor to deliver a fully operational Refurbished Facility according to the defined technical specifications. The subcontract, while incorporating some provisions from the head contract, did not change the nature of the contract to a performance-based one. The court scrutinised the subcontract's entire contract clause and surrounding circumstances to ascertain the parties' objective intention, concluding that the subcontract was not void for uncertainty. Regarding the liquidated damages provisions, the court held that they should reflect an accurate pre-estimate of the contractor’s loss.
Further, the court considered whether the subcontract excluded the concurrent common law duty of care and whether it completely and exclusively set out the legal rights and obligations of the parties. The court held that while the subcontract did not explicitly exclude common law duties, it did comprehensively outline the contractual obligations. The court also addressed the claim for rectification of the subcontract price, finding that the evidence did not sufficiently justify a rectification order. The court examined the adequacy of the works program and the implied terms within the subcontract, concluding that the contractor was not required to provide a regularly updated and accurate works program but was subject to implied obligations to co-operate and act in good faith.
Lastly, the court assessed the causes of delays in achieving the provisional and final acceptance stages, the admissibility of expert evidence, and the claims for extensions of time and recovery of prolongation costs. The court found that the subcontractor had not proven the causes of delays and that some claims were barred due to prior agreements to forego certain claims. The court also ruled on the legality of liquidated damages deductions and the subcontractor’s entitlement to extensions of time and additional costs.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Established by: BLEBY J
That the head contract was indeed a turnkey contract is reasonably clear from a number of its terms. The expression “Works” or “Scope of the Works” was defined in the head contract to mean:… the design, construction and commissioning of the whole of the Refurbished Facility, including:(a)the provision of the Services and Materials and Equipment and the furnishing of Construction Aids as required of Contractor in order to design, construct, procure, erect, start up, commission, test and place in operation a complete Refurbished Facility as defined in the Schedules, and as otherwise required to meet the Performance Guarantees;(b)all items of supply and services required or that can be reasonably inferred from this Contract even though not expressly stated, to deliver to Owner a completed and fully operational Refurbished Facility in accordance with this Contract;(c)all other things which must be done by Contractor under this Contract to achieve Final Completion; and(d) the Warranty Obligations;each in accordance with the terms of this Contract.[Emphasis added] Alstom was required to deliver a “Refurbished Facility”. The expression “Refurbished Facility” was defined to mean the Existing Facility after refurbishment on the basis described in, and as required by, the “Technical Specifications”.[39][39] Ibid Article 2.5. The expression “Technical Specifications” was defined to mean the technical specifications set out in Schedule A to the head contract.[40] By Article 3.4.2(a) Alstom acknowledged that the Technical Specifications was a functionally focussed specification. It was in the following terms:[40] Ibid.3.4.2 Contractor acknowledges that:(a) the Technical Specifications:(i)is not a comprehensive or complete design; and(ii)is a functionally focused specification, andpreparation of a detailed design for the Refurbished Facility shall form part of the Works and is the responsibility of Contractor; and(b) the obligations of Contractor under this Contract including the warranties in sub-article 3.4.1 and Contractor’s Design Obligations shall remain unaffected notwithstanding:(i)the Technical Specifications and any other documents or information provided by Owner to Contractor in relation to the Refurbished Facility or any error, omission, inadequacy or deficiency in such documents;(ii)any design work incorporated in the Technical Specifications or carried out by or on behalf of Owner in relation to the Refurbished Facility;(iii)any receipt or review of, or comment or direction on, the Design Documents or Deliverable Documents by Superintendent or Owner;(iv)any Owner-directed Change. As a functionally focussed specification the eight sections of Schedule A spoke of Alstom’s responsibilities to design, engineer, construct and deliver a power station with certain features and performance characteristics. The contract did not merely require Alstom to assume responsibility to execute certain work in accordance with the scope of works. Article 3.3.1 imposed an obligation on Alstom to perform the Works in accordance with the terms and provisions of the head contract and an obligation to ensure that the Refurbished Facility achieved the Performance Guarantees. Because of their significance in comparison with the requirements of YDRML under the EC&I contract, it is necessary to recite the relevant provisions of the head contract concerning Performance Guarantees.