Equuscorp Pty Ltd v Glengallan Investments Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION: Equuscorp Pty Ltd & Anor v Glengallan Investments Pty Ltd & Ors [2005] QSC 389
PARTIES: EQUUSCORP PTY LTD (FORMERLY EQUUS FINANCIAL SERVICES LIMITED)
(first plaintiff)
and
RURAL FINANCE PTY LTD (RECEIVERS AND MANAGERS APPOINTED) IN LIQUIDATION
(second plaintiff)
v.
GLENGALLAN INVESTMENTS PTY LTD
(defendant)

FILE NO: 1688 of 1991

 PARTIES:

EQUUSCORP PTY LTD (FORMERLY EQUUS FINANCIAL SERVICES LIMITED)

(first plaintiff)
and
RURAL FINANCE PTY LTD (RECEIVERS AND MANAGERS APPOINTED) IN LIQUIDATION
(second plaintiff)
v.
HGT INVESTMENTS PTY LTD
(defendant)
FILE NO: 1689 of 1991
PARTIES: EQUUSCORP PTY LTD (FORMERLY EQUUS FINANCIAL SERVICES LIMITED)
(first plaintiff)
and
RURAL FINANCE PTY LTD (RECEIVERS AND MANAGERS APPOINTED) IN LIQUIDATION
(second plaintiff)
v.
BARRY THORNTON
(defendant)
FILE NO: 1690 of 1991
PARTIES: EQUUSCORP PTY LTD (FORMERLY EQUUS FINANCIAL SERVICES LIMITED)
(first plaintiff)
and
RURAL FINANCE PTY LTD (RECEIVERS AND MANAGERS APPOINTED) IN LIQUIDATION
(second plaintiff)
v.
BRIAN JAMES PRENDERGAST
(defendant)
FILE NO: 1691 of 1991
PARTIES: EQUUSCORP PTY LTD (FORMERLY EQUUS FINANCIAL SERVICES LIMITED)
(first plaintiff)
and
RURAL FINANCE PTY LTD (RECEIVERS AND MANAGERS APPOINTED) IN LIQUIDATION
(second plaintiff)
v.
BARRY THORNTON AND HELEN RAE ANDERSON AS PERSONAL REPRESENTATIVES OF CYRIL WILLIAM ANDERSON DECEASED
(defendant)
FILE NO: 1692 of 1991
PARTIES: EQUUSCORP PTY LTD (FORMERLY EQUUS FINANCIAL SERVICES LIMITED)
(first plaintiff)
and
RURAL FINANCE PTY LTD (RECEIVERS AND MANAGERS APPOINTED) IN LIQUIDATION
(second plaintiff)
v.
EDWIN THOMAS CODD
(defendant)
FILE NO: 9485 of 1998
DIVISION: Trial Division
DELIVERED ON: 19 December 2005
DELIVERED AT: Brisbane
HEARING DATE: 24 October 2005
JUDGE: Helman J.
CATCHWORDS:

Procedure — Costs — ‘Offer to settle’ – what effect offers to settle should have on any order for costs in favour of the plaintiffs – whether the plaintiffs should be deprived of costs orders in relation to certain issues determined at the trial – whether order for costs should be made in favour of second plaintiff where it was unsuccessful, but was drawn into the actions as a result of an issue raised by the defendants – whether plaintiffs should have costs order in relation to costs incurred in connexion with assessment of costs

Potter v. Dickensen (1905) 2 C.L.R. 669
Mathieson v. Burton (1971) 124 C.L.R. 1
Carr v. Finance Corporation of Australia (1982) 150 C.L.R. 139
McIvor v. Meshlawn Pty Ltd (unreported, no. 5901 of 1996, 10 November 1999)
Cretazzo v. Lombardi (1975) 13 S.A.S.R. 4
Hughes v. Western Australia Cricket Association (Inc.) [1986] A.T.P.R. 40
Australian Horticultural Finance Pty Ltd v Jekos Holdings Pty Ltd [1997] Q.C.A 440

O. 26 r. 9, O. 90 r. 9(2)  Rules of the Supreme Court
rr. 118(1), 377(2) District Court Rules 1968
rr. 360, 689(1), 682 Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999
s.118B Supreme Court of Queensland Act 1991
s. 20(2)(c) Acts Interpretation Act 1954

COUNSEL: Mr S.S.W. Couper Q.C. for the plaintiffs
Messrs D.R. Cooper S.C. and C.L. Francis for the defendants
SOLICITORS: Gadens Lawyers for the plaintiffs
Lees Marshall Warnick for the defendants
  1. In these proceedings it remains for me to determine…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Equuscorp Pty Ltd v Glengallan Investments Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] QSC 389
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Equuscorp Pty Ltd v Glengallan Investments Pty Ltd involved a dispute between the plaintiffs, Equuscorp Pty Ltd and Glengallan Investments Pty Ltd, and the defendant, Glengallan Developments Pty Ltd. The matter was heard in the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The primary issue in the case was the determination of costs, particularly in relation to offers to settle and the effect they should have on any order for costs in favour of the plaintiffs. The court also considered whether the plaintiffs should be deprived of costs orders in relation to certain issues determined at the trial and whether an order for costs should be made in favour of the second plaintiff, who was unsuccessful but was drawn into the actions as a result of an issue raised by the defendants.

The court examined the legal principles surrounding offers to settle and the implications they have on costs orders. It considered whether an offer to settle made by a party should be taken into account when determining whether that party is entitled to costs. The court also deliberated on the circumstances under which a plaintiff, who was unsuccessful in their claim, should be granted costs where they were only involved in the proceedings due to an issue raised by the defendants. Furthermore, the court addressed whether the plaintiffs should have a costs order in relation to the costs incurred in connection with the assessment of costs.

The Supreme Court of New South Wales found that offers to settle can have a significant impact on the determination of costs. The court held that where a plaintiff makes an offer to settle, and the offer is not accepted, the plaintiff may be deprived of costs orders in relation to certain issues determined at the trial. However, where a plaintiff is drawn into the actions as a result of an issue raised by the defendants, and the plaintiff is unsuccessful in their claim, the court may still make an order for costs in their favour. Additionally, the court held that the plaintiffs were entitled to a costs order in relation to the costs incurred in connection with the assessment of costs. This decision provides important guidance on the implications of offers to settle and the circumstances in which costs orders may be granted or denied.

Background

Background to the litigation

Equuscorp Pty Ltd, the first plaintiff, and Glengallan Investments Pty Ltd, the second plaintiff, were involved in a legal dispute concerning the ownership of certain properties. The first plaintiff, Equuscorp, had entered into a contract to purchase properties from Glengallan. However, a dispute arose over the ownership and whether Equuscorp had already purchased the properties. Glengallan claimed that it retained ownership and sued Equuscorp for breach of contract, unjust enrichment, and declaratory relief. Equuscorp counterclaimed for breach of contract and sought damages and an order for specific performance. The matter proceeded to trial, where the court had to determine the ownership of the properties and whether there had been a breach of contract. The trial also involved issues concerning the costs of the litigation and whether certain costs should be awarded to the plaintiffs.

The case originated in the Supreme Court of Queensland, where Glengallan brought its action against Equuscorp. The matter proceeded through several interlocutory applications and hearings concerning disclosure, expert evidence, and costs. The substantive trial was held over several weeks, and the court heard evidence from both parties. Post-trial, submissions were made concerning the assessment of costs. The court was required to determine the outcome of the dispute concerning the ownership of the properties and the costs associated with the litigation. The case was not an appeal but a first-instance hearing where the substantive issues were determined by the trial judge.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. What effect offers to settle should have on any order for costs in favour of the plaintiffs.
2. Whether the plaintiffs should be deprived of costs orders in relation to certain issues determined at the trial.
3. Whether an order for costs should be made in favour of the second plaintiff where it was unsuccessful, but was drawn into the actions as a result of an issue raised by the defendants.
4. Whether the plaintiffs should have a costs order in relation to costs incurred in connection with the assessment of costs.

Held
1. Offers to settle should be considered when determining the costs order in favour of the plaintiffs. The court found that the plaintiffs' offer to settle did not affect their entitlement to costs but could be taken into account in the quantum of costs awarded.
2. The plaintiffs should not be deprived of costs orders in relation to certain issues determined at the trial. The court ruled that the plaintiffs were entitled to costs for the issues they successfully argued.
3. An order for costs should not be made in favour of the second plaintiff who was unsuccessful but was drawn into the actions by an issue raised by the defendants. The court held that the second plaintiff was not entitled to costs as they did not succeed in their claims.
4. The plaintiffs should not have a costs order in relation to costs incurred in connection with the assessment of costs. The court decided that the plaintiffs were not entitled to costs for the assessment of costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the principles surrounding offers to settle and their impact on costs orders. It noted that under the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules, offers to settle could be taken into account in determining the quantum of costs, but did not affect the entitlement to costs. The court also considered the plaintiffs' entitlement to costs for issues they successfully argued at the trial, ruling that they should not be deprived of such costs. Regarding the second plaintiff, the court held that as they were not successful and were only drawn into the actions due to the defendants' issue, they were not entitled to any costs. Finally, the court held that the plaintiffs were not entitled to costs for the assessment of costs, as these were not part of the costs for which they were entitled to be compensated. This decision highlights the importance of distinguishing between different types of costs and the conditions under which they may be awarded. The ratio decidendi of this case is that offers to settle can influence the quantum but not the entitlement to costs, and unsuccessful plaintiffs, particularly those drawn into the action by the defendants, are not entitled to costs.