Players Pty Ltd (In liquidation) (Receivers Appointed) v Clone Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 72 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil)

PLAYERS PTY LTD (IN LIQUIDATION) (RECEIVERS APPOINTED) & ORS v CLONE PTY LTD

[2015] SASC 133

Judgment of The Honourable Auxiliary Justice Hargrave

28 August 2015

PROCEDURE - JUDGMENTS AND ORDERS - AMENDING, VARYING AND SETTING ASIDE

New trial - Whether successful party engaged in malpractice by failing to discover relevant document - Likelihood of different result in absence of alleged malpractice - Whether unsuccessful party used reasonable diligence to find document - Nature of court’s discretion to set aside final orders - Relevant principles - Whether court’s discretion to set aside final orders enlivened by the alleged malpractice - Finality principle - Commonwealth Bank of Australia v Quade (1991) 178 CLR 134 applied - Lexcray Pty Ltd v Northern Territory of Australia (No 3) (2003) 13 NTLR 154 doubted.

PROCEDURE - DISCOVERY AND INTERROGATORIES - DISCOVERY AND INSPECTION OF DOCUMENTS - DISCOVERY OF DOCUMENTS

Discovery - Obligation to discover document in a party's power - Taylor v Santos Ltd (1998) 71 SASR 434 applied.

PROCEDURE - DISCOVERY AND INTERROGATORIES - DISCOVERY AND INSPECTION OF DOCUMENTS - PRODUCTION AND INSPECTION

Notices to produce to party - Failure to call upon notice to produce - Supreme Court Rules 1987 (SA), r 59.07.

Supreme Court Rules 1987 (SA) r 58.07, r 59.07; Supreme Court Civil Rules 2006 (SA) r 262, referred to.
Commonwealth Bank of Australia v Quade (1991) 178 CLR 134; Taylor v Santos Ltd (1998) 71 SASR 434, applied.
Lexcray Pty Ltd v Northern Territory of Australia (No 3) (2003) 13 NTLR 154, not followed.
Bailey v Marinoff (1971) 125 CLR 529; Briginshaw v Briginshaw (1938) 60 CLR 336; Brookfield v Yevad Products Pty Ltd [2004] FCA 1164; Browne v Dunn (1893) 6 R 67; Chong v CC Containers Pty Ltd & Ors [2015] VSCA 137; Clone Pty Ltd v Players Pty Ltd & Ors [2005] SASC 281; Clone Pty Ltd v Players Pty Ltd & Ors [2006] SASC 290; Clone Pty Ltd v Players Pty Ltd (in liq) (rec apptd) & Ors [2012] SASC 12; D’Orta-Ekenaike v Victorian Legal Aid & Anor (2005) 223 CLR 1; Jones v Dunkel (1959) 101 CLR 298; Players Pty Ltd & Ors v Clone Pty Ltd [2006] SASC 118; Players Pty Ltd (in liq) (rec apptd) & Ors v Clone Pty Ltd (2013) 115 SASR 547; Redcliffe Forestry Venture Ltd v Commissioner of Inland Revenue [2010] NZHC 176; The Ampthill Peerage [1977] AC 547; Transport Industries Insurance Co Ltd v Longmuir [1997] 1 VR 125; White Industries (Qld) Pty Ltd v Flower & Hart (a firm) (1998) 156 ALR 169, discussed.
Aon Risk Services Australia Ltd v Australian National University (2009) 239 CLR 175; Commercial Union Assurance Co of Australia Ltd v Ferrcom Pty Ltd (1991) 22 NSWLR 389; Commissioner for Railways v Small (1938) 38 SRNSW 564; Ho v Powell (2001) 51 NSWLR 572; Karidis…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Players Pty Ltd (In liquidation) (Receivers Appointed) v Clo... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] SASC 133
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Players Pty Ltd (In liquidation) (Receivers Appointed) v Clone Pty Ltd, the Court was required to determine whether the final orders made in the case should be set aside on the basis that the successful party had failed to discover a relevant document, and whether the unsuccessful party had used reasonable diligence to find the document. The Court also had to consider the nature of its discretion to set aside final orders, the relevant principles, and whether the alleged malpractice by the successful party had enlivened the court’s discretion. The Court found that the unsuccessful party had not used reasonable diligence to find the document, and that the malpractice by the successful party did not justify setting aside the final orders. The Court held that the finality principle is important, but must be balanced with the justice of the particular case where there is misconduct and a real possibility that the result would have been different in the absence of that misconduct.

The Court considered the case of Commonwealth Bank of Australia v Quade, where the High Court held that where there is misconduct and a real possibility that the result in the case would have been different in the absence of that misconduct, the Court must balance general considerations relating to the administration of justice, including the finality principle, with the justice of the particular case being considered. The Court also considered the case of Lexcray Pty Ltd v Northern Territory of Australia (No 3), which doubted the application of the finality principle in cases of serious misconduct. The Court found that the approach taken in Quade was correct, and that the possibility that the unpleaded unconscionable conduct issue would form part of the issues to be determined in any new trial should be given little weight in the exercise of the Court’s discretion. The Court also found that a fair trial was still possible given the lapse of time since the original trial and the relevant events concerning the deletion issue.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

When commenting upon the unpleaded unconscionable conduct issue which could arise if the appeal on the deletion issue had succeeded, Doyle CJ stated: A striking feature of the case is that on Players’ own case Mr Griffin did nothing at all to bring the deletion of the word “NIL” to the attention of any representative of Clone. Moreover, the signed Agreement was returned to Clone’s agent (Colliers) in circumstances that would suggest that Players had accepted the draft Agreement in the terms proposed by Clone. Thereafter Players maintained its silence while the Agreement was executed by Clone and while the terms of the Lease were negotiated and the Lease was executed.Even if I were persuaded that Mr Griffin’s evidence that he deleted the word “NIL” should be accepted, I find no basis to reject the evidence of Mr Grope, Ms Roche and Mr England that they did not notice the deletion. The appearance of condition 11(i) in exhibit P9 and exhibit D9 is such that the possibility of them having failed to observe the deletion cannot be put aside.On those facts and findings, could or should the court order that the Lease be rectified to provide (in accordance with the Agreement) that Clone should pay consideration to Players for the hotel licence and for the gaming machine licence? On those facts and findings, the proper finding might be that Clone executed the Agreement under a mistake as to one of its terms. Normally that would not enable Clone to deny that it was bound. Players would be entitled to say that by signing the Agreement Clone had so conducted itself as to indicate to a reasonable person that it assented to the terms of the Agreement.But on the facts and findings referred to, it may be that the proper conclusion would be that Clone’s mistake as to condition 11(i) is one of which Players (through its directors) was aware, and that the mistake was attributable to Mr Griffin altering the Agreement without having the alteration initialled, and without doing anything to bring to Clone’s attention the fact of the alteration, in circumstances in which Clone had no reason to think that any alteration had been made. In those circumstances a finding that Players had been guilty of unconscionable conduct might be made. The case might be similar to A Roberts & Co Ltd v Leicestershire County Council,[49] in which rectification was ordered at the instance at the mistaken party. I refer also to Leibler v Air New Zealand Ltd (No 2).[50]This matter was not argued on appeal. Nor in its Defence to the Counterclaim has Clone raised this defence to the Counterclaim for rectification. Nor has it claimed that it is entitled to rectification in the event that the Agreement was signed after the word “NIL” was deleted. The closest Clone has come to this appears to be para 16.5 of its Defence to Counterclaim which asserts:The first defendant is estopped from asserting that the Lease does not embody the terms of the Agreement between the plaintiff and the first defendant and is estopped from seeking rectification of the Lease.In substance that plea is based on the fact that Players executed the Lease and that the parties have relied upon the terms of the Lease as governing the situation between them.This is a matter on which I would have wished to hear further submissions, had I been persuaded that the Judge erred in finding that the word “NIL” had not been struck out of condition 11(i) before Clone signed the Agreement.[51][49] [1961] Ch 555. [50] [1999] 1 VR 1, 14 (Kenny JA).[51] Players Pty Ltd & Ors v Clone Pty Ltd [2006] SASC 118 [192]-[197] (emphasis added; citations in original). Further decision of Vanstone J

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In my opinion, the possibility that the unpleaded unconscionable conduct issue will form part of the issues to be determined in any new trial should be given little weight in the exercise of the Court’s discretion. The form in which Clone intends to raise the issue is uncertain, there is no certainty that the Court will grant leave for the issue to be raised, and the Court cannot predict the outcome if the issue is permitted to be raised. General considerations relating to the administration of justice Clone, the Commissioner and the Attorney-General all join in the submission that the public interest in the finality of litigation should be given significant weight in the exercise of the Court’s discretion in determining the Application. I agree that the finality principle is an important one. However, as Quade makes clear, where there is misconduct and a real possibility that the result in the case would have been different in the absence of that misconduct, the Court must balance general considerations relating to the administration of justice, including the finality principle, with the justice of the particular case being considered.[157] In Quade, the High Court approved the approach of Burchett J in the Full Federal Court in respect of a serious failure by the successful party to comply with its discovery obligation. The High Court described Burchett J’s approach to such a case in the following terms:His examination of the relevant documents led him to conclude that the result ‘might’ have been different if the Bank had not failed to produce them to the respondents on discovery. In these circumstances, his Honour considered that the question whether the verdict should be set aside should be determined by reference to ‘broad considerations of justice’ including the public interest in finality of litigation and the ‘equally important principle that a party should not be permitted to mock the orders of the court’. It should be apparent from what has been said above that the approach adopted by Burchett J was correct.[158][157] Quade (1991) 178 CLR 134, 141-3. [158] Ibid 143. In my opinion, this is a similar case. Another relevant consideration is whether a fair trial is now possible given the lapse of time since the original trial (10 years) and the relevant events concerning the deletion issue (21 years). Clone contends that the further fading of memories since the original trial will, especially in a case involving credit issues, ‘make a fair trial extremely problematic’. Players contends first that the factual issues arising on the deletion issue are confined to a few witnesses, Griffin, McDermott, Mackie, Grope, Roche, England and Brown, each of whom gave evidence on oath at the original trial. The transcript of that evidence is available for tender on a new trial and there is unlikely to be any further oral evidence beyond that already given. Second, Players contends that the probabilities will likely be determined by the contemporaneous documents and the evidence already given by Messrs Griffin and McDermott. Third, Players contends that Clone’s culpability in this case is serious enough that the interests of justice should prevail and, if memories have further faded, that is a secondary consideration.