Clone Pty Ltd v Players Pty Ltd (In liquidation) (Receivers Appointed)

Link copied
Case Copied 80 min read

Supreme Court of South Australia

(Full Court: Civil)

CLONE PTY LTD v PLAYERS PTY LTD (IN LIQUIDATION)

[2016] SASCFC 134

Judgment of The Full Court

(The Honourable Justice Blue, The Honourable Justice Stanley and The Honourable Auxiliary Justice Debelle)

8 December 2016

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL - APPEAL - GENERAL PRINCIPLES

PROCEDURE - DISCOVERY AND INTERROGATORIES - DISCOVERY AND INSPECTION OF DOCUMENTS - DISCOVERY OF DOCUMENTS

PROCEDURE - DISCOVERY AND INTERROGATORIES - DISCOVERY AND INSPECTION OF DOCUMENTS - PRODUCTION AND INSPECTION

PROCEDURE - COSTS - DEPARTING FROM THE GENERAL RULE - ORDER FOR COSTS ON INDEMNITY BASIS

Appeal against order setting aside judgment after trial and ordering new trial.

In 1994, the appellant and first respondent entered into an agreement to lease premises for 10 years. Clause 11(i) provided for transfer, on determination of the lease, by the first respondent to the appellant of any liquor and gaming machine licences in respect of the premises. A dispute later arose whether the word “NIL” in the phrase “for NIL consideration” in clause 11(i) had been struck through by the respondent prior to execution of the agreement. The parties subsequently executed a lease.

In 2004, the appellant instituted the action against the first respondent and its directors seeking inter alia a declaration that the first respondent was obliged to deliver up the licences at the expiration of the lease. The respondents counter-claimed seeking inter alia a declaration that the appellant was obliged to pay reasonable consideration for delivery up of the licences and rectification of the lease to accord with the agreement to lease.

At trial, the original agreement to lease could not be located. The appellant tendered the respondents’ discovered photocopy of the agreement to lease (the first copy) and the respondents tendered the appellant’s discovered photocopy of the agreement to lease (the second copy).

During evidence in chief of the second respondent Mr Griffin, the appellant’s lawyers learnt that there was a photocopy of the agreement to lease (the third copy) in the possession of the fifth respondent, The Liquor and Gambling Commissioner. The appellant inspected the Commissioner’s file containing that document at his premises. The appellant did not discover or disclose the existence of the third copy.

During cross-examination of Mr Griffin, the appellant issued a notice to produce to the fifth respondent, who delivered several files to the Court. Unbeknown to the appellant, one of those files contained a fourth photocopy of the agreement to lease (the fourth copy). Mr Griffin was cross-examined concerning plans in those files but the notice to produce was not called on and no explicit disclosure was made by the appellant of its issue.

In 2005, the trial Judge granted judgment in favour of the appellant, relevantly finding in accordance with the approach articulated in Briginshaw v Briginshaw that the word “NIL” had not been struck through by the respondents. The respondents’ appeal to the Full Court was relevantly dismissed.

Subsequently, the respondents learnt of the existence of the third and fourth copies…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Clone Pty Ltd v Players Pty Ltd (In liquidation) (Receivers... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] SASCFC 134
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case involved an appeal to the Full Court of the Supreme Court of South Australia by Clone Pty Ltd (in liquidation, receivers appointed) against orders made by a trial judge. Players Pty Ltd (in liquidation) was the respondent. The dispute concerned allegations of malpractice, for which Clone accepted legal responsibility for the conduct of its lawyers during the original trial, despite having no direct knowledge of the alleged malpractice.

The primary legal issues before the Full Court were whether to grant permission to appeal to the Commissioner, and whether to allow Clone's appeal against the trial judge's orders. The court was also required to consider the appropriate costs orders, particularly in relation to the Commissioner's participation in the proceedings.

The Full Court allowed Clone's appeal, finding no issue of principle that warranted granting the Commissioner permission to appeal. The court reasoned that while the Commissioner had participated to refute allegations against his staff, their conduct was not central to the application, and therefore, even if successful in defence, he would not have been entitled to an order for costs. The court held that a statutory authority should generally bear its own costs regardless of the outcome. Consequently, the Full Court set aside the trial judge's orders, except for the order concerning the Commissioner's costs, and remitted the matter for the parties to be heard on the costs of the action and the appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

It should be noted that Clone itself (and in particular its director Fiona Roche) had no knowledge of the matters alleged by Players or found by the Judge to comprise malpractice. However, Clone accepts that it bears legal responsibility vis a vis Players for the conduct of its lawyers when acting on its behalf during the original trial.Background Clone was part of the Roche group of companies, owned by John Roche’s family. In 1994 and 1995, its directors were John Roche, his daughter Fiona Roche, and Richard England. In 1993, Clone purchased the land on which the premises were situated for future redevelopment as a multi-storey office tower. Clone expected that it would take at least 10 years before market demand for tenancies justified construction of the office tower. The premises comprised two vandalised vacant buildings: one having been used as the Oaks Tavern some years earlier and being fire-damaged and the other having previously been used by a firm of solicitors. Clone intended to demolish the buildings when it undertook the future redevelopment. Clone had a sister company, the Adelaide Development Company Pty Ltd (ADC). Both companies formed part of the Roche group of companies and ADC acted as agent for Clone for certain purposes. For ease of reference, I treat ADC and Clone as a single entity. Ross Mallett was general manager of ADC. Clone engaged Colliers (Alistair Mackie) to find a tenant willing to undertake the capital works necessary to make the premises usable. Mr Mackie entered into negotiations with a prospective tenant, the Hokie Pokies Group. On 24 May 1994, he wrote a letter to the Hokie Pokies Group setting out proposed terms and conditions for a lease. In 1994, Players Pty Ltd was conducting Players Bar in Grenfell Street Adelaide. Its directors were Messrs Griffin, Cahill, McDermott and Timothy May. Players became interested in conducting a hotel at the premises. Mr Griffin was a solicitor and partner at Phillips Fox. On 19 July 1994, Mr Griffin and Mr McDermott viewed the premises in company with Mr Mackie. On 21 July 1994, Mr Griffin and Mr McDermott met with Mr Mackie and Mr Mallett. Mr Mallett said that ADC’s long-term plan was to demolish the buildings and erect a high-rise office tower and at the end of the lease Players could take the licences and equipment.[9] Mr Mackie gave to Mr Griffin a copy of his 24 May 1994 letter to the Hokie Pokies Group to indicate the proposed terms of a lease.[9] The trial Judge admitted this evidence and made these findings as relevant to Messrs Griffin’s and McDermott’s state of mind and not as evidence of the position of Clone. On 27 July 1994, Phillips Fox by Mr Griffin wrote to Mr Mackie expressing Players’ interest in taking the tenancy of the premises. He set out proposed terms by reference to Mr Mackie’s 24 May 1994 letter. There was no suggestion in the letters of 24 May or 27 July 1994, or during the discussions prior to execution of the agreement to lease by Players Pty Ltd, that the licences to be obtained by Players Pty Ltd if a lease eventuated were to be transferred to Clone at the expiration of the lease.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

As the trial judge records at [98], although the Commissioner was a party to the Application, no relief was sought against him. The Full Court, however, had expressed the view that having regard to the nature of the allegations to be made against the Commissioner’s representatives, he should be entitled to appear on the hearing of the application. The Commissioner participated in the actions and sought to refute the allegations made against members of his staff. However, the conduct of the Commissioner’s staff was not a central issue in the application. It was an instance of a statutory authority assisting a court in the determination of issues. I do not think, therefore, the Commissioner would have been entitled to an order for costs had he succeeded in defending the attacks upon his staff. This was a case where a statutory authority should bear its own costs whatever the outcome of the proceedings. There is no issue of principle that warrants an order granting permission to appeal. For these reasons, I would not grant the Commissioner permission to appeal.Conclusion For all of these reasons I would allow the appeal by Clone but dismiss the application for permission to appeal by the Commissioner. I would set aside the orders made by the trial judge save and except for paragraph [10] of his order in each action which made no order as to the costs of the Commissioner. I would dismiss the application and hear the parties as to the orders that should be made concerning the costs of the action and the costs of this appeal.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.