Spalla v St George Motor Finance Ltd (No 5)

Link copied
Case Copied 42 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Spalla v St George Motor Finance Ltd (ACN 007 656 555) (No 5)

[2004] FCA 1262

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – pleadings – strike out – res judicata –  issue estoppel – pleadings of fact inconsistent with previous judgment between same parties – repleading to allege judgment obtained by fraud – criteria for setting aside judgment obtained by fraud – whether fresh evidence – allegation of mistaken pleading in previous litigation based on misreading of transaction document –  alleged knowing failure by respondent to disclose error – whether fresh evidence not reasonably capable of discovery at or prior to previous proceedings – claim to set aside judgment for fraud unsustainable – other aspects of pleading embarrassing – statement of claim struck out with leave to replead

Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth)

Federal  Court Rules  O 35 r 7(2)

Spalla v St George Wholesale Finance Pty Ltd [1999] FCA 513 cited
Spalla and Others v St George Wholesale Pty Ltd (1999) 95 FCR 359 cited
Wentworth v Rogers (No 5) (1986) 6 NSWLR 535 applied
Monroe Schneider Associates (Inc) v No 1 Raberem Pty Ltd  (No 2) (1992) 37 FCR 234 applied
Magarditch v Australian and New Zealand Banking Group Ltd (1999) 17 ACLC 1275 cited
Pembroke School Incorporated v Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission [2002] FCA 1020 cited
Owens Bank Ltd v Bracco [1992] 2 AC 443 cited

DM Gordon QC, ‘Fraud or New Evidence as Grounds for Actions to Set Aside Judgments (1961) 77 LQR 358

ANTHONY PATRICK SPALLA, ANDREW DAVID BENTLEY STILL and IRLMOND PTY LTD (RECEIVERS AND MANAGERS APPOINTED IN LIQUIDATION) (ACN 066 314 870) v ST GEORGE MOTOR FINANCE LTD (ACN 007 656 555), ST GEORGE WHOLESALE FINANCE PTY LTD (ACN 001 834 886), ANDREW WILLIAM BECK, ANDREW STEWART HOME, DELOITTE TOUCHE TOHMATSU, AUSTRALIAN SECURITIES AND INVESTMENT COMMISSION and SIMON ALEXANDER WALLACE-SMITH
V3203 of 2002

FRENCH J
28 SEPTEMBER 2004
PERTH


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIAN DISTRICT REGISTRY

V3203 OF 2002

BETWEEN:

ANTHONY PATRICK SPALLA
FIRST APPLICANT

ANDREW DAVID BENTLEY STILL
SECOND APPLICANT

IRLMOND PTY LTD (RECEIVERS AND MANAGERS APPOINTED IN LIQUIDATION) (ACN 066 314 870)
THIRD APPLICANT

AND:

ST GEORGE MOTOR FINANCE LTD
(ACN 007 656 555)
FIRST RESPONDENT

ST GEORGE WHOLESALE FINANCE PTY LTD
(ACN 001 834 886)
SECOND RESPONDENT

ANDREW WILLIAM BECK
THIRD RESPONDENT

ANDREW STEWART HOME
FOURTH RESPONDENT

DELOITTE TOUCHE TOHMATSU
FIFTH RESPONDENT

AUSTRALIAN SECURITIES AND INVESTMENT COMMISSION
SIXTH RESPONDENT

SIMON ALEXANDER WALLACE-SMITH
SEVENTH RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

FRENCH J

DATE OF ORDER:

28 SEPTEMBER 2004

WHERE MADE:

PERTH

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

A.On the motion of the third, fourth, fifth and seventh respondents filed 21 May 2004 and the motion of the first and second respondents filed 24 August 2004 IT IS ORDERED THAT:

1.The further amended statement of claim is struck out.

2.Leave to file the second further amended statement of claim and the third amended application is refused.

3.The applicants have liberty to file and serve a substituted application and statement of claim on…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Spalla v St George Motor Finance Ltd (No 5) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] FCA 1262
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Spalla v St George Motor Finance Ltd (No 5) involves the applicants, Spalla, and the respondents, including St George Motor Finance Ltd and others. The dispute pertains to the applicants' attempt to amend their statement of claim for a second time and to proceed with associated legal actions. The court was tasked with determining whether the proposed second further amended statement of claim could proceed and if leave should be granted to file it. Additionally, the court had to address the broader issue of whether the applicants could bring forward claims that were barred by res judicata and issue estoppels due to prior litigation.

The court meticulously examined the applicants' attempts to amend their statement of claim, noting that several allegations were untenable due to the legal doctrines of res judicata and issue estoppel. The court emphasised that merely alleging fraud was insufficient to overcome these barriers. The applicants' claims were further complicated by the fact that the true positions could have been easily verified through relevant transaction documents. Despite the applicants' argument that a common mistake might have occurred due to the similar names within the St George Finance group, the court found the allegations unconvincing. The court ruled that the proposed second further amended statement of claim could not stand as it was built on unsustainable allegations.

In light of its findings, the court ordered that the further amended statement of claim be struck out, and leave to file the second further amended statement of claim and the third amended application was refused. The applicants were, however, granted liberty to file a substituted application and statement of claim by a specified deadline. Additionally, the applicants were ordered to pay the costs of the respondents' motions.

Orders

Orders of the court

A. On the motion of the third, fourth, fifth and seventh respondents filed 21 May 2004 and the motion of the first and second respondents filed 24 August 2004 IT IS ORDERED THAT:

1. The further amended statement of claim is struck out.

2. Leave to file the second further amended statement of claim and the third amended application is refused.

3. The applicants have liberty to file and serve a substituted application and statement of claim on or before 21 October 2004.

4. The applicants are to pay the costs of the third, fourth, fifth and seventh respondents’ motion filed 21 May 2004 and the costs of the first and second respondents’ motion filed 24 August 2004.

Background

Background to the litigation

This case involves a dispute between Spalla and St George Motor Finance Ltd, with multiple iterations of amended statements of claim. The first proceedings resulted in a judgment that has now been challenged by Spalla. The existing amended statement of claim has been identified as problematic due to unsustainable allegations in light of res judicata and issue estoppels. The proposed second further amended statement of claim seeks to address these issues by amending certain allegations and introducing new allegations of fraud regarding the first proceedings. The core of the allegation of fraud is that St George Motor Wholesale, not St George Wholesale Finance, was previously known as Barclays Motor Wholesale Pty Ltd, and that this was concealed from the court during the first proceedings.

The matter has been through multiple amendments to the statement of claim, with the latest being the proposed second further amended statement of claim. Various motions have been filed by the respondents, leading to the current application to strike out the further amended statement of claim and to refuse leave to file the second further amended statement of claim and the associated third amended application. The applicants have also filed a reply to ASIC’s defence.

Decision

Reasons for decision

FRENCH J
The applicants have also filed a reply to ASIC’s defence. General Conclusions on the Existing Amended Statement of Claim It is not necessary to canvass all of the submissions made in respect of the existing amended statement of claim. Certain aspects of the pleading have already been identified as embarrassing. The pleading suffers from the serious difficulty that a number of the allegations contained in it are unsustainable in the light of the res judicata estoppel and issue estoppels generated by the first proceedings. This difficulty is not cured by raising an allegation of fraud in a reply. The question that then arises is whether the proposed ‘second further amended statement of claim’ and the associated ‘third further amended application’ can stand.The Proposed Second Further Amended Statement of Claim The proposed second further amended statement of claim is based on its predecessor with various amendments. It identifies the parties (pars 1-12) and adds the allegation that St George Motor Wholesale was known as Barclays Motor Wholesale Pty Ltd until 6 April 1994 (par 6A). The St George facilities and securities are identified with minor amendments to define terms for each of the facilities (par 13B). It is now alleged, of the Irlmond debenture, that it ‘did not secure the payment or repayment of monies owing by Irlmond to Motor Wholesale’ (par 13E). Irlmond was not liable to St George for money owed by APS to St George, nor did the Irlmond debenture secure such money (par 13F). After describing the respective functions of Irlmond and APS in selling used and new vehicles bailed by St George Motor Wholesale (par 14), the second further amended statement of claim pleads the matters relied upon to establish that the judgment or certain of the findings and orders in the first proceedings were obtained by fraud (pars 14AA-14BI). In substance it is alleged that, in the first proceedings, Irlmond pleaded that St George Wholesale Finance had previously been called Barclays Motor Wholesale Pty Ltd until 6 April 1994 (the Motor Wholesale allegation) (par 14AB). This was a mistake. It was St George Motor Wholesale which had previously been known as Barclays Motor Wholesale Pty Ltd. St George Wholesale Finance was previously known as Barclays Wholesale (Finance) Pty Ltd. It is alleged that ‘St George well knowing the Motor Wholesale allegation to be false, concealed the truth from the Court’ (par 14AE). St George and the receivers ‘admitted the Motor Wholesale allegation’ and St George cross-claimed against Irlmond for sums owing under the Irlmond Bailment Plan Agreement (par 14AC). The allegation of fraud on the facts raised in these proceedings does not, at first blush, seem inherently plausible. It is not in dispute that the true position could have been ascertained upon examination of the relevant transaction documents. The similarity of the names attaching to the various members of the St George Finance group no doubt could be invoked to support an inference that there was a common mistake in the first proceedings.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: FRENCH J

The court considered the serious difficulty that certain allegations in the existing amended statement of claim were unsustainable due to res judicata and issue estoppels generated by the first proceedings. Despite the allegation of fraud in the reply, the court found that this did not cure the pleading's deficiencies. The court further examined the proposed second further amended statement of claim, which introduced new allegations of fraud based on the claim that the Motor Wholesale allegation was knowingly false. However, the court found these allegations not inherently plausible given the availability of relevant transaction documents that could have clarified the true position. The court also noted that the similarity of names within the St George Finance group could suggest a common mistake, but this did not make the fraud allegations plausible on the presented facts. Consequently, the court refused leave to file the second further amended statement of claim and the third amended application. The court's decision established that allegations of fraud, to warrant a new trial, must be inherently plausible and not merely based on the availability of evidence that could have been used in the original proceedings.