DISTRICT COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA
(Civil: Application)
GOODARZI v COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA
[2021] SADC 107
Judgment of his Honour Judge Burnett
16 September 2021
PROCEDURE - CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS - DISCOVERY AND INTERROGATORIES - DISCOVERY AND INSPECTION OF DOCUMENTS - DISCOVERY OF DOCUMENTS - UNDERTAKINGS AND USE OF DOCUMENTS - RELEASE FROM IMPLIED UNDERTAKING
This is an application by Australasian Correctional Services Pty Ltd (ACS) and The GEO Group Australia Pty Ltd (GEO) for release from the implied undertaking to use in other proceedings certain specified documents that were disclosed to them in the course of these proceedings. The documents in question relate to the detention of the applicant at the Woomera and Baxter Immigration Detention Centres.
In these proceedings, the applicant brought claims against the Commonwealth of Australia (the Commonwealth). The Commonwealth defended the proceedings and joined as third parties ACS, GEO, G4S Australia Pty Ltd (G4S) and G4S Regional Management (UK & I) Limited. The detention centres and the system of detention for refugees was established by the Commonwealth, but were operated by G4S and ACS pursuant to a contract with the Commonwealth. The proceedings brought the applicant settled at mediation.
Other detainees have brought similar claims. One of those claims is brought by a Mr Payam Saadat against the Commonwealth, in which ACS, G4S, GEO and G4S Regional Management (UK & I) Limited have been joined as third parties. The Saadat proceeding is currently being heard in the Supreme Court. To date, the proceedings have occupied about eight sitting weeks and are expected to continue for some further time.
In the Saadat proceedings, Mr Saadat has provided a list of witnesses that he intends to call. These witnesses include the applicant in these proceedings, Mr Goodarzi. Mr Goodarzi will give evidence about his detention at Woomera and Baxter Immigration Detention Centres. ACS and GEO seek release from the implied undertaking to use the documents in their cross-examination of Mr Goodarzi when he gives evidence.
Mr Goodarzi opposes the making of an order releasing ACS and GEO from the implied undertaking. The Commonwealth opposes the orders, but G4S does not. Mr Goodarzi did not adduce any evidence or make any submissions in support of his opposition.
Held:
1. ACS and GEO are to be released from the implied undertaking to use the specified documents in the Saadat proceedings.
2.The use of the documents obtained as a result of an order for discovery in these proceedings for the purpose of the cross-examination of Mr Goodarzi in the Saadat proceedings is a use that is for a collateral or ulterior purpose and is prohibited unless ACS and GEO establish special circumstances: Mann v Medical Defence Union Ltd [1997] FCA 45 applied.
3. Special circumstances exist to permit ACS and GEO to be released from the implied undertaking and to use the documents in the Saadat proceedings: Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Marshall Bell Hawkins Limited [2003] FCA 833 and Springfield Nominees Pty Ltd v Bridgeland…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Goodarzi v Commonwealth of Australia and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2021] SADC 107
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the court centred on whether the documents obtained through discovery in the initial proceeding could be used in a different proceeding, and if so, under what circumstances. The court had to determine whether the use of the documents for the purpose of cross-examination in the Saadat proceedings constituted a collateral or ulterior use, which would require the establishment of special circumstances to overcome the implied undertaking. The court also had to consider whether the use of the documents was reasonably required to achieve justice in the Saadat proceedings and whether it would enable the proper testing of Mr Goodarzi’s evidence.
The court found that the use of the documents in the Saadat proceedings was indeed a collateral or ulterior use, as per the decision in Mann v Medical Defence Union Ltd. However, it also found that special circumstances existed to permit the Commonwealth to be released from the implied undertaking and to use the documents in the Saadat proceedings. The court noted that special circumstances did not require extraordinary factors to exist before exercising the discretion, and it was sufficient if good reason was shown for the use of the documents. The court concluded that the use of the documents was reasonably required for the purpose of achieving justice in the Saadat proceedings and would enable Mr Goodarzi’s evidence to be properly tested. The court ordered that the ACS and GEO were to be released from the implied undertaking to use the specified documents in the Saadat proceedings.
The court's decision was based on a careful consideration of the relevant authorities and the particular circumstances of the case. It recognised that the use of documents obtained in one proceeding in another proceeding was generally not permitted, but it also acknowledged that exceptions could be made in appropriate cases. The court found that the special circumstances in this case justified the use of the documents in the Saadat proceedings, and it ordered that the Commonwealth could use the documents for that purpose. This decision provides guidance to parties in similar situations and highlights the importance of considering the specific circumstances of each case when deciding whether to permit the use of documents obtained through discovery in one proceeding in another proceeding.
Orders
Orders of the court
Held:
1. ACS and GEO are to be released from the implied undertaking to use the specified documents in the Saadat proceedings.
2.The use of the documents obtained as a result of an order for discovery in these proceedings for the purpose of the cross-examination of Mr Goodarzi in the Saadat proceedings is a use that is for a collateral or ulterior purpose and is prohibited unless ACS and GEO establish special circumstances: Mann v Medical Defence Union Ltd [1997] FCA 45 applied.
3. Special circumstances exist to permit ACS and GEO to be released from the implied undertaking and to use the documents in the Saadat proceedings: Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Marshall Bell Hawkins Limited [2003] FCA 833 and Springfield Nominees Pty Ltd v Bridgeland Securities Ltd (1992) 38 FCR 217 applied. Special circumstances do not require extraordinary factors to exist before the discretion is exercised. It is sufficient if good reason is shown for the use of the documents, contrary to the usual position that documents or information in one set of proceedings should not be used in another set of proceedings: Liberty Funding Pty Ltd v Phoenix Capital Ltd (2005) 218 ALR 283 applied.
4. Use of the documents are reasonably required for the purpose of achieving justice in the Saadat proceedings and will enable Mr Goodarzi’s evidence in the Saadat proceedings to be properly tested. The Court in the Saadat proceedings will make findings as to the conditions of detention at Woomera and Baxter and in doing so may be informed by the evidence of Mr Goodarzi. Most of the documents were authored by Australasian Correctional Management Pty Ltd (ACM) or form part of its business records.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Full text does not contain this section.