SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA
COURT OF APPEAL
S APCI 2015 0084
| WINKY POP PTY LTD & ANOR | Applicants |
| v | |
| MOBIL REFINING AUSTRALIA PTY LTD & ANOR | Respondents |
---
| JUDGES: | WARREN CJ, ASHLEY and OSBORN JJA |
| WHERE HELD: | MELBOURNE |
| DATE OF HEARING: | 23 May 2016 |
| DATE OF JUDGMENT: | 5 August 2016 |
| MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION: | [2016] VSCA 187 |
| JUDGMENT APPEALED FROM: | [2015] VSC 348 (Digby J) |
---
TORTS – Damages – Damage to land – Claim for loss of opportunity damages – Claims for diminution in value of land or cost of reinstatement not pursued – Opportunity allegedly lost was opportunity to have land rezoned from industrial to residential use and to obtain a planning permit for residential development – Whether judge erred in concluding that plaintiffs had failed to establish existence of opportunity as alleged – Whether judge erred in concluding that defendant’s admitted breach of duties was immaterial to whether land could be rezoned and residentially developed – No error in judge’s conclusions.
TORTS – Damages – Damage to land – Usual basis of assessing damages is diminution in value or else cost of reinstatement, together with consequential damages in certain circumstances – Whether damages for loss of opportunity may be awarded in substitution for usual bases of assessment – Principles relevant to awarding loss of opportunity damages – Sellars v Adelaide Petroleum NL (1994) 179 CLR 332 – Critical question is what basis of assessment will most appropriately ensure an award of fair and reasonable compensation in the particular case – Risk of overcompensating plaintiff if damages assessed on loss of opportunity basis avoided if due account taken of probabilities and possibilities, but reliability of assessment made on alternative bases in the particular case relevant to basis selected.
PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – Evidence – Application to adduce further evidence on appeal – Evidence not precisely identified – Whether proposed evidence related to ‘comparable land’ – Whether, so far as proposed evidence was in existence before the trial concluded with publication of reasons and entry of judgment, there was a high degree of probability, if evidence received at trial, that result of proceeding would have been different – Whether, so far as proposed evidence came into existence after trial, it would satisfy test stated in Foody v Horewood [2007] VSCA 307 – Application refused.
---
| APPEARANCES: | Counsel | Solicitors |
| For the Applicants | Mr C M Scerri QC with Mr S R Senathirajah and Ms M H Foley | King & Wood Mallesons |
| For the First Respondent | Mr C M Caleo QC with Ms P Neskovcin and Ms F C Spencer | Ashurst Australia |
| For the Second Respondent | Mr S R Horgan QC with Ms E Latif | Clayton Utz |
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Circumstances generally described
The writ
The applicants’ claim as pursued at trial
The evidence at trial
The judge’s reasons
Proposed grounds of appeal
The application to adduce further evidence
Reasons for refusal of application for leave to adduce further evidence
Grounds 1 to 4
Planning controls
Planning history
The opinion evidence
The…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Winky Pop Pty Ltd v Mobil Refining Australia Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2016] VSCA 187
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues addressed by the court were whether the judge had erred in concluding that the plaintiffs had not proven the existence of the opportunity as alleged, and whether the judge had erred in concluding that Mobil's admitted breach of duties was irrelevant to the potential rezoning and development of the land. Additionally, the court examined whether damages for loss of opportunity could be awarded in lieu of the usual bases of assessment for damage to land, which typically involve diminution in value or the cost of reinstatement, along with consequential damages under certain circumstances.
The court found no error in the judge's conclusions. It was established that the plaintiffs had not proven the existence of the opportunity as alleged, and that Mobil's breach of duty was immaterial to the potential rezoning and residential development of the land. The court further explained that while damages for loss of opportunity could be awarded, the critical question is what basis of assessment will most appropriately ensure fair and reasonable compensation in the particular case. The court noted that the risk of overcompensation when assessing damages based on loss of opportunity can be mitigated if the probabilities and possibilities are duly considered. However, the reliability of the assessment made on alternative bases in the specific case is also relevant to the basis selected.
The court also considered an application to adduce further evidence on appeal. The proposed evidence was not precisely identified, but it was suggested that it related to 'comparable land.' The court determined that there was no high degree of probability that the outcome would have been different if the evidence had been received at the trial. The application to adduce further evidence was therefore refused.
Background
Background to the litigation
The case was initially heard in the Supreme Court of Victoria. The judge found in favour of the defendant, concluding that the plaintiffs had not established the existence of the opportunity as alleged and that the defendant's breach of duties was immaterial to whether the land could be rezoned and residentially developed. The plaintiffs appealed to the Court of Appeal, arguing that the judge had erred in these conclusions. The Court of Appeal considered the appeal and ultimately dismissed it, upholding the original decision of the Supreme Court.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the judge erred in concluding that the plaintiffs had failed to establish the existence of the opportunity as alleged.
2. Whether the judge erred in concluding that the defendant’s admitted breach of duties was immaterial to whether the land could be rezoned and residentially developed.
Held
1. The court held that the judge did not err in concluding that the plaintiffs had failed to establish the existence of the opportunity as alleged. The plaintiffs claimed that they had an opportunity to have the land rezoned from industrial to residential use and to obtain a planning permit for residential development. The court found that the plaintiffs did not provide sufficient evidence to establish the existence of this opportunity.
2. The court also held that the judge did not err in concluding that the defendant’s admitted breach of duties was immaterial to whether the land could be rezoned and residentially developed. The court found that even if the defendant had not breached their duties, it would not have necessarily resulted in the land being rezoned and a planning permit being granted for residential development.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court considered the principles relevant to awarding loss of opportunity damages, citing Sellars v Adelaide Petroleum NL. The critical question is what basis of assessment will most appropriately ensure an award of fair and reasonable compensation in the particular case. The risk of overcompensating the plaintiff if damages are assessed on a loss of opportunity basis can be avoided if due account is taken of the probabilities and possibilities, but the reliability of the assessment made on alternative bases in the particular case is also relevant to the basis selected. In this case, the court found that the plaintiffs did not provide sufficient evidence to establish the existence of the opportunity to have the land rezoned and obtain a planning permit for residential development. The court also found that the defendant’s admitted breach of duties was immaterial to whether the land could be rezoned and residentially developed. The court did not find any error in the judge’s conclusions on these issues. Regarding the application to adduce further evidence on appeal, the court found that the proposed evidence was not precisely identified and did not meet the tests set out in Foody v Horewood. Therefore, the application was refused.