A.P. Motors (No 2) Pty Ltd v Balfour

Link copied
Case Copied 73 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

A.P. Motors (No 2) Pty Ltd v Balfour [2024] QSC 18

PARTIES:

A.P. MOTORS (NO 2) PTY LTD
ACN 010 585 243

(plaintiff)

v
SANDRA BALFOUR

(first defendant)

AND

STEWART ALEXANDER BALFOUR
(second defendant)

AND

MICHAEL DAVID BALFOUR
(third defendant)

FILE NO/S:

BS No 5288 of 2018

DIVISION:

Trial

PROCEEDING:

Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

16 February 2024

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

3–6 April 2023

Further submissions received 23 May 2023 (plaintiff); and 24 May 2023 (third defendant)

JUDGE:

Brown J

ORDER:

1.   The plaintiff is to pay the defendant his costs of the proceedings, including the costs of the Freezing Order on a standard basis until February 2020.

2.   The plaintiff is to pay the defendant his costs of the proceedings including the costs of the Freezing Order on an indemnity basis after March 2020.

3.   The third defendant’s application for compensation pursuant to the Undertaking be dismissed.

CATCHWORDS:

INDEMNITY COSTS – STANDARD COSTS – DISCRETION – whether plaintiff had no reasonable cause of action against the third defendant - whether the plaintiff acted unreasonably in conduct of litigation – whether plaintiff unduly prolonged allegations against the third defendant for which there was no reasonable cause of action – whether the plaintiff unreasonably delayed the proceedings or otherwise acted unreasonably

FREEZING ORDERS – USUAL UNDERTAKING UPON GRANT OF FREEZING ORDER – COMPENSATION – COSTS – LOSS OF OPPORTUNITY – CALCULATION OF DAMAGES BY REFERENCE TO PROBABILITIES – whether the third defendant is entitled to compensation pursuant to an undertaking given for a freezing order - where the third defendant must show damage caused by freezing order as distinct from being caused by existence of litigation – whether costs can be claimed as compensation under an undertaking – whether the third defendant is entitled to compensation under an undertaking for loss of opportunity to purchase property – whether compensation for distress is available under an undertaking – whether compensation for loss of inheritance is available under an undertaking

Legal Profession Act 2007 (Qld) ss 316, 341, 705
Uniform Civil Procedures Rules 1999 (Qld) rr 5, 171, 260A, 293, 389, 444, 658

Air Express Ltd v Ansett Transport Industries (Operations) Pty Ltd (1981) 146 CLR 249
Al-Rawas v Pegasus Energy Ltd [2008] EWHC 617
Badenach v Calvert (2016) 257 CLR 440
Baltic Shipping Company v Dillon (1993) 176 CLR 344
Beach Retreat Pty Ltd v Mooloolaba Marina Ltd [2009] 2 Qd R 356
Cockburn v Edwards [1881] UKLawRpCh 203
Colgate-Palmolive Co v Cussons Pty Ltd (1993) 46 FCR 225
European Bank Ltd v Evans (2010) 240 CLR 432
First Mortgage Finance Corp Ltd v Kace Management Pty Ltd [2009] QSC 319
Flegg v Hallett [2015] 1 Qd R 191
Hamod v New South Wales (2002) 188 ALR 659
Hunt v Ubhi [2023] EWCA Civ 417
JSC Mezhdunarodniy Promyshlenniy Bank v Pugachev [2015] EWCA Civ 139
Latoudis v Casey (1990) 170 CLR  534
Laws v Collins Exposed Aggregate Pty Ltd [1997] NSWCA…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read A.P. Motors (No 2) Pty Ltd v Balfour and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] QSC 18
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of A.P. Motors (No 2) Pty Ltd v Balfour, the plaintiff sought to recover costs from the defendants, including a claim for compensation under an undertaking given in relation to a Freezing Order. The Court was required to determine whether the plaintiff had a reasonable cause of action against the third defendant, whether the plaintiff acted unreasonably in the conduct of the litigation, and if the third defendant was entitled to compensation under an undertaking. The plaintiff argued that the proceedings against the third defendant were wrongly brought and that the third defendant was not entitled to compensation for the loss of opportunity to purchase property or for distress and loss of inheritance. The third defendant contended that the proceedings were wrongly brought and that the loss claimed was foreseeable at the time the Freezing Order was granted.

The Court held that there were difficulties in the proposition that the proceedings were wrongly brought against the third defendant. The Court noted that the third defendant had legal representation in relation to the Freezing Order and did not contest its grant. Furthermore, the Court found that the third defendant was in a different position to the other defendants, as he shared joint bank accounts and jointly owned the property. The Court concluded that the loss claimed was not of a kind that could have been reasonably foreseen. The Court also found that the plaintiff was not entitled to compensation under the undertaking, as the third defendant had not established a causal link between the Freezing Order and the loss claimed.

The Court ordered that the plaintiff pay the third defendant standard costs of the proceedings until February 2020 and indemnity costs from March 2020 until the proceedings were dismissed. The Court further dismissed the third defendant's application for compensation under the undertaking. The Court directed that the plaintiff deliver its submissions on costs on 8 March 2024 and the third defendant deliver his submissions on 15 March 2024.

ORDERS:
1. The plaintiff is to pay the defendant his costs of the proceedings, including the costs of the Freezing Order on a standard basis until February 2020.
2. The plaintiff is to pay the defendant his costs of the proceedings including the costs of the Freezing Order on an indemnity basis after March 2020.
3. The third defendant’s application for compensation pursuant to the Undertaking be dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The plaintiff is to pay the defendant his costs of the proceedings, including the costs of the Freezing Order on a standard basis until February 2020.

2. The plaintiff is to pay the defendant his costs of the proceedings including the costs of the Freezing Order on an indemnity basis after March 2020.

3. The third defendant’s application for compensation pursuant to the Undertaking be dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

As to the notion that the proceedings were wrongly brought against Stewart on the same basis as Michael, there are a number of difficulties with that proposition. First, Stewart had legal representation in relation to the Freezing Order and did not contend that the Freezing Order should not be made. Secondly, the proceedings against Michael were dismissed in June 2021. Stewart was informed that the criminal charges against him would be dropped on 9 June 2021. Notwithstanding that, he took no steps to have the Freezing Order dismissed against him. While Counsel for Michael referred to the same evidence he had relied on in relation to Michael to say there was no case, Stewart was in a different position to Michael insofar as he shared the joint bank accounts into which large amounts of money alleged to be misappropriated were paid. the property was jointly owned by Sandra and Stewart and the allegation made against him were different. As to the question of whether the loss claimed is foreseeable at the time the Freezing Order was granted, Counsel for Michael contends that the proper question was whether property frozen cannot be dealt with by a registered proprietor in a way in which he ordinarily could and any loss that flows from that inability to so deal with it which would include the property being disposed of under that person’s Will. However the loss claimed is that suffered by a beneficiary under the Will said to arise because the party to a Freezing Order could not sever a tenancy to leave the beneficiary the property the subject of the Freezing Order. In circumstances where the Freezing Order was against both property owners and there was no evidence that Stewart was in ill health at the time of the making of the order, loss was not of a kind that could have been reasonably foreseen. Summary of Conclusions Michael has been successful insofar as the Court has determined he is to be paid standard costs of the proceedings up until February 2020 and indemnity costs from March 2020 until the proceedings were dismissed. As to the claims for compensation, I do not find that Michael has established an entitlement to compensation under the undertaking. The Court orders that:(a)The plaintiff is to pay the defendant:(i)His costs of the proceedings, including the costs of the Freezing Order on a standard basis until February 2020;(ii)His costs of the proceedings including the costs of the Freezing Order on an indemnity basis after March 2020.(b)The third defendant’s application for compensation pursuant to the Undertaking be dismissed. I will hear submissions from the parties as to costs of the third defendant’s application filed 26 May 2022 at a time to be agreed between the Court and the parties in the week of 26 February 2024 unless the Orders can be agreed between the parties. When judgment was delivered, following submissions of the parties, the Court gave directions for the delivery of submissions as to costs if the costs order could not be agreed. The Court therefore directed that the plaintiff would deliver its submissions on 8 March 2024 and the third defendant will deliver his submissions on 15 March 2024.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.