Winky Pop Pty Ltd v Mobil Refining Australia Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 67 min read
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA AT MELBOURNE Not Restricted

COMMON LAW DIVISION

VALUATION, COMPENSATION & PLANNING LIST

S CI 2009 6345

WINKY POP PTY LTD (ACN 082 744 769) and
OR AUSTRALIA PTY LTD (ACN 073 102 520)
Plaintiffs
v
MOBIL REFINING AUSTRALIA PTY LTD (ACN 004 300 163) and THE STATE OF VICTORIA First Defendant
Second Defendant

---

JUDGE:

Digby J

WHERE HELD:

Melbourne

DATE OF HEARING:

3-7, 11-12, 19-21 June, 21-23 October 2013 and 12-13 February 2014

DATE OF JUDGMENT:

13 July 2015

CASE MAY BE CITED AS:

Winky Pop & anor v Mobil & anor

MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION:

[2015] VSC 348

---

TORT – Negligence – Nuisance – Duty of care and breach of duty admitted – Leak of petroleum hydrocarbons contaminating the groundwater beneath the plaintiffs’ land – Plaintiffs’ land undeveloped – Application for mandatory injunction abandoned – Dispute as to the appropriate measure of damages – Loss of opportunity involving profits for the development of land – Damages for the diminution in value of land – Pipelines Act2005.

DAMAGES – Diminution in value – Change in market value of the land caused by contamination from the leak – Diminution in value accepted as the appropriate measure of damages.

DAMAGES – Loss of opportunity – Did an opportunity to develop the land residentially exist – Was that opportunity lost because of the contamination from the leak – Valuation of the alleged opportunity – Sellars v Adelaide Petroleum NL (1994) 179 CLR 332, applied.

DAMAGES — Assessment of claims for loss of profit.

---

APPEARANCES:

Counsel Solicitors
For the Plaintiffs Mr C Scerri QC with Ms M Foley King & Wood Mallesons
For the First Defendant Mr P Riordan SC with Ms P Neskovcin and Ms F Spencer Ashurst Australia
For the Second Defendant Mr S Horgan SC with Ms E Latif Clayton Utz

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Introduction......................................................................................................................................... 1

Summary of Findings........................................................................................................................ 3

Chronology.......................................................................................................................................... 4

Pre-leak........................................................................................................................................... 4

Planning law framework.................................................................................................................. 5

Planning history pre-leak................................................................................................................. 7

L14 Amendment............................................................................................................................ 7

1998 Application for 107 warehouses........................................................................................ 7

C1 Amendment.............................................................................................................................. 7

2006 Application for 69 warehouses.......................................................................................... 8

The leak and clean-up response...................................................................................................... 8

Planning history post-leak............................................................................................................. 11

C33 Amendment.......................................................................................................................... 11

C74 Amendment.......................................................................................................................... 13

The plaintiffs’ pleaded case........................................................................................................... 13

Mobil’s pleaded case....................................................................................................................... 16

State’s liability to be determined separately............................................................................... 17

The plaintiffs’ submission calling for inferences to be drawn against the State................. 22

Adverse inference sought in relation to potential rezoning evidence................................ 22

The State’s pleaded case................................................................................................................. 23

Negligence and nuisance................................................................................................................ 26

Damages for torts affecting land................................................................................................... 32

Plaintiffs’ submissions............................................................................................................... 32

Mobil’s submissions................................................................................................................... 36

The State’s submissions............................................................................................................. 37

What is the appropriate measure of damages for torts affecting land? In General – diminution in value – reinstatement of costs.......................................................................................... 39

Conclusion as to the appropriate measure of damages............................................................ 55

Plaintiffs have no special value in the land............................................................................ 58

Other suitable development properties.................................................................................. 58

Circumstances rendering diminution in value damages more appropriate and just than loss of opportunity damages....................................................................................................... 61

Conclusion................................................................................................................................... 63

Damages for loss of opportunity................................................................................................... 64

Plaintiffs’…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Winky Pop Pty Ltd v Mobil Refining Australia Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] VSC 348
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Winky Pop Pty Ltd brought a claim against Mobil Refining Australia Pty Ltd for damages arising from the contamination of Winky Pop’s land by petroleum hydrocarbons leaking from Mobil’s pipeline. The parties admitted that Mobil owed a duty of care to Winky Pop, breached that duty, and that the breach caused the contamination. The dispute was over the appropriate measure of damages. The Federal Circuit Court was tasked with determining whether the proper measure of damages was the diminution in value of Winky Pop’s land or a loss of opportunity for profit.

The court was required to determine whether the contamination destroyed an opportunity to develop the land for residential purposes and whether the opportunity was lost due to the contamination. The court needed to apply the principles established in Sellars v Adelaide Petroleum NL (1994) 179 CLR 332 to assess the valuation of the lost opportunity. The court also needed to decide whether the diminution in value of the land was an appropriate measure of damages under the circumstances.

The court found that the appropriate measure of damages was the diminution in value of the land. It held that the land had no market value prior to the contamination and therefore no diminution in value could be claimed. However, the contamination had caused a change in the market value of the land, and this was accepted as the appropriate measure of damages. The court rejected the argument that the opportunity to develop the land had been lost, finding that the opportunity was too speculative and uncertain to be compensable. The court held that the diminution in value of the land, as assessed by expert evidence, was the appropriate measure of damages.

The court ordered Mobil to pay Winky Pop damages for the diminution in value of the land, as assessed by expert evidence. The court did not award damages for loss of opportunity as it found the claim to be speculative and uncertain. The court found that the diminution in value of the land was the appropriate measure of damages in this case, given that the land was undeveloped and had no market value prior to the contamination.