Taulahi v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection

Link copied
Case Copied 76 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Taulahi v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2016] FCAFC 177

File numbers: NSD 585 of 2016
NSD 872 of 2016
SAD 164 of 2016
Judges: KENNY, FLICK AND GRIFFITHS JJ
Date of judgment: 14 December 2016
Catchwords:

MIGRATION – Mr Taulahi’s visa cancelled under s 501(3) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) – character grounds – failure to take into account legal consequences of cancellation decision – where passing character test is a condition for revocation of cancellation – futility of making representations

MIGRATION – Mr Taulahi’s and Mr Carrascalao’s visas cancelled – whether cancellation in the national interest pursuant to s 501(3)(d) – formation of reasonable suspicion – has been or is a member of a group which has been or is involved in criminal conduct – misconstruction of legislative provisions – jurisdictional error

MIGRATION – power to provide information to visa holder – whether s 503A prohibits disclosure – natural justice not to apply – limited circumstances in which Minister can disclose s 503A information – no misconstruction of disclosure powers

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – legal nature of a suspended sentence – whether Minister misunderstood the character of a sentence not involving imprisonment on condition of good behaviour – Minister’s conclusion that conduct was “serious” – need to construe reasons fairly and as a whole

CONSTITUTIONAL LAW – Mr Stevens’ visa cancelled under s 501(3) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) – whether Mr Stevens was an alien for the purposes of s 51(xix) of the Constitution – application of Shaw v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2003] HCA 72; 218 CLR 28

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – adjourning grounds raising issues arising under the Constitution – pending High Court hearing

Legislation:

Crimes (Sentencing Procedure) Act1999 (NSW), s12

Migration Act 1958 (Cth), ss 14, 501(3), 501(4), 501(6)(a), 501(6)(b), 501(7), 501C, 501C(3), 501C(4), 503A, 503A(1), 503A(2)

Migration Amendment (Character and General Visa Cancellation) Act 2014 (Cth)

Constitution, ss 7, 8, 15, 24, 25, 30, 128, 51(xix)

Cases cited:

AEK15 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2016] FCAFC 131

Al-Kateb v Godwin [2004] HCA 37; 219 CLR 562

Assistant Treasurer v Cathay Pacific Airways Limited [2009] FCAFC 105; 179 FCR 323

Ayoub v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2015] FCAFC 83; 231 FCR 513

AZAFQ v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2015] FCA 681

Cayzer v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2016] FCAFC 176

Coco v The Queen [1994] HCA 15; 179 CLR 427

Cotterill v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2016] FCAFC 61; 240 FCR 29

Cunliffe v Commonwealth [1994] HCA 44; 182 CLR 272

Grain Pool of Western Australia v Commonwealth [2000] HCA 14; 202 CLR 479

Lee v New South Wales Crime Commission [2013] HCA 39; 251 CLR 196

Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v Eden [2016] FCAFC 28; 240 FCR 158

Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v Le [2016] FCAFC 120

Minister for Immigration and Citizenship…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Taulahi v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] FCAFC 177
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Taulahi v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection involved the applicants Tomasi Taulahi, Jose Carrascalao, and David Stevens, whose visas were cancelled under section 501(3) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth). The applicants sought judicial review of the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection's decision to cancel their visas on character grounds. The applicants argued that the Minister failed to consider the legal consequences of the cancellation decision and misconstrued the legislative provisions. The Minister argued that the cancellation was in the national interest and that there was no obligation to consider the legal consequences of the cancellation decision. The applicants also sought access to protected information withheld from them and argued that the Minister misconstrued the legal nature of a suspended sentence. The applicants further contended that section 503A of the Migration Act was beyond the legislative competence of the Commonwealth Parliament.

The court was required to decide whether the Minister failed to consider the legal consequences of the cancellation decision, whether the Minister misconstrued the legislative provisions, whether the Minister was required to provide information in advance, and whether the Minister misconstrued the legal nature of a suspended sentence. The court also had to determine whether section 503A of the Migration Act was beyond the legislative competence of the Commonwealth Parliament and whether the applicants were aliens for the purposes of section 51(xix) of the Constitution.

The court held that the Minister did not fail to consider the legal consequences of the cancellation decision and that there was no obligation to consider the legal consequences of the cancellation decision. The court held that the Minister misconstrued the legislative provisions in finding that the applicants had been or were involved in criminal conduct. The court held that the Minister was not required to provide information in advance and that there was no misconstruction of the legal nature of a suspended sentence. The court held that section 503A of the Migration Act was not beyond the legislative competence of the Commonwealth Parliament and that the applicants were aliens for the purposes of section 51(xix) of the Constitution.

The court dismissed the proceedings brought by each of the applicants. The court held that the Minister did not fail to consider the legal consequences of the cancellation decision and that there was no obligation to consider the legal consequences of the cancellation decision. The court held that the Minister misconstrued the legislative provisions in finding that the applicants had been or were involved in criminal conduct. The court held that the Minister was not required to provide information in advance and that there was no misconstruction of the legal nature of a suspended sentence. The court held that section 503A of the Migration Act was not beyond the legislative competence of the Commonwealth Parliament and that the applicants were aliens for the purposes of section 51(xix) of the Constitution. The court dismissed the proceedings brought by each of the applicants.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The parties have liberty to file any submissions (limited to 3 pages) no later than 4 pm on 22 December 2016 as to whether the hearing and determination of ground 6 of the Further Amended Originating Application should proceed before Charlesworth J or before this Full Court.

2. No later than 4 pm on 22 December 2016, the parties file submissions (limited to 3 pages) as to the costs of the proceeding to date in the Full Court.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

TABLE OF CONTENTS

INTRODUCTION

[1]

THE FACTUAL BACKGROUND

[15]

Mr Taulahi

[16]

Mr Carrascalao

[23]

Mr Stevens

[29]

THE STATUTORY PROVISIONS

[36]

THE GROUNDS OF REVIEW RESOLVED

[40]

(a) A failure to have regard to the legal consequences of the Minister’s decisions

[46]

(i) Did the Minister fail to consider the legal consequences of the cancellations made under s 501(3)?

[53]

(ii) Was there an obligation to consider the legal consequences of a cancellation decision under s 501(3)?

[79]

The decision of the Full Court in NBMZ

[80]

Consistency of approach with High Court authority

[86]

The reasoning in Roach

[89]

The decisions in Tanielu and Stevens

[94]

Disposition of the first common ground

[100]

(b) Has been or is a member and has been or is involved in criminal conduct – a disconformity in the Minister’s fact finding?

[101]

Disposition of the second common ground

[149]

(c) The provision of information in advance

[151]

Disposition of the third common ground

[173]

Mr Carrascalao’s additional ground – the legal nature of a suspended sentence

[174]

Is Mr Stevens an alien or one of the people of the Commonwealth?

[185]

CONCLUSIONS

[205]

Background

Background to the litigation

The argument in the proceeding commenced by Mr Stevens which was deferred pending the decision of this Court focussed upon the invalidity of s 503A. As with the proceedings commenced by Messrs Taulahi and Carrascalao, the s 503A argument is to be adjourned pending the decisions of the High Court; the argument founded upon Mr Stevens not being an “alien” is now resolved and is rejected for reasons given below.THE FACTUAL BACKGROUND Although the resolution of the grounds of review that have presently prevailed may be resolved largely by reference to the Minister’s statements of reasons, it is prudent nevertheless to set forth the factual background which gave rise to the Minister taking action to cancel the visa of each Applicant.Mr Taulahi Mr Tomasi Taulahi was born in Tonga and is a national of that country. He first arrived in Australia in December 1988. He was then 12 years old. He was granted a Class UA Transitional (Temporary) visa in December 1989. An application for a Refugee and Humanitarian visa was lodged in 1993, with Mr Taulahi named as a dependant applicant. That application was refused and the Refugee Review Tribunal affirmed the decision refusing the visa in March 1997. Mr Taulahi thereafter remained unlawfully in Australia until he was granted a Class WE Subclass 050 Bridging Visa in October 2007. He was granted a number of further visas with his final bridging visa ceasing in August 2008. The Minister intervened in 2010 and Mr Taulahi was granted a Class BS Subclass 801 Partner visa – a permanent visa. Of present relevance is the provision to the Department of Immigration and Border Protection (the Department) of an information report prepared by the Australian Crime Commission in December 2015. Further information was provided for the consideration of the Minister which was said to be protected by reason of s 503A of the Migration Act. The information in the Australian Crime Commission’s report included “several images … in which Mr Taulahi is shown in Lone Wolf Outlaw Motorcycle Gang … colours…”. When making his decision, the Minister had placed before him an Issues Paper, which included a number of annexures. In addition to information provided by the Australian Crime Commission and the Protected Information provided under s 503A, the other annexures varied from a summary of Mr Taulahi’s visa history; a media article and a media release; letters of support; and personal information such as a birth certificate and a marriage certificate. The Minister concluded that Mr Taulahi did not pass the character test by reason of s 501(6)(b). Mr Taulahi filed an Originating Application seeking judicial review of the Minister’s decision in April 2016. A Notice to Produce seeking the Protected Information was served on the Minister in May. An Amended Originating Application was filed in June 2016, which added grounds 4 to 11. Leave was granted at the hearing for Mr Taulahi to file a Further Amended Originating Application. Mr Carrascalao

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The three common grounds which are resolved are addressed below. As will emerge:(a)the first ground is resolved in favour of Mr Taulahi, but not Mr Carrascalao;(b)the second ground is resolved in favour of both Mr Taulahi and Mr Carrascalao; and(c)the third ground is rejected in the cases of both Mr Taulahi and Mr Carrascalao. (a) A failure to have regard to the legal consequences of the Minister’s decisions The first of the three grounds addresses the contention advanced by both Mr Taulahi and Mr Carrascalao that the Minister failed to have regard “to the statutory and/or legal consequences of his decision” under s 501(3). In Mr Taulahi’s proceeding the argument is raised by ground 8 of his Further Amended Originating Application, which provides as follows:8.The Minister unlawfully failed to have regard to the statutory and/or legal consequences of his decision.Particulars(i)The Minister was obliged to have regard to the statutory and legal consequences of visa cancellation.(ii)Those consequences included that:a.the necessary and sufficient condition for the exercise of the revocation power under s 501C(4) is that the affected person satisfies the Minister that the person passes the character test;b.accordingly, save for when making the cancellation decision, there is no statutory occasion for the Minister to consider discretionary factors or factors not bearing on the Minister’s satisfaction that a person does not pass the character test, including the effect of the cancellation decision on the interests of the person's children, family and business interests, and whether the person is in general of good character;c.any representations or submissions made by the applicant under s 501C(4), or any information otherwise available to the Minister after the making of the cancellation decision, which went to those factors would be irrelevant to the course of the Minister's decision-making;d.the position would be different if the Minister exercised his power under s 501(1) because the person would then be afforded natural justice and would have an opportunity to make representations or submissions going to the effect of the cancellation decision on the person's children and family and as to the person's general good character.(iii)The Minister was not informed of and did not have regard to the matters in (ii) above when making the cancellation decision. In Mr Carrascalao’s proceeding, the corresponding ground is ground 5. As the Minister’s statements of reasons in both Taulahi and Carrascalao indicate, the Minister may, and in these cases did, consider a range of matters in making his decision under s 501(3). A number of these matters related to his exercise of discretion and were likely to have had significant human implications. In the absence of information from the visa holder, the Minister may very well proceed without knowledge of the true facts. This possibility is highlighted in Taulahi and Carrascalao by the Minister’s references in his statements of reasons to his lack of information on some potentially significant matters viewed in human terms.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In each of these proceedings the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection has made a decision to cancel the visa of each Applicant in reliance upon s 501(3) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (the Migration Act). In making each of these decisions, the Minister had before him an Issues Paper which included information withheld from each of the Applicants. The information withheld has been variously referred to as the “Secret Information” or the “Protected Information”. In withholding that information, the Minister relies on s 503A of the Migration Act. If valid, s 503A potentially authorises the withholding of the protected information from not only each of the Applicants but the Court itself. Common to all three proceedings is the validity of s 503A. The Applicants contend that s 503A is beyond the legislative competence of the Commonwealth Parliament. One of the bases upon which this contention is advanced is that the withholding of information from the Court invalidly permits the Minister to effectively determine the limits of his own power and therefore offends Chapter III of the Constitution. The proceeding commenced by Mr Stevens raises an additional argument not relied upon by either Mr Taulahi or Mr Carrascalao. In Mr Stevens’ case, it is common ground that Mr Stevens was entitled to vote and has in fact voted at a number of federal elections. He separately contends that s 501(3) as it applies to him is beyond the legislative power conferred upon the Commonwealth Parliament by s 51(xix) of the Constitution. The Chief Justice made a determination pursuant to s 20(1A) of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) that the proceedings are to be heard and resolved by the Court as presently constituted. In each proceeding the Applicant also sets forth in his Originating Application (as amended) a series of grounds of review seeking to impugn the relevant decision. In the proceeding commenced by Mr Stevens, some of his grounds of review have been considered and rejected by Charlesworth J and one ground (ground 3) has been deferred pending the determination by this Court of two other grounds (grounds 5 and 6): Stevens v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2016] FCA 1280 (Stevens). All of the grounds of review remain to be resolved in the other two proceedings. In Mr Taulahi’s proceeding there were initially eleven grounds of review; in Mr Carrascalao’s proceeding, there were nine grounds of review. There is a substantial overlap in the grounds of review in those two proceedings. But Mr Carrascalao relies upon one additional ground not relied upon by Mr Taulahi. In advancing two of the grounds of review in Mr Taulahi’s and Mr Carrascalao’s proceedings, access is sought to the Protected Information. In each of those proceedings a Notice to Produce has been served requiring production of that information. The Minister resists production but is prepared to provide to the Court and to the Applicants’ legal representatives a redacted version. In resisting production, the Minister:·seeks to rely upon the prohibition on disclosure set forth in s 503A; and·foreshadows that a claim may be made for public interest immunity privilege (which was formerly known as “Crown privilege”).Submissions in respect to those affected grounds of review cannot proceed without resolution of the question whether access is to be granted to the information withheld. It would have been preferable for any claim for privilege to have been made at the same time as argument relating to the withholding of information pursuant to s 503A.