Plaintiff M47/2018 v Minister for Home Affairs

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

KIEFEL CJ,
BELL, GAGELER, KEANE, NETTLE, GORDON AND EDELMAN JJ

PLAINTIFF M47/2018  PLAINTIFF

AND

MINISTER FOR HOME AFFAIRS & ANOR  DEFENDANTS

Plaintiff M47/2018 v Minister for Home Affairs

[2019] HCA 17

Date of Order:  13 February 2019
Date of Publication of Reasons:  12 June 2019

M47/2018

ORDER

The questions stated in the special case for the opinion of the Full Court are answered as follows:

1.On their proper construction, do ss 189 and 196 of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) authorise the present detention of the plaintiff?

Answer:Does not arise.

2.If so, are those provisions beyond the legislative power of the Commonwealth insofar as they apply to the plaintiff?

Answer:Does not arise.

3.What relief, if any, should issue to the plaintiff?

Answer:None.

4.Who should pay the costs of and incidental to this special case?

Answer:The plaintiff.

Representation

R Merkel QC with L T Livingston, E M Nekvapil and C G Winnett for the plaintiff (instructed by Human Rights for All Pty Ltd)

S P Donaghue QC, Solicitor-General of the Commonwealth, with P D Herzfeld and Z C Heger for the defendants (instructed by Australian Government Solicitor)

Australian Human Rights Commission appearing as amicus curiae, limited to its written submissions

Notice:  This copy of the Court's Reasons for Judgment is subject to formal revision prior to publication in the Commonwealth Law Reports.

Immigration – Unlawful non-citizens – Detention pending removal from Australia – Where s 189 of Migration Act 1958 (Cth) requires unlawful non‑citizen be detained – Where s 196 requires unlawful non-citizen detained under s 189 be kept in immigration detention – Where plaintiff an unlawful non‑citizen – Where plaintiff arrived in migration zone using false passport and personal details – Where plaintiff kept in immigration detention since arrival in migration zone – Where plaintiff previously used false personal details – Where plaintiff's identity and nationality not known – Whether ss 189 and 196 authorise plaintiff's detention – Whether ss 189 and 196 constitutionally valid in application to plaintiff.

High Court – Original jurisdiction – Practice – Special case – Drawing of inferences – Where factual basis of questions of law depends on drawing inferences under r 27.08.5 of High Court Rules 2004 (Cth) – Where inferences concern likelihood of plaintiff's future removal from Australia – Where prospects of plaintiff's future removal depend on information provided by plaintiff and cooperation by plaintiff – Where plaintiff made false statements and failed to assist and cooperate – Where plaintiff gave inconsistent accounts of personal and family background – Where plaintiff seeks to take advantage of falsehoods and non-cooperation – Whether inferences can be drawn.

Words and phrases – "habeas corpus", "identity", "immigration detention", "inferences", "onus of proof", "prospects of removal", "real prospect", "reasonably foreseeable", "special case", "unlawful non-citizen".

High Court Rules 2004 (Cth), r 27.08.5.
Migration Act 1958 (Cth), ss 189, 196, 198.

  1. KIEFEL CJ, KEANE, NETTLE AND EDELMAN JJ. Section 189 of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) ("the Act")…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Plaintiff M47/2018 v Minister for Home Affairs and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] HCA 17
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In *Plaintiff M47/2018 v Minister for Home Affairs*, the High Court of Australia considered a special case concerning the immigration detention of an unlawful non-citizen. The plaintiff, who arrived in Australia using false identity documents, had been detained since his arrival. The Minister for Home Affairs relied on sections 189 and 196 of the *Migration Act 1958* (Cth) to authorise the plaintiff's ongoing detention. The plaintiff challenged the lawfulness of this detention, arguing that these provisions no longer authorised it or, alternatively, that their application to him exceeded the Commonwealth's legislative power.

The central legal issues before the Court were whether sections 189 and 196 of the *Migration Act* authorised the plaintiff's continued detention, and if so, whether these provisions were constitutionally valid in their application to him. A key factual element underpinning these questions was the plaintiff's identity and the prospects of his removal from Australia. The plaintiff contended that the inability of the authorities to establish his identity meant there was no practical possibility of his removal, thereby rendering his detention unlawful.

The Court, in its joint reasons, addressed the plaintiff's invitation to draw specific inferences from the facts presented in the special case. It applied the principle that evidence is weighed according to what a party could have produced or contradicted, noting that the plaintiff, not the defendants, was in the best position to provide information regarding his identity and place of origin. The Court concluded that the plaintiff's inconsistent statements about his background did not demonstrate genuine uncertainty or ignorance, and therefore, it could not be assumed that he was unable to provide further information that might improve his prospects of removal. Consequently, the Court found that the inferences urged by the plaintiff were not available, and no factual basis was established to support the argument that his detention was unlawful.

As a result of these findings, the Court answered the questions posed in the special case. It determined that no question arose as to the lawfulness of the plaintiff's detention under sections 189 and 196 of the *Migration Act*, nor did any question arise regarding the constitutional validity of those provisions in his case. The Court ordered that no relief should issue to the plaintiff and that the plaintiff should pay the costs of and incidental to the special case.

Orders

Orders of the court

The questions stated in the special case for the opinion of the Full Court are answered as follows:

1. On their proper construction, do ss 189 and 196 of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) authorise the present detention of the plaintiff?

Answer: Does not arise.

2. If so, are those provisions beyond the legislative power of the Commonwealth insofar as they apply to the plaintiff?

Answer: Does not arise.

3. What relief, if any, should issue to the plaintiff?

Answer: None.

4. Who should pay the costs of and incidental to this special case?

Answer: The plaintiff.

Background

Background to the litigation

The plaintiff, an unlawful non-citizen, arrived in Australia on 28 January 2010 using a false passport and false personal details. This information was provided at the time of his arrival, and since that date, he has been held in immigration detention under the provisions of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth). Despite efforts by the Minister for Home Affairs, the plaintiff's identity and nationality remain unknown. The plaintiff has provided inconsistent accounts of his personal and family background, and has made false statements and failed to assist and cooperate with authorities in determining his identity and eligibility for removal from Australia.

The defendants, relying on sections 189 and 196 of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth), argue that the plaintiff's detention is lawful as he is an unlawful non-citizen who must be detained pending removal from Australia. The plaintiff contends that, given his inability to establish his identity and nationality, there is no prospect of his removal from Australia in the reasonably foreseeable future, and as such, his detention is unlawful. The case before the High Court concerns the proper construction of the relevant provisions of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth), and whether they authorise the plaintiff's detention in the circumstances.

The special case submitted to the High Court for the opinion of the Full Court sets out the factual basis for the legal questions to be answered. It includes information on the plaintiff's arrival in Australia, his use of false personal details, and the efforts made by authorities to determine his identity and nationality. The special case also includes the plaintiff's inconsistent accounts of his background and his failure to assist and cooperate with authorities. The special case does not contain agreement that there is no prospect of the plaintiff's removal from Australia in the reasonably foreseeable future, and the parties were notified that the Court would be assisted by the identification of the inferences that the plaintiff invites the Court to draw from the facts stated and the documents identified in the special case.

This case, Plaintiff M47/2018 v Minister for Home Affairs, originated in the High Court of Australia exercising its original jurisdiction. The plaintiff, an unlawful non-citizen who arrived in Australia using a false passport and personal details, challenged the lawfulness of his detention under sections 189 and 196 of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth). He claimed that these provisions no longer authorised his detention due to the impossibility of determining his identity and thus his prospects of removal from Australia. Alternatively, he argued that the provisions, as applied to him, exceeded the Commonwealth's legislative power and were therefore invalid. The High Court, upon referring to a special case, was tasked with answering questions regarding the construction and constitutional validity of these provisions in light of the plaintiff's circumstances.

The proceedings in the High Court were marked by the plaintiff's refusal to provide accurate information and cooperate with efforts to ascertain his identity, leading to significant procedural challenges. The Court was asked to draw inferences from the plaintiff's inconsistent statements and lack of cooperation, which he argued should lead to the conclusion that his detention was unlawful. However, the Court determined that the special case did not support the plaintiff's contentions, finding that the plaintiff's inconsistent accounts and non-cooperation did not establish a factual basis for the application of the minority view in Al-Kateb v Godwin. Consequently, the Court concluded that no question arose as to the lawfulness of the plaintiff's detention, and the questions referred to the Full Court were answered in a manner that did not require a determination on the validity of the plaintiff's detention. The plaintiff was ordered to pay the costs of and incidental to the special case.

Decision

Reasons for decision

KIEFEL CJ, KEANE, NETTLE AND EDELMAN JJ BELL, GAGELER AND GORDON JJ
This consideration is compelling in this case: it is the plaintiff, not the defendants, who could reasonably be expected to provide information on the facts relating to the identity of his parents and their place of birth and residence. Insofar as the special case is deficient by reason of the absence of this information, that deficit does not provide a basis for drawing any one of the inferences urged by the plaintiff. In that regard, the present case brings to mind the considerations of common sense underlying the maxim stated by Lord Mansfield in Blatch v Archer[30] that "all evidence is to be weighed according to the proof which it was in the power of one side to have produced, and in the power of the other to have contradicted". [30](1774) 1 Cowp 63 at 65 [98 ER 969 at 970]. In this Court see, eg, Vetter v Lake Macquarie City Council (2001) 202 CLR 439 at 454 [36]; [2001] HCA 12.Conclusion The inconsistent statements made by the plaintiff as to his identity and place of origin are not explicable by genuine uncertainty or ignorance, and so it cannot be assumed that it is beyond his power to provide further information concerning his identity that may shed positive light on his prospects of removal. Neither can it be concluded that the options for his removal within a reasonable time, if his cooperation is forthcoming, have been exhausted. Accordingly, the Court answered the questions referred to it on the basis that the inferences urged by the plaintiff were not available and no factual basis for the application of the view of the minority in Al‑Kateb was established. The result was that no question arose as to the lawfulness of the plaintiff's detention. The plaintiff has been held in detention by officers of the second defendant since his arrival in Australia on 28 January 2010. The defendants rely on ss 189 and 196 ("the provisions") of the Migration Act1958 (Cth) to authorise the plaintiff's detention. In proceedings commenced in the Court's original jurisdiction, the plaintiff challenges the lawfulness of his detention on the ground that, on their proper construction, the provisions have ceased to authorise his detention; alternatively, on the ground that, in their purported operation on him, the provisions exceed the legislative power of the Commonwealth and, to that extent, are invalid. The factual predicate of the challenge, in each way it is put, is the inability of the defendants to establish the plaintiff's identity at any time in the future such that there is "currently no practical possibility" of his removal from Australia to any other country. As Kiefel CJ, Keane, Nettle and Edelman JJ in their joint reasons explain, the revised special case stating questions of law for the opinion of the Full Court does not contain agreement that there is no prospect of the plaintiff's removal from Australia in the reasonably foreseeable future. Prior to the hearing, the parties were notified that the Court would be assisted by the identification of the inferences that the plaintiff invites the Court to draw from the facts stated and the documents identified in the special case[31] as would give rise to the questions of law.[31]High Court Rules 2004 (Cth), r 27.08.5.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: KIEFEL CJ, KEANE, NETTLE AND EDELMAN JJ, BELL, GAGELER AND GORDON JJ

In Plaintiff M47/2018 v Minister for Home Affairs, the High Court of Australia considered the legality of the plaintiff's detention under sections 189 and 196 of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth). The plaintiff, an unlawful non-citizen who had arrived in Australia using false documents, argued that these sections did not authorise his detention, or if they did, they were constitutionally invalid in their application to him. The Court was tasked with answering questions of law referred to it by the Court's original jurisdiction, based on a special case that outlined the factual circumstances of the plaintiff's case. The Court's reasoning focused on whether certain inferences could be drawn from the plaintiff's conduct and statements, which would have implications for the questions of law posed.

The Court began by examining the plaintiff's conduct, specifically his use of false documents and his failure to cooperate with authorities in establishing his identity. The plaintiff had provided inconsistent accounts of his background and had not provided any information that could have assisted in determining his identity or prospects for removal. The Court held that the plaintiff's inconsistent statements were not due to genuine uncertainty or ignorance, and therefore, he could reasonably be expected to provide further information that would clarify his identity and prospects for removal. Given this, the Court determined that the inferences the plaintiff sought to draw were not available, as they relied on a hypothetical scenario that was not supported by the facts.

The Court also considered the legal principles relevant to the case, including the proper construction of sections 189 and 196 of the Migration Act, and the Commonwealth's legislative power under the Constitution. The Court noted that the special case did not establish a factual basis for applying the view of the minority in Al-Kateb v Godwin, which had suggested that detention may not be lawful where there is no prospect of removal in the reasonably foreseeable future. The Court emphasised that the onus of proof was on the plaintiff to demonstrate that there was no prospect of his removal, which he had not done. Therefore, the Court concluded that the provisions did authorise the plaintiff's detention, and no question arose as to the lawfulness of that detention.

In terms of the relief that should issue to the plaintiff, the Court found that none was warranted, as the plaintiff had not established a basis for invalidating his detention. The Court also addressed the issue of costs, determining that the plaintiff should bear the costs of and incidental to the special case, as the plaintiff had not succeeded in his challenge to the lawfulness of his detention. The Court's decision reflects a cautious approach to drawing inferences in special cases, where the facts are not fully before the Court, and a clear emphasis on the plaintiff's responsibility to provide information that could impact the outcome of the legal questions at hand. The ratio decidendi of this case is that sections 189 and 196 of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) do authorise the detention of unlawful non-citizens, provided that there is a reasonable prospect of their removal from Australia, which can be established based on the information provided by the non-citizen and their cooperation with authorities.