R v Davey; Ex parte Freer

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read
56 CLR 381

DAVEY AND OTHERS

Ex PARTE FREER. Immigration-Prohibited immigrant-Dictation test-Failure to pass-No attempt

made by immigrant-Language, by whom to be chosen-Suitability or desirability of immigrant-Decision of Minister-Review by court-Certificate of health- Immigration Act 1901-1935 (No. 17 of 1901-No. 13 of 1935), secs. 3 (a), 3J, 14*.

A passage of not less than fifty words in the Italian language was dictated to an immigrant by a person duly authorized under sec. 3 (a) of the Immigration Act 1901-1935. The immigrant, who deliberately prevented herself from hearing the dictation, refused to, and did not in fact, write any words in the Italian or any language. * The Immigration Act 1901-1935

ized person." Sec. 3.1: The Minister by sec. 3 provides -Sec. 3: "The

may, if he thinks fit, prevent an immigration into the Commonwealth

intending immigrant from entering of the persons described in any of the

the Commonwealth, notwithstanding following paragraphs of this section (hereinafter called prohibited immi-

issued to the intending immigrant." grants') is prohibited, namely -(a)

Sec. 14: "Every officer may with any person who fails to pass the dicta-

any necessary assistance prevent any tion test: that is to say, who, when an

prohibited immigrant, or person reason- ably supposed to be a prohibited fifty words in any prescribed language,

immigrant, from entering the Common- fails to write them out in that language in the presence of the officer or author-

56 CLR 382

Held that the immigrant had failed, within the meaning of sec. 3 (a), to pass the dictation test.

Despite the amendment of sec. 3 (a) since the decision in Chia Gee v. Martin, (1905) 3 C.L.R. 649, it is for the officer, or other representative of the Common- wealth, and not the immigrant to select the prescribed language for applying the test under sec. 3 (a) of the Immigration Act 1901-1935.

The power conferred by sec. 3J of the Immigration Act 1901-1935, is intended to be exercised upon grounds relating to health. It does not confer an absolute and unqualified power upon the Minister to prevent an intending immigrant from entering the Commonwealth.

Neither the court nor any other tribunal has authority, upon an application for a writ of habeas corpus, to review a decision of the Minister as to the suit- ability or desirability of the visitor or immigrant to the Commonwealth.

ORDER NISI for habeas corpus.

An application was made to Evatt J. on 4th December 1936 for an order that a writ of habeas corpus issue to Arthur Henry Davey, master of the S.S. Awatea, Herbert Bede Cody, an officer of customs, and the Commonwealth of Australia, to produce one Mabel Magdalene Freer before the court. His Honour granted an order nisi returnable during the afternoon of that day, and ordered that the applicant, Mrs. Freer, was not to be removed from the jurisdiction until the further order of the court or a justice. thereof. On the return of the order the following facts were brought before the court by…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Davey; Ex parte Freer and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1936] HCA 58
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case concerned an application for a writ of habeas corpus brought on behalf of Mabel Magdalene Freer, who was detained on board the S.S. Awatea by customs officers and the Commonwealth of Australia. The respondents sought to justify her detention on two grounds: first, an authority issued by the Minister under section 3J of the *Immigration Act 1901-1935*, and second, that Mrs. Freer was a prohibited immigrant by reason of failing to pass a dictation test under section 3(a) of the same Act, as enforced by section 14.

The court was required to determine whether the Minister's authority under section 3J provided a lawful basis for detention, and whether Mrs. Freer had indeed failed to pass the dictation test as prescribed by the *Immigration Act 1901-1935*. Specifically, the court had to consider who had the authority to select the language for the dictation test and whether Mrs. Freer's actions constituted a "failure" to pass the test. The court also considered the scope of its jurisdiction in reviewing executive decisions regarding immigration.

Evatt J. held that the power conferred by section 3J was intended to be exercised solely on grounds relating to health and did not grant the Minister an absolute power to prevent an immigrant's entry. Regarding the dictation test, the court found that, despite amendments to the Act, the officer or authorised representative, not the immigrant, was responsible for selecting the language. The court determined that Mrs. Freer had failed the dictation test within the meaning of section 3(a) because she deliberately prevented herself from hearing the dictation in Italian, and her refusal to attempt the test in that language, or any other save English, constituted an objective failure. The court affirmed that it had no authority to review the Minister's decision on the suitability or desirability of an immigrant.

Consequently, the detention of Mrs. Freer was found to be lawful, and the order nisi for habeas corpus was discharged.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.