ASF17 v Commonwealth of Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 74 min read

HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

GAGELER CJ,
GORDON, EDELMAN, STEWARD, GLEESON, JAGOT AND BEECH‑JONES JJ

ASF17  APPELLANT

AND

COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA  RESPONDENT

ASF17 v Commonwealth of Australia

[2024] HCA 19

Date of Hearing: 17 April 2024

Date of Judgment: 10 May 2024

P7/2024

ORDER

Appeal dismissed with costs.

Representation

L G De Ferrari SC with M W Guo and C J Fitzgerald for the appellant (instructed by Zarifi Lawyers)

S P Donaghue KC, Solicitor-General of the Commonwealth, with B D Kaplan and N A Wootton for the respondent (instructed by Australian Government Solicitor)

C L Lenehan SC with T M Wood and J R Murphy for AZC20, intervening (instructed by Human Rights Law Centre)

Notice:  This copy of the Court's Reasons for Judgment is subject to formal revision prior to publication in the Commonwealth Law Reports.

  1. GAGELER CJ, GORDON, STEWARD, GLEESON, JAGOT AND BEECH‑JONES JJ.   NZYQ v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs[1] held that the continuing detention under ss 189(1) and 196(1) of the Migration Act1958 (Cth) ("the Act") of an alien required to be removed from Australia under s 198(1) or s 198(6) of the Act exceeds the temporal limitation on the valid application of those provisions imposed by Ch III of the Constitution if and for so long as there is no real prospect of removal of the alien from Australia becoming practicable in the reasonably foreseeable future. NZYQ further held that where an alien detainee who seeks a writ of habeas corpus establishes reason to suppose that their continuing detention exceeds the constitutional limitation, the detainer bears the legal burden of establishing that the constitutional limitation is not exceeded.[2]

    [1](2023) 97 ALJR 1005 at 1018 [55], 1018-1019 [59].

    [2](2023) 97 ALJR 1005 at 1019 [59].

  2. The application of those principles in NZYQ to hold that ss 189(1) and 196(1) of the Act did not validly apply to authorise the continuing detention of the alien detainee in that case was noted to have been in a factual context in which the detainee had cooperated with officers in the undertaking of administrative processes directed to facilitating his removal from Australia.[3]

    [3](2023) 97 ALJR 1005 at 1019 [62].

  3. This appeal concerns the application of those principles to a case in which an alien detainee who claims that their continuing detention exceeds the constitutional limitation identified in NZYQ has refused to cooperate in the undertaking of administrative processes necessary to facilitate their removal from Australia.

    Factual background and procedural history

  4. The appellant, ASF17, is a citizen of Iran. He arrived in Australia as an unlawful non-citizen at the age of 27 in 2013. Except for a short period during which he held a bridging visa between 2013 and 2014, he has been held in immigration detention continuously since his arrival.

  5. While in immigration detention, ASF17 in 2015 made an application for a Safe Haven Enterprise Visa ("SHEV"). The application was refused by a delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection in 2017. An…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read ASF17 v Commonwealth of Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] HCA 19
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of Australia considered an appeal by ASF17, an Iranian citizen who arrived in Australia as an unlawful non-citizen and has been held in immigration detention since 2013. Following the final determination of his visa application, s 198(6) of the *Migration Act 1958* (Cth) imposed a duty on officers to remove him from Australia as soon as reasonably practicable, and s 196(1) required his continued detention until removal. ASF17 refused to cooperate with administrative processes necessary for his removal to Iran, stating he would only consent to removal to a country other than Iran, though no alternative country was identified. He sought a writ of habeas corpus, arguing his continued detention exceeded the constitutional limitation established in *NZYQ v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs* [2023] HCA 37.

The central legal issue before the Court was whether ASF17's ongoing detention, necessitated by his refusal to cooperate in facilitating his removal to Iran, transgressed the constitutional limits on executive detention for immigration purposes as articulated in *NZYQ*. This required the Court to determine if there remained a real prospect of his removal to Iran becoming practicable in the reasonably foreseeable future, notwithstanding his non-cooperation.

The Court reasoned that a detainee cannot unilaterally create circumstances that negate the practicability of their removal by withholding consent or cooperation, particularly concerning removal to their country of origin. Applying this principle, the Court found that ASF17's refusal to cooperate in obtaining the necessary travel documents from Iranian authorities was the sole impediment to his removal to Iran. Given that he had the capacity to change his mind and cooperate, the primary judge's finding that there was a real prospect of his removal to Iran becoming practicable in the reasonably foreseeable future was upheld. Consequently, the Court concluded that ASF17's continuing detention did not exceed the constitutional temporal limitation on the valid application of ss 189(1) and 196(1) of the *Migration Act*.

The appeal was dismissed, and ASF17 was ordered to pay the costs of the Commonwealth.

Orders

Orders of the court

Appeal dismissed with costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

This appeal concerns the application of those principles to a case in which an alien detainee who claims that their continuing detention exceeds the constitutional limitation identified in NZYQ has refused to cooperate in the undertaking of administrative processes necessary to facilitate their removal from Australia.Factual background and procedural history The appellant, ASF17, is a citizen of Iran. He arrived in Australia as an unlawful non-citizen at the age of 27 in 2013. Except for a short period during which he held a bridging visa between 2013 and 2014, he has been held in immigration detention continuously since his arrival. While in immigration detention, ASF17 in 2015 made an application for a Safe Haven Enterprise Visa ("SHEV"). The application was refused by a delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection in 2017. An application for judicial review of the decision of the delegate was dismissed by the Federal Circuit Court of Australia in 2017[4] in a decision which was upheld on appeal to the Federal Court of Australia in 2018.[5][4]ASF17 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2017] FCCA 2498.[5]ASF17 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCA 1149. The final determination of his application for a SHEV which occurred upon the dismissal of the appeal in 2018 engaged the duty imposed on officers of the Department of Home Affairs ("the Department") by s 198(6) of the Act to remove ASF17 from Australia as soon as reasonably practicable. Unlike the plaintiff in NZYQ,[6] ASF17 has never formally requested to be removed from Australia so as to engage the other duty to remove imposed on officers of the Department by s 198(1) of the Act.[6]See (2023) 97 ALJR 1005 at 1009 [4]. For the purpose of facilitating removal of ASF17 from Australia, officers of the Department conducted regular interviews with him from 2018. Throughout those interviews, he consistently told officers that he would not voluntarily return to Iran. He consistently refused to sign a request for removal or to engage with Iranian authorities in planning for his removal. He repeatedly told officers that he would agree to be sent to any country other than Iran. However, he did not suggest that there was any country to which he might be removed other than Iran. Iranian citizens cannot enter Iran from Australia without a travel document issued by Iranian authorities and Iranian authorities have a longstanding policy of not issuing travel documents to involuntary returnees. The Department has a policy of not removing anyone to a country in respect of which they have no right of residency or long-term stay ("the third country removal policy"). Considerations underpinning the third country removal policy include the potential for diplomatic controversy were someone to be removed to a country which had not agreed to accept them and the lack of any basis for generally considering that a country would agree to accept anyone who has no right of residency or long-term stay in that country.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

JONES JJ EDELMAN J
To sum up in language used by French J in WAIS v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs,[50] to which attention was drawn in NZYQ,[51] "[a] detainee cannot, in effect, create a circumstance which negatives any reasonable likelihood that he can be removed in the foreseeable future by withholding his consent or cooperation to a particular avenue for removal and specifically to removal to the country from which he came".[52] That, in a nutshell, is what ASF17 has tried and failed to do.[50][2002] FCA 1625.[51](2023) 97 ALJR 1005 at 1019 [61], fn 72.[52][2002] FCA 1625 at [61].Conclusion The statutory position of ASF17 is unambiguous. His removal from Australia is required by s 198(6) of the Act. In the absence of an extant protection finding, which would engage the operation of s 197C(3), his removal to Iran is permissible under s 198(6). The litigious position of ASF17 is correspondingly uncompromising. He has not sought a writ of mandamus to compel his removal from Australia. No question has therefore arisen as to whether his removal from Australia, whether to Iran or to anywhere else, could be compelled under s 198(6) of the Act. He has not sought that the Minister exercise any personal non-compellable power under s 48B or s 195A which may result in a protection finding by reason of his claimed fear of harm in Iran based on his sexual orientation. He has sought only a writ of habeas corpus. By it, he has sought to secure his immediate release from detention in Australia. The sole question which has arisen, and on which issue has been joined at the hearing and on appeal, is whether ASF17's continuing detention in Australia under ss 189(1) and 196(1) for the purpose of removal under s 198(6) exceeds the constitutional limitation on the valid application of ss 189(1) and 196(1) identified in NZYQ. ASF17 could be removed to Iran if he cooperated in the process of obtaining the requisite travel documents from Iranian authorities. He has decided not to cooperate. He has the capacity to change his mind. He chooses not to do so. On those undisturbed findings of primary fact, the evaluative characterisation of the primary judge, that there is a real prospect of removal of ASF17 from Australia to Iran becoming practicable in the reasonably foreseeable future, such that the constitutional limitation identified in NZYQ has not been exceeded, is correct. ASF17's continuing detention under ss 189(1) and 196(1) of the Act does not exceed the temporal limitation on the valid application of those provisions imposed by Ch III of the Constitution. The appeal will be dismissed with costs. Introduction ASF17 is a bisexual man who arrived in Australia by boat in 2013. He has been convicted of no offence in this country. But he has been continuously detained in immigration detention since 2014. He has now said that he is prepared to be removed willingly from Australia to any country in the world except Iran. But for a decade he has refused to assist the Commonwealth in his removal to Iran, where private and consensual sexual intercourse between men may attract the death penalty and where persons may face persecution for a choice "to live ... aspects of their lives that are related to, or informed by, their sexuality".[53] ASF17 has refused to sign a request for his removal to Iran and has refused to engage with Iranian authorities in order to obtain travel documents required by Iran for his removal to that country. [53]Appellant S395/2002 v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (2003) 216 CLR 473 at 501 [81].

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: JONES JJ, EDELMAN J

Full text does not contain this section.