ASF17 v Commonwealth of Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 77 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

ASF17 v Commonwealth of Australia [2024] FCA 7

File number: WAD 289 of 2023
Judgment of: COLVIN J
Date of judgment: 11 January 2024
Catchwords:

MIGRATION - application for writ of habeas corpus and declaratory relief regarding alleged unlawfulness of applicant's detention - where applicant has been in immigration detention for almost 10 years - where applicant is citizen of Iran and refuses to cooperate with his removal to Iran - where applicant claims to be bisexual - where applicant claims to have converted to Christianity - where applicant claims to fear harm due to ethnicity and opposition to the government - whether determination of a real prospect of a detainee's removal from Australia becoming practicable in the reasonably foreseeable future involves consideration of reasons for detainee's voluntary noncooperation - whether relevant that a detainee's noncooperation is due to a genuine subjective fear of harm - held evaluation of prospects of removal involves consideration of outcomes if the detainee assists in their removal irrespective of the reason for any refusal of the detainee to assist - application dismissed

CONSTITUTIONAL LAW - consideration of constitutional limit on executive detention as held in NZYQ v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs [2023] HCA 37 - consideration of application of NZYQ where failure by detainee to cooperate - where facts are distinguishable from AZC20 v Secretary, Department of Home Affairs (No 2) [2023] FCA 1497 - where constitutional limit per NZYQ not correctly confined by principle held in AZC20 - consideration of relevance of authorities prior to NZYQ - consideration of constitutional limit where Migration Act 1958 (Cth) provides for ability to seek protection and constitutional limit based upon purpose of removal not being able to be effectuated - held evaluation of prospect of applicant's removal from Australia in the foreseeable future depends upon assessment of purpose of detention taking account of his ability to cooperate regardless of demonstrated unwillingness

Legislation: Migration Act 1958 (Cth) ss 189, 196, 198
Cases cited:

AKW22 v Commonwealth of Australia [2023] FCAFC 71; (2023) 297 FCR 650

Al-Kateb v Godwin [2004] HCA 37; (2004) 219 CLR 562

ASF17 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCA 1149

AZC20 v Secretary, Department of Home Affairs (No 2) [2023] FCA 1497

BVT20 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2020] FCAFC 222; (2020) 283 FCR 97

CPCF v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2015] HCA 1; (2015) 255 CLR 514

DMH20 v Minister for Home Affairs [2022] FCA 1054

DMH20 v Minister for Home Affairs [2023] FCAFC 31; (2023) 296 FCR 256

Gett v Tabet [2009] NSWCA 76; (2009) 109 NSWLR 1

Hicks v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2003] FCA 757

Lim v Minister for Immigration, Local Government and Ethnic Affairs (1992) 176 CLR 1

McHugh v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2020] FCAFC 223; (2020) 283 FCR 602

Minister for Immigration and Multicultural…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read ASF17 v Commonwealth of Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] FCA 7
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of ASF17 v Commonwealth of Australia involved an Iranian national, ASF17, who had been in immigration detention for nearly a decade. ASF17 had refused to cooperate with his removal to Iran due to his fear of persecution based on his sexual orientation and conversion to Christianity. The applicant sought a writ of habeas corpus and declaratory relief, arguing that his continued detention was unlawful. The court was required to decide whether the determination of a real prospect of the detainee's removal from Australia in the reasonably foreseeable future involved consideration of the reasons for the detainee's noncooperation, and whether the constitutional limit on executive detention under the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) was correctly applied.

The Federal Court evaluated the prospects of ASF17's removal by considering the outcomes if he assisted in his removal, irrespective of his reasons for noncooperation. The court noted that the constitutional limit on detention, as established in NZYQ v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs, required proof of a real prospect of removal in the reasonably foreseeable future. The court rejected the argument that the detainee's willingness to cooperate was irrelevant, holding that the evaluation of the prospect of removal depended on the assessment of the purpose of detention, taking into account the detainee's ability to cooperate.

The court further clarified that the constitutional limit on detention was based on the purpose of removal not being able to be effectuated, and that the High Court in NZYQ had distinguished the case from previous instances where detainees had frustrated inquiries or where inquiries had not been exhausted. Given ASF17's persistent refusal to cooperate and his singular focus on remaining in Australia, the court found that there was a real prospect of his removal becoming practicable in the foreseeable future. Consequently, the application was dismissed.

The court ordered that any party seeking an order for costs had to file and serve submissions of no more than three pages specifying the terms of the order sought and the reasons why it should be made, together with any necessary affidavit in support. The other party could then file and serve submissions of no more than three pages in answer, together with any necessary affidavit in response. Any question of costs was to be determined on the papers, subject to further order.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application is dismissed.

2. Within 10 days, any party seeking an order for costs do file and serve submissions of no more than three pages specifying the terms of the order sought and the reasons why it is submitted that the order should be made together with any necessary affidavit in support.

3. Within 10 days of any submissions being filed in accordance with order 2, the other party may file and serve submissions of no more than three pages in answer together with any necessary affidavit in response.

4. Subject to further order, any question of costs shall be determined on the papers.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In the alternative, the applicant says that the willingness or otherwise of a detainee to cooperate in their removal is irrelevant. It is enough that Iran does not accept involuntary removals and that there is no other place to which the applicant can be removed (even though he is willing to be removed to some other place). In those circumstances, so it is submitted, the constitutional limit for lawful detention has been reached.Application of the decision in NZYQ where there has been a failure by a detainee to cooperate in their removal In NZYQ, the High Court unanimously reopened and overruled its earlier constitutional holding in Al-Kateb v Godwin [2004] HCA 37; (2004) 219 CLR 562. All members of the Court in NZYQ determined that in order to establish that 'the Migration Act validly applied to authorise continuation of the plaintiff's detention, the defendants were accordingly required to prove that there existed a real prospect of his removal from Australia becoming practicable in the reasonably foreseeable future': at [60] (emphasis added). It may be accepted that by reason of the parties' agreement in NZYQ that the detainee had 'complied with requests for information made by officers of the [Minister's] Department and had otherwise assisted the Department with its inquiries' (at [62]), the High Court did not have to decide whether a failure to cooperate might be relevant to the application of the constitutional limitation. Nevertheless, it is significant that the High Court in NZYQ distinguished the facts before the Court on that occasion from the facts in two previous cases that had been before the Court. Having noted the agreement between the parties as to the provision of assistance by the plaintiff, the High Court then said:This was not a case of a person in immigration detention having contributed to the frustration of the pursuit of lines of inquiry by officers of the Department attempting to bring about the person's removal. The above sentence concluded with a footnote reference which was 'Compare Plaintiff M47/2018 v Minister for Home Affairs (2019) 265 CLR 285. See at 297 [30]-[33], 301-302 [47]'. Following the above sentence was a second example:Nor was it a case where officers of the Department remained in the process of pursuing lines of inquiry based on circumstances peculiar to the person in detention. The reference to the second example concluded with a footnote reference which was 'Compare Plaintiff M76/2013 v Minister for Immigration, Multicultural Affairs and Citizenship (2013) 251 CLR 322. See at 334-335 [4], 368 [135]'. Plainly, the references to Plaintiff M47 and Plaintiff M76 emphasised distinguishing features in those two cases from the circumstances of the case at hand. Read in context, the Court was saying that where a person in immigration detention has frustrated the pursuit of lines of inquiry by Departmental officers or those officers have not yet exhausted lines of inquiry the constitutional limitation may not have been exceeded.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

After the applicant failed to obtain a protection visa on the basis of the version of events that he gave in his statement, he maintained that he cannot return to Iran. He gave no reason for that position despite the passage of many years. He simply refused to cooperate with any effort to return him to Iran. Although he says he is willing to be removed to another place, he has not advanced a basis for seeking removal to any other place and there is no independent evidence in the documentary record that suggests that he has agitated for his removal.Alleged significance of duration of detention for applicant's claims Against these matters is the fact that the applicant, since August 2018, has consistently maintained that he cannot return to Iran because he has a problem in doing so. He has maintained that position in circumstances where he must be taken to be aware that, as a citizen, arrangements could be made for his voluntary return to Iran. He maintained that it could be inferred from the fact that he had endured many years in detention rather than return voluntarily to Iran that the account that he has now given in his affidavits in support of his present application is a true account. However, the applicant's behaviour is also consistent with a singular focus upon being able to secure permission to be released into the Australian community rather than face economic difficulty if he was to be made to return to Iran. Indeed, in his Second Affidavit he says that the case managers always gave him hope, that they made requests for the Minister to consider his case and that he would get a visa and be released. The documents show that, for much of the time since August 2018, there were pending requests for Ministerial intervention to allow the applicant to remain in Australia. The applicant produced an aide memoire which included 10 references in the documents to discussion between case officers and the applicant concerning the pendency of his requests for Ministerial intervention. The most recent of those references was on 20 November 2023 which was 'his MI [Ministerial intervention request] is still ongoing'. Before that the previous reference is for 31 October 2023 which is in the following terms:… he [the applicant] wanted to know about the MI request to the Minister, I informed him that work had been done recently and that there was no indication of what the outcome would be … Plainly the pursuit of those requests shows that the applicant has been seeking to obtain permission to remain in Australia. It is not the case that for the past five years he has been pressing to be removed from Australia to some place other than Iran. Indeed, the only reference in the applicant's aide memoire to records in the documents of the applicant's willingness to go anywhere except Iran is a record of a statement on 25 June 2020 by the applicant that the Department could send him anywhere but he couldn't return to Iran. When asked what country would allow him to live there permanently, the applicant replied that he did not know. All other references are to the applicant's unwillingness to return to Iran.